7 Ups & 2 Downs From AEW Dynamite (June 5 - Results & Review)

MJF returns as the babyface he should have played last year on a promising episode.

5 6 Swerve Strickland Roderick Strong
AEW

While AEW is in the process of building towards Forbidden Door, it is Blood & Guts that can't come soon enough. (The annual Dynamite special has yet to be announced, but by AEW standards is a ratings hit and hot ticket. AEW would be daft not to do it, even if the match has never reached its artistic ceiling).

This Tony Khan Vs. the Elite power struggle angle simply isn't working. AEW didn't commit to it. It scanned as a ratings stunt - a well thought-out ratings stunt, but a stunt all the same. Hasn't it already been resolved?

Tony Khan is now back, healed, and manning the Go position. The Young Bucks apparently signed an ironclad contract stipulating that they'd run the show in Khan's absence, but he's no longer absent. That he couldn't run Dynamite remotely was a stretch to begin with, and the Bucks didn't bother to shape Dynamite in their image, much less Collision. The shows, largely, have unfolded as they would have had Khan never taken that Tony Khan Driver.

As a heckled Dax Harwood discovered on Collision over the weekend, the fanbase would rather be shown that AEW is still great, and not told. This war for AEW's soul angle is passé.

What's frustrating is that, were the act not linked to this illogical slant on a tiresome authority figure angle, the Elite would be tremendous. Kazuchika Okada maximises his seconds, Nicholas Jackson is a delightful ham, Jack Perry feels refreshed, and Matthew Jackson - "Every time this song plays it costs us like $200,000" - has never been funnier.

It's time the Elite simply become a gang of pricks.

Is the end of a failed experiment in sight...?


Downs...

2. Who's The Boss?

5 6 Christopher Daniels
AEW

The Acclaimed aren't ideal short-term title challengers for the Young Bucks.

The act is barely over. They are overexposed, and Max Caster has compounded the lack of goodwill with his senseless social media conduct and raps that even for him were tasteless. Billy Gunn's parody of the veteran who won't sell hasn't remotely helped either.

The Acclaimed motioned to make their entrance, but the Young Bucks appeared on the big screen to tell them, petulantly, that their segment had been cut, Matthew Jackson sought to fill the plot hole by saying "We still have a little stroke around here".

Do they?

Because Tony Khan is back and healed and, moreover, Christopher Daniels is playing a second babyface authority figure. A wildly unnecessary authority figure: why does AEW need somebody to tell the audience that a match is happening and why, when they've not done this for five years?

Who's in charge?

And why, since the show is basically the same as it ever was, should anybody care?


1. Chris Jericho Remains At Large

Chris Jericho Big Bill Bryan Keith Learning Tree AEW
AEW

Chris Jericho, who continued his zombie shuffle of an AEW run, was followed around the arena by a camera crew throughout the show.

In the running gag, Jericho, with a new ultra over-the-top disingenuous happy guy voice, offered his advice on virtually everything. He told the camera operator how to hold their equipment and even told somebody how to correctly fill their bowl in catering. That might have scanned as funny in 2020. That Jericho thought somebody would even need to learn how to do this is the sort of irreverent gag at which AEW once excelled. But this version of Chris Jericho is awful and unwanted.

He was flanked by Learning Tree "branches" Big Bill and Bryan Keith. Bill is wasted in this role - he was infinitely funnier when he got weird with it during his in-ring heat sequences - and Keith isn't crazed nor intense enough to play the hothead bad cop gimmick. He lacks the comedic timing, too. It's almost as if he's been shoehorned into something that doesn't suit him because Jericho thinks it will do him good. We've been here before, and it derailed a man's promising career. This is death. Jericho's new voice is a physical agony. He is a cartoon worse than new Simpsons.

But it's working, guys! You're supposed to hate it! You're not meant to enjoy yourself!


Ups...

7. All About Mariah Enters Third Act

Saraya Mariah May
AEW

To much online controversy, Saraya defeated Mariah May.

