7 Ups And 3 Downs From NXT TakeOver: Philadelphia
Run, don't walk, to see this PPV, including a can't-miss main event.
If you spent your Saturday night watching NXT TakeOver: Philadelphia, chances are you had a pretty damn enjoyable evening. And chances are you are wondering how in the hell WWE is going to top this with the Royal Rumble on Sunday.
NXT has made a habit of throwing down the gauntlet with its Saturday TakeOver shows before a big WWE PPV, but the Philly version might have topped them all, with the last two matches being as close to flawless as you can get. Despite some hiccups here and there, nearly everything clicked during the show. Even the one match this writer didn’t care for was more of a personal opinion, and others won’t see it the same way.
And let’s just say this: If you didn’t like the main event, you have no business calling yourself a wrestling fan. Just call up Cameron the Funkadactyl and discuss the merits of Melina versus Alicia Fox. Johnny Gargano and Andrade “Cien” Almas mesmerized a traditionally tough Philly crowd that already had seen great action from Velveteen Dream, the Undisputed Era and Aleister Black.
Clocking in around two hours, these TakeOvers are usually easy to digest, but you might find your heart racing a little bit in the main event.
Let’s get to it…
Downs...
3. No Nigel
TakeOver opened with a bad omen as Mauro Ranallo announced that broadcast colleague Nigel McGuinness was unable to call the PPV, leaving us with Percy Watson to serve as the sole color commentator.
It turned out that Watson did a serviceable job after months of subpar performances in the booth, but McGuinness’ presence was definitely missed. Nigel has become one of the better color commentators in WWE, and you knew Mauro and Percy were going to have to be on point to account for that missing man.
Thankfully, it all worked out, but still. (And for the record, when this is one of the few negative things you can say about a PPV, that should tell you something.)
2. Breaking Arms
It was bad enough when the Philadelphia fans busted out a “Bulls***” chant after Ember Moon couldn’t cover a defeated Shayna Baszler due to a bad elbow, but what followed was the kind of thing that just shouldn’t happen in 2018.
The appeal of Baszler is that she has legit MMA creds, so when she locked in a cross-armbreaker on Moon after the doctor and ref nearly stopped the match, it really should have been over in a matter of seconds. Instead, Ember fought it for well over a minute, rolling through, grabbing at her arm to prevent it from being straightened out, etc., until she managed a fold-up cover for the pin to escape with her title.
So why is this a down? Moon should have either tapped within 10 seconds or started rolling out of the hold immediately. If you’re relying on the fact that Baszler is a legit MMA fighter, then you have to at least respect that when she slaps a submission hold on an injured body part. The finish could have gone the same way, with time cut down by two-thirds, and it might have worked way better.
Instead, Baszler looked ineffective, rather than it looking like Moon persevered. It didn’t help that the match suffered from other problems (more on that), and this just piled on.
1. Not Quite Ready For Primetime
MMA fighters making the transition over to professional wrestling are not necessarily guaranteed success. Far from it. While there are success stories, there are others who didn’t pan out.
Shayna Baszler is still a relative newcomer to the squared circle in many ways, with a little more than two years under her belt. So this isn’t an indictment of her. However, putting her in a lengthy title match on PPV like this was a mistake.
Baszler has legitimacy as an MMA fighter, and she showed during the Mae Young Classic that she has an aptitude for wrestling. But her match against Ember Moon showed that a bout of any length where she has to step outside her comfort area is still sketchy. Baszler landed a gruesome elbow stomp early in the match and followed with… a standing armbar? She didn’t have much beyond a few basic wrestling and submission moves, and it showed.
If WWE was planning on cashing in on her as a member of the MMA Four Horsewomen, then they should have booked a squash against the Iconic Duo or something like that rather than an NXT Women’s Championship match that led fans to chant, “Bulls***.”
And if they are considering making her the female Brock Lesnar and run through the women's division, then play to her strengths. Long matches aren't among them (yet).
Ups...
7. Never Mention Dallas In Philly
As a semi-local boy, this writer has to acknowledge the fans not missing an opportunity to openly boo a fan-favorite simply due to where she resides.
As Ember Moon was announced for her NXT Women’s Championship match, fans started to cheer, until they heard her as being from “Dallas, Texas.” That led to some strong feelings from the City of Brotherly Love, as fans booed the mention of her hometown (despite cheering Ember) and then letting her know that Dallas definitely sucks.
While this was probably missed by 95% of the fans watching, it was a simple thing that shows that fans are paying attention. And with the Philadelphia Eagles playing in the Super Bowl next week, it was a safe bet that the Philly faithful were going to find a football tie-in on Saturday.
6. Smooth Antics
More on his match itself later, but a quick kudos to Velveteen Dream for antics before, during and after his match against Kassius Ohno.
