7 Ups & 3 Downs From WWE WrestleMania 38 (Night 1)

'Stone Cold' is back; Cody Rhodes re-debuts; WrestleMania's first night clicks.

WWE WrestleMania 38 Steve Austin
WWE.com

He's baaaaaaaaaaack.

Millions of 'Stone Cold' fans around the world probably winced a little when Steve Austin took a weak bump into the security barricade outside the ring. That, mercifully, was the only duff moment in a spirited talk-show-segment-turned-brawl between the legend and Kevin Owens.

WrestleMania 38's opening night was a successful one all in. WWE delivered big surprises (depending on how closely you follow wrasslin' news, at least), iconic comebacks and fitting sendoffs. Was it surreal to watch The Undertaker wave goodbye when Austin was on the comeback trail? Absolutely, but "surreal" could sum up most of the card.

No, some matches definitely didn't feel worthy of the 'Mania treatment, but everybody worked hard and tried to make the most of things. Overall, only the most curmudgeonly of fans could come away from Night 1 thinking it sucked.

AEW > WWE jumps, a proper "Final Farewell", more Stunners/beer drinking than some 'Attitude' era episodes of Raw, injuries, title changes and more - yep, WrestleMania 38's opening salvo was a fun ride that mixed future greatness with past glories.

Here's all the good and bad.


Downs...

3. Rick Boogs’ Injury

WWE WrestleMania 38 Rick Boogs
WWE.com

Michael Cole reported after the fact that Rick Boogs had suffered a nasty knee injury, and that appears to be legit. It's one that will require surgery, and it cut short 'Mania 38's opening match. That's a bit of double whammy for Boogs - not only did he suffer physical pain, but the big man missed out on a proper WrestleMania debut match.

You've got to feel bad for the guy.

It's nobody's fault, because these things happen, but this was a miserable kickoff point for the card. Fans in Dallas obviously knew something was up when The Usos double-teamed Shinsuke Nakamura to retain their SmackDown Tag-Team Titles. The finish was understandably rushed.

This doesn't get a 'Down' because of bad booking, or anything like that. Nah, it's here 'cause everyone wants 'Mania to start with a bang. Sadly, the only bang/pop Rick Boogs heard was his knee giving way midway through the match.


2. Not ‘Mania Worthy

WWE WrestleMania 38 Happy Corbin Drew McIntyre
WWE.com

Both Drew McIntyre and Happy Corbin were right up against it after working a never-ending feud full of ponderous creative missteps. The latest came on Friday's SmackDown when Corbin, for some reason, made a joke about Drew's deceased mother. That was cheap, and came a little too late anyway.

Honestly? The final few mins of this match are all you need to see from it. The bout never came across as one worthy of WrestleMania's main card, and that's a real shame considering the fact that McIntyre often carried WWE through the pandemic days. He really, really deserved better than this afterthought.

Better days are ahead, at least.

WWE will surely reward Drew with something mega after putting him through this interminable storyline with the Happy Folks. As for Corbin and Madcap Moss? Well, it looks like they're heading for 'Splitsville' over the next few weeks.


1. A “Main Event” Struggle

WWE WrestleMania 38 Ronda Rousey Charlotte Flair
WWE.com

Hmm.

Charlotte Flair vs. Ronda Rousey wasn't bad (like, at all), but it couldn't top bouts like Becky Lynch vs. Bianca Belair or Cody Rhodes vs. Seth Rollins before it. Worse, it was sandwiched between Cody's re-debut and Steve Austin's comeback. That was a death spot for these women.

Fans in Texas struggled to get onboard for anything but the closing stretch. Even that fell a bit flat; Flair hit a big boot (of all things) on Ronda to score the victory and hold onto her SmackDown Women's Title. Sometimes, it's wise just to give people a babyface tapping the heel out with an arm bar and then move on.

WWE want to drag this feud out a little more though, and they will. There's a rematch coming for these two. Do they merit it? Your writer isn't so sure. More content means more wobbly promos from Rousey, and it's hard to see her having a convincing argument for a redo despite the ref bump.


Ups...

7. The Set

WWE WrestleMania 38
WWE.com

A smattering of fans on social media thought WrestleMania 38's set was underwhelming. This guy doesn't agree - if anything, WWE's design was clean and classy, and it was a neat touch that wrestlers came from underneath the gigantic 'Mania logo in the middle.

All of those star motifs made everything look like a Cowboys' home game too, which was surely the point. Was it as epic as some previous sets from down throughout the years? Maybe not, but it was hardly a miss. Wide shots of the stage were visually stunning.

There was a remarkable lack of CGI too.

WWE didn't go overboard or try to make the set a focal point. The actual matches, and the wrestlers working them, were very much in the spotlight. That ramp, whilst still lengthy, didn't seem as long as some others either. 'Stone Cold' was probably grateful for that!


6. Surprise Package

WWE WrestleMania 38 Logan Paul Rey Mysterio
WWE.com

Logan Paul's performance was yet another celebrity winner for WWE.

The YouTuber's work was nowhere near as flashy or memorable as Bad Bunny's last year, but Logan looked good out there and didn't over-extend himself by trying to be Kenny Omega. Paul played his role very well, and likely has a guaranteed match vs. The Miz in his back pocket.