While this initially scanned as late 2010s WWE booking move, it made sense in the context of the wider storyline between May and Toni Storm (granted, Saraya seems unlikely to do much with the win). In the recent past, Storm threw in the towel on May's behalf in a match against Serena Deeb. Here, she believed in May's ability to withstand the pain of Saraya's chicken wing sharpshooter. She could not, and tapped. This was a gesture of support and a show of confidence, but it could well scan to May - who has another mother onto whom she can...latch - as a callous act of parental neglect.

The action and flow of the match itself wasn't great, but Saraya at least knows how to play heel in the selfless, traditional way. Too few wrestlers do. She generated a solid atmosphere with her stalling and deception. She's washed but she knows a few more tricks than many seem willing to admit.

It's a silly but entertaining storyline, this twisted psychosexual drama, but the finish here makes sense within it. In the post-match, Mina Shirakawa fended off Saraya and Harley Cameron's attack. May didn't know where to turn as both Storm and Shirakawa bumped up against one another and presented their bosoms to their child/love interest (!).

It's a trifle weird, but the performers are clearing loving it.


6. Mark Briscoe Elevates Solid Match

5 6 Mark Briscoe Brian Cage
AEW

Even though it's a mess of his own making, you have to sympathise with Tony Khan to an extent. He signed far too many wrestlers, many of which he couldn't not sign on a case-by-case basis - you couldn't just let WWE have Will Ospreay - and now he struggles with who exactly to push.

Rush?

Konosuke Takeshita?

Daniel Garcia?

Jay White?

Who, outside of the established main event bracket, is truly worth the investment?

It's a hard decision, but Mark Briscoe makes it easier every single time he appears on TV. Structurally, this was a very familiar match in which the underdog babyface survives the hoss monster. Everything more or less happened in the "correct" order. It should have been predictable and bereft of drama, particularly since Brian Cage is one of Khan's trusted glorified enhancement talents, but Mark Briscoe is incredible. He has such a bump on him and such an ability to work the crowd that Cage's Liger bomb looked like a kill-shot.

Briscoe won with the Froggy 'bow and the crowd exploded not because they didn't expect the finish but because they badly wanted to see it. At an absolute minimum, AEW should position Briscoe on the slow-burn chase to a midcard title. The crowd is in love with the guy.

He wears every single babyface characteristic so well.


5. Wheeler YUTA Is Back

5 6 Wheeler YUTA
AEW

The Blackpool Combat Club defeated a CMLL four-man unit of Magnus, Volador Jr., Esfinge and Rugido. It was essentially a welcome back match for the returning Wheeler YUTA, who took the pinfall win. It more or less existed just to be nice, but it had the decency to turn into something very exciting in the second half after the odd awkward blip in the first.

The exchange between Claudio Castagnoli and Esfinge sparked the match into life. Claudio, it won't surprise you, was once again fantastic in the lucha environment. He took two monkey flips from Esfinge. Both times, he flew across the breadth of the ring and, allowing his opponent to look like a threat, only tucked his neck at the very last second. Volador Jr is incredible, like PAC doing Manami Toyota in his physical movements with his sensational float-over Code Red. The match was built around YUTA, who was up to the task of starring in it.

Weirdly, Bryan Danielson was mostly anonymous and Jon Moxley undermined the flow and excitement by telegraphing certain spots with some obvious positioning. This was a very unnecessary end to a feud that was thought done months ago. Most seemed to accept that it went 50/50 in the end, as a politically delicate novelty.

A great deal of fun regardless - mostly,


4. All-Action Four-Way Is Welcome Surprise

5 6 Rey Fenix
AEW

In a rare development, the winner of an AEW television match wasn't all but guaranteed.

Fénix, Kyle O'Reilly, and Orange Cassidy all competed for the opportunity to pin Jay Lethal in a four-way held to determine the #1 contender to the International title. In that respect, the finish was obvious, but the three babyfaces all held a claim.

O'Reilly is one more near-miss away from potentially turning heel; Cassidy is always in the mix and a sequel against Will Ospreay could have functioned as a way of reminding the audience about the magic of Forbidden Door; Fénix has just returned from a lengthy layoff and was the dream match pick.

Fénix won, which was the correct choice. The prospect of a TV Match of the Year contender next week is thrilling.