Dream promised he would knock the Knockout Artist out within 30 seconds during the preshow, then had a personal ring attendant present him a mouthguard (with Velveteen wearing boxing shorts). The Philly fans counted along at the outset, and Dream landed a punch that felled Ohno about 25 seconds into the match.
On cue, Dream celebrated like he had won the match. (The fact that a boxing theme was applied to a match in the home of fictional boxing superhero Rocky Balboa was apropos.) As the match continued, Velveteen kept at it, doing a “Ravishing” Rick Rude impersonation, dancing over Kassius at one point. And after winning, Dream made sure to step on and over Ohno as part of his celebration.
It was a great display of Dream understanding his role and character. Hopefully, this will translate well during his wrestling career, as it seems like he has a bright one.
5. Ciampa Returns
With Johnny Gargano once again wrestling in the main event of an NXT TakeOver PPV, you had to believe there was a better than 50/50 chance that former DIY tag partner Tommaso Ciampa would make his presence felt.
And the Psycho Killer didn’t disappoint.
As Gargano stood on the entrance ramp to soak in cheers from the crowd with his wife Candice LeRae, the end credits came up and you assumed that was it for the night. And just like in Chicago, Ciampa delivered the fatal blow when you thought the cameras would be fading to black. This time, he whacked Gargano with a crutch and just stood over him.
It’s unclear how close Tommaso is to returning, as he had a knee brace on and limped off the stage, but fans definitely still have this rivalry to look forward to in 2018.
4. Dream Come True
After his star-making performance at the last TakeOver PPV, could Velveteen Dream continue to raise the bar on Saturday night?
The answer was a polite “no,” but that didn’t make his match against Kassius Ohno a disappointment. Dream had another hard-hitting match against a strong veteran, winning this bout with a Purple Rainmaker elbow from the ringpost. He stood toe-to-toe with Ohno on punches/forearms and kept coming, even after a cyclone kick and a series of stiff forearms.
This was the kind of win Velveteen needs to up his profile. He clearly has a bright future, and wins like this will only help him. Hats off to Kassius for making him look like a million bucks while also looking solid himself. He has been great in that role for NXT since returning to the company.
3. Styles Clash
When the NXT Tag Team Championship match got underway, it was looking like the heel/heel dynamic and odd pairing was going to drag the match down. And while it took a bit to click, the match ended up working pretty well.
The Authors of Pain have been a dominant heel team for much of their NXT tenure, overpowering opponents and matching up best with speedy, strong moves. Kyle O’Reilly and Bobby Fish were also heels, but are not as flashy as some of AOP’s top opponents. They use more strikes and submission wrestling.
It was also weird to see AOP’s Akam playing the “face-in-peril” roll, but it worked well enough. O’Reilly’s submission moves looked odd at first since he was so much smaller, but they kept at it and made a believer out of this writer.
By the end of the match, fans were rocking along with the bout, which ended with Undisputed Era capitalizing on Akam’s injury rather than outright cheating to win. That might be a subtle difference to some, but it’s huge – and smart to keep both groups strong.
2. An Extremely Good Match
When you put two guys in the ring who understand how to put together a great match, odds are that’s exactly what you’re going to get. Throw in a few weapons in the city of Extreme, and you’ve got Aleister Black versus Adam Cole (Bay-be!).
Cole and Black had a really, really good match that mixed in chairs, tables, ladders and kendo sticks in the right proportion while battling back and forth. Black took a hellacious shot when he caught a tossed chair that was superkicked into his face, knocking him off the turnbuckle and through two tables on the floor. Cole got put through the announce table after Sanity ran off the rest of the Undisputed Era.
In the end, Black remained undefeated by taking out Cole with Black Mass. It was a well-laid-out match with no slow points or down spots, which is exactly what you’d want.
1. MOTY
If you watch nothing else from TakeOver Philadelphia, fast-forward to the NXT Championship match between Johnny Gargano and Andrade “Cien” Almas. Watch it. Then watch it again. If you don’t come out of your seat two or three times in shock, you might want to check your pulse.
Gargano and Almas tore the house down with a match built on Johnny Wrestling’s standing as NXT’s ultimate underdog, while Cien relied on his manager Zelina Vega to bail him out of a few tight spots. The two wrestled an almost-flawless match, with Gargano refusing to give up and constantly pushing Almas to the brink.
The last 10 minutes were a series of moves, counters, two-count pinfalls and crowd freak-outs over and over. At least three times, everyone bought a moment as the finish. Even the normally cynical Philly fans were unable to fire off any snark, as Andrade and Johnny delivered a tremendous bout from beginning to finish.
Some will say that Gargano not winning the title should be a huge “down,” but part of what makes him so appealing to fans is his constant pursuit and effort to overcome. He needs to get to the mountaintop, but this was fine for an ending. For now.