7 Ups & 3 Downs From WWE SmackDown (6 Dec - Results & Review)
New tag champs crowned; Kevin Owens attacks Cody Rhodes; WWE's "Transfer Window" announced.

Forget Rikishi, because Kevin Owens is WWE's best 'Bad Man'.
There was a lot to like on this week's SmackDown if you enjoy character advancement, fun angles and great wrestling. Triple H's team served up all three, and the most amazing thing is that this would've been considered a possible down week for the blue brand going in. WWE is coming off Survivor Series: WarGames, so knowledge that Roman Reigns probably wouldn't be there could've been a turn off to some.
Anyone skipping the show because of that missed out. KO brought back a story from Bash In Berlin, Johnny Gargano joined Tommaso Ciampa's heel crusade by cruelly cheating to win the Tag-Team Titles, Chad Gable looked like the second coming of Kurt Angle yet again, and two women's division matches totally ruled. Go out of your way to watch Bianca Belair vs. Piper Niven. Seriously.
One of the bigger stories coming out of Smackers is this new fangled "Transfer Window". Let's call it what it is: It's a different name for the superstar shakeup, and it's rather unnecessary given WWE barely pays attention to their own Draft rules as it is. That was one of three 'Downs' from this week's show - the other pair were admittedly minor, and might actually be one writer grumbling about next to nothing. You can make your own minds up on that.
Opinions are opinions though. Even those minor gripes couldn't stop SmackDown from being another excellent way to spend two hours. The program moved with a pleasing zip, and the mix of top storytelling with solid wrestling action really worked. Sometimes, Trips makes this booking stuff look easy, eh?
Here's all the good and bad.
Downs...
3. The Most Minor Of Gripes

Most minor, sure, but a gripe worth bringing up.
Bianca Belair had taped ribs following events at WarGames. Then, on SmackDown, Piper Niven booted her in the midsection during a quick backstage skit. That set up a match between the pair, which is cool. What wasn't cool? Belair proceeding to dance her way down to ringside smiling from ear to ear. Why? Someone should've had a word with Bianca about that before she went through the curtain - you don't need to dance every time.
Being fair, Belair did repeatedly clutch her ribs before and during the match, but the dancing entrance should've been cut. Selling the injury (and a backstage attack that had literally just happened a short while before) would've been smarter. Again, this is a minor complaint and might be one fan looking into things a little too much, but little things like this add up and matter.
There’s a difference between gritting teeth and fighting through the pain within the context of a match due to adrenaline and needing to do your usual entrance just because it’s expected. It’s a wee bit more annoying ‘cause the ribs played such a huge part in the actual match too. For the record, that bout turned out strong. More on it to come.
Wrestlers have to remember that they're out there to tell stories, not go through the motions and spring into life like a video game character. Would some kids be bummed out if they attended SmackDown and the 'EST' didn't twirl her braid around? Sure, but it would've fit the segment better and positioned Bianca as an injured hero who was up against the odds from the off.
2. Retreading Old Ground

Everyone gets what WWE were going for with Michael Cole interviewing Kevin Owens in his car, and KO trolling Cole by winding up the window was funny, but the segment wasn’t very interesting overall. Neither man said anything new. The whole thing was just Owens ranting about how everyone’s wrong as Cole tried to get a word in. We've heard all of this before in multiple forms and fashions.
Brownie points go to the writers for trying to put a fresh spin on the presentation, but yeah - not sure why they bothered airing this unless Kev was going to attack MC or something. Being totally honest, this guy is not a fan of how WWE dialled back on some of the viciousness after that Randy Orton piledriver on the 8 November episode, but they admittedly made up for that come the end of the night. Fair's fair, and all that.
Back to the promo with Cole.
It was middle of the road. If WWE were going to book something like this, then they needed Owens to drop some sort of bombshell about his match with Cody Rhodes at Saturday Night's Main Event. Sorry, but KO arguing with a play by play announcer like some surly teenager who was about to get grounded didn't cut it.
Thank God this week's SmackDown closed out the way it did. Without that moment, Kevin's night would've been wasted. It's hard to do every time, but it's important that WWE at least tries to make these unique sit down chats mean something. They should always offer something tangible that makes them memorable.
In other words, KO should've gone full blown Kane and set Michael on fire. Only kidding.
1. This “Transfer Window” Business

It's early days, obviously, but this "Transfer Window" thing just sounds like WWE’s latest excuse to nullify their own Draft. Maybe things would be different if wrestlers hadn’t been moving around since April. Sadly, the 2024 Draft was wrecked pretty much straight away, so it’s hard to get pumped for more chat about “ironclad contracts/rosters” in coming weeks and months. Dunno, hopefully Triple H has a plan he sticks to, but we’ve been here before.
There are only so many times fans can get fooled into caring about the brand split stuff when creative continually ignores it. If anything, doing away with the split roster pretence would suit most viewers. It'd also suit the writers, 'cause then they wouldn't be forced to concoct various schemes that explain why workers are ignoring the rules.
It'd also be great if this was limited to maybe 5-7 wrestlers per brand.
GUNTHER was shown shaking hands with SmackDown GM Nick Aldis backstage, so perhaps he and Cody Rhodes will switch brands. It makes sense that Netflix want Cody on their platform as much as possible, and it's hardly like GUNTHER is a crap get for Friday nights anyway. Shaking things up is fine, just...stop insulting the intelligence of fans or laughing in the face of their emotional investment surrounding the Draft.
Put it this way: If GUNTHER is heading to SmackDown, then he shouldn't be spotted on Raw full stop for at least 6 months. If WWE don't treat the "Transfer Window" with respect, then it'll count for nothing. That's one latter day Vince McMahon habit Hunter should move mountains to avoid.
Ups...
7. Solo’s Crew Takes Out Frustrations

