7 Ups & 7 Downs From AEW All Out 2022

MJF returns; AEW crowns new champions; Tony Khan badly needs to show some restraint.

AEW All Out 2022 CM Punk
AEW

AEW boss Tony Khan is one self-appointed World Title reign and a New York accent from turning into this generation's Vince Russo. OK, that's over-the-top, but deliberately so - this writer is still smarting from an awkward, often convoluted build towards All Out, and he's not quite ready to forgive TK for it.

Then, the pay-per-view happened.

The latest All Elite supershow was a bloated one, but it did boast some seriously good moments. Those, unfortunately, were tempered by baffling decisions and a few too many crowd-displeasing finishes that didn't help when inevitable fan burnout reared its ugly head late into the 15-match strong show (if one includes Zero Hour, which most probs do).

Also, that f*cking build! It wrecked some of All Out's biggest potential treats, there's no doubt about that. Sticking CM Punk vs. Jon Moxley out there again so suddenly just never felt like suitable follow-up for the Dynamite squash, for example.

However, and this is a big "however", MJF's return does open up real possibilities for a World Title triumph everyone wants to see. That's true even though the heel is still giving fans the middle finger and maybe even about to launch yet another heel stable.

Here's all the good and bad from Sunday's epic.


Downs...

7. Most Of Zero Hour

AEW All Out 2022 Sammy Guevara Tay Melo
AEW

Skip 75% of Zero Hour.

No, seriously. You'll be doing yourself a favour when catching up on All Elite's latest, because this was a complete and utter waste of everyone's time. Tony Khan should've sent out a group text to fans attending the pay-per-view and told them to skip the support bands.

Nobody needed another mixed tag between Sammy Guevara, Tay Melo, Ruby Soho and Ortiz. Also, the less said about what poor Ruby is experiencing (booking hell, basically), the better. Elsewhere, Hook vs. Angelo Parker should've been on Rampage, and the same could be said for Kip Sabian challenging PAC.

Some may argue that it was a pre-show appetiser, so Zero Hour didn't need to be spectacular. That misses the point a wee bit - this is AEW, and the quality bar has been said ridiculously high. People do not need three Sunday Night Heat-worthy bouts on an already-overstuffed night, optional or not.


6. The Overbooked Opener

AEW All Out 2022 Joker MJF Stokely Hathaway
AEW

Sure, it's hard to bash AEW for opening with the all-action 'Casino Ladder' fray, but the whole exercise did make workers like Claudio Castagnoli and Andrade El Idolo feel unimportant. Everyone just sort of bumped around for no reason before Stokely Hathaway and gang cleared the way for MJF.

It was also very obvious that this was MJF.

AEW didn't want to unmask the heel right there and then though, so there was a fair stretch of awkward silence as Hathaway, W. Morrissey, The Gunn Club, Ethan Page and more hijacked the bout to pre-empt the 'Joker's' entrance. This was a kinda confusing start to the pay-per-view, being honest.

Was it dreadful? No, not really, but it is sad to see something so obvious happen. The masked gimmick also came across as more RETRIBUTION from WWE than anyone would care to admit, and it's gonna be a tough sell to present...whatever this faction is as something more than nWo 'B' squad.


5. Still Not Sure What The Point Was

AEW All Out 2022 FTR Wardlow Samoa Joe
AEW

Right, Dax Harwood's daughter getting paraded around the ring was undeniably sweet. You'd have to be coldhearted to begrudge the FTR man that, but smiling for a happy daddy/daughter moment doesn't mean one has to like AEW giving this nothing six-man 16 whole minutes (20+ if you include entrances).

Why was this even on the card?

AEW shouldn't be booking house show-esque fare like this on major pay-per-views, but that's exactly what this was. Wardlow and FTR vs. Jay Lethal and The Motor City Machine Guns lacked context and story next to some other matches on the card, and yet it was handed way more time than them.

Samoa Joe returning to save the day and randomly bleeding (?!) wasn't enough to stop the match from feeling like filler. Just move onto FTR vs. The Machine Guns already, and give Wardlow a fresh feud for his TNT Title.

Pretty please?


4. Luchasaurus Turns (Again)

AEW All Out 2022 Christian Cage Luchasaurus Jungle Boy Jurassic Express
AEW

Right, a quick recap.

Luchasaurus turned on Jungle Boy back in June. Then, at Fyter Fest in July, the big dinosaur seemed to soften and hint that Jurassic Express weren't quite finished as a tag-team after all. Then, at All Out, Lucha chokeslammed the t*ts off of JB and posed with Christian Cage.

Fans online are already wondering why AEW's creative braintrust bothered to tease the Fyter Fest reunion at all if they were gonna go this route in the end anyway. It also feels rather strange to see Tony Khan use a pay-per-view this massive to effectively set up Dynamite rematches between Cage and Jungle.

There's another rant about card length coming later in the 'Downs' (brace yourselves for that), but this is worth saying here too: All Elite's pacing and presentation was, at times, all over the bloody shop in Chicago. It's the kind of sh*t WWE get criticised for.


3. Thanks For Coming, Malakai Black!

AEW All Out 2022 Sting Darby Allin
AEW

Live reports from fans who were actually in the building say Malakai Black was blowing kisses and waving to fans after doing the J.O.B for Darby Allin in All Out's other six-man exhibition. He might only be taking some time out from wrestling for personal reasons, but Black's AEW career needs a proper rethink.

Losing to Darbs, Sting and Miro here means that his House Of Black group currently floats around the bottom of the rankings for those brand new Trios Titles, and that's sad. They should be one of the most powerful units on the roster, but...they're losing more matches than The Dark Order these days.

It's hard to think positively about any of this.

Yours truly is an old WCW mark who genuinely enjoys seeing the Stinger still out there doing his thing. That nostalgic blast can't stop him from questioning why Malakai is being handled worse than he was by Vince McMahon in WWE.

Wasn't his AEW run supposed to right all of those wrongs?!


2. Too Many Matches

AEW All Out 2022 Powerhouse Hobbs
AEW

Look, no-one out there needs to get into another argument about general show length. It's also pretty impressive that AEW managed to get through this amount of content in a shade under four hours. The agents, producers and workers all deserve credit for that, but yeah...

...All Out didn't need so many attractions.

Stories like Powerhouse Hobbs vs. Ricky Starks, Jade Cargill vs. Athena and even Jungle Boy vs. Christian Cage weren't given nearly enough time to breathe. Meanwhile, rather bizarrely, two exhibition-style six-mans got a combined half hour between them despite barely featuring any must-see narrative going in.

Tony Khan badly needs an editor for these events. Sorry, but he does. Constantly slinging as many matches as a card can handle at fans and screaming about value for money isn't enough. Giving people bang for their pay-per-view dollars/pounds is fine - sacrificing crucial stories isn't.


1. AEW Do Not Get A Pass

AEW All Out 2022 CM Punk
AEW

Some will be surprised to see the main event top these 'Downs'.

That's fair, and the match was enjoyable bell-to-bell. Unfortunately, AEW's build towards what should've been a first-time meeting between Jon Moxley and CM Punk f*cking sucked. Moxley's interim title reign was a waste of time, and they barely even touched on Punk's foot injury side quest.

It's easy to say now, yes, but Tony's panicky interim booking shouldn't have happened even when Punk was struck down by injuries at Double Or Nothing. His story, from emotional 'I'm going away' announcement to return, squash match loss and more, has been messy as f*ck.

Punk has been in AEW for one year and he's already a two-time champ. Something doesn't feel right about that, because it's like the company has burned through an unnecessary amount of storytelling in too short a time period.

They don't get a pass for panicking.


Ups...

7. A Tone Setter

AEW All Out 2022 Zero Hour Eddie Kingston Tomohiro Ishii
AEW

You need a boatload of positivity after all of that whining, right? Same.

Cheerfully, Eddie Kingston and Tomohiro Ishii were on hand to deliver a predictably-physical war on the Zero Hour portion. These boys beat the hell out of one another, and their chop-heavy exchanges were the only thing worth watching on the pre-show full stop.

Chicago's crowd finally got hooked on a match at just the right time (after sitting through some Rampage-worthy card cannon fodder), so it was smart to headline Zero Hour with this one. Kingston and Ishii set the tone for everyone else by delivering physicality without trying to squeeze too many high spots in.

They deserve a pat on the back for that. The best workers know their place on the card and can deliver fun matches without stealing from the true ticket-sellers; that's what Kingston and his absurdly-robust foe achieved here.


6. Jade Cargill Retains

AEW All Out 2022 Jade Cargill
AEW

There were concerns that Tony Khan would flash his knickers at a shiny new ex-WWE toy by giving Athena the TBS Title at All Out. It's not that the former Ember Moon wouldn't be deserving, it's just that well...Jade Cargill is a true homegrown name with star power few on the women's side can match.

That must be protected at all costs.

Jade got to dominate yet again on Sunday night. Some won't have liked the match brevity, and maybe rightly so, but this guy was relieved to see Cargill march on instead of dropping her belt and being shoved to the back of the chasing pack. She's worth more than that, and it seems AEW is fully aware of that.

