7 Things WWE Fans Wanted (Until They Got Them)
It seems that Daniel Bryan was right after all. We really are fickle...
Every wrestling fan is a fantasy booker in their own mind. Each one of us has their favorites, wrestlers we would like to become a champion, changes to be made, people to come and go. And yet, when we finally get what we want, more often than not it turns out not at all like we thought it would.
Sometimes it's due to the expectations simply being too high. Other times, it's due to other people's incompetence, bad decisions or lack of foresight. Either way, we end up disappointed. Matches that were supposed to be all-time classics end up being just okay and people we thought would become megastars keep sliding down the card.
Expectations not meeting reality is a big part of every wrestling fan's experience. Things we build up in our heads to be amazing end in a whimper and there's nothing we can do about it. With that said, let's look at some cases of WWE fans being, as Daniel Bryan would say, fickle. With the way this company operates, do we not have the right to be just that?
7. Shane McMahon Back In WWE
Shane McMahon left WWE on 1 January 2010. As the years went on, he became a fondly remembered character. As they say, absence makes the heart grow fonder.
When Shane finally returned to WWE after over six years away, the pop was enormous. Fans were elated and genuinely surprised, so even the lackluster "McMahon Lockbox" storyline didn't manage to dampen their enthusiasm.
How things have changed since then. While he has continuously entertained the crowds with his familiar falling-off-of-high-places routine and painful to the eyes shadowboxing, in recent months he also managed to gather a fair amount of go-away heat.
Shane McMahon is the Best in the World. Even though he wasn't even originally included in the tournament. The gimmick admittedly had some potential, but writing it in a non-exhausting way was seemingly way above WWE creative's paygrade.
Since that night in Saudi Arabia, he slowly started taking over both of the main roster brands. There was no escape from him as he was feuding with many different people at the same time while also collecting sidekicks like trading cards.
What seemed like a dream couple of years ago eventually turned into a true nightmare for the fans.
6. Main Roster Call-Ups
NXT is supposedly a developmental brand, even though many of its stars are grizzled indie veterans who don't really have anything left to learn. However, there's only so much time an already fully developed star can spend wrestling in front of the Full Sail crowd until the fans start campaigning for them to move up to the main roster.
While obviously some NXT graduates have managed to find success on the main roster, others have been lackluster to say the least.
Some wrestlers' tenure - Samoa Joe and Finn Bálor come to mind - in NXT seemed to just drag on and on, so their move up the ranks was simply a matter of time. Now Samoa Joe's highest accolade is the US Championship and Finn hasn't really been relevant since losing the Universal Championship after one day due to unfortunate injury.
There's too many to count - The Revival, American Alpha, even The Ascension - who all showed tremendous promise down in NXT, but were a letdown on the main roster.
Right now, Johnny Gargano has seemingly exhausted all his options in NXT and his move to the main roster feels inevitable. Sadly, his chances up there don't look too promising.
5. Japanese Favorites In WWE
Japanese wrestling is amongst the best in the world, so it stands to reason its many fans wish to see their idols migrate to the so-called biggest league.
Shinsuke Nakamura, Asuka, Kairi Sane. For one reason or another, their WWE main roster careers have been a disappointment so far. All of them are excellent wrestlers when they apply themselves. Given the opportunity to spread their wings, they are capable of putting on world class performances.
Shinsuke Nakamura had so many matches in WWE that were supposed to be all-time classics - vs. AJ Styles and vs. Seth Rollins to name a few. And yet, they were perfectly mediocre. Not exactly bad, but certainly not meeting the expected high standard. His recent "low blow machine" gimmick did him no favors either.
Charlotte ended Asuka's undefeated streak at WrestleMania. While it was a necessary conclusion to Asuka's excellent run, the way she has been booked since leaves much to be desired. She's one of the best wrestlers in the world today, male or female, and for months she was a complete non-entity. And Kairi Sane, well... apparently she's really Io Shirai, according to the WWE graphics team.
4. The Brand Split
For years, SmackDown was the ugly stepsister of WWE programming. It pretty much doubled as a Raw rerun with constant recaps and rehashes of the exact same matches and angles from the night before... only with even less effort. The Brand Split offered more opportunities for wrestlers who have been forgotten about or just couldn't get enough TV time to showcase their talents
Things started rather promisingly, actually. For a few months after the beginning of the Brand Split, SmackDown was almost always enjoyable viewing. Since then the fans' attitude towards it started to sour.
More TV time for midcarders? How about for the same three people over and over again? From the land of opportunities, SmackDown soon descended into extreme mediocrity. Sadly, it could be felt that it was still clearly considered to be the B show by WWE's management.
With the Wild Card Rule running rampant, and SmackDown being drowned by Raw recaps anyway, many started to question the validity of the Brand Split. Who is even on which roster anymore? And does it matter, seeing as there are virtually no differentiating characteristics to both brands?
3. Dean Ambrose's Heel Turn
Roman Reigns was and perhaps still is WWE's Golden Boy. Seth Rollins, while only reaching the status of the face of the company in recent months, has orbited around the main event scene almost non-stop for many years. Dean Ambrose was clearly less coveted by WWE and burdened with a ridiculous "lunatic" gimmick, which did his popularity no favors.
So, when he returned from injury more jacked and ready to rumble than ever it seemed like the best time to pull the plug. Dean turning heel was seemingly a dream come true. It was supposed to help revitalize his character and finally push him back into the spotlight on equal position with his former Shield teammates. And yet, it's looked on as a great disappointment and one of the reasons he decided to leave WWE.
WWE creative managed to turn him from a vicious badass to a bad joke in a matter of weeks. They made him do promos pretending to get vaccine shots, walk around in gas masks and call fans dirty. Apparently, they also wanted him to say a line about Roman Reign's cancer so disgusting that he didn't even want to repeat it.
2. NXT UK
According to WWE, NXT's United Kingdom branch was supposed to give British wrestlers more opportunities to expand their brand and get on another level without damaging the local wrestling scene too much. That was just a very measly cover as they couldn't openly voice their true reasoning without facing major backlash.
The reality is sadly very different. NXT UK is extremely niche and may be watched by even fewer people than 205 Live which somehow doesn't seem to bother WWE too much. Triple H's earlier promises about the non-exclusivity of performers ring more and more false as the time goes by.
WWE has raided the independent wrestling scene in the UK almost beyond repair. They snatched up as many top stars as possible and weren't really interested in doing much with them at all. What does interest them, however, is tying them up with deals that don't allow them to be shown on any other promotions' televised events.
NXT United Kingdom has actually been touted by WWE as something that was going to be a good thing for the fans and wrestlers alike. So far, it has only been a major disappointment and it doesn't look like that is going to change any time soon.
1. Seth Rollins As The Face Of WWE
Seth Rollins has been in the WWE main event scene for many years now, and for much of that time, he was a fan favorite. In 2019, he won the Royal Rumble and left WrestleMania as the Universal Champion. So, why does it feel like the worst time to be his fan?
Seth Rollins is a work rate machine, and that's a fact. He has occasionally shown himself to be a good promo as well. And yet, when in a company of the greats of the past during the Raw Reunion, he ended up looking like a total geek. When fighting Brock Lesnar, he had to resort to a low blow. And it seems like his greatest accomplishment, while being the supposedly top guy of the company, is who his on screen (and also in real life, didn't you know? Michael Cole probably didn't bring it up enough times) girlfriend is.
His conduct on social media and in interviews turned the tide against him even more. Now branded as a company shill, his reputation isn't at the place it was mere a couple of months ago. Who would have previously thought that Rollins could be the top champ and yet look weaker than ever?