7 Ups & 2 Downs From WWE Elimination Chamber 2023
This ain't the first WWE heartbreak in Montreal, but it'll live with Sami Zayn forever.
"Sami looks disappointed, but he has nothing to be disappointed about".
That one line on commentary from Michael Cole almost earned WWE's Elimination Chamber 2023 pay-per-view a third 'Down'. It was a senseless moment from the lead play-by-play man. What did he mean Sami Zayn had "nothing to be disappointed about"? He'd just lost the chance to punch his ticket to WrestleMania and tear down Roman Reigns.
Thankfully, this year's Chamber show was better than that announcing brain fart. The night felt like a one match card going in, but both titular gimmick bouts delivered way more than anyone had any right to reasonably expect they would, and WWE took the opportunity to set up at least one major 'Mania grudge match.
Sami's quest to become Undisputed Champ was the main course. His genius underdog story was ably backed by everyone from Roman and The Usos to Paul Heyman and Kevin Owens. Meanwhile, a hot Montreal live crowd devoured every second like they were having the time of their lives.
Here's all the good and bad from a memorable pitstop en route to April's surely-stunning 'Mania weekender.
Downs...
2. Not Sure What To Think
Sorry, but Brock Lesnar vs. Bobby Lashley has to get a 'Down' for the finish alone.
Both guys went at one another like monsters battling it out for supremacy, and they didn't waste time with headlocks, chain wrestling or anything of the sort. Instead, Brock hits lots of F5s, Lashley hit lots of spears, and his Hurt Lock caused Lesnar to kick Bob in the balls for the disqualification.
It was better for being on the shorter side, but...the finish was questionable. This was a revived feud running on fumes before Elimination Chamber, and now WWE will probably try to squeeze yet another match out of it at WrestleMania 39. Or, will they? Bray Wyatt is looming in the background and challenged the winner.
Technically, that'd be Lashley, but Brock is a more likely opponent. WWE painted themselves into a corner a bit here, and it's difficult to see another brawl (even one backed by a gimmick) carrying much water on either night in April. The sudden Wyatt inclusion feels kinda clumsy now too.
1. Where Do You Go From Here?
"Where do you go from here?" was also applicable to the Judgment Day vs. Edge and Beth Phoenix situation on Saturday night. It's pretty weird that WWE decided to have Edge pin Finn Bálor, 'cause now creative has nowhere to go with that rivalry, and it's not like either guy has anything else in the pipeline for 'Mania.
Also, Rhea Ripley. Remember her? The Royal Rumble winner was a secondary concern at Chamber, and even struggled to match up against a legend like Beth. Surely the right result was having Rhea rip through Phoenix on her way to challenging Charlotte Flair in April?
The match was far from bad, but it was another puzzling finish that held it back. There was an awkward ref moment too - Ripley clocked Edge with some brass knuckles, but Beth was late for the save. Edge had to halfheartedly kick out, and the ref stopped his count.
The whole segment was a slight miss.
Ups...
7. In The Right Spot
Your writer is genuinely shocked that this made the 'Ups', but here we are.
Being honest, the women's Chamber bout had to open the card. It was definitely the weaker-looking of the two gimmick scraps going in, and no amount of hyperbole about who'd challenge Bianca Belair at 'Mania could elevate workers like Natalya or Carmella in the eyes of the fans.
Cheerfully, everyone worked well together and played their roles well. Special praise must go to Liv Morgan and Nattie for keeping the energy up during the first five minutes of the match, and to Nikki Cross for taking her lumps and giving the match that violent edge it sorely needed.
Was this a Chamber classic people will talk about for years? Hardly, but it was a pleasant surprise on the night and didn't tank the way some feared it might. Nabbing that opening slot 100% helped things, and so did the rowdy live crowd up north.
6. The Only Choice
Any smart betting man or woman would've put mouth and money on Asuka coming out on top and marching on to a clash with Belair at 'Mania. The clown-faced Japanese stalwart was really WWE's only choice on Saturday, if only because nobody else would've measured up to Bianca.
Sometimes, going the obvious road with booking is the best plan.
Asuka vs. Belair should be a fun addition to either night at WrestleMania 39, although it does come across as lower key for Bianca than her past few 'Mania matches have been. It's absolutely the least-essential women's match confirmed for the card right now, put it that way.
Still, it was lovely to see WWE come through for Asuka and view her as someone who can get the job done when they're in a tight spot creatively. Raquel Rodriguez was the outside bet, but she'll have to wait for her moment. It's coming later this year, at least.