It was O'Reilly who was the star of the match, however; his venus fly trap submission game worked wonderfully here as he shifted the momentum and scored several near-falls by ensnaring the various flying bodies raining down on him. The action was paced brilliantly in a short-ish match that didn't muck about; in one scorching sequence, Fénix dove feet-first onto Kyle the second that he'd applied an arm-bar.

A very good sprint with a promise of something mind-blowing next week.


3. MJF Returns With Killer Promo

5 6 MJF
AEW

MJF opened the show with a promo. He was masterful.

He teased several potentially incredible matches, but not in an obvious way. He established his credentials as the best in the world, drawing the ire of one of his targets later in the night. He said Kazuchika Okada can't be the best, since he can't be arsed to buy a gym membership. He said Swerve Strickland can't be the best; his promos aren't good enough. He also - with a great mocking accent - said that Will Ospreay can't be the best, bruv, because he hasn't beaten all of the names MJF has throughout his AEW tenure: CM Punk, Bryan Danielson, Chris Jericho, Kenny Omega, Adam Cole, Cody Rhodes, Hiroshi Tanahashi, Jon Moxley...

(Jericho's star has fallen from such a steep height that the mention of his name amongst this crop was almost surreal).

MJF's dig at Ospreay's teeth was hardly imaginative, but it was well-delivered. Rush interrupted, and again, MJF did the thing you have to do, but not in a way that felt forced. When he put Rush over, he did so with such conviction that he actually elevated his imminent opponent without just ticking off the checklist. MJF likely hand-picked Rush on this evidence.

In a welcome deviation from the traditional MJF interview segment, Rush didn't trade barbs in a formal back-and-forth. He lunged at him, sparking a rare good pull-apart brawl. Rush is the perfect opponent with which to unleash MJF's promised new babyface act. He said he won't do kangaroo kicks anymore. Instead, it's looking like he's going to narrowly survive an absolute pasting.

A potent injection of star presence, and an excellent tease of MJF's short and long-term directions. A home run of a TV return.


2. The Summer Is Looking Hot

5 6 MJF 2
AEW

MJF cut his promo in the opening segment where, just prior to the main event, Bryan Danielson vowed to reverse his big match form and win this year's Owen Hart Cup - the victor of which will challenge the World Champion at All In: London.

Swerve Strickland in his backstage interview meanwhile promised to deal with MJF later. He said "MJF, you little bitch!" with a wonderful, sinister faux-sincerity that was infinitely funnier than Chris Jericho's bullsh*t. Remember when Jon Moxley took an ax to the "GFY" by telling a heckler to go f*ck himself? That was the margin here.

These developments hinted at the main event and semi main event of All In II: Will Ospreay Vs. Bryan Danielson II, and MJF Vs. Swerve Strickland. If that is indeed the direction, Tony Khan has responded to the critics who savaged last year's edition for its lack of major singles attractions.

You could argue that telegraphing these matches has undermined the unpredictable and bold Forbidden Door main event - but at long last, the World title scene feels big-time.


1. Very Good Main Event

5 6 Swerve Strickland Roderick Strong
AEW

Swerve Strickland Vs. Roderick Strong was a very good main event - the sort of match that you'd explode for in 2019, but in 2024 you've been spoiled by.

Swerve is sometimes one of the most dazzling hybrid style athletes ever. Here, he executed a walking handstand and took Strong down with a headscissors in one fluid motion. It looked unreal. At other times, and it's really not too often, Swerve's stuff can look a little landfill PWG. His awkward slow-motion forward roll into a flatliner looked particularly slow and contrived here. Worse still, this was the moment chosen for the double down and the bit where they asked the crowd to give it up. A killer finishing stretch elevated the match and the atmosphere.

In one gruesome moment, Strong executed a release suplex onto the apron, and the back of Swerve's rotated head clipped it. That was a wild, crucial moment, a wild tweak on the trope got the crowd back. Roderick Strong joins Hangman Page in the short list of wrestlers who can position themselves for the Swerve Stomp as if they're not politely accepting their fate. Swerve attempted to boot Strong out of the ring. Strong, and he did this expertly so that it didn't look at all phony, found his foot stuck under the rope. Swerve's connection was beautiful, and he quickly retained the World title with the House Call.

Another very good night for Swerve, on the whole.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!