7 Ups & 2 Downs From AEW Dynamite (December 20 - Results & Review)
Mark Briscoe is a delight on a show with a great plot development wasted...
After a putrid stretch of television in the build towards Full Gear, the Continental Classic has done much to restore faith in AEW's creative process.
Where for much of 2023, fans seemed happy to accept Daniel Garcia's comedy prelim role as a thrusting meme, his C2 arc - of the wrestler within surfacing more with every loss, each more narrow than the last - has raised his stock immeasurably. Several wrestlers have won three consecutive matches in AEW this year - but because his wins were framed to really matter, and awarded with points, Andrade el Idolo has never felt more like a concern in the promotion. His brute force and motivated performance levels have helped too; the great thing about a round robin tournament is that it is a competition within a competition. The characters want to win it; the wrestlers want to steal it.
Bryan Danielson sold an entire arena on a worked injury and has flitted seamlessly between sadist bully and undying underdog. Claudio Castagnoli has been on fire too, displaying his mutant strength and, against Eddie Kingston, panicked urgency. Even in taking two losses, the awesome Brody King feels like an otherworldly horror.
You'll notice that every name mentioned above is part of the Blue League.
Did the Dynamite-exclusive Gold League finally have a night worthy of stealing Collision's buzz...?
Downs...
2. Feeling Not Exactly Restored
Komander wants to keep his momentum going by running through Roderick Strong!
Watch #AEWDynamite: #HolidayBash LIVE on TBS!@KomandercrMX pic.twitter.com/oQM4PYzp65
— All Elite Wrestling (@AEW) December 21, 2023
You might think, given the ratio of Ups to Downs, that last night's episode of Dynamite was a high quality two hours of television. It was and it wasn't.
The action was mostly very good, and while it's probably unfair or entitled to expect or demand incredible action week after week, that's what's happening over on Collision. The three C2 matches on Dynamite all nestled in the "very good" range, but nothing was truly blow-away great. Nothing was so good that it left you howling, standing and pacing. The C2 has only orbited the heights of peak G1 on Saturdays, and that trend continued last night. The Devil storyline is at this point so bad - mostly - that the stench lingers over everything. Little things continue to grate, too.
Why is Alex Abrahantes the designated "hype man" for virtually every luchador? What's up with the conflation there?
He doesn't do his translator bit anymore. All he does, with his borderline selfish sartorial choices and scenery-chewing body language, is steal focus and make some of the most exciting and eye-catching performers in the company seem infinitely less cool by association.
Mileage varies on the Toni Storm character, even to those prone to enjoying it, but her guest commentary bit is distracting.
In general, the so-called "feeling" AEW is attempting to restore hasn't in fact been restored. It's almost irritating that it's become canon. It is entirely the sort of thing that must be shown and not told.
1. The Devil Storyline Reaches A New Nadir
The mind games continue!
Watch #AEWDynamite: #HolidayBash LIVE on TBS!@SamoaJoe | @The_MJF pic.twitter.com/1ByXuhk2qu
— All Elite Wrestling (@AEW) December 21, 2023
Didn't AEW just do this?
Samoa Joe openly suspected MJF to be the Devil in a live promo segment. He didn't mention how the AEW World title is the prize he must claim to underscore his legacy. He didn't create a wonderful, bloody image of MJF to sell a grudge match worth paying for. He suspected that MJF was the Devil. For the second consecutive pay-per-view cycle, the identity of the Devil and a goofy-looking mystery has taken precedent over the top prize in the sports league.
MJF arrived on the scene to accuse Joe of being the Devil, and can this fellow please take off his mask so that AEW can then book a proper World title match?
MJF at least had a killer line here, saying that Joe cared about protecting him as much as he cared about his diet. Just the intonation of "diet" here was a reminder of how superb MJF was in the heel role. The Masked Men surrounded the ring as soon as MJF and Joe threatened to come to blows. MJF and Joe sent them fleeing, but didn't attempt to remove their masks. Yet more Masked Men, who look like Dark Order creepers for Christ's sake, surrounded them as a message played on the screen. Once again, the Devil challenged MJF to an ROH World Tag Team title match.
Again: hasn't this challenge already happened?
And didn't the match not happen because the Masked Men attacked MJF beforehand? Do the Masked Men actually want to win gold, and if not, what the f*ck are they doing in a wrestling company? On that note, how can Tony Khan possibly sanction this? The Masked Men can't be trusted. They could very well assault MJF before the bell yet again. Why would Khan risk the health of his World champion ahead of an important pay-per-view?
Then again, he could always get someone more injured to replace him. Shame Charlotte Flair just re-signed with WWE, she'd have been perfect apparently.
End this Devil business now.
It is extravagantly stupid.
Mostly...
Ups...
7. Credit Where It's Rarely Given
Riho hasn’t lost a step!
