7 Ups & 6 Downs From WWE SummerSlam 2022
Edge returns; Bayley leads a new WWE faction; Becky Lynch goes babyface; Brock Lesnar destroys.

WWE delivered several surprise returns and zero title changes at SummerSlam 2022.
That last bit might've caught some fans off-guard, because everyone has become so accustomed to seeing at least one belt switch on major shows like this. Triple H's revamped creative team resisted the urge though, but...not everything they booked in Nashville was a rip-roaring success.
The good definitely outweighed the bad, but some of the bad must be called into question. For example, where the hell are Judgment Day even going as a group? Also, is it written into every Money In The Bank winner's contract that they must be made to look like a total loser immediately after winning the briefcase/cashing in?
On the plus side, WWE bookended SummerSlam with top title scraps that are well-worth seeing. The opener introduced a brand new faction, turned Becky Lynch babyface and more, and the main event had quite the stunt set piece to separate it from the chasing pack.
Here are all the 'Ups' and 'Downs' from a night when WWE tussled with their own past and future plans.
Downs...
6. Judgment Day Look Like Losers

Oh wow.
Judgment Day has been wobbling big time ever since Finn Bálor replaced Edge as the group's leader, but WWE might've just squished them flat at SummerSlam. Losing to Rey and Dominik Mysterio, even with Edge's return and help, leaves the threesome with absolutely nowhere to go.
Honestly, creative might be better off just ending this now, because JD isn't even helping to elevate Damian Priest or Rhea Ripley anymore. Both looked better whilst sitting under Edge's learning tree, but Bálor has been booked as a leader who's weaker than he supposedly was - the story doesn't make any sense.
In retrospect, Edge shouldn't have been supplanted by Finn at all. His return fell a little flat too, largely 'cause...well, who wants to see this six-man tag WWE are surely planning anyway? Judgment Day carry no threat, and Saturday made that clear.
5. Not Quite On Par

Going into the weekend, this fan predicted that Happy Corbin vs. Pat McAfee would be an undercard gem both guys could be proud of. Sadly, it wasn't quite on par with McAfee's previous efforts. A few pesky botches and slips here or there are to blame for that.
Both guys worked hard, but there was a strange lack of chemistry for dudes who are real-life friends and former roommates; though pro wrestling chemistry is different to just being mates, more was expected here. Maybe that's harsh when Pat has had like four matches to dare, but yeah.
Something was missing.
The match did make one thing obvious: WWE shouldn't go down the rematch route come Clash At The Castle. There isn't enough to the story to keep it going, and the first bout wasn't nearly good enough to merit a repeat.
4. Theory Becomes Less-Than

Speaking of chemistry.
Bobby Lashley and Theory showed they had it by the bucketload at Money In The Bank. There, the duo pieced together a worthwhile United States Title showdown that made a rematch logical. Come SummerSlam though, they didn't produce anything resembling a worthy follow-up.
In fact, the match kinda made Theory look less-than, which is unfortunate when he's holding the MITB briefcase and is supposed to be a future World Champ. Nothing about this short, one-sided showing made Theory look like someone who could credibly cash in on top names like Roman Reigns or Brock Lesnar.
It's fine to make Theory look like an opportunistic coward every now and then, but to make him seem like he's way in over his head this often? Come on now, WWE. Lashley may as well have been wrestling some no-name jobber out there, and that's a pity.
3. Liv’s Halfhearted Push Continues

Screw this story about Liv Morgan "looking timid" too. Again, that's the problem with MITB sometimes - Liv hasn't come across as someone who's in the same league as workers like Ronda Rousey, Becky Lynch or Bianca Belair. Nah, it's way better to position her as 'happy to be here', right?
Right?!
The match between Morgan and Rousey was too short to really mean anything, and the wishy-washy finish wasn't satisfying at all. Replays made it crystal clear that Liv tapped out before the referee counted Ronda's shoulders to the mat. So, why should fans hate on Rousey? For having a justifiable complaint?
Some fans may encourage others to sit back and see how this one plays out, but few have faith in WWE to write a good second chapter after how badly they botched that situation between The Usos and The Street Profits.
This was a miss.
2. Too Little, Too Late!

Meanwhile, this came too late.
Ronda's heel turn should've happened at Money In The Bank, or at least on SmackDown before WWE reached SummerSlam. The promotion has wrecked this story by refusing to pull the trigger earlier, and by painting the reigning champion (Liv) as somebody who's out of her depth.
Prediction: Rousey's heel turn will fail, because she'll be 100% justified when she starts bitching about screwy finishes. The ref counted her down when Morgan had already tapped out - technically, she should be champion again. Yeah, this writer is struggling to see what's so heelish about pointing that out.
Add in the fact that Ronda isn't exactly comfortable on the mic and this is a recipe for disaster. She's gonna have a tough time selling herself a heel when everyone can see that Morgan doesn't deserve to hold the title. What a weird way to book things.
1. The Point?