It would've been some buzz for Rey Mysterio to team up with his son Dominik at WrestleMania as well. Their twin Eddie Guerrero-inspired outfits struck an emotional chord, one which Dallas used to boo the sh*t out of Logan when he hit Guerrero's triple suplex spot and landed a Frog Splash.

Paul didn't look out of place here, and he can be proud of that considering he was sharing the ring with veterans like Miz and Rey. Vince McMahon would've witnessed enough here to suggest bringing Logan back in for a few more matches is the right call.


5. Echoes Of SummerSlam 2021

WWE WrestleMania Becky Lynch Bianca Belair
WWE.com

Who else was fooled when Becky Lynch landed that Manhandle Slam right at the start of the Raw Women's Title match? It seemed like WWE might repeat history by having 'Big Time Becks' lay Bianca out within seconds yet again. What an echo from SummerSlam 2021 that was.

The moment could've done without Belair stupidly going to shake hands with Lynch though. What is up with dumb pro wrestling babyfaces? Bianca should be fully aware of Becky's temperament and tactics by now. Going the respect route after everything they've been through didn't make sense.

However, that was a hot start.

A few fans inside AT&T Stadium were tricked into believing that the referee might count three and spell the end of Bianca's latest title push. That's what both workers wanted them to think, and they pulled off the ruse majestically.


4. Bianca Belair’s Revenge

WWE WrestleMania 38 Bianca Belair
WWE.com

Then, in the end, Belair got her hand raised.

She's the future of the women's game in this promotion, there's no doubt about it. Giving Bianca revenge for last year's SummerSlam embarrassment was the correct decision. It's worth pointing out that a star of Becky's quality also doesn't lose any street cred for staring at the lights here.

Both women told a solid story of desperation from Lynch. She couldn't put Belair away, and even tried to settle for a countout near the end. When Bianca hauled herself back inside the ring, Becks went on the offensive with punches and lost her composure.

That plot point is one she can use as promo fuel later. For now though, WWE better find Belair some new challengers and take Becky out of the title scene. She's a unique worker in the sense that she can put others over without shedding her own importance.

'Mania 38 was living proof of that.


3. One More Deadman Entrance

WWE WrestleMania 38 The Undertaker
WWE.com

WWE's "Final Farewell" for The Undertaker back at Survivor Series 2020 never satisfied at all. There were no fans in attendance for a start, and that badly hurt what was supposed to be one last sendoff for Vinnie Mac's greatest ever gimmick. Thank f*ck for this then.

'Taker got one more entrance in front of a massive crowd who bellowed his name. In return, the icon patted his heart and repeatedly said, "Thank you" to his adoring public. After 30+ years of sacrifice and spine-tingling moments, that was richly deserved.

What a way to go out.

It's heartwarming to think that The Undertaker got the chance to say goodbye to his fans properly. No amount of documentaries, shoot interviews or social media posts were ever going to match the tag-team attack of Hall Of Fame induction and WrestleMania stage send off.


2. AEW’s Cody Rhodes Is WWE’s Cody Rhodes

WWE WrestleMania 38 Cody Rhodes
WWE.com

Well, it was weird as balls to hear that entrance track in WWE after seeing it on AEW TV so many times, wasn't it? Corey Graves said it best when he shouted, "This is surreal!". That walk to the ring alone must've been a special moment for Cody - he tapped the ring post and took a deep breath before stepping through the ropes.

Home.

The match vs. Seth Rollins was a doozy too. Yours truly cannot lie; he was concerned that a standard back-and-forth bout would flop, but it ended up being a credit to the card and one of the best matches from WrestleMania's first night. This is one Rhodes will look back on for years to come.

Cody and Seth then added in some nice nods to old mentors/rivals from the past when they used Triple H's Pedigree as a false finish. Trips' retirement means he won't wrestle Rhodes himself, so inserting a few tricks from 'The Game' here or there worked for the fans and tied the story together.


1. ’Stone Cold’s’ First Match In 19 Years

WWE WrestleMania 38 Steve Austin Kevin Owens
WWE.com

It was clever of WWE not to announce an actual match between Steve Austin and Kevin Owens ahead of time, because people would've started getting ahead of themselves with unrealistic expectations. By revealing plans live at 'Mania, the company took the pressure right off Austin's shoulders.

Dallas came alive once it became clear that a 'No Holds Barred' battle between both men was on, and the noise didn't relent until 'Stone Cold' was sinking beers mid-ring and cameras faded to black. This wasn't a technical classic, but it was never going to be. Hell, it didn't need to be.

Sorry, there was just no way this was getting anything other than an 'Up'.

Countless Austin marks who grew up with the icon's rebellious act would've been throwing every punch and cheering every kick in their living rooms. That's what WWE's brand of wrestling is all about, and it'd take a special kind of misery guts to come away from this brawl with a scowl.

19 years in the making, and 25 minutes (or so) of top quality entertainment.

What did you think of WrestleMania 38 Night 1? For more WWE, check out 2 Ups & 6 Downs From WWE WrestleMania SmackDown (April 1) and 7 Ups & 8 Downs From WWE's Road To WrestleMania 38!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.