7 Ups And 8 Downs From WWE Survivor Series 2019
NXT 'wins' battle for brand supremacy; head-scratching booking loses.
On Saturday, NXT did what it usually does when there’s a TakeOver before a WWE PPV: throw down the gauntlet with some incredible wrestling and dare the main roster to beat them.
Sunday, WWE delivered a fairly enjoyable Survivor Series PPV that didn’t have any horrible matches and produced a couple really good ones. However, the two best ones featured NXT wrestlers prominently, so maybe there was a reason for that.
Overall, Survivor Series was hampered by the “brand supremacy” motif that now dominates the event. Either you love the inter-brand rivalry that only exists for about four weeks of the year, or you detest it.
Regardless, we got decent to excellent in-ring action with some questionable decisions from the writing team. None of these were cardinal sins, and while there are more “downs” listed than “ups,” that shouldn’t discourage you from checking out the PPV. But fair warning, there were plenty of moments where you had to question the booking choices made.
You get the feeling that WWE occasionally is just a couple steps away from putting on an outstanding show, but then makes 3-4 decisions that drop the event a few notches into the “decent” or “average” range. Someday, somehow, that’s gotta change.
For now though, let’s get to it…
Downs...
8. Battle Royal Nonsense
OK, so the cross-branded tag team battle royal (try saying that fast three times) did count toward the overall tally of Raw versus SmackDown versus NXT matches for the night, but really, did anyone actually care or pay attention?
The match breezed by with teams getting eliminated about every minute with no real rhyme or reason. The end came down to The OC, Street Profits and Robert Roode & Dolph Ziggler, the latter pair emerging victorious.
The crowd was pretty silent for much of the match, only coming alive for the Street Profits at the end (so or course, they were eliminated last), and some “CM Punk” guy.
Wouldn’t it have been 20 times better to do something as simple as put a tag title shot on the line as a prize to the team that wins? Winning team score a point for their brand (which is the real prize here!), but they also get a tag title shot later this week. Easy.
But apparently, that’s too much thinking for the 37 writers to work out.
7. The Sounds Of Silence
Assuming a large portion of WWE fans have not watched NXT regularly, you would want to try to “get over” as much of their personas as possible. And one simple way sometimes could be to shut up and let them do their thing.
Adam Cole has a distinct entrance that involves audience participation. It’s not the most groundbreaking thing out there, but it shows immense fan awareness and familiarity with the NXT Champion.
So, as Cole made his entrance Sunday, what happened? Nigel McGuinness and Michael Cole talked over the first part (where he gestures “Boom!” at himself). And then, they cut to a replay from Saturday night right before he did his “Adam Cole Bay-Bay!” gesture, muting the crowd.
It wouldn’t have taken much effort to quiet down and delay the video replay by five seconds to get that portion of Cole’s entrance across to fans. And it’s not like what he does is a mystery to the production monkeys in the back.
6. Screwy Storytelling
Teams overcoming the odds to triumph is a normal story that often works very well in wrestling. In the realm of Survivor Series, a team down in the number of wrestlers coming back to win can be a powerful tale.
But when that team is decimated by its own infighting, it makes the story tougher to swallow.
Team SmackDown in the men’s Survivor Series match saw two of its five members eliminated due to squabbles amongst teammates, with King Corbin distracting Mustafa Ali, leading to him falling to a stomp, and Roman Reigns taking Corbin out with a spear and allowing Tommaso Ciampa to pin him.
This left Reigns by himself, and he managed to pull out the win for his team. That by itself is not a negative. But having the team that couldn’t hold it together still win (see the women’s Team Raw for an example of the right way to have a meltdown) was just screwy.
5. Missed Opportunity
Little things can make wrestling great, but they also can count against you when you miss them.
A theme heading into the men’s Survivor Series match was whether Team Raw could trust Kevin Owens, who Saturday night joined Team Ciampa at NXT TakeOver: WarGames. And early in the match, we got a test: Tommaso Ciampa and Shorty G were down in the ring and KO climbed to the top rope to deliver a frogsplash, but he had to choose who to attack.
He chose SmackDown’s Gable for the splash and pin. It added to the story that Owens was secretly siding with NXT.
But then moments later, KO was getting back into the ring and Ciampa caught him with a draping DDT for the pinfall, ending Owens’ night – and the mystery.
WHY? Why would you do that? Why not have Shorty G or Mustafa Ali or anyone on Team SmackDown eliminate Owens? You could have kept that veneer up a little longer, maybe even beyond Survivor Series.
Instead, the mystery, which started Saturday night and carried over into Sunday and into the damn match itself, was ended just like that. Dumb.
4. Too Much Humanity
The upside of adding NXT to the Survivor Series PPV was that the company’s third brand got some much-needed exposure. The downside was that it increased the size of every match by 50%.
In the case of the 5-on-5 (-on-5) Survivor Series elimination matches, that just proved to be way too much, especially in the women’s bout. There was too much dead weight in the match to really allow for things to flow. You could have nixed Toni Storm (sorry, love her, but she added nothing to the match), Dana Brooke and Sarah Logan and not lost anything except about 5 minutes off the match.
If WWE is going to insist on keeping NXT in the mix in Survivor Series PPVs going forward, they might want to consider a switch to a 4-on-4-on-4 lineup to keep things moving at a good pace.
3. WWE Misses The Point
The moment NXT was brought into the mix for Survivor Series, you had to wonder how the WWE braintrust would book them for this PPV. If you’re a diehard NXT fan, you certainly would be skeptical.
And there were quite a few instances where you’d have to wonder what they were thinking. Why bring WALTER in for his WWE PPV debut and job him out in 3 minutes? Why have Toni Storm debut and do absolutely nothing of note? Why have Seth Rollins – persona non grata among a large swath of fans – eliminate Tommaso Ciampa? Why not give Keith Lee some actual time to shine against Roman Reigns and really earn that respect fist bump afterward? Why have Matt Riddle get taken out like a geek without showcasing any of his talents?
The fans were clearly jonesing for NXT to take center stage, and while they technically “won” Survivor Series, there were quite a few instances where they missed the point. Not all of these were critical mistakes, but it shows that the company still doesn’t entirely get it.
2. Women’s Match Stumbles
This writer tried to really enjoy the main event, but something about it just felt completely… off.
The crowd just wasn’t into it, and it’s not like they were burned out. Bayley, Becky Lynch and Shayna Baszler all are capable wrestlers who have had really good PPV matches, so this should have worked. And maybe as a one-on-one between Lynch and Baszler, it would have. But as a triple threat, it just didn’t hold up.
And while someone had to lose, Bayley’s post-heel turn period has been less than stellar. She lost her SmackDown Women’s Championship (though she quickly regained it), changed her look from something truly distinctive to what could be politely called nondescript, lost to Charlotte Flair several times, and taken a backseat in this mini-rivalry.
The women tried really hard, and this wasn’t a bad match, but it also wasn’t all that good, definitely not what you’d want from your main event.
1. Mysterios Job Out
Maybe we should have ended the storyline between Rey Mysterio and Brock Lesnar after Rey decimated The Beast on Raw with a steel pipe.
Now, the conclusion to this story was that Rey and his son ganged up on Lesnar with a pipe and chair and Brock still managed to beat them about 20 seconds after they attacked him. Seriously, from the time Lesnar kicked out of a pinfall attempt to when he pinned Mysterio was less than 1 minute.
So Rey and his son were beaten and abused by Lesnar, only gained a modicum of retribution, and then were squashed like geeks in a matter of minutes despite hitting the champ in the groin and beating him with a pipe.
Sign us up for Dominick Mysterio’s WWE debut. Can’t wait.
Ups...
7. Cruiserweights Speed It Up
Man, what a mess.
The NXT Cruiserweight Championship match between Lio Rush, Akira Tozawa and Kalisto was not a good match. It was sloppy and disjointed. But the match was fast-paced throughout, and the story (which Byron Saxton and Aiden English missed) was Raw and SmackDown teaming up on NXT’s Rush multiple times.
The upstart brand’s champ had a target on his back for multiple reasons, but he managed to grab a victory and retain his title. The ending, which featured Tozawa’s German suplex with Kalisto stealing the pinfall attempt, followed by a Salida del Sol and Final Hour, was nicely done and ended the match on a positive note.
We’ll give this passing marks for that finish, but barely.
6. Tag Teams Persist
The tag team triple threat match on the Survivor Series kickoff show was a great lesson in not giving up and continuing to push forward.
The bout was not clicking all that well in the beginning – with the fans in attendance or as it came through the TV. It felt like a forced three-way bout, trying to do psychology and to sell the brand battle as Big E and Ivar teamed up to take out Undisputed Era.
But that quickly gave way to all six men just trying to top the other with crazy maneuvers: Erik slamming Ivar off the apron onto everyone else, Kofi alley-ooping Big E to the floor, Viking Raiders hitting a springboard German suplex on Big E, Undisputed Era hitting High/Low on Kofi Kingston, then trying it on Ivar, only for him to cartwheel out of it.
