7 Wrestlers WCW Gave Up On

If at first you don't succeed... hire the real Ultimate Warrior three years later.

WCW The Renegade
WWE

At the height of their 1998 excess, the long-departed Atlanta promotion WCW had something like 700,000 wrestlers on their active roster, not including loanees from Japan and those sent on exchange programmes in the other direction.

So it's only natural - similar to the problem WWE have today owing to their gratuitously large talent pool - that not everybody could be pushed to the top of the card. In fact, the fat contracts and creative control of an elite, black-and-white wearing cartel virtually guaranteed that all but half a dozen or so veterans occupied the sharp end of PPVs for all of WCW's brief time on top.

That's not to say the company didn't try to make new stars. It's just that they when they did, they'd more often than not fall foul of the Hogan test. WCW turned the boat around on a handful of potential new draws in the pre-nWo years of Nitro, nearly all of them owing to a yellow and red intervention. After the faction's emergence, routes to the top became basically impassable.

And that's when WCW clearly stopped even trying in earnest. They can't have been serious about Berlyn, right?

7. The Renegade

Renegade WCW
PWI/WWE

WCW were so convinced of snagging The Ultimate Warrior's signature ahead of Uncensored '95 that they started hyping the debut at the show of "The Ultimate Surprise!".

Only, they didn't get big Jim to sign on the dotted line - yet continued to promote him anyway.

Come the pay-per-view, out ran a man something almost but not entirely unlike the Warrior, replete with slightly off facepaint and slightly off Jimmy Hart theme music. Given some fans aren't willing to believe to this very day that the actual Ultimate Warrior who appeared at WrestleMania VIII was the real deal, absolutely nobody was falling for WCW's scam.

'The Renegade', as he was known, looked like Warