7 Ups And 7 Downs From WWE Payback 2015

Solid matches and a hot crowd, but PPV overload could be setting in...

The seemingly never-ending parade of WWE PPVs continued Sunday night with Payback, a hastily assembled affair that exceeded low expectations and delivered several quality matches. A hot crowd that reacted to nearly everything and stayed strong throughout the night certainly added something, but the performers definitely upped their game. Payback was the second of four special events taking place within a seven-week span from late April through mid-June, a rapid-fire run that could lead to a WWE overdose among fans. On paper, there really wasn€™t much to draw people in: Extreme Rules, Elimination Chamber and Money in the Bank all have their gimmick matches to sell each event. Payback offered seven matches (on the main card) with the only €œgimmicks€ being a two-out-of-three falls tag title match, a Fatal Four-way for the WWE World Heavyweight Championship and an €œI Quit€ match for the United States Championship. Despite the rushed, nondescript nature of the PPV, those who watched were treated to solid matches overall and an evening that breezed by. Being in a period where you sometimes walk away from WWE programming cringing, having an enjoyable evening is a welcome occasion. So what put butts in the seats and what sent fans heading for the exits? Let€™s find out.

Downs...

7. A King-Sized Dilemma

It€™s hard to call this a €œdown,€ but the third encounter between Neville and King Barrett pretty much left the door wide open for a fourth match between the two Brits. And while every bout they€™ve had has been pretty entertaining, WWE is painting itself into a proverbial corner with this one. Barrett is in need of some serious momentum after winning the King of the Ring tournament last month, otherwise it€™s just another meaningless €œachievement€ for him. Sure, Barrett can lose a feud here and there, but not the first one after winning KOTR. Neville has made great strides in his first six weeks on the main roster, and it€™s obvious WWE brass is high on him, so losing to Barrett could slow him down a little. What to do? Booking a countout victory for Neville really was a cop-out €“ unless WWE is going to blow things off in the Elimination Chamber for the Intercontinental Championship. In that case, having Neville capture the title by beating Barrett could be an interesting course, especially if Neville comes out of it with a new challenger. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xC95Ju_DHxQ This is one where it really isn€™t a negative on its face, but WWE€™s history of mishandling situations like this has to give you pause. Ideally, this rivalry would be well-booked and elevate both men. Time will tell in this case

6. Battle Of The Insignificant

Not every match on PPV can be a main event in any arena, but some matches that come across our screens just leave fans scratching their heads. Take the €œbonus€ Payback kickoff match between R-Truth and Stardust. These two define directionless right now, as they both have lost at least twice as many televised matches as they€™ve won this year. It also doesn€™t help when the announcers try to make this into a real feud, claiming that the match stems from €œlong-standing issues€ between the two, specifically the King of the Ring qualifier three weeks ago. Of course, there was the match on Raw two weeks ago that Stardust won by bringing a bag of fake spiders to the ring, so the stakes had been raised heading into this match. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QmKB2dMnan0 Snark aside, throwing two guys out there like this for a match that no one has any reason to care about does absolutely nothing to help either competitor. Give us a reason to care about these guys or don€™t put them out there. And leave the spiders at home too.

5. Flashing Too Much

For whatever reason, there seems to be a new trend during WWE televised events, where some idiot fan opposite the hard camera waves his (or her) cell phone flashlight at the camera whenever it is focused on the ring. This forces the camera to zoom in more to crop the annoying fan out of the shot or make rapid cuts to other cameras. The result is a distraction that keeps growing until security shuts it down, hopefully kicking the €œfan€ out of the arena. This happened on Raw a couple weeks back, resulting in the same tight shots and rapid cuts. Seeing it again Sunday raises a concern that this is a new trend that could continue. There€™s no reason for this to take place, and hopefully WWE will find a way to quickly nip this in the bud.

4. Mega Dud

It€™s bad enough that the Axelmania/Macho Mandow tribute quickly devolved into parody, but when the match simply becomes an opportunity for announcers to work in as many insider jokes as possible, you know you have a horrible gimmick. JBL spent the entire match (all three minutes) burying the gimmicks and working in references to Nacho Man and the Huckster (from the then-WWF€™s €œBillionaire Ted€ sketches during the Monday Night War) and Fake Razor and Diesel (another Monday Night War-era deal). To top it off, the Ascension made short work of Curtis Axel and Damien Sandow, who both are infinitely more talented than Konnor and Viktor. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EnhFg2WM_VQ If this was the one and only appearance of the duo and this crushing defeat knocks them to their senses, then count this as a positive. But instead, we€™ll probably get three more weeks of this before the two split up and feud. WWE will probably have a Diva stand in for Miss Elizabeth too, just to make it worse.

3. Kane Stays The Course

In the lead-up to Payback, Kane emerged as the central antagonist to Seth Rollins€™ title reign, setting him up in a triple threat match, then opening the door to add Dean Ambrose to the match. The sight of a conflicted Kane being pushed around by a spoiled champion got fans to jump behind the Big Red Machine for the first time in what felt like eons. It felt like we were on the verge of Kane stepping out from his corporate suit and re-emerging as an individual force again. Alas, we got the status quo Sunday night. After weeks of going from the least interesting character in the WWE main event scene to a central figure, Kane bucked all conventional wisdom and remained a loyal company man. An argument could be made that his loyalty to Triple H and the Authority superseded his hatred of Rollins, but Kane almost seemed gleeful to interfere in the Fatal Four-way, which he did so liberally throughout the match. Kane could have at least appeared somewhat conflicted or resigned to getting involved, but it was easy to lose count of the number of times he interfered. While we could see Kane and Rollins at each other€™s throats again as soon as Monday, it feels like a lost opportunity at Payback.

2. Pay-Per-View-A-Palooza

While Payback delivered several solid matches and managed to not be offensive (save really for the pre-show), it sadly will be forgotten almost immediately, as WWE has to begin building up to Elimination Chamber in two weeks. While seeing the Elimination Chamber make a return is welcome, jumping straight into another PPV so soon leaves little to no time to actually digest what happened at Payback. In fact, when you consider that Money in the Bank will take place two weeks after Elimination Chamber, it will be four WWE PPVs in a seven-week span. Throw in the King of the Ring special too and you€™ve got five events (and that doesn€™t even count NXT Takeover: Unstoppable). It€™s nearly impossible to become invested in the outcome of one event when there€™s another literally around the corner. On the one hand, it€™s good to see WWE take advantage of the Network for stuff like King of the Ring and Elimination Chamber, but bunching stuff up like this could very easily lead to fan burnout and apathy.

1. Who Quits?

WWE backed itself into a corner at Payback by booking an €œI Quit€ match between a nearly indestructible Bulgarian Brute and a grappler whose entire mantra is €œNever give up.€ So what€™s the easy, cheap way out of that? Have someone else say the words for one of the wrestlers. The problem with this is the stipulation itself. Eden very clearly spelled it out by saying that the only way to win is to make your opponent literally say the words, €œI quit.€ This stip reared its ugly head toward the end when Rusev made John Cena pass out in the Accolade €“ which in any other type of match would have won the United States Championship for him €“ but since Cena never said the words, the match continued. Fast-forward to the end, with Rusev hooked in the STF yelling in (presumably) Bulgarian, and Lana jumped into the ring, grabbed the mic and said that Rusev quit €“ which the ref took to be good enough and called for the bell. So does that mean that Rusev simply should have kept beating on an unconscious Cena earlier until someone ran out from the back to quit for him? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UpEs7lzA8IU OK, it€™s professional wrestling, not a court case. There are going to be loopholes and logic gaps. But this just defied any logic at all. It might be a plot point to break up Lana and Rusev, but come on.

Ups€

7. Another Divas Duo Rises Up

Like it or not, the Bella Twins are the faces of the Divas division in WWE. Since returning in 2013, they have been front and center on WWE programming, whether it€™s promoting €œTotal Divas€ or dominating in the ring. The sudden retirement of AJ Lee certainly did not help shake up that image. That€™s why it was refreshing to see Naomi undergo a character change and enlist the help of her cousin Tamina to take on the Bellas €“ and then defeat them convincingly at Payback. Regardless of all the comments that the Bellas are improved in the ring, they still lag behind several female competitors, most notably the majority of NXT women€™s roster. The twins still have a role to play in WWE, but being a dominating force should not be it. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RpabzTQeFCE Watching Naomi (who busted out Chris Jericho€™s arrogant cover) and Tamina take out the Bellas was a welcome sight, and hopefully there is a sea change coming. With NXT competitors like Charlotte and Sasha Banks ready to make an impact in WWE, that change hopefully will be coming soon.

6. Battle Of The Big Guys

Call it the advantage of having low expectations, but Ryback versus Bray Wyatt was better than what anyone could have expected. The feud popped up out of nowhere a couple weeks ago after Wyatt€™s cryptic promos found their target, Ryback. It could have been an interesting pairing, but Bray€™s €œRyback got in my way€ reasoning didn€™t help matters. However, the duo put in solid work at Payback, delivering a hard-hitting match that saw Lucha Bray hit a senton from the ring apron to the floor and Air Ryback, with the Big Guy hitting a top rope splash. It wasn€™t a great match, but they had fans hanging in there throughout the bout. The power moves and false finishes, coupled with Wyatt using an exposed turnbuckle to win, gave fans more than they bargained for. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H611HgOb6lg Does this make this a worthwhile feud? It€™s doubtful, but at least they put on a good show for their first match.