It was a pretty good match, not great, but good enough with some decent car crash material in the second half of the contest.
5. Asuka, Charlotte Break Down
One of the annual gripes this column has during Survivor Series each year is how rivalries are immediately pushed aside for the good of “defending the brand,” which is just a silly motif.
So when a rivalry bubbles up during an elimination match, you’ve got to pay special mind to it.
Asuka and Charlotte Flair actually have a lengthy history with each other, though WWE seems to downplay it from time to time. Flair ended Asuka’s WWE undefeated streak at WrestleMania 34 and has had the upper hand on her multiple times. Recently on Raw, Charlotte has battled Asuka in tag team action a few times, reigniting that feud a bit.
So when Charlotte blind-tagged herself into the match Sunday night, Asuka took offense, and Flair’s ego – yelling, “Get out of my ring!” – only worsened it. The Empress of Tomorrow left the ring, but returned seconds later to nail Charlotte with the green mist(!), blinding her and allowing Lacey Evans to pin Flair.
It would be nice to see these two now engage in a serious singles feud, because it could provide some really good matches, and it could serve as a #1 contender’s match if WWE so desired. Regardless, let’s hope there’s some follow-up Monday night.
4. A Clever ‘Injury’
When Candice LeRae and Io Shirai came up lame during a match breakdown and had to be helped to the back, this writer was prepping a negative comment, noting that it was a pretty lame way to “eliminate” two wrestlers and leave NXT at a huge disadvantage.
And then it all paid off at the end of the match.
Shirai and LeRae returned at the climax of the match, saving captain Rhea Ripley from Sasha Banks and helping her secure a win for Team NXT. Since they never were actually eliminated, they were able to return and help her out.
Thus, the NXT women won with three survivors, which is pretty damn impressive.
3. Bryan Does What Rollins Couldn’t
Thank God for Daniel Bryan.
After two disastrous matches between Seth Rollins and Bray Wyatt, you had to wonder whether The Fiend was dead in the water. Their matches at Hell in a Cell and Crown Jewel were likely designed to be like a horror movie, but they didn’t play out quite as well, and they descended into self-parody – only WWE wasn’t in on the joke.
Enter Bryan, who challenged Wyatt for the WWE Universal Championship at Survivor Series Bryan went on the offensive right away, to no effect, but he stayed after The Fiend in what was a more competitive match that featured more conventional moves (unlike Rollins, who stomped Wyatt’s head a dozen times, spamming his own finisher).
Bryan nailed his Running Knee finisher once for a two count, then broke out of a Mandible Claw and charged for another knee, only to get caught with a claw and pass out into a pinfall. Simple and effective.
Fiend looked dominant, while Bryan looked like a game challenger who was outmatched by an unearthly villain, but he didn’t look like a doofus hitting his opponent in the head with a sledgehammer after 23 curbstomps.
2. Secondary Title Triple Threat Is Top-Notch
You’d be forgiven if you thought the triple threat between three heels – AJ Styles, Shinsuke Nakamura and Roderick Strong – would connect with the crowd, but you’d also be wrong.
After a short feeling-out process, the trio engaged in a solid bout, with Nakamura looking more motivated than he has in a good while. We saw some nice double teams on the third man, and each wrestler got plenty of time to shine. Strong hit his array of backbreakers and slams, Shinsuke kicked and kneed everything that moves, and AJ was, well, phenomenal.
The end result, with Styles hitting the Phenomenal Forearm and Strong stealing the pin on Nakamura, worked pretty well too. Even in defeat, Shin controlled large swaths of the match, and someone had to eat the pinfall.
1. Cole, Dunne Steal The Show
When the NXT Championship match began with Adam Cole and Pete Dunne selling their injuries from TakeOver: WarGames, you got the sinking feeling that they were going to use the wounds to dumb the match down to WWE pace (noticeably slower, more basic).
Instead, the two ramped things up and just unloaded on each other, hitting all their signature spots. Dunne hit his X-Plex, moonsault to the floor and a Bitter End for a close two count. Cole caught Dunne’s attempted moonsault out of the corner with a superkick, nailed a Panama Sunrise on the apron and hit a Shining Wizard.
There were too many false finishes to count, but the actual ending was memorable: Dunne went for a second Bitter End, only for Cole to seamlessly counter into a modified Panama Sunrise, and then immediately nail the Last Shot for the pin.
Great, great match. If you weren’t a fan of NXT before the match, you had to be afterward.