7 Ups & 4 Downs From WWE Raw (2 Dec - Results & Review)
The New Day's anniversary makes everyone sour on WWE Raw.
Coming out of a mediocre Survivor Series and steaming toward a heavily hyped Saturday Night’s Main Event, WWE needed Monday Night Raw to deliver several huge notes to set the table not just for the television special, but also for WrestleMania Season.
Raw succeeded on all fronts, producing one of its better episodes in recent months, aided tremendously by one of the best segments of the year, the New Day’s 10th anniversary. If you thought you knew how things were going to go heading into Monday night, you were wrong. Suffice it to say, this was an emotional ride, and anyone who hasn’t seen it yet should run to YouTube and buckle up.
Several top-level talent became inextricably intertwined throughout the night, creating a web of characters who have the potential to crash into each other repeatedly during the next couple of months, which could generate some interesting rivalries and matches along the way. It’s far from a sure thing, but the first glimpse and fantasy booking bodes well.
As usual, not everything was a success, but the negatives this week were minimal, with nothing really dragging the show down. Call this a win for WWE that could in hindsight be a big table-setting episode that also managed to deliver one of the segments of the year.
Lets get to it…
Downs…
4. RIP Original Raw Main Event
Until the end of time, this will forever be a gripe…
If Seth Rollins and Sami Zayn, two babyfaces who are longtime friends in reality and storyline, hadn’t lost their minds and started arguing with each other to open Raw, what would have closed out the show?
Surely, Raw GM Adam Pearce wasn’t going to throw R-Truth versus Pete Dunne out there as the last match. But if not that, what was supposed to main event the program? The impromptu matchmaking coming out of the opening segment has become less prevalent under Triple H, but it remains a booking crutch that the company can’t seem to shake. To accept this, you’d have to believe that WWE didn’t have a match booked for the last 15 minutes of Raw and were saved by short tempers.
Of course, many fans just turn that logical part of their brains off and accept it, much how everyone just accepts the “physics” behind an Irish Whip. But it wouldn’t take much to plug the logic gap here. A 20-second conversation backstage where Pearce cancels a match or interview segment to make room for the new main event would suffice.
As always, this is an original sin, not a cardinal one, but it remains a pet peeve.
3. The Dreaded Surprise Rollup
If you’re looking for one of WWE’s dumber “comedy” storylines in recent memory, look no further than R-Truth still calling Pete Dunne “Butch”.
The joke of Sheamus using Dunne’s former moniker to get under his skin has long since stopped being amusing, and even the Celtic Warrior has moved on, no doubt sensing that the gag is played out.
Enter, R-Truth.
Truth has been solely focused on confusing the two names, often to Dunne’s consternation, so this naturally boiled over into a match on Monday night. Pete jawed with fans, further instigating them to call him Butch, which led him to argue more… and allowed Truth to hit his one offensive move, the surprise rollup, for the pin.
In reality, Dunne is little more than a warm body on Raw these days, but it really is insane to realize he was more of a threat and a serious wrestler when he was Sheamus’ renamed little buddy and rabid pet dog. “Pete Dunne” on the main roster is a goof who exists to get a handful of fans to call him by the wrong name.
2. Just A Match
RHEA RIPLEY HAS ARRIVED! ??#WWERaw pic.twitter.com/nmuOJk96IE
— WWE (@WWE) December 3, 2024
There’s really not much to say about the women’s tag team match. In some ways, it was almost forgettable by design, lumped between the opening segment and women’s Intercontinental Championship tournament match, and then completely overshadowed (along with everything else) by the New Day’s 10th-anniversary debacle.
Still, Damage CTRL versus Liv Morgan and Raquel Rodriguez should have felt like a bigger deal than this, considering Morgan is the Women’s World Champion and Iyo Sky is the number one contender. Unfortunately, things did not go smoothly during this match, with a few sloppy moments and “just there” vibes throughout.
It all seemed to be in service of reminding fans that Iyo and Liv will face off at Saturday Night’s Main Event, and to set the stage for Rhea Ripley battling Raquel after the match. That scuffle ended when Rodriguez sent Ripley face-first into the edge of the announce desk, presumably reinjuring her orbital socket.
This wasn’t bad, but fans would be forgiven if they turned off Raw after the end and completely forgot that this match happened.
1. One Small Detail…
Let’s get the one small problem with the entire Sami Zayn/Seth Rollins/CM Punk story out of the way.
The show-opening promo went incredibly well, weaving a bunch of separate threads together. The main event between Zayn and Rollins itself? Not gonna lie, but it left something to be desired. The match itself was fine, albeit abridged, but it suffered from a heavy dose of forced drama.
