7 Ups & 5 Downs From WWE Raw (8 May - Results & Review)

Rollins has his moment, Cody can't close latest chapter, Stark debuts, Lynch returns.

Brock Lesnar
WWE

On the heels of a wildly successful Backlash premium live event, WWE should have been riding high and delivered a high-energy Raw that had fans coming unglued.

And to be fair, Raw was a pretty decent show, with good in-ring action and some good extracurriculars as well. But the fans (the live ones, not the piped-in crowd) were hit-or-miss most of the night, which somewhat hampered the reaction to the show and its impact.

You would think a tournament to crown the first-ever WWE World Heavyweight Champion would have an epic feel to it, but it might as well have been a tournament to determine who gets the Employee of the Month parking spot closest to the arena. Sure, the fans reacted to all the obvious spots and moments in the matches, but compare that to the San Juan crowd Saturday night, where they were hanging on nearly every punch.

Raw did see the return of a superstar who had been missing from WWE for the better part of a month, and they immediately rekindled a feud that has underwhelmed thus far, but could still deliver. The question is where Becky Lynch and Trish Stratus have it in them to really fire it up, because “Thank you Trish” isn’t cutting it.

And of course, Brock Lesnar made his presence felt, and we now know what he will be doing at Night of Champions.

Let’s get to it…


Downs…

5. Just Not Clicking

Trish Stratus
WWE.com

Sorry, sports fans, but heel Trish Stratus just isn’t doing it.

Trish showed up on Raw Monday night, handing out “missing” fliers of Becky Lynch, claiming that The Man was not coming back to Raw, and that she would finally be found somewhere in Iowa, huddled up with her “dumb kid” (Stratus’ words, more or less), who is 2 and doesn’t know her colors.

We got the old “heel uses the babyface’s music to fool the fans” bit, but when Becky’s theme kicked in again, it signaled the actual return of Lynch, who hasn’t been seen on Raw in nearly a month. Becky quickly tossed Trish around and said she was back to kick Stratus’ a**.

Technically, there was nothing wrong with this, and fans reacted well to a returning Lynch, but Trish’s delivery was cringeworthy, and her MO for hating Becky is flimsy at best. It’s just not clicking how you’d think a feud between a Hall-of-Famer and one of the biggest stars on the active roster should go.

Here’s hoping they can turn it around because fans and both women deserve something better.


4. Nak’s Slide Into Miz Midcard Continues

Shinsuke Nakamura
WWE.com

Last week, Shinsuke Nakamura showed up on Raw as a preview to his formal arrival as a roster member for the first time.

What should have been a big deal ended with Nak making fun of Miz and his “tiny balls.” Cue the groaning. But at least it looked like he might be moving on, as he was inserted into the 12-man World Heavyweight Championship tournament.

Fast-forward to Monday night, where it was Shinsuke who took the pin in his triple threat match. Later, he ran into Miz backstage, who continued his pitch for the two of them to become a tandem: Miz-ke Nakamura. You can’t make that up.

Instead, we’re now getting Miz/Nak next week. We’ll call this a very minor “down,” as everyone needs building block wins, but the longer Nakamura is embroiled with Miz, the more midcard he feels. And you can’t help but feel like this is going to drag on for six weeks because Vince McMahon loves the “Miz-ke” gag.

End the mini-program next week and we’ll call it a wash.


3. Impromptu A-Go-Go

Xavier Woods Dominik Mysterio
WWE.com

It’s really a good thing superstars constantly get into backstage altercations during Raw, or else they’d never be able to fill the entire three-hour show.

On Monday night alone, three matches were made during Raw due to impromptu challenges. Imperium ran afoul of Kevin Owens & Sami Zayn, drawing an offer to meet them in the ring later. Zoey Stark was doing a backstage interview when she spied Nikki Cross talking to herself, leading the newcomer to call her a weirdo and challenge the Scot to a bout.

The worst offender had to be Xavier Woods, who was laughing with Akira Tozawa and inadvertently interrupted Rhea Ripley’s backstage interview. Dominik Mysterio bowed up to Woods, sparking a very lame exchange between the two before Ripley accepted a challenge on behalf of “Dom-Dom.”

Those three matches ran for a collective 20+ minutes, a significant amount of programming time.

You want to know how to avoid this? Stop making matches mid-show. Announce the card from the jump and then have the backstage confrontations happen “earlier” to explain how the matches came to be. All three of these situations would have worked using that method.