5. A New Era For New Day

A couple months ago, it looked like Kofi Kingston, Big E and Xavier Woods would soon be banished to Superstars and WWE Main Event, never to sniff the main programs again unless they were cannon fodder. The New Day was greeted with absolute silence and no one seemed to care from the minute the trio stepped on stage until they went back behind the curtain. Then a funny thing happened. The group turned up its message of positivity several notches and began dialing in small doses of sarcasm, which started to elicit a response from the crowd €“ jeers. Since then, they have continued to turn up the sarcasm and smarmy attitude, which has turned them into a full-fledged heel act. And they€™ve played that to the hilt, giving New Day new life. Throw in Woods trying to use the €œFreebird Rule€ to enter the match between falls (which was predicted here) and then illegally subbing in to steal the deciding fall and you have a group that suddenly has legs. Let€™s hope WWE doesn€™t bail on them too soon.

4. A Little Color

Ever since WWE went PG, the instances of bloodshed in matches have been extremely limited, typically to accidents. Lately, however, we€™ve seen more and more situations where wrestlers have gotten a little color in their matches. Whether this is a slight reversal of policy, if done correctly, a little blood can add something to a match. Case in point, Dolph Ziggler was making a comeback against Sheamus. He threw a headbutt, only to be busted wide open. Almost immediately, he went from being on offense to too dazed to function and ate a Brogue Kick seconds later to lose. The sight of blood magnified how injured Ziggler was, tempering his loss a little. At the same time, it made Sheamus look like a killer, standing over a bloodied and beaten opponent. It will be interesting to see if this was something that was authorized, or if it truly was accidental. Even if the higher-ups okayed it, chances are we€™ll get the same denial we did about Brock Lesnar bleeding at WrestleMania €“ which was another effective use of bloodshed to drive a bigger narrative.

3. Rusev And Cena Give Fair Warning

Rusev and John Cena were not reserved in repeatedly having referee Mike Chioda ask the other if he quit. In fact, they sometimes wanted their opponent asked multiple times in a matter of seconds. But one of the better uses of the question came before several big moves. Rusev started the trend, asking Cena if he quit, or else he would get whipped into the steel steps set up inside the ring. Cena pulled the same stunt before crashing Rusev through the timekeeper€™s barricade and again before bashing the Bulgarian Brute with a metal barricade. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yf6F1hHFgJc The pre-emptive request was a cool wrinkle to the typical €œonly ask if your opponent quits after every big move.€ By asking before a big, painful move, Cena and Rusev left it that their opponent only had himself to blame if he took the punishment. It also made the wrestler think about the pain that was coming if they answered, €œno.€ That, in some ways, is better than simply beating them to a pulp €“ make them think about the beating that€™s coming.

2. A Shield Mini-Reunion

Ever since their breakup a year ago, fans have clamored for the day when all three members of the Shield reunite. We got our first taste of what that reunion would feel like Sunday night, when Seth Rollins, Dean Ambrose and Roman Reigns combined to triple powerbomb Randy Orton through an announce table. The crowd reaction to the powerbomb and mini-reunion was off the charts. If it had been the real deal, fans would have collectively lost their minds. As it turned out, it was simply a one-off, the trio combining to take out Orton. Ambrose and Reigns no-sold Rollins€™ attempt at a Shield fist bump and ganged up on him, sending the fans again into a frenzy. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OmzUF102S5w The simple truth is, the members of the Shield are easily three of the most popular guys on the roster, and if they were to reform, the crowd reaction would be deafening. Sunday€™s mini-reunion planted the seeds ever so slightly that we could see something like that in the not-too-distant future. If handled properly, it could be huge. For now, maybe WWE should just run triple threat matches between all three regularly, as they know how to deliver entertaining performances whether they are teaming or mortal enemies.

1. Tag Team Wrestling Takes Center Stage

If Sunday€™s New Day versus Cesaro/Kidd match doesn€™t encourage WWE to go back to contesting all Tag Team Championship matches as two-out-of-three falls, then something is wrong with the company. The tag title bout was a show-stealer, with all five men (counting Xavier Woods) delivering a collectively awesome performance. The teams hit some incredible moves that exemplified why fans still love tag team wrestling: Tyson Kidd timing Cesaro€™s delayed vertical suplex before helping to force Kofi Kingston to the ground; Kidd€™s catapult into a spinebuster and giant swing/dropkick for the first fall; Big E spearing Cesaro through the ropes and out of the match; Kidd then having no one to tag for the rest of the second fall; and the backbreaker/springboard elbow combo from Cesaro and Kidd. Describing those moves doesn€™t do them justice. Both teams had fans eating outing of their hands, and it€™s worth a second look. Of course, the finish €“ Xavier Woods sneaking in to steal the final pin after failing to successfully use the €œFreebird Rule€ earlier €“ perfectly capped the match, with the fresh man holding down a spent Cesaro. This match showed why a 2/3 falls match still is an awesome tool to break out. Perhaps WWE should revert to the old Saturday Night€™s Main Event deal for tag title matches and have them always be held under 2/3 falls rules.

Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.