Seeing Jade go all She-Hulk for the night was a giggle too. She's someone who properly understands the need for pageantry on the bigger events, and the sheer potential she has is borderline crazy. Perhaps All Elite's top brass could be persuaded by a longer match next time, but this was fine for what it was.


5. New Champ & Spin-Off Story

AEW All Out 2022 Toni Storm
AEW

Toni Storm had to win this, didn't she? Her All Elite career has been tail spinning since it started, but she finally has that banner moment to give a sense of purpose to her standing on a crowded roster. At All Out, one could almost see just how much this show of faith meant to Toni.

The four-way to crown a new interim Women's Champ (who knows when Thunder Rosa will return) had another purpose: Britt Baker snuffed out Jamie Hayter's chances of winning the thing, and that'll lead to a spin-off feud between them. It should also see Hayter breakout as a babyface, which will be fun.

Fans getting right behind Jamie is a promising sign for her too. AEW's decision makers would've noticed that from behind the curtain, and they'll be pleased by the early swell of support for what could be a top non-title female rivalry.

No complaints with any of this.


4. The Elite Wins

Kenny Omega The Young Bucks Elite AEW Trios Titles
AEW

Your tolerance for these kind of sugar rush matches will naturally vary, but everyone knows what they're going to get from bouts involving Kenny Omega and The Young Bucks by now. That threesome did their thing, and it was great to see The Dark Order keep up with them to produce a solid six-man.

Like in the women's four-way though, there was a bigger story at play.

Hangman Page accidentally blasted John Silver with his Buckshot Lariat, and that opened the door for Omega to score the pin/snag the titles. It was the right call to put those shiny new belts on The Elite, and it was nice to see a story emerge rather than straight-ahead moves, moves, moves for the sake of them.

Even Alex Reynolds got a chant from the Illinois masses, which was unexpected. Credit where it's due: Reynolds and Silver have blossomed into one of the most dependable teams on the roster. Having Hangman with them helped, but they earned this spot.


3. That Tag Title Fire

AEW All Out 2022 Keith Lee Billy Gunn The Acclaimed
AEW

All Out was a win for the traditional doubles ranks too.

This is the best that Keith Lee and Swerve Strickland have looked as tag champs. Arguably, AEW should've called an audible and put those belts on The Acclaimed (Chicago really wanted to see it), but it's difficult to dump on the match. That's especially true for the second hall, which was straight up awesome.

Max Caster and Anthony Bowens will grab hold of those straps at some point, so nobody should start worrying quite yet. Also, 'Swerve In Our Glory' can stick around a little longer if they're gonna produce the goods on major pay-per-views like they did on Sunday night.

Perhaps the only downer from this entire segment was that unwanted scissor action between Lee and Billy Gunn post-match. The live crowd didn't care for that. Maybe they were still upset that The Acclaimed didn't come out as new champs.

Excellent effort all-round.


2. As Good As Everyone Hoped It’d Be

AEW All Out 2022 Chris Jericho Bryan Danielson Daniel Garcia
AEW

Behold the image of a young lion watching two true masters of their craft.

Chris Jericho vs. Bryan Danielson was a total clinic, as expected. A few grumblers on social media are already querying why Danielson lost, but either one of these veterans winning would've been acceptable. Besides, they delivered a bout that occasionally turned back the clock for Jericho.

It's easy to forget just how good the old 'Lionheart' can be when he's motivated, and Jericho was damn motivated to show off in-ring vs. Bryan. Meanwhile, his JAS stable started to show more cracks as Garcia begins to move onto something else. That side story was a neat complement to the match.

Danielson is one of the best pro wrestlers on the planet, and that means he'll survive this loss. All Elite bosses might want to be careful they don't have BCC members suffer too many high-profile pay-per-view defeats in a row though. Just saying!


1. MJF’s Return

AEW All Out 2022 MJF
AEW

The entire pro wrestling world was stunned when reports surfaced that MJF's future in AEW could be under threat. He had seemed like such a can't-miss prospect - the kind of young star that WWE missed out on and Tony Khan could boast about having. Then, things hit a brick wall.

All's well that ends well.

MJF returned with a bang at All Out. Truthfully, the pay-per-view needed him as much as he needed it, because this was the newsworthy, headline-making moment that the show craved going in. OK, so most could've done without the convoluted 'Joker' business earlier in the show, but it's ace to see MJF back on AEW screens.

Seeing him challenge CM Punk for the World Title will be even better. This, regardless of how bumpy the road there had been, was the strongest possible finish to All Out. It got the fans back onboard in a big way, and let everyone's favourite little pr*ck steal Punk's moment.

What did you think of AEW All Out 2022? For more wrestling, check out 10 New Directions After WWE Clash At The Castle and 4 Ups & 5 Downs From AEW Rampage (Sept 2)!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.