5. Way Better Than Predicted
Being brutally honest, this fan wasn't up for the men's Chamber match before it started. The match completely exceeded expectations by delivering a fun sprint through some seriously cool spots. Christ, this was like a WWE 2K23 car crash of big bumps, and that's meant as a compliment.
Montez Ford's Spider-Man impression from the top of the structure was incredible, and Johnny Gargano's hurricanrana from atop one of the Chamber pods was frankly insane. In the end, Austin Theory retained (which was the right decision), and the match will be remembered as pure fun from beginning to end.
Take a bow, lads.
This was the best Gargano and Bronson Reed have looked since rejoining WWE. Similarly, Damian Priest got some shine in, and Theory came out looking like an opportunistic heel champion who will eat sh*t next time he isn't bailed out.
4. Giving Seth Rollins An Out
WWE also used the bout to setup a WrestleMania grudge match.
Logan Paul entered the Chamber following Montez Ford's injury angle (which was convincing and might've had a touch of reality to it), then attacked Seth Rollins multiple times with a goofy smile on his face. This was good stuff, and was made better for the searing heat Montreal rained down on LP.
Hardcore pro wrestling fans just hate this guy, and it's awesome to see him embrace it. Having him sneak in the cage as Ford was being helped to the back was a neat way to give Rollins an out and keep things building towards their showdown in April. Win-win - Austin Theory retained and now Seth has another reason to be mad.
It was shrewd of the company to go all in on Paul as a heel. He has this slappable quality to him, and Rollins has been getting huge face reactions anyway. Something suggests these men will produce the goods in SoFi Stadium a little under two months from now.
Can't wait.
3. What A Story!
Sami Zayn and Roman Reigns barely touched for the first few minutes of their match. They didn't need to. The atmosphere inside Montreal's Bell Centre was thick, and both masters knew they could afford to stall/take their time. Then, they produced a slow-burning epic of a story.
This one took twists, turns and didn't rush through a thing.
Roman jawed off with Sami's family at ringside (Zayn's wife was super-into it), and Zayn's hope spots were roared on like the Canadiens were on a momentum-filled comeback in the Stanley Cup finals. Everything felt important, and it was just a really, really strong headliner from minute one.
Sami didn't disappoint in his biggest WWE role yet either. Fingers crossed this is the start of his main event paydays and not a one off, because the dude richly deserves every penny Vince McMahon/Triple H throws at him.
2. Jey Uso’s Part To Play
What a Royal Rumble callback this was.
Jey Uso earned big cheers for stepping between a chair-wielding Reigns and Sami. Crucially, even when he had the chance to, Jey resisted the urge to do an over-the-top wind up motion as if he was going to crack his cousin with the weapon. Instead, he looked utterly conflicted by a Bloodline rift he's been powerless to stop.
Creative can spin this out for a while yet, and now they can use the fact that Zayn accidentally speared Jey too. Man, this storyline continues to sprinkle star dust on everyone involved. It has turned guys like The Usos and Sami into legitimate heavyweight players, and they ain't done yet.
Jey will be understandably p*ssed at Zayn for hammering into his ribs when he'd literally just refused to do Roman's bidding. The greatest tale in pro wrestling has one more layer to it after Chamber, folks. Can this story get any better?!
1. A Taste Of What’s Next
Begrudging looks of respect between Sami and Kevin Owens are nothing new, but there was something different about the one they shared as Elimination Chamber went off the air. A heartbroken Zayn (he was disappointed, Cole!) started to realise that he'd failed to beat Roman, and KO looked legit gutted for his on/off friend.
Next stop: WrestleMania tag-team partners.
That glance or two between the pair was a sign of what's to come, and so was Sami spearing Jey Uso unintentionally. Now, Jimmy can get in his brother's head and claim that Zayn was never properly family. After that, KO and Sami can come together to end The Usos' dominance over the tag division.
The Usos vs. Kevin and Sami is strong enough to headline 'Mania's opening night. It probs won't, but it certainly has the chops to do so if Triple H deems that necessary. Despite Chamber closing doors (hopefully temporarily) on Zayn's main event aspirations, he and his fans still have a lot to look forward to.
Hope out of heartbreak.
What did you think of WWE's Elimination Chamber 2023? For more wrestling, check out 4 Ups & 3 Downs From WWE SmackDown (Feb 17) and 3 Ups & 5 Downs From AEW Rampage: Slam Dunk (Feb 17)!