Anyone who keeps tabs on WWE's usual style probably knew there was no chance Roman Reigns would be on SmackDown. That's why it was so important that Solo Sikoa's crew bounced back from defeat at WarGames by coming out swinging. WWE knew that too, which is why they kicked the night off with Apollo Crews coming through security then Solo's Bloodline attacking him for no particular reason.
They're just frustrated. Good, they should be.
Later, Sikoa, Tama Tonga and Jacob Fatu ambushed LA Knight and Andrade. Shinsuke Nakamura, who was also involved in the United States Title promo train, started dribbling black mist and skulked away, but The Bloodline got to the other two. Y'know what, you've got to like that. It shows that Nakamura is a threat even to other villains on the roster, and both segments portrayed Solo's team as psychotic bullies who hit down when they've been put in their place.
That's simple but effective character work. It's worth noting that Fatu got to look like a monster yet again. This dude steals the scene every time he's on camera, and it's only a matter of time before he's jousting for the big prizes around here. The patient approach has been a fruitful one for WWE - they're in no rush with Jacob.
Matches like Fatu vs. Knight/Andrade/Nakamura all sound interesting. So, mind you, do Solo vs. Knight/Andrade/Nakamura. Tama Tonga is clearly the least fascinating of the remaining Bloodline trio (they're two members down due to injuries suffered at Survivor Series), but he's a decent shout if someone must be fed quickly to LA.
6. Elektra Lopez Shines

Legado del Fantasma member Elektra Lopez doesn't get too many chances to further her skillset in TV matches. On Friday, it would've been easy for her to sink as the worker with the least high profile reps vs. Naomi and Tiffany Stratton, but she didn't. Instead, Lopez looked really good throughout, and thriving in a spot like this should give her some confidence.
Go get 'em, Elektra.
A few of WWE's opening round three ways in the Women's United States Title tourney have done wonders for relative rookies. B-FAB and Lash Legend come to mind there. Whilst matches have varied in quality, it's been a nice idea overall. This week's version was certainly a winner, and Lopez will be chuffed with her efforts. She didn't try to do too much, but everything she tried came off without a hitch.
That was surely Triple H's plan when he formatted things this way. Stars like Bayley and Stratton have picked up the wins (rightly so), but that didn't mean others have to sink into the background. WWE legend Jesse Ventura was camped out around ringside before returning to the commentary table at Saturday Night's Main event next weekend, and he must've been impressed by what he was seeing.
Lopez never once looked out of place. If anything, it's notable that the only slight botch in the bout came from Naomi. She lost her balance on the ropes, but recovered well. Some of Naomi's matches have suffered from mistakes since her comeback, but this was nothing major.
5. Tiffy Time Takes It Home

What a weird position for Tiffany Stratton to be in on Friday.
She was a default babyface due to her Minnesota roots, and actually felt like the biggest star in the match too. To their credit, WWE didn’t try to swim against the tide. They handed her the win to advance in the tournament, which was a welcome decision. Sometimes, the most obvious result is also the most pleasing. “Tiffy” and “Tiffy Time” chants aplenty helped justify the plan.
'The Game' would’ve been listening to that backstage at Gorilla. He might see babyface potential in Stratton eventually, but the woman’s a star on the rise regardless of alignment. Her moonsault is literally perfect, and it's inevitable that she'll successfully cash in Money In The Bank to become either WWE Women's or Women's World Champ. There's no need to go bait and switch with the briefcase there.
Candice LeRae did sprint out to distract Naomi and Elektra Lopez before the finish. That's something else worth discussing. LeRae has been trying to pip Stratton to the post as Nia Jax's second in command/best friend. Outright replacing Tiffy wouldn't be the worst spot in the world for Candice. Of course, WWE may fancy sticking her with a freshly turned heel DIY instead.
Either works.
This was a bigger night for Stratton than some might think. WWE fans fully embraced her for perhaps the first time (the cheers were loud), and that support is an addictive feeling. She was the right winner. The semi final bout vs. Michin on next week's SmackDown should be tidy.
4. Belair & Niven Give Us A Banger

