7 Times Payback Wasn't Delivered In WWE

Sometimes the comeuppance just never arrives.

Edge SummerSlam 2005.jpg
WWE.com

This Sunday, World Wrestling Entertainment will present Payback, the fifth special event of 2016 and the company's first following the extravaganza that was WrestleMania.

The promo video for the show includes Bray Wyatt (now injured) waxing lyrical in his usual style, talking of how 'one word drives us', and that one word is payback.

'Payback' is defined as the act of revenge or retaliation, and it is an integral part of professional wrestling. At its heart wrestling is the story of good versus evil, of the bad guys antagonising the good guys, often getting the upper-hand before eventually getting their comeuppance. It might not be true in real life, but in pro wrestling good triumphs more often than not.

There are many examples in wrestling history when this hasn't quite been the case however. On a few occasions the bad guy has antagonised the good, has downright bullied them for a period of time and still coming out on top, with the bullied left to look like a chump.

Of course, this isn't to say that every single story in wrestling must end with the good guy on top, for such a state of affairs would be stale. Still, there are a few examples where payback was necessary but payback never came.

Here are seven such times.

7. Brie Bella Accepts Her Fate

Brie Bella Nikki Bella
WWE.com

2014 should have been a beautiful year for Brie Bella. It started with her beau Daniel Bryan rising to the very top of professional wrestling and the two tying the knot soon after.

The outlook looked rosy, but injury would rob her husband of his career and her boss made her life hell. She quit but would return, only for her own sister to cost her victory over Stephanie McMahon-Helmsley in a big grudge match at SummerSlam.

Nikki continued to berate her sister, running her down on a weekly basis with increasingly hurtful words. The two had a match at Hell in a Cell 2014 where the loser would be forced to become the winner's personal assistant for 30 days.

Such matches generally lead to the heel winning and putting the babyface through further hell until they can't take it anymore, clawing their way back and eventually vanquishing their foe.

The first half of that was true, as Nikki defeated Brie thus forcing her to take on PA duties for the Bella Empire. Just three days before the stipulation would end, however, Brie would assist Nikki in defeating AJ Lee for the Divas Champion.

The twins were reunited, with the hurtful comments of the previous couple of months seemingly forgotten. What we learnt was that if you bully your sibling, they will probably help you in your dastardly ways just because.


6. Cheats Sometimes Prosper

Edge, Matt Hardy
WWE.com

The Edge/Lita/Matt Hardy mess from a decade a go has been dissected to death in the time since. Matt and Lita were together in real life, but Lita sort of put a knife in all of that by cheating on him with Edge.

Somehow this led to Matt being released by WWE, and Edge and Lita were paired up on screen. This real-life tomfoolery made the Edge the star he threatened to become but never seemed able to.

Matt Hardy, quite obviously the heavily wronged person in the saga, wasn't about to go down without a fight however. There was a wonderful few weeks on RAW where a Hardy return was teased, and he did just so by attacking Edge out of nowhere a few times.

This was done in a shoot style, and somehow a feud between Edge and Matt Hardy was the hottest thing in wrestling. Matt was re-signed, and a match between the two was booked for SummerSlam 2005.

Logic dictates that a fired up Matt will return and defeat the man who wronged him, right?

Well, no. The match happened, and less than five minutes after the bell had rang it was over. Not just that, but Edge was the victor. Oh, it gets worse too, Edge was the winner by referee stoppage. Matt Hardy went from a white-hot face to a chump in four minutes and fifty seconds.

Hardy would eventually pick up a victory over Edge, but the feud would culminate with the latter going over in a 'Loser Leaves RAW Ladder Match'. Hardy lost his girl, his job and his credibility.

Cheats sometimes do prosper.


5. The Humiliation Of Celeste Bonin

big e aj lee kaitlyn
wwe.com

Despite a rocky start in the third season of NXT, by 2013 Kaitlyn has made such vast improvements in the wrestling world that she found herself the Divas Champion, and the distinction was very much deserved. A feud with ex-Chickbuster chum AJ Lee was inevitable, but Kaitlyn had to deal a secret admirer first.

Speculation was rife as to who was sending Kaitlyn gifts, with Cody Rhodes the most likely potential beau. The big reveal came, and rather than Cody (or Hornswoggle, who usually gets the reveal stories) it was none other than AJ Lee's bodyguard, Big E.

The former Mr. Langston headed to the ring, only for the whole thing to be exposed as a ruse by the dastardly AJ, a mind game ahead of their forthcoming title match at Payback.

I'm sure there's a modicum of irony in there somewhere, but Kaitlyn never did get that payback. AJ defeated her for the title at the PPV, and Kaitlyn was unsuccessful in every subsequent challenge.

