7 Ups & 2 Downs From AEW Dynamite (January 17 - Results & Review)
Samoa Joe retains, HOOK ascends, and the Young Bucks go CORPORATE on another strong Dynamite...
Samoa Joe Vs. HOOK was the main selling point of Dynamite last night.
That had nothing to do with the hysterical tribalist nonsense on X over whether HOOK was a better wrestler than Jinder Mahal or a more worthy title challenger than Jinder Mahal. It had everything to do with HOOK and what he can do and how far he can go. Wrestling isn't (or shouldn't) be a relentlessly tedious pissing contest. It is a star-creation enterprise, and HOOK is both a star and not.
A prodigy, the most youthful presence in all of wrestling in late 2021, his career has stuttered since. An incredibly unique and enigmatic character with a captivating judo-inspired style and frightening agility, AEW was his to inherit, it seemed - but that overloaded roster manifested with yet another problem. There was nowhere for HOOK to really go, and where he should have gone on excursion somewhere, Tony Khan instead booked him to buddy up with various babyfaces in irreverent side quests. HOOKhausen was meant to be a fun exercise in juxtaposition, but it was very lightweight, and HOOK didn't quite have the aura to withstand it. He became everybody's moody, reluctant mate, which defeated the purpose by the end. It was no longer special, getting the rub from the cool loner, since Khan ran that device into the ground.
It was much too early in his career for his first World title match for it to act as a referendum on HOOK - but it was a test of his main event credentials, all the same...
Downs...
2. An Understandably Rusty Match
Top Flight Vs. Private Party was, rather fittingly, very spotty in every way. It wasn't electrifying. It was, if anything, strong evidence of how great the Young Bucks are.
Even if you don't like the style necessarily, you cannot possibly argue in good faith that they aren't the best to have ever practised it. Matt and Nick - sorry, Matthew and Nicholas - have worked matches with both teams that were better than this by orders of magnitude. At points, this match briefly flirted with its own potential. Darius Martin was on fine form with his eye-catching creativity; his stereo DDT and reverse DDT spot are fantastic in particular. The overall experience however was undermined by a nagging sense of awkwardness. The complexity of the layout was rarely met with hermetic execution. This was understandable.
It was Marq Quen's first match after a torn pectoral tendon had ruled him out of action since December 2022. He didn't look as sharp as he will in a few months (that's if he receives consistent opportunities to shake off the rust, never a guarantee in AEW). A show-down with the Hardys looks likely. Keep that to Rampage.
Complaining about not being on Dynamite should not be a ticket to Dynamite.
1. Another Typical Night In The AEW Women's Division
Deonna Purrazzo Vs. Anna Jay wasn't as good as the former's reintroduction against Red Velvet. In her match, Velvet dared go for hold-for-hold with the submission specialist, who punished her insolence with a dominant introducory showing.
Here, Jay actually managed to get the advantage in an early cradle trade-off before the match settled, bleakly, into Dynamite Autopilot: presumed loser actually gets in a lot of offence before the expected result happens. It might have worked on its own misjudged terms, but in a further issue, Jay just wasn't as sharp on the mat as her opponent.
It's very early for all that numbing back-and-forth, which was so even that Purrazzo's Venus de Milo submission win felt anticlimactic, it was applied so shortly after a forearm exchange. Purrazzo should at this point be the unsolvable puzzle that Toni can't begin to approach.
Instead, she is already victim of the picture-and-butchering that is life in the AEW women's division.
Ups...
7. Just OK
Bullet Club Gold Vs. Mogul Embassy was fine, acting as a backdrop for a further tease of a 'Bang Bang Scissors Gang' stable alongside the Acclaimed, who neutralised the interference of Prince Nana to strengthen their pitch.
It was the sort of match nobody will ever remember but was decent enough in the moment. The Gates of Agony are a fun meathead team, and the Gunns are good flailing bumpers. That dynamic was just about inspired enough to stop you from reaching for a distraction on your phone. It was a touch more interesting watching Jay White play situational babyface.