Just before the match, Jey Uso was attacked backstage, leading Sami to assume that it was Rollins. This made no sense in storyline as Seth already had “forgiven” Jey for helping Roman Reigns at Survivor Series because they’re related, turning his focus to Zayn. Even the tension between Sami and Seth leading up to the match wasn’t at a fever pitch. They were angry with each other, but it hadn’t boiled over, and nothing should have led Sami to assume Rollins would snap and attack Jey.
Then during the match, Zayn lost focus in a completely uncharacteristic way and grabbed a chair to wallop Rollins, leading to a ridiculously drawn-out standoff with Seth pleading his case as Sami stood over him with the chair. Zayn finally relented, and Rollins rolled him up for the win.
The entire escapade was melodrama for the sake of it, and betrayed Sami’s character. At the very least, if WWE was going to do this, Sami should’ve had a bit more pressure or reason to suspect and turn on Seth. This felt like an abrupt change because the story demanded it.
Ups…
7. Women’s Triple Threat Surprises
On paper, Dakota Kai versus Shayna Baszler versus Katana Chance sounded like an exercise in how quiet an arena could be for a match. But the Women’s Intercontinental Championship tournament match managed to succeed by avoiding pitfalls and not overstaying its welcome.
Rather than falling exclusively into the trap of the old WWE triple threat trope of “one person gets tossed to the floor and the other two wrestle, then switch one out,” they weaved in a few fun spots and kept the action going, particularly coming out of the commercial break.
They subverted the typical Tower of Doom spot by having Baszler punch Chance down, only for Kai to shove Shayna to the mat. Then Katana hit a Frankensteiner to send Dakota crashing down on top of Baszler. They cycled through a series of impact moves and pin attempts before Chance hit a 450 splash to break up a Kirafuda Clutch, but she fell victim to a Kai GTK for the pin.
This was nowhere in the ballpark of the men’s IC title triple threat, but the women kept it lean and full of action, and fans reacted accordingly, so that’s a win.
6. Who Would’ve Thunk It?
TICK-TOCK... ⏳#WWERaw pic.twitter.com/1NePowKrO8
— WWE (@WWE) December 3, 2024
Is Final Testament versus the Wyatt Sicks actually a good feud?
The simmering rivalry deserves praise for simply existing outside the larger WWE wrestling universe without pulling other mainline stars into the mix. The Wyatts can’t exist in a “normal” wrestling universe, and the Final Testament is an ideal act to get sucked into that world.
However, Karrion Kross’ promo on Monday night was legitimately a good one. He acknowledged that he’s “done terrible things” and paid the price for those actions, but he took exception to the Wyatts sending Nikki Cross after his wife Scarlett last week, a bridge too far. This prompted a callout from Karrion for next week (an eight-man tag was announced later) to get his hands on each member of the group.
Kross noted that the Wyatt Sicks “started the fire, but [he was] going to make sure [they] burned in it.” That’s a pretty simple, compact, and visual line. The match probably won’t be the best of the night next week, but WWE is at least ticking all the boxes along the way.
5. Dom-Dom Nearly Steals One
Dominik Mysterio really never stood a chance against Gunther on Monday night, but the fun with the weaselly heel’s matches is seeing how he finds himself nearly lucking into a win.
The match itself served a bigger purpose with Finn Balor’s rivalry with Gunther, but on its own, it was good fun, a house show-style match that gave the fans plenty to enjoy. Gunther started out hoisting Dom onto the apron and patting him on the head, and Mysterio didn’t take the “little bro-ing” too well, taking the fight to the Ring General. It didn’t often go well for him, but he actually stood toe-to-toe with the World Heavyweight Champion for a bit chopping back and forth.
But then Dirty Dom came through as everyone expected. With the referee’s view obstructed, Dom hit a mule kick low blow, followed by a 619 to the family jewels, then a normal 619 and a frog splash for an incredibly hot two-count. That was Mysterio’s last flurry though, as Gunther immediately came back and put Dom down with a powerbomb.
WWE had no business booking a match that realistically made fans think for a second that Dominik might pin Gunther, but be damned if you didn’t flinch on that frog splash. Bravo.
4. Finn Gets What He Wants
Ever since ousting Damian Priest and Rhea Ripley from the Judgment Day, Finn Balor has been scheming. The Judgment Day drama is tired and honestly played out, but the Prince found a better focus on Monday night.
Balor approached Gunther for a World Heavyweight Championship match, claiming credit for his two title defenses against Damian Priest. Gunther laughed off the challenge and instead offered Dominik Mysterio a match because Dirty Dom had actually beaten Priest previously. That only served to enrage Finn, who got his revenge after that match.
Finn attacked Gunther, leveling him and delivering three Coup de Graces while taunting Dom to “watch and learn”. The notion that Balor is trying to lead the leaderless Judgment Day by example is pretty funny, actually.
Backstage, Balor got his world title match for Saturday Night’s Main Event, thanks to pissing Gunther off enough to get the Ring General to demand the match-up. Good setup for a match that should be really fun with situational babyface Gunther, as Finn continues to sink his teeth into being a prick.