Instead, we’re left to believe that Raw went on the air with a gaping hole in production time that miraculously got filled by matchmaking superstars.


2. At Least Give Us Lip Service

Cody Rhodes
WWE.com

Since returning to WWE more than a year ago, Cody Rhodes has spoken passionately about winning the title that his father Dusty Rhodes never could quite capture, the WWE Championship. In the lead-up to WrestleMania 39, he constantly talked about the need to “finish the story,” a further reference to winning this title.

After falling short at Mania, Rhodes has referenced how he needs to finish the story, so this thread is still alive and well.

So why did Cody just open Raw by saying his next focus on Raw is the new World Heavyweight Championship? No reference to Roman Reigns, the WWE Championship, or finishing the story – just moving onto the next available world title.

Regardless of anything that happened afterward, having Rhodes brush past any reference to that title was a mistake and betrays the character. All he had to do was mention that he still wants to finish the story, but since he can’t get to Roman, he was turning his focus to the WHC. Simple, takes 30 seconds, and gives a logical explanation that’s true to Cody’s ongoing story.

Otherwise, we’re all asked as fans to just forget about that quest for the time being and pretend it doesn’t exist. We can dispute whether Rhodes should have been in the tournament, but if you’re going to do it, then do it right.


1. This Isn’t ThunderDome 2.0

Cody Rhodes
WWE.com

Just days after a wildly successful – and extremely loud – trip to Puerto Rico, WWE felt like the hottest product on Earth. Fans chanted and cheered nearly everything, with deafening noise permeating SmackDown and Backlash.

Flash forward to Raw Monday night, and WWE was forced to pipe in ThunderDome-era fake crowd boos for Brock Lesnar. The fake noise was fairly obvious and almost distracting by how even and static it was, never wavering as Lesnar screamed into the mic.

That’s really bad on its own, but even if WWE felt like they needed to use crowd sweeteners to make Lesnar’s appearance feel more impactful, the fact that is the best they can do in 2023 is just inexcusable.

Do better. At the very least, don’t make it so obvious you’re piping in noise, unless you want to get called out and mocked.


Ups…

7. KO’s Side Antics

Giovanni Vinci Sami Zayn
WWE.com

Few WWE wrestlers are better at being understatedly entertaining than Kevin Owens. Even when the focus isn’t on him, he manages to reward those paying attention.

Backstage Monday night, Owens and Sami Zayn were talking when they were interrupted by Imperium. Sami tried to get them to wait a few minutes, but they kept insisting on finishing their rant about Gunther coming to Raw next week.

That’s when KO kicked in. Hey kept making side comments about how hard it was to concentrate on their conversation with Ludwig Kaiser and Giovani Vinci standing right there, then was apoplectic about Kaiser having his finger in their faces. It was just a simple, subtle way to express frustration without hogging the spotlight.

Just before their tag match, while Imperium was posing at the hard camera, Owens stood on the apron behind them making faces and looking exasperated by the whole deal, looking at a fake watch and giving a mock thumbs-up to the camera about Kaiser and Vinci’s stance.

Sometimes, it’s the little things that make Raw entertaining and enjoyable, and KO and his antics definitely fit the bill Monday night.


6. A Decent Debut

Zoey Stark
WWE.com

Not every NXT callup is going to get a glitzy welcome to the main roster, but at least Zoey Stark picked up the win and got to hit her signature spots Monday night.

Stark defeated Nikki Cross in a short, but energetic match that saw the newcomer take the fight to the veteran and overcome the Scot’s frenzied flurry at the beginning. Zoey’s Z-360 finisher is always an eye-catching finale to a match, so that hopefully will stick with fans more than anything. She’s a talented wrestler who could add a lot of value to the women’s roster if given the opportunity.

The crowd unfortunately was fairly quiet, but you can only hope that that isn’t held against her going forward. It’s a challenge for WWE to overcome, not something to blame on Stark.


5. A Conflicted Otìsè

Mustafa Ali Otis
WWE.com

When Maxxine Dupri targeted Otis as the next member of Maximum Male Models, there was some potential right away for fun hijinks involving the oversized, lovable goof.

But the biggest problem was figuring out how to pry Otis away from Chad Gable and Alpha Academy. For the past couple months, the two entities have tried to co-exist, to varying degrees of amusement. However, the only way for this to advance is for the issue to be forced.

Cut to Monday night, with Otis battling Mustafa Ali. With Ali on the mat, Otis was thinking about a Caterpillar, and Gable encouraged it, but Maxxine jumped on the apron to talk him out of it. The two argued and tried to sway Otis, and by the time he decided to charge Ali in the corner, it was too late. Otis posted himself and fell victim to a 450 splash, with Ali picking up the win.