She would finish the feud victorious, but this was in a mixed tag match with Dolph Ziggler against AJ and the man who broke her heart, Big E.

Just a few months later, Kaitlyn lost her final match in WWE. Her opponent? AJ Lee of course.


4. Slut-Shaming Is Okay Kids!

Rock and Lana
WWE.com

On a number of occasions, WWE has tried to talk its way out of the blatant bullying on its programming with the old 'it's heroes and villains' cop-out. Regardless of the success of such claims, it is difficult to back it up when arguably the most popular 'hero' on the show bullies the 'villain', for no reason other than all-out misogyny.

Dwayne Johnson may come across as one of the greatest human beings on the planet, but The Rock as a fictional character has often been a steaming pile of the brown stuff when it comes to his treatment of women.

On his most recent return to the company to build towards WrestleMania, it was Lana who happened to be in his sights.

The entire thing was uncomfortable, unnecessary and offensive. In a backstage segment The Rock spoke graphically about a supposed night with Lana, running her down in a most objectified manner as her on-screen and real-life partner Rusev stood there and, well, seethed.

Everyone laughed, everyone cheered, and educated wrestling fans died a little more inside.

Did the bully get his comeuppance? Unless comeuppance comes in the form of almost universal adulation, I'd say 'no'.


3. The McMahons Never Lose

Stephanie Mcmahon ziggler
WWE.com

More so than most characters on the television show, the one who desperately is waiting to be served up some cold payback on a plate of colder payback is none other than the Billionaire Princess, Stephanie McMahon-Helmsley.

Sure, there have been a couple of minor moments, but more often than not Steph comes out on top.

Even at the height of his dastardly power, Vince McMahon frequently got his. He may have made Steve Austin's life a living hell, but when push came to shove Vince would get his.

Now, obviously the physical interaction with Steph isn't the desired outcome, but far too often she has emasculated members of the male roster and belittled the females, all without even the slightest hint of retribution for the downtrodden.

The case of Stephanie McMahon-Helmsley is a complex one, as for years when she first arrived on WWF TV she was treated despicably by the majority of men on the show.

Despite this, she portrays an evil authority figure on TV and is fantastic in the role itself but less commendable when it comes to finishing up on the wrong end of the stick.


2. Triple H Proves Himself Correct

booker t triple h
WWE Network

For a while in 2002 and 2003, Triple H was all over Monday Night RAW. He was gifted the World Heavyweight Championship by Eric Bischoff, and with the help of Ric Flair and his cronies in Evolution would hold on to that title via ever more nefarious means. Heading into WrestleMania XIX Hunter was challenged by a red-hot Booker T.

The build towards the match is famous for the wrong reasons. Triple H gave a number of promos with questionable content, with thinly-disguised racism sullying the feud at every single turn.

Anyone with even the vaguest understanding of wrestling was ready for Booker to shut the privileged champion up, defeating him and proving him wrong on the biggest stage of them all.

Nope, not quite. Triple H defeated Booker T at WrestleMania, taking everything Booker could throw at him and then defeating him with a Pedigree and a cover that seemed to come an age after.

Despite all of the inherently-offensive things he said in the build up, Triple H was never on the losing end of a battle with Booker T.


1. Seriously, The McMahons NEVER Lose

Dr Hiney Vince McMahon Jr
WWE Network

Jim Ross is arguably the greatest commentator in the history of professional wrestling. Good ol' JR was the voice of WWE television throughout the Attitude Era along with the Ruthless Aggression days, and his voice carried a huge amount of credibility along with it.

He was loyal to the company too, and has always given the impression of being a true company man.

One constant throughout his on-screen career was the total disdain that he would receive from none other than the boss himself, Vincent Kennedy McMahon.

The laundry list of things McMahon has done to JR is long to say the least, from inducting him in to the Kiss My !*$% club, mocking his Bells Palsy condition on television, berating other aspects of his appearance and more.

As far as I'm aware, JR never once got his payback. Sure, he may have reacted in an excited manner when someone was giving McMahon a whipping in the ring, but vicarious payback isn't really payback.

JR is no longer with the company and is unlikely to return in an on-screen capacity, so the chances of retribution here are slim to none.

So remember kids; the McMahons never, ever lose.


Contributor
Contributor

Born in the middle of Wales in the middle of the 1980's, John can't quite remember when he started watching wrestling but he has a terrible feeling that Dino Bravo was involved. Now living in Prague, John spends most of his time trying to work out how Tomohiro Ishii still stands upright. His favourite wrestler of all time is Dean Malenko, but really it is Repo Man. He is the author of 'An Illustrated History of Slavic Misery', the best book about the Slavic people that you haven't yet read. You can get that and others from www.poshlostbooks.com.