Eyebrows were raised when WWE announced that Jeff Jarrett would be the special guest referee for a rematch between The Usos and Street Profits. However, things might've worked out well had the home-state legend actually been a factor in the match.
He wasn't.
Jarrett barely got involved, and that superkick spot from Friday's SmackDown meant nothing in the end. Jeff's comeback gig wound up being pointless, and he added bugger all to the match. Worse, The Street Profits are pretty rudderless after losing so definitely, and The Usos really have no viable babyface challengers left to work with.
This is poor planning all-round from creative. What should've been another tag-team classic (the MITB match was awesome) turned into yet another rematch that was inferior to its predecessor. Theory and Bobby Lashley know a little something about that themselves.
Ups...
7. Short But Sweet Angles

Watching SummerSlam live without the aid of a skip button was a tad arduous.
It wasn't the length of the show that was problematic here. No, it was the sheer number of video packages for random superstars that aired throughout. Thankfully, WWE used downtime in between matches much better on exactly two occasions, and they're worth talking about.
Drew McIntyre cut a short promo about being number one contender, and he even took the p*ss out of the main event by making light of how many matches Roman Reigns and Brock Lesnar have worked against one another. It was nothing fancy, sure, but the promo kept McIntyre in the conversation and didn't chew up much time.
The same goes for Riddle calling out Seth Rollins then getting stomped. Credit to WWE's production team for almost missing the stoner as he grabbed a microphone at ringside - seeing Corey Graves' shocked expression sold the moment better than a full entrance would have.
6. Michael Cole/Commentary

Let's take a minute to talk about Michael Cole.
The "Voice Of WWE" has got it right in the neck from pro wrestling fans for decades. He's been called Vince McMahon's puppet, and was ridiculed for having the cheek to replace Jim Ross as the company's lead play-by-play announcer. Some criticisms have been valid, but others haven't.
Credit where credit is due: Cole was noticeably having a blast during this year's SummerSlam. During Pat McAfee vs. Happy Corbin, Corey Graves quipped, "I liked you more when you weren't allowed an opinion". Not missing a beat, Cole replied with, "A lot has changed" before going hard on previously-frowned upon language like "wrestling" and "wrestlers".
Michael even fired off a line about Big Boss Man at SummerSlam 1991, which definitely wouldn't have happened with Vince in his ear behind the curtain. Cole was loose, relaxed and seemed to relish the chance to do his job without McMahon screaming in his ear.
5. Logan Paul’s Performance

Pre-SummerSlam, many wondered how Logan Paul would fare in a singles setting. That's a tougher task than dipping in and out of the ring for carefully-planned spots in a tag-team match, but Paul looked great against The Miz. Obviously, Miz deserves a pat on the back for that too.
He provided a solid base that Logan could work around.
Some on social media have pointed out that LP was visibly sucking wind just a few minutes into the match, but...are people really going to hold that against a guy with so few in-ring reps? That'd be ridiculous, and it's not like his heavy breathing ruined the match.
WWE packed Paul's first big one-on-one with enough bells and whistles to distract fans too. AJ Styles getting involved to take out Ciampa was smart, and Logan's dazzling frog splash through the announce table probably even made Shane McMahon's nod his head.
Y'know, if he was watching.
4. Brock Lesnar Lifts The Ring

Spare a thought for the poor sods who bought ringside seats opposite the hard cam, because they had to stare at a big screen for the closing moments of the main event. Still, it was worth it for folks watching from home - Brock Lesnar literally lifting the ring with a tractor was some laugh.
Has that ever been done before? Probably not.
Lesnar is no stranger to ring-related hijinks. Years ago, he and Big Show destroyed the thing on an episode of SmackDown after working a superplex spot. No tractors back then, man. In 2022, farmer Brock sloooooowly drove his vehicle to ringside and then used it to great effect.
Take a bow, Roman Reigns. The way the 'Tribal Chief' bumped for the corner lifting was a riot. This is the kind of moment that'll be replayed over and over for years and years to come. WWE adores these unique set pieces, and it's easy to see why.
3. The Main Event Generally

Now this could be a polarising point.
This writer likes to gauge a wrestling bout's success on how much fun he had watching it. Yes, there are loads of other factors to consider, but viewer enjoyment is the most important. Generally, he thought the 'Last Man Standing' match between Roman and Brock delivered.
Lesnar kicked things off by leaping on top of Reigns from his tractor (that was like something out of SmackDown: Here Comes The Pain), and Paul Heyman even took an F5 through the announce desk towards the night's conclusion. F*cking hell, someone check on Paul E after that!
Brock and Roman improved on their so-so WrestleMania 38 effort by deploying carnage aplenty. No, WWE cannot do this match again for a long, long time (if they ever do again), but both men can be pleased with what they accomplished here.
2. Exorcising Her Demons

There was to be no 26-second repeat for Bianca Belair at SummerSlam 2022.
The Raw Women's Champion and old foe Becky Lynch were handed a healthy chunk of time to work with, and they made the most of it from minute one. This was a top effort from start to finish - it's also one that let Bianca exorcise those 2021 demons in the best way possible.
Belair won clean as a whistle, but not before pausing to let the commentary team wonder aloud whether or not she was still haunted by prior events; OK, so that sort of ignored her 'Mania win over the same opponent, but it was a fine-enough story beat.
Focus on Bianca's injured arm was welcome (even if it's ironic that Becks' own arm seemed to be legitimately hurt after taking a suplex outside the ring), and these women blatantly love working one another.
What an opener.
1. Three For One On Surprises

Perhaps the biggest shocker here is that WWE didn't book Bayley's comeback and union with Io Shirai and Dakota Kai on free TV. They could've saved it for Raw or SmackDown easily, but Triple H's writing staff wanted to make a statement at SummerSlam.
That's not a complaint. It's nice to see something that totally deviates from the sort of booking fans expect from the company, because things have defo become way too formulaic over the years. Also, Bianca Belair suddenly has three top challengers waiting in the wings for title shots.
That's another huge plus.
Everything here worked. The match between Bianca and Becky was great, Lynch's show of respect was unexpected, Bayley's comeback popped the crowd, Io and Dakota joining her was a surprise - yeah, this was good sh*t.
More, please.
What did you think of WWE SummerSlam? For more like this, check out 6 Ups & 1 Down From WWE SmackDown (July 29) and 5 Ups & 3 Downs From AEW Rampage (July 29)!