3. WrestleMania Season Starts Early
When a two-hour WWE program opens with 20-plus minutes of talking and a heated pull-apart segment, you know they’re building something big… like WrestleMania season big.
CM Punk opened the show by quite literally signposting that this was all angled towards 'Mania by pointing at a non-existent sign and saying that he can see his path(s) to WrestleMania and invited fans to come with him on this journey.
This brought out Seth Rollins, who lamented how he made a mistake in not dropping Punk the first time he saw him back in WWE, or when he ran into the Second City Saint after Hell in a Cell. Punk revealed that while Seth has been thinking about him for the past six months, he doesn’t think about Rollins at all. He wanted Seth because he was a champion, but Rollins isn't anymore, so Punk couldn’t care less.
Rollins clearly wanted a fight, but the two only got to shoving and wrapping each other up before Sami Zayn and Jey Uso broke it up – not referees and officials. Things only got worse from there, with Seth turning his anger on Sami, who defended Jey before being forced to defend himself. Rollins and Zayn sparred over Punk, Roman Reigns, and their roles in the Tribal Chief’s ascension. This all gave way to the match that closed Raw, as previously mentioned.
Overall, great stuff threading together four wrestlers (with more to follow!) and personal issues between most of them. Sami even made sure to mention that he didn’t want Punk on their WarGames team, a line that could easily come back to bite him later with the Punker.
2. Adding An Unstable Element
As much as the tension and instability grew between the four wrestlers in the opening segment and throughout the night, the formula was jolted in the closing moments of Raw.
Seth Rollins, CM Punk, Sami Zayn, and Jey Uso started fracturing from the outset of the night, with Rollins and Punk finally coming to blows briefly, and then Sami and Seth’s subsequent argument bubbling over into a heated main event. Jey has always been at odds with Rollins, so that is something that can reignite down the line. And Zayn observed that he didn’t want Punk on their WarGames team, which could cause issues there.
Moments after Rollins defeated Zayn, Drew McIntyre appeared and dropped Zayn with a Claymore, returning to rage and cause mayhem. McIntyre is the straw that stirs the drink in this situation, a remorseless person who has an axe to grind with everyone. His feud with Punk is well-documented. Drew’s heel turn started when Uso made his way over to Raw. Zayn landed on McIntyre’s radar for defending Jey, but siding with Roman at Survivor Series had to escalate it – which is likely true for Jey and Punk as well. And he and Rollins feuded over the World Heavyweight Championship at WrestleMania XL.
McIntyre could simply be the Scottish Psychopath and target everyone indiscriminately. He could try to draw Rollins over to the dark side, as Seth was spouting a lot of the same gripes with Punk (and even Zayn) that Drew raised nearly a year ago.
Suddenly, there are five wrestlers on Raw who are intertwined as a result of Bloodline shenanigans, but they’re stories are independent of the Bloodline Civil War drama on SmackDown. If booked properly, this could be electric stuff going forward.
1. Dare To Be Sour
Heading into the New Day’s 10th-anniversary segment, fans had to be feeling a bit of anxiety and dread: Would the longtime stable finally disintegrate, would a heel turn be forthcoming, or would outside forces arrive to save the day?
It turns out that all three of those options turned out to be true.
Kofi Kingston and Xavier Woods were just about to break the bad news to fans, like parents telling their kids that they were getting divorced, when Big E made his return to WWE television, pleading with his brothers to not throw the group away. After getting very personal with them, he told them that until he’s medically cleared, he would show up every week and serve as the duo’s manager. Everything seemed to be set for a Hallmark movie conclusion…
But Xavier and Kofi had other thoughts in mind. They proceeded to tear into Big E for waiting until they were at the end of their rope to step in to try to help. What followed was an epic heel turn as Kingston and Woods took turns verbally thrashing E, accusing him of using his broken neck as an excuse for abandoning them, noting that other wrestlers like Steve Austin, Kurt Angle, and Edge all came back from broken necks sooner than E had. They called him selfish, choosing a ”desk job” over the New Day.
Fans rained down boos on the duo for the first time in nearly nine years as they effectively kicked E out of the group, pledging that it was just the two of them going forward.
This was a tremendous, sublime piece of business. Rather than Woods turning heel and the team splitting, or the group patching things up with E’s help, they went a completely unexpected route, finding a way to force fans to mercilessly boo a unit that has been one of the most positive, beloved acts in recent memory. They presented the perfect solution to New Day’s woes to the fans, only to rip it away in the cruelest manner. Worse, Kingston and Woods, on the verge of breaking up minutes earlier, were reunited by their anger at Big E.
Absolutely fantastic stuff, and it allows Kofi and Xavier to evolve after – by their own admission – not changing or growing since E’s injury. A tearful slow clap for this entire segment.