Watch #AEWDynamite: #HolidayBash LIVE on TBS!@Saraya | #Riho pic.twitter.com/9chMqMleXI
— All Elite Wrestling (@AEW) December 21, 2023
Riho Vs. Saraya was surprisingly fine, but perhaps that shouldn't be a surprise.
Saraya hasn't exactly repaid the investment in both salary and more importantly time, since her failure to get over was rewarded by her becoming the fulcrum of the entire division, but she has entered a handful of serviceable to outright good performances since All In: London.
This was closer to the former, in truth, though Saraya does a good, low-key "Karen". It's really quite infuriating listening to her scream for no reason at the top of her lungs, and her grasp of the facial expression never gets the credit it should. Action-wise, this was only fair, but Saraya bumped with zero ego and did a job that left no ambiguity whatsoever over who the better wrestler was on the night. Riho's finishing flurry looked very good at least, the top-rope foot stomp in particular.
It's weirdly fashionable to bury Saraya, but she is almost antithetical to the entitled self-anointed saviour figure who first walked into the promotion. She does jobs the right way. Perhaps some of her ex-WWE contemporaries can learn a thing or two from her.
Toni Storm provided commentary, to uneven effect - though her resigned "And speaking of t*ts, Saraya looks like she's about to win" line was excellent.
6. Good Match, Yet Another Bad Devil-Related Promo
Komander takes out Roddy and #TheKingdom!
Watch #AEWDynamite: #HolidayBash LIVE on TBS!@RoderickStrong | @KomandercrMX pic.twitter.com/2LI0YZqV3w
— All Elite Wrestling (@AEW) December 21, 2023
Roderick Strong defeated Komander in a brief, good match that presumably existed to remind you that he will interact with MJF in a major way at some point. Then again, he's been at this thing for months, and the only thing he's done is rise out of his wheelchair.
In what was either a great moment of improvisation or serendipity, Komander lost his footing flipping over Strong, but he lured him into the ropes after stumbling backwards. Whether intended or not, the match felt like a good, convincing struggle in that moment. Tony Khan remains a very good matchmaker, and he likely suspected that Komander would take a quite incredible End of Heartache.
The reason for the match revealed itself when Komander flip-rotated before jarring his spine across Strong's knee in a wonderful EoH variation. Awesome finish.
In a post-match promo, Strong ranted and raved about MJF being the Devil in his comedy voice, screaming every other word. It wasn't funny, and part of the problem with this entire main event storyline is that it's so frivolous. The Masked Men look like sh*t, and the Strong subplot is played for pure comedy. It's as if AEW is actively doing everything in their power, like their very lives depended on it, to make the Devil - this character is named after Satan himself! - not feel remotely intimidating.
It's a shame because, as will be covered shortly, the actual plotting isn't half-bad...
5. A Fun Use Of Tony Schiavone
Tony Schiavone will read a prepared statement from TNT Champion Christian Cage!
Watch #AEWDynamite: #HolidayBash LIVE on TBS!@tonyschiavone24 | @Christian4Peeps pic.twitter.com/3YLHNEVkZx
— All Elite Wrestling (@AEW) December 21, 2023
In his absence from the building, Christian Cage asked Tony Schiavone to read a prepared statement on his behalf. The general crux of it was that he is going to respond to Adam Copeland's challenge for a No DQ TNT title rematch on Collision.
Schiavone's performance was brilliant, though, and the idea to juxtapose Cage's vile words with Tony's warm, honeyed delivery was inspired comedy - much funnier than the broader fare that has polluted the company elsewhere over the last few months.
Cage wrote in his promo that if Schiavone phones it in "like usual" - quality - he'd "slap the yellow off his teeth" the next time he saw him. At the end of the promo, in another great touch, Cage's music played.
The whole "Christian has a great mind for the business" thing is hardly insightful at this point, but delivering a high point of a show he wasn't even present for is something else.
4. Good Use Of Plotting
"Are you the Devil?" - #AEW World Champion MJF to Swerve.
Watch #AEWDynamite: #HolidayBash LIVE on TBS!@The_MJF | @swerveconfident pic.twitter.com/MFGHL9QSOY
— All Elite Wrestling (@AEW) December 21, 2023
After speaking with Joe again backstage, MJF discovered a Masked Men mask outside of the Mogul Embassy's dressing room door - one presumably placed there by the actual Devil to implicate Swerve Strickland.
This led to a verbal exchange between MJF and Swerve which, while heavy on the exposition, was well-performed. The idea that Swerve's dual obsessions with Hangman Page and the AEW World title pin him as a potential suspect was really quite inspired, as was the first tease of what could and should be the World title match at Revolution. It's almost irritating, this deft use of plotting. Swerve has emerged from out of nowhere as a credible red herring, after the use of Hangman Page in that role last week, and for what? A sub-2019 Dark Order presentation that undermines all of it?
If you can look past the hokey presentation - and you can't - AEW is actually telling an intricate, unpredictable story with some degree of narrative sophistication.
They're just getting in their own way.