Tiffany and Michin will have to go some to better what Bianca Belair and Piper Niven produced on this week's show. Yes, Belair could've done a much better job of selling her rib injuries before the match got underway, but wow. The bell sounded and these women went off! Most knew it'd be decent if the pair were given enough time, but surely nobody saw this early Christmas pressie coming.
Niven got to look like a dominant powerhouse for much of the match, then Bianca rallied to fight through the pain and score a crowd-popping win. By the end, fans were leaping up out of their seats and going nuts for the 'EST'. The KOD that sent Piper crashing onto a helpless Chelsea Green looked fantastic. Normally, this fan would roll his eyes at the played out, "This Is Awesome" chants, but they were fully deserved on this occasion.
Both women actually told a story rather than running through lots of moves and trying to get their stuff in. There was a little bit of extra added spice too; Bianca wanted to rule out Niven and Green as potential suspects in the 'who attacked Jade Cargill' hunt. She's still unsure whether or not they had anything to do with it, but managed to blow off some steam by using adrenaline to power through agony and get the victory.
A lot of WWE stars had their best matches ever in 2024. This hearty scrap will be right up there for Piper Niven. Anyone who followed her on the UK independent scene and on NXT UK already knows how good she can be, but this might be the best she's ever looked on the main roster.
3. Heel DIY Steals The Tag Titles

Let's be honest about something upfront: DIY and the Motor City Machine Guns could work more aesthetically pleasing matches than this in their sleep, but the quartet prioritised storytelling over 'movez n' spotz'. Good on them for doing that. The in-ring five star dazzling stuff can come later on PLE/at Saturday Night's Main Event if need be. For now, on TV, it was more pressing that they furthered story and character development.
At first, it looked like Tommaso Ciampa and Johnny Gargano would be at odds after the tag title match. Swerve, bro! It was all a ruse to sucker the Machine Guns in. Now, it's crystal clear that DIY attacked The Street Profits backstage, and that Gargano used his friendships with Alex Shelley and Chris Sabin to get his team the title shot instead. This has been a solid ‘B’ story for SmackDown recently, and there’s your payoff.
Going forwards, it’ll be interesting to see if MCMG fizzle out, or if they’ll get revenge on the new heel champs. If nothing else, Gargano and Ciampa going rogue is a fun twist for them on the main roster. There's a decent chance Candice LeRae will be installed as their valet soon, so remortgage the house on some six-person tags against The Profits and B-FAB in the near future.
Or, maybe Shelley and Sabin will team up with a female star. Who knows? WWE has options in the tag division for the first time in a while, and that's a huge plus. This heel turn for Gargano worked flawlessly.
2. Chad Gable Targets The Ankle

Hey, remember when Cody Rhodes called out Kevin Owens for failing to take advantage of his injured leg back at Bash In Berlin this past August? That played a part in KO's slow burn heel turn before he attacked his so-called friend out in the parking lot at Bad Blood then hit a vicious piledriver on Randy Orton last month. Well, Rhodes suffered more leg-related trauma on this week's SmackDown.
Chad's attacks injured his ankle, and the heel went after that like his name was Charlie Bucket and he'd just been handed a golden ticket. This plot point was logical given Gable's Ankle Lock finisher anyway, but it also fits in with the prior story Cody was working with Kev. Now, his ankle and his knee could be considered soft targets heading into Saturday Night's Main Event.
It'd be a huge surprise if Cody and Kevin missed a trick next weekend by failing to make that part of their WWE Title match. Pros this accomplished don't miss easy lay ups like that. That's next week - on SmackDown this week, Gable and Rhodes worked a predictably excellent match that showed Cody's toughness whilst also making the American Made leader look like he has way more to offer WWE.
Please give this man his flowers in 2025, Hunter. No, Chad will never be the guy in this promotion, but an Intercontinental or United States Title reign isn’t out of the question. His poise is incredible. The way Gable kept countering the Cross Rhodes near the end of this main event was awesome, and adding splashes of late drama like that is nothing new for our Chad.
1. Let Them Fight!

Earlier, this article had a right good moan about the pointlessness of Michael Cole getting into KO's cosy rental car, listening to him rant about the same old stuff, then getting booted back out into the cold. WWE made up for that mediocrity by having Owens come back to haunt Cody straight after the headliner. He stomped on Rhodes' bad ankle, then the friends turned enemies worked ye olde pull apart brawl angle.
Fans chanting, "Let them fight! Let them fight! Let them fight!" will be music to everyone's ears.
This dude is a big fan of Owens being a dirtbag by wearing a Dusty t-shirt for this segment, and he's an even bigger fan of Rhodes refusing to take the abuse. He's hurting and now has a compromised ankle to deal with heading into Saturday Night's Main Event, but you best believe Cody will come out clubberin'. He might even bring a bicycle! Right, that's enough of the Dusty on WCW comms jokes.
Kevin repeatedly finding ways to spit in the face of Nick Aldis, Triple H and other members of upper management by attacking their top stars is gripping stuff. It's even better because Owens thinks his heel behaviour is justifiable. See? This sort of thing is way more compelling than Owens ranting and raving at Cole. No, it doesn't matter how hilarious him calling MC back only to slowly put the car window up was.
People are desperate to see Kev and Cody go at it. That's remarkable, because this is a match they saw over the summer. KO's heel turn gives it a fresh wrinkle.
What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more wrestling, check out 50 Things You Learn Binge-Watching Every WWE Royal Rumble and 50 Things You Learn Binge-Watching Every WWE WrestleMania!