7 Ups & 4 Downs From AEW Dynamite (22 Mar - Review)

The Elite are attacked, The BCC get brutal, and "Dream Match" undersells a television all-timer.

Vikingo Kenny Omega
AEW

Ahead of a fascinating-on-paper edition of Dynamite, it was starting to feel like Tony Khan had might have his creative groove back.

The build to Revolution stuttered badly after a hot start to 2023, but the pay-per-view itself was anything but. That's not to say that the specific end justified the means, but the diverse and dynamic roster came through for the booker when he needed it most. With momentum seemingly back on AEW's side, a moribund edition of Dynamite left fans yet again wondering what exactly was the state of the company going forward.

The group's debut in Winnipeg seven days later offered some big answers.

The Elite are finding each other again, and as babyfaces literally and figuratively behind Hangman Page. As their opposition, The Blackpool Combat Club were suddenly bigger heels than when they'd actually turned. The Outcasts of the Women's Division met actual push-back from a group five-strong on the babyface side willing to fight for AEW's right. Canadian Stu Grayson was presented as the old heart and soul of the promotion in a standout undercard performance and rehired as a result.

As sweet as it was shrewd, the Canadian love-in took place as the promotion got set to sell tickets for their first tour North of the border. Thoughtful booking obscuring corporate synergy, perhaps brought about live events tsar Jeff Jarrett, who peaked in his own recent in-ring renaissance with an epic-feeling old school loss to Orange Cassidy.

And off the back of all of that, we got this - Omega working his first Dynamite singles match in over a year and a half, Jon Moxley cast as the party-spoiler against Grayson, and Cassidy linking arms with Darby Allin and Sting in more toasting of his International Championship success.

On paper, this is pro wrestling magic. In practice?


Downs…

4. The Gunns Vs Top Flight

FTR Gunns
AEW

The problem with booking lame-duck Champions on purpose is that it's really hard to find the balance between them being knowingly rubbish and the show not sucking as a result.

The Gunns were given three other teams and party match-adjacent agenting for their Revolution pay-per-view defence, and had to face this match being hacked to bits by commercials and a run-in from The Kingdom in order to get away with a 10-minute token defence against Top Flight.

As with the end of the aforementioned four-way, the paper Champions had to contend with the best team in the land walking out after their win. FTR stared The Gunns down, listened to their trash talk and offered up their AEW careers before being spat at.

The all-or-nothing match is on, and that'll almost certainly be one of the year's best nail-biters. Getting there - per the limitations of the Champions - has felt a little too pedestrian.


3. Hook Vs Stokely Hathaway

Hook Stokely Hathaway
AEW

The live crowd loved portions of this, but the live crowd deserve an up all of their own for being hot for the whole show. This match felt more like a beneficiary of the audience than something truly earning the praise.

It wasn't bad per se, but the build to this individual showdown and the never-ending Firm/Matt Hardy nonsense needed something extra special to elevate it beyond, well, Elevation fare. A few weapon spots (there was a lovely callback to one of his father's most famous ECW Tazplexes by Hook) and Big Stoke cracking jokes and trying to keep out of trouble was all just a little too lightweight for the end of this chapter.

If only it was the end of the entire story. Hardy convinced Ethan Page to be the next one to challenge Hook before Hathaway was even carted out.


2. Jon Moxley Vs Stu Grayson

BCC Stu Grayson
AEW

Between damaging moments of miscommunication, a pacing issue the pair just couldn't seem to address, and the live crowd not so much taking a quick breather but letting the breather happen to them, Jon Moxley Vs Stu Grayson ended up being one of the bigger TV under-deliveries in recent memory.

Moxley and The Blackpool Combat Club's new heel energy was explored elsewhere on the show to tremendous effect, but it simply didn't connect within the body of a sludgy match that somehow managed to douse a lot of Grayson's typical fire without particularly showcasing Moxley's increased vindictiveness. For men that historically have chemistry with almost everybody they wrestle, the bout badly underwhelmed.

