7 Ups & 4 Downs From WWE SmackDown (Jan 17)

Team Hell YES.

Roman Reigns Robert Roode

Last week's SmackDown was notable for Robert Roode's spirited comeback, The Usos wrestling again (oh how the tag-team division missed them) and John Morrison being a super-dick on guest commentary. The Friday night weekly has been fun lately, and appears to have finally found its groove after October's jump to FOX was sullied by the Draft, Survivor Series stuff and Brock Lesnar suddenly bolting to Raw after bringing 'KofiMania' to a screeching halt.

Things have calmed down, the writers have settled and that's why the blue brand continues to have more 'Ups' than 'Downs'.

There is a danger that the upcoming Royal Rumble card will be overstuffed by peripheral treats like Sheamus vs. Shorty G and a rather forced Lacey Evans vs. Bayley title match though, but things are looking up generally. WWE is typically a rosy place during this time of year, and even the most perfunctory episodes of TV seem a little bit brighter when WrestleMania is right around the corner.

So, between comebacks, losing streaks, awkward authority, gimmick match set ups and touching tributes, here's every plus point and negative from SmackDown's latest...


Downs...

4. The Numbers Don't Work Again

Elias Cesaro Shinsuke Nakamura Sami Zayn
WWE.com

If Sami Zayn was the managerial genius he should be, then he'd pay off some muscle mountain to match biceps with Braun Strowman. That's the sort of thing Bobby Heenan would've done, anyway, and it is ever-so-slightly confusing that Sami, Shinsuke Nakamura and Cesaro can't seem to handle business.

They were made to look second-rate next to Braun yet again.

The story should be that Strowman dominates one-on-one and the heels have the advantage when they hunt as a pack. WWE disagree. They believe that Braun should smash everything in his path, and the reigning Intercontinental Champion, his 'Swiss Superman' partner and 'Great Liberator' mouthpiece should flee in terror.

Maybe WWE think having two factions on the same show who target one guy, like 'King' Corbin and crew are doing with Roman Reigns, would be overkill. Even if they do, they must realise they're doing Shin and company zero favours.


3. Ye Olde Losing Streak Gimmick

The Revival
WWE.com

Speaking of "zero favours", it's The Revival!

As much as losing a match to the returning Usos is totally fine, this constant harping on The Revival's funk that Michael Cole and Corey Graves are doing won't get anyone over. The old losing streak gimmick has to be one of the dullest tropes in the WWE playbook.

There is some real life sh*t going on with Dash and Dawson behind the scenes, and WWE are probably hesitant to do anything worthwhile with them until that's sorted out, but they're still one of the best tag-teams in the industry today and deserve a little more shine.

All WWE need to do is put The Revival in lengthy, traditional tag bouts and let them do what they love to do bell-to-bell. Tacking on this loser storyline simply will not work. Why would fans care about a duo they're persistently told can't get the job done?


2. "Has Anyone Seen Shorty G?"

Sheamus Shorty G
WWE

Ugh, the short jokes are back.

When Sheamus attacked Shorty G during his return bit several weeks ago, it was hoped that he'd offer something different for Chad Gable to get stuck into; Sheamus could've pointed out that he was targeting Shorty because he saw something in him, knew of his Olympic background and wanted to test himself against a fine athlete before hunting titles.

WWE, again, said b*llocks to that and went in a different direction. They're booking Sheamus to make those God awful height jokes and relying on the most one-dimensional aspect of Shorty's entire character. "Has anyone seen Shorty G?" is not stellar banter. When will the writers learn that this isn't particularly interesting stuff?

Gable is roughly the same size as most wrestlers on NXT, and he matches up physically with a fair number of others on Raw and SmackDown. It makes no sense that he won Tag Titles for years then suddenly "came to terms" with the fact he's not 6'5".


1. The Authority?

Adam Pearce Sasha Banks Bayley
WWE

What the f*ck was this?

Adam Pearce, the guy who confronted Sasha Banks and Bayley in the doctor's office to tell them some bad news, has literally been presented as someone who breaks up brawls on TV every now and then. He has never once been presented as a character capable of making matches or with any authority at all.

He's an agent, the kind of guy who tells heels to calm down when they're ripping babyfaces to shreds or threatening to put someone through the announce table. It's absolutely random that he was suddenly thrust into power on SmackDown and forcing Bayley to wrestle Lacey Evans in Sasha's stead.

Worse, Cole called Pearce a "WWE official" on commentary and even thanked him for making the match happen. Eh!? Are viewers supposed to believe that Adam is the guy behind all the decisions on Friday nights, or was this a one-off?


Ups...

7. A Touching Tribute To The 'Soulman'

Rocky Johnson
WWE.com

If there's one thing WWE do better than any company on the planet, it's video packages.

The production team deserve a pat on the back for the sensitive, heartwarming and classy way they handled Rocky Johnson's tribute vid. It was emotional, informative to younger fans who know nothing of his career, managed to include The Rock as a reference point to those fans and was a lovely tribute to a real industry trailblazer.

Johnson came across as a doting family man who worked hard to tear down barriers for African Americans in pro wrestling. His WWF Tag-Team Title run with Tony Atlas was shown, and so was his pride upon being inducted into the WWE Hall Of Fame by his son in 2008.

In another classy touch, Rocky's message about inspiring people regardless of their skin colour, religious background or upbringing was as hard-hitting here as it was 12 years ago.