It’s a role in which he's probably miscast, but he's a very intelligent wrestler, a key babyface attribute that might help him slide into the role. The fans enjoyed how he lulled Bishop Kaun into the Blade Runner for the finish.
The action wasn't spectacular, though the match was packed with it - but the idea of a juxtaposed babyface supergroup going up against a heel stable with no juice is the sort of convoluted move Tony Khan should leave in 2023.
6. Toni Storm Is Back On Form
While the one women's match of the week was misjudged structurally, and a bit slow in execution, the post-match was amusing.
Toni Storm again provided colour commentary duties, and was on decent form, after which Deonna grabbed a microphone and wondered aloud what had happened to somebody she used to consider a sister. Storm refused to answer this plea to re-enter reality and instead mocked Donna's fake tan. Storm also - and this was vulgar but brilliant - said "I ought to march into that ring and sock you in the box!"
Storm has an absolutely incredible knack for exhuming very funny words that have rarely been uttered on North American wrestling television, conjuring delightful mental images, and it's in character. She is meant to be a saucy and outrageous old Hollywood dame.
This moment, however small, was prime Dynamite vibe - it was legitimately funny, and the anti-synthetic appeal of old surfaced when Renee almost lost it and had to compose herself.
5. A Fun Sprint...BUT...
Orange Cassidy and Trent Vs. Penta El Zero Miedo and Komander was fun, if a bit of a clichéd and by this point over-familiar Dynamite match.
It broke down, and often, with minimal discipline to old tag rules, the dives were relentless, and it might shock you to read that Penta executed a Canadian destroyer (though the variation in which he used his partner as a launchpad is always really cool). The sort of superficial thrill that felt like an awesome novelty on cable in 2019, in 2024, much of that charm has diminished. There was nothing actively wrong with it - hence its inclusion in the 'Ups' column - but it was just there, mostly.
It was a very Dynamite match and very Dynamite segment overall: it only existed as a backdrop for Roderick Strong to challenge Orange Cassidy for the International title at Revolution. There has to be a different way of telling stories. This was route one.
Happily, though, AEW has deviated from 2023 form and either announced a not-inconsiderable portion of the Revolution card six weeks in advance, or all but told you what is happening. This is reassuring: it's as if Khan has finally listened to the complaints about the tepid PPV builds last year and is telling you to expect more compelling twists and turns along the way.
4. Could The Young Bucks Be Back?
It says something damning when the Young Bucks taking their jobs more seriously is the most shocking plot twist they've been involved in since 2021.
They - now going by Matthew and Nicholas, the disruptors now embracing a sort of corporate detachment - were interviewed in a sit-down by Renee Paquette, who was typically great at trying to suppress her inner despair with a veneer of professionalism. Matthew, touching on the events of Brawl Out, explained that while Sting himself is a stand-up pro, he represents a generation of "cancerous" wrestlers that AEW should have stamped out before the promotion lost its way. It was a strong verbal performance, even if the link between Sting and CM Punk was a bit tenuous.
Matthew was great at playing it sanctimoniously, reframing himself with an almost Christ-like selflessness for building a company that can give a cheque to someone like Renee beyond just the one viable major league. He told her she was welcome in a good bit of bastardry.
There's a danger here that AEW flirts with the WWE move of all WWE moves - the heel authority figure - but for the first time in a long time, "let it play out" can be applied here.
The Bucks are finally moving in a very intriguing and different direction.
3. God Bless The Briscoes
Last night's Dynamite marked the one year anniversary of Jay Briscoe's tragic passing.
In a very touching segment, Mark Briscoe came out by the set to remind fans of that and put over Dem Boys. In a quite incredible moment, he also reminded the fans that Jay's daughters were also in the car crash that claimed his life, and that the doctors warned that his eldest daughter, Gracie - having lost movement below her knees - may never walk again. She then walked out, to an enormous pop, and I burst into tears at the strength and perseverance she showed. It was life-affirming, honestly.