In truth, the best things got between the two came after the bell. Cameras caught up with Grayson recovering from the defeat backstage, only to be jumped by The BCC in an unprovoked attack that foreshadowed yet more violence from the heels and built the case for them being the ones behind the big show-opening assault.


1. QTV

QTV AEW
AEW

The joke got no funnier, Powerhouse Hobbs got no more shine and the entire QTV idea got no better as Week Three for the concept (sort of) put over the TNT Champion's title match against Penta.

Low-rent and one-note, that's QTV. Intentionally lame gags between the bunch of people you'd least likely want to be in a room with who just happen to have the ear of the biggest and most dangerous man in the company, it's cornball trash that only gets itself over at the expense of the monster. Insufferable heat is heat, but that's closer to WWE than anything The Outcasts or The Jericho Appreciation Society have ever managed, and "being close to WWE" is the mission statement of both.

Hobbs being done with these useless cretins and decimating the lot of them one day doesn't justify however long it takes to get there, not least because he got into bed with them in the first place.


Ups…

7. The Bucks, Stopped Here

Elite Kenny Omega
AEW

A break in traditional Dynamite formatting is always welcome on a show that typically stays to a tried and true layout, and opening the show with the shocking news of a backstage attack on The Young Bucks was a perfect way to express the transgression.

The Elite's tentative reunion last week was destined to increase the drama, but nobody called something this substantial cropping up so soon.

Matt and Nick going off to the hospital raised questions of just who and what put them in such a state, but Hangman Page going with them answered others about where new loyalties are starting to lie. With his dream match later on in the night, Kenny Omega wasn't able to join them, and looked all the more rattled by the turn of events.

Exactly as it should, the intriguing mystery only deepened as the night wore on, too.


6. Orange Cassidy, Sting & Darby Allin Vs The Butcher & The Blade & Kip Sabian

Orange Cassidy
AEW

A white hot crowd elevated an opener that was already deliriously fun and a distilled version of AEW operating at its very best.

Orange Cassidy might be the International Champion, but you'd be fooled for thinking the strap slung in his backpack was the industry's richest prize. A monster, monster babyface, Cassidy's influence and impact was shrewdly promoted here thanks to his Iconic partner aping his lazy spots to get in the heads of the dastardly heels.

It worked a treat. The superhero squad acted in perfect harmony making relatively straightforward work of Butcher, Blade and Sabian, but the result was greeted as if the trio were the SuperBowl-winning Kansas City Chiefs. The whole thing was a stirring and stellar way to kick things off.

Allin locked eyes with the Double Or Nothing banner afterwards, and his look of longing fed into a video package topping up the AEW Championship chatter from last week. That match might not make the pay-per-view, but at least one of them could a take singles shot once the first-time meeting of all Four Pillars has taken place.


5. Jade Cargill Has A Storyline!

Jade Cargill Smart Mark
AEW

"Smart" Mark Sterling is typically your writer's least favourite storyline driver in all of AEW, but either the return of QT Marshall as a ringside botherer has made the irritant sidekick seem less of a loser or this mini-programme is...actually decent?!

The lack of story for Cargill beyond keeping her streak warm for Kris Statlander has been inexcusable, but this week's Dynamite followed up on the natural avenue to take between the the TBS Champion and upcoming challenger Taya Valkyrie.

They've both got the same killshot in Jaded/Road To Valhalla, Cargill doesn't like it, and the paperwork's been served to the babyface to try and remove the bullet from her gun. It might sound like celebrating the basics, but they've been missing so long that this scanned as a genuinely pleasant surprise.


4. Adam Cole Has An Opponent...

Ricky Starks Adam Cole
AEW

...and please dear god let it just be for a one-off technical thriller.

Daniel Garcia became the man to occupy one of the more intriguing spots on the show when he accepted Adam Cole's open challenge, and made a great case for himself and his wider story arc in the process.