6. This Rose Has No Thorns (Yet)

Otis Mandy Rose
WWE.com

Mandy Rose hasn't been presented very well in recent weeks, but she was here.

She wasn't wrestling, so there were no "you will never look like me" outbursts at fellow women, and she even seemed a little shy and retiring when Sonya Deville suggested her pal was smitten with Otis. Later, Rose flashed a smile when Otis saved her from a nasty fall and did that tongue flutter thing that's begging to become a meme.

There's an innocent vibe to the entire story that's somehow endearing despite the soap opera style of it. Otis is thawing an ice queen's heart, and forcing her to look behind physical appearance to the person beneath that shell. Or, this writer is a sucker and Mandy is setting the Heavy Machinery man up for a fall.

Whatever the case, the story was well done this week. If Rose is going to turn on Otis (which is likely), reveal that she's been playing him and become SmackDown's biggest bitch, then she's playing a nice poker face.


5. The Miz Returning The Favour

The Miz John Morrison
WWE.com

Yes, it was totally lazy, routine booking to have The Miz help John Morrison beat Big E after JoMo had helped him topple Kofi Kingston one week before. Sure, this is a go-to WWE strategy when they want to dip-feed storyline fuel and stretch it out for as long as possible.

That doesn't change the fact that this tag feud could be special.

Seeing Miz and Morrison back in the saddle feels right, and New Day needed a credible team to tango with at Royal Rumble and beyond. Now, they have that, and the resultant matches should be wonderful reminders of how good Kofi and E can be together when they actually have purpose and a rivalry to work with.

It might be straightforward stuff, but having the heels help one another week-to-week was the correct booking call here. They needed a few wins under their belt over the SmackDown Tag Champs to justify any title shot on pay-per-view.


4. Team Hell Yes

Kane Daniel Bryan
WWE.com

Kane got a nice response from the live crowd because he was first through the curtain when SmackDown started. Kicking off with Kane's promo (during which he put over the importance of the Royal Rumble), and having Bray Wyatt interfere as himself then stalk him as the 'Fiend' was fun booking.

Things got even better when Daniel Bryan came out to stop one masked demon from mauling another, and everyone got to see an unlikely Team Hell No reunion in 2020. WWE's logic was solid in this segment; Kane has history with both men in the Universal Title feud, and so he was a great choice to act as a third wheel cameo.

Team Hell YES.

Wyatt's past transgressions have been a linchpin of his current guise too, which is why he looked back through history at his own rivalry with Kane. Bray was playing mind games with Daniel Bryan by messing with someone he cares about (like he did with Miz's family), and that's rather clever.


3. The Universal Title Bout's Gimmick

Royal Rumble 2020
WWE.com

There were some grumbles on social media when Daniel Bryan revealed that he wanted Bray Wyatt's 'Fiend' in a Strap Match at Royal Rumble. That gimmick is usually mixed when it comes to match quality, and it means the Universal Title bout on 26 January will likely be slow and plodding rather than fast-paced and bump-heavy.

Whether individual fans like the strap idea or not, it's true that Bryan vs. 'Fiend' II needed some sort of stip.

Another singles match like the one at Survivor Series was never going to cut it. It may have been better had WWE went for something more exciting (like a Steel Cage, for example), but they probs want to steer clear of cages after Wyatt's HIAC misery late-last year. A Strap Match it is then.

On the plus side, Bryan is that good of a worker that he'll find a way to inject the gimmick with some thrills and spills. It's also not ridiculous that an overtly pain-hungry character like the 'Fiend' would agree to be bound to his opponent so he couldn't "run away".


2. Robert Roode's Jump Start

Roman Reigns Robert Roode
WWE.com

Opportunistic heels take every chance they can to inflict damage on rivals and get the upper hand. That's why it was so good to see Robert Roode sprint out and hit Roman Reigns from behind before their main event could get properly started.

Great heel work rocks.

The announcers subtly guessed that 'King' Corbin had put Roode up to it. This was another good story moment that put Corbin's menace over and showed that Roode and Dolph Ziggler are willing to go the extra mile for their 'King'. Why let Reigns get settled in-ring when he and his cheerleading fanbase can be taken by surprise?

Roode's ambush only made the crowd cheer louder when Roman recovered enough to send his would-be table victim tumbling out of the ring. The entire match was meticulously laid out to sell the idea that Roode, Corbin and Ziggler can't beat Reigns solo, but that Roman also needs some help from The Usos.


1. Falls Count Anywhere

Royal Rumble 2020
WWE.com

There's an odd 'Down' hidden inside this 'Up'.

Roman Reigns should've, if he was being smart, banned Robert Roode and Dolph Ziggler from getting involved at the Royal Rumble. Instead, he chose a Falls Count Anywhere scenario against 'King' Corbin and forgot to ensure that it'll be strictly one-on-one. Meh, since when are babyfaces the most cerebral of characters?

The big upside here is that Falls Count Anywhere is a good stipulation for those who might normally find Corbin's matches boring. Now, rather than straight singles fare, they can brawl around the stadium in Houston and use all manner of shortcuts. That worked for them (to an extent) at TLC.

Fingers crossed this is the end of the Reigns vs. Corbin feud though. It cannot continue beyond Royal Rumble, and it's clear that this match represents the last few drops of juice WWE can squeeze from a story that doesn't exactly scream WrestleMania worthy.

What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more, check out 5 Ups & 3 Downs From WWE SmackDown (Jan 10) and 10 Wrestling Matches That Led To Massive Lawsuits!


In this post: 
Royal Rumble
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.