A beautiful, beautiful moment.
2. Exquisite CRAFT
Christian Cage Vs. Dustin Rhodes was a gripping opener brimming with an utterly refreshing sense of craft.
At first, the match didn't suggest a vintage Dynamite opening "banger" - but by the finish, Rhodes and Cage generated two near-falls that will likely last longer in the memory than most. That is the hallmark of two old masters.
Cage's diamond-sharp mind was again on display. He was very tentative in locking up with Dustin early, selling his opponent's strength advantage and the idea that he was destined to lose a fair fight. The fight, as a result, was not fair: Nick Wayne and Killswitch made their presence felt and cheated at various, well-timed moments. Building the drama with an assured sense of pacing, this was worked with a classic sensibility - the sort of match that looks boring written down on paper but was performed to near-perfection. They're just great goddamn wrestlers. You see dives every week. You see too many dives every week. The ageing Dustin scanning the crowd, silently asking them if he can do it, getting that reassurance and dialling up the volume: that's the crowd interaction nous of a master, and Cage choosing that moment to shift the momentum is the work of a genius heel.
It's no wonder the crowd later screamed - they were white-hot for the final third - when Dustin threatened to kick Cage in the balls. He did everything to earn it, the performer and the character. In an exquisite near-fall, Rhodes struck Cage with the Cross Rhodes. The positioning on that spot was incredible. The impact was close enough to the ropes to wrong-foot the crowd into thinking they'd do a rope break, but Cage was revealed to be too far away during the count and at that point a shock title switch felt certain. His 2.99er was also as great as anybody's in that moment.
They got the crowd again with Cage's first, unsuccessful Killswitch attempt - particularly since Dustin looked out on his feet after eating a turnbuckle and selling it in the way it was meant to be sold.
Elegant, disciplined, chop-free, slow-burn pro wrestling action that underscored that less is more: more of this everywhere please.
1. Joe Rules, HOOK Belongs
Samoa Joe Vs. HOOK was a perfect end-to-end presentation.
AEW by their weirdly apathetic standards promoted this big as a major hook at the beginning of the broadcast. HOOK's awesome, nihilistic rain-soaked social media promo was screened alongside a replay of Joe's fantastic champion's inauguration last week. Both champion and challenger were shown entering the building to further lend the match the big fight feeling. The hype was real and AEW probably should have done more to sell something that had captured the imagination of the public.
The match itself was tremendous, another simple story perfectly told, like the opener but also not at all. The range on the bookends of this show was so wonderful that the filler spot-fest quality in the middle was all the more pronounced.
Crucially, until he really got the crowd on side, HOOK only launched into brief offensive flurries by flying into Joe. He was the helicopter; Joe was King Kong. HOOK attempted flying clotheslines using the barricade and the apron, but he was for a while woefully outmatched. Joe demonstrated this, brutally, by rocking HOOK with a gruesome uranage on the announce desk. HOOK skimmed it skull-first and the thing still broke. In just one defence, Joe restored the transgressive meaning of the commentary table wreckage spot. That's aura.
He then basted HOOK with a powerbomb on the apron in another familiar scene that his awesome presence elevated. He tried to put HOOK away with a Muscle Buster, but HOOK - glowing with an aura of his own - kicked out at one. That was awesome, earned, and while HOOK's subsequent barrage of flying clotheslines didn't feel all that snug, that only added to the sense of pathos. He wasn't really ready for Joe, but came across as a badass for trying and for surviving for as long as he did. Paul Heyman once said that, in the perfect match, one wrestler goes over and their opponent gets over. AEW tries this a lot, possibly too often, but this was exactly that.
In the post-match, in a deft touch, Khan both further teased a rare interesting and logical three-way at Revolution between Joe, Hangman Page and Swerve Strickland - but also, via Page's post-match endorsement of HOOK, gave the challenger his well-earned moment.
Dynamite's excellent 2024 form continues.