Noting his vast experience in Dynamite/Rampage main events and acceleration up the card in Cole's absence, Garcia worked as hard as he could at being a Sports Entertainment caricature before the mask briefly slipped and - much to the joy of the crowd - he almost called himself a pro wrestler again. Free to luxuriate in being the best one of those, Cole levelled up himself and promised his very best in what will presumably be next week's headliner.

The freshness of the pairing was reassuring but - and it's one of the biggest buts in television wrestling at this point - if Garcia is the conduit to a Cole/Chris Jericho Double Or Nothing feud, consider this promo exchange the peak of the next two months and tearfully wave it away.


3. Toni Storm Vs Skye Blue

Skye Blue Willow Nightingale Riho
AEW

Toni Storm hits really hard and Skye Blue is an awesome sympathetic babyface when she's getting beaten up, so it's little wonder the in-ring portion came across so well here. A huge underdog, Blue's near-misses registered fabulously with the live crowd as the women made the best of good matchmaking rather than great booking.

The match overall gets an Up as a result because, as usual, it's a far harder task generating a reaction when your stories are obligatory rather than focussed-upon parts of the show. The post-match was horrifically lazy auto-pilot stuff - The Outcasts attacked, Willow Nightingale and Riho saved - but the performers continue to add flavour to the wafer-thin plot.

Pipe-weilding Riho has instantly nailed AEW's ability to make magic from something feeling more like a meme too. In the big battle down the line, her swinging it wildly into the heads of the heels will make for a standout moment.


2. Kenny Omega Vs El Hijo del Vikingo

AEW

Spectacular from the moment Vikingo flew at Kenny Omega in the first few seconds, a match too impossibly great to fail set about exceeding sky high expectations with the greatest of ease and - with the exception of one ad break - never ever stopped.

"Breathtaking exhibition of spots" is knocked out a minimum of once per show. "Innovative high risk exchanges" are as good as expected when dives are used to help shows crash into commercials. "He landed on his friggin' head" is a call Taz has to make too often in truth, as the mutual rush of adrenaline between performers and punters is chased on a weekly basis.

Kenny Omega Vs El Hijo del Vikingo found the next futuristic base beyond all of those common themes, and for 16 minutes escalated them to such an extent that the rest of wrestling may still be catching up ten years from now. This article doesn't exist for play-by-play but it'd be futile to offer some anyway because does seeing "Super Dragnonrana" "Outside-In Springboard Phoenix Splash" or "Step-Up 630" in writing really communicate how stunning those spots were in execution?

Not completely without psychology, this mind-bending spotfest instead used the chaotic ideas of the men as the story. How can Kenny Omega beat this opponent when his opponent cannot possibly be 100% human? How can Vikingo survive some of the most wicked offence in wrestling turned up to eleven because a "Best Bout Machine" is feeling like he might not be able to live up to his name across from someone just as worthy of the tag.

A mesmerising spectacle of perpetual motion, beautiful aerials and convincing killshots, this wasn't just the perfect ideal of what these men could do but the blueprint of what hundreds of others will now try. Wrestling history is manifested in many different ways, and it felt like some was playing out live right in front of all of us.


1. Hangman Plays Hero & Don Gets Desperate

Hangman Page
AEW

The closing moments of Dynamite were imperfect pending the response to what happens when Kenny Omega or anybody close to him reveals that Don Callis was being a lying snake.

Hangman Page returning from The Young Bucks' bedside to save Omega from a Blackpool Combat Club beating was gloriously daft pro wrestling magic, with the clip of Page commandeering the ambulance sending fans into hysterics as it played out on the big screen.

After running them off though, Page fell afoul of Callis' strange theatrics. He acted as if he'd been floored, and when Kenny came to, he bought the ruse. Again, he simply can't when he sees what went down, but that's (hopefully) a plot development for next week. In the meantime, the former Tag Team Champions were yet again brought together for the show's closing moments. Speculation hung over exactly who decked Matt and Nick Jackson, with the game-playing from 'The Invisible Hand' suggesting he knows much more than he's letting on.


In this post: 
Kenny Omega
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.