3. Very Good Match Misses Its Ceiling Slightly
What a 450 by Swerve but RUSH wasn't having any of it!
It’s the #AEWContinentalClassic: #TournamentForTots on #AEWDynamite LIVE on TBS!@rushtoroblanco | @swerveconfident pic.twitter.com/0tXopC1xd6
— All Elite Wrestling (@AEW) December 21, 2023
Rush Vs. Swerve Strickland was a very good and effective opener.
Both wrestlers had endured storyline injuries throughout the C2 and carried them into this match, which, in addition to it being a straight must-win shoot-out, developed a more palpable sense of urgency and drama as a result. Even when selling - and selling well and with a rare degree of subtlety - Rush is just so awesome at working in beast mode. The story ultimately became one of survival for Swerve - a glimpse, perhaps, into his future as the babyface ace of All Elite Wrestling. Rush was relentless.
Swerve attempted to smash him with a German suplex on the outside, but Rush popped back up and blasted him with a shotgun dropkick. After aggressively targeting Swerve's shoulder, deeper in the match, Rush kicked out of a 450 splash at one. While this was a cool spot in and of itself, it's been done a few too many times in the C2 alone. Everybody is chasing the pop that Kenny Omega generated at Forbidden Door II and a point of diminishing returns is imminent. It might be time for Tony Khan to intervene and relay strict instructions to his team of agents.
Still, on this occasion, it worked to make Rush seem undeniable on the night. The match was very familiar to a lot of Gold League fare structurally, with its chop battles and double downs and apron spots and the like, but it was hot, the crowd was lively, and Swerve continued to wrestle like the Ace elect. His darting for a submission as soon as Rush hit his tranquilo pose was smart, defiant babyface work.
Swerve went over, leaving it up to Jay White to deliver later in the show.
2. Dramatic Main Event
Can Jon Moxley finish the sweep?
It’s the #AEWContinentalClassic: #TournamentForTots on #AEWDynamite LIVE on TBS!@JayWhiteNZ | @JonMoxley pic.twitter.com/940cbZxOCT
— All Elite Wrestling (@AEW) December 21, 2023
Jon Moxley Vs. Jay White followed a familiar pattern: it was very, very good without hitting that Blue League high.
In a great sequence, one that played with the idea that this was almost a New Japan match in an AEW ring, Mox did Gedo's beloved count-out tease. He dashed back into the ring at the last moment, and in a superb twist lulled White into the Paradigm Shift, having set the trap by walking into the Blade Runner set-up with the intention of reversing it. That was a scorcher of a near-fall.
Rules are set in fiction so that, when they are eventually broken, the impact resonates all the more. The C2 has been framed as a clean, competitive battlefield, and so, when Jay White managed to sneak in a chair shot to further damage Mox's leg, it actually felt like a rare, unpopular heel transgression.
This is the way forward, or rather the way back to the feeling: a sporting framework, wins visually represented by points or scaling the rankings, a clean finish-heavy approach that allows every match to hold meaning, for cheating to actually retain the old power.
Conceptually, the main event - won by Jay, setting up a three-way final between him, Mox and Swerve next week - was excellent. Some of the exchanges were a tad lethargic, and so it wasn't on the level of the best G1 matches, but it was refreshing.
1. Belt Up Mark Briscoe
Mark Briscoe has nothing to lose!
It’s the #AEWContinentalClassic: #TournamentForTots on #AEWDynamite LIVE on TBS!@SussexCoChicken | @TheLethalJay pic.twitter.com/YJ7hk6Yrj0
— All Elite Wrestling (@AEW) December 21, 2023
Imagine having Mark Briscoe on your roster.
He's an ageless, incredible worker who doesn't even need a mastery of playing babyface, because he's so inherently likeable, but has it nonetheless. He is piss-funny. He can do the TV format in his sleep. The guy must win a belt next year. Not that Jay Lethal wasn't very good in this C2 wooden spoon match, but Mark Briscoe is a delight. He elevated a match with zero stakes, that might as well have not happened, against an opponent whose work can be dry on occasion, into the most entertaining segment of Dynamite this week. It was a riot.
After Lethal had an answer for redneck kung fu, and attempted to flatten Mark with a dive, he was caught mid-attack. Mark turned it into a suplex on the floor. He then commanded the best atmosphere felt throughout the entire Gold League - in a pointless match against Jay Lethal - with his sensational babyface stylings. He first borrowed a ringside fan's hat and celebrated with him, just casually making someone's life, before attempting over and over and over again to throw a chair in the ring. This was a great, irreverent running gag because, within the strict confines of the C2, it made no sense to do it even once. Eventually, Mark propped it up and launched himself from it, Sabu-style, to smash Lethal with a somersault plancha on the outside. A trusting Lethal ate it so well. This was just one of several moments in which their chemistry was on full, striking display.
Mark won with the Jay Driller after talking one of his own, which looked a bit more brutal than intended. Still, it helped the drama of the near-fall, if nothing else. Belt the guy up.
He's the best.