This should jumpstart the fracture between Dupri and Gable, forcing Otis to choose. That could lead to some interesting conflict for the big man, and hopefully some entertaining segments ahead.


4. Professional Grade Triple Threat

Seth Rollins Shinsuke Nakamura Damian Priest
WWE.com

Really, if you’re putting Damian Priest, Seth Rollins and Shinsuke Nakamura into a match together, odds are you’re going to get a class performance.

And that’s exactly what we got in Raw’s opening contest, with the three vying for a spot in the semifinals of the World Heavyweight Championship tournament. Rollins, Priest and Nakamura clicked exceptionally well, as their triple threat didn’t have any lulls or rely solely on several one-on-one segments.

Priest sold his injured leg from Backlash, which also then factored into the match itself, with Shinsuke hooking in a kneebar near the conclusion, only for Rollins to fly in with a frog splash and Pedigree for the win.

Quality work from all three men. Nothing approaching a classic, but if you’re having a world title tournament, this isn’t a bad match to kick it off.


3. Unfinished Business

Brock Lesnar Cody Rhodes
WWE.com

The Backlash Ups and Downs column rated the finish of the Cody Rhodes/Brock Lesnar main event as a “down” – with a caveat: If this was leading to a rematch at Night of Champions, then it could possibly negate the criticism.

Fast-forward 48 hours, and Rhodes was battling Miz and Finn Balor in a triple threat for a spot in the semifinals of the World Heavyweight Championship tournament. Cody nailed three consecutive Cross Rhodeses on Miz and appeared to have the match won when Brock – with a black eye and fresh stitches – appeared out of the crowd and pulled Rhodes out of the ring. He quickly nailed the American Nightmare with an F-5, leaving him laid out as Balor got the win.

Lesnar wasn’t finished though. He hit Cody with another F-5 through the announce table and screamed at Rhodes that he had lucked into a victory at Backlash – Rhodes’ rollup while in a Kimura was more fortuitous than anything – and that he wanted a fight at Night of Champions.

So, there you have it: Lesnar/Rhodes II at NOC, likely with a stipulation such as Last Man Standing or Falls Count Anywhere. That gives Cody a main event-level feud that isn’t a world title match (though it would be a lot better if this was for the WWE Championship) and explains the rollup finish.

Cody fleeing the ring afterward and celebrating while retreating up the entryway at Backlash though… that was just dumb.


2. Rhea The Badass

Rhea Ripley
WWE.com

The easiest way to continue the very real perception that Rhea Ripley is a dominant champion is to have her go out there weekly and dismantle an opponent. Period.

Just 48 hours after toppling hometown hero Zelina Vega in Puerto Rico at Backlash, Ripley was on Raw demolishing Dana Brooke like she was cannon fodder. It was a great little piece of business, as Brooke is little more than a jobber with a name. There have been literal no-name wrestlers who have gotten more offense on WWE programming in the past five years than Dana did Monday night.

But that really is fine, as Rhea tapped her out, then laid Brooke out again with a Riptide and hooked in the Prison Lock a second time until Natalya sauntered down for the save.

A Nattie/Rhea feud is a fine program for the SmackDown Women’s Champion going forward, as we know Neidhart can handle herself in the ring and will give Ripley a really good, physical match, further building her legend. If WWE wants to build to an epic showdown between Ripley and Bianca Belair at WrestleMania 40, then squashes and programs like these will only help.


1. Rollins One Step Closer

Seth Rollins Finn Balor
WWE.com

Each day, it seems more and more like the new WWE World Heavyweight Championship is Seth Rollins’ to lose, like it was made for him.

Few superstars have managed to become as Teflon as Rollins, able to lose feuds and still retain his credibility and popularity. Last year, he lost all three matches to Cody Rhodes, a fight pit match to Matt Riddle and his United States Championship to Austin Theory, and he still was one of the biggest stars on Raw.

If you’re going to crown a new world champion to hold a title that’s being billed as a workhorse title, there are few people better suited than Rollins. The Visionary won his triple threat Monday night, then beat back a serious challenge from Finn Balor in the main event, which included a great callback to their SummerSlam 2016 match for the then-new Universal Championship – a Balor bucklebomb into the barricade.

Rollins now heads to Night of Champions to face the winner of the SmackDown bracket, which will be determined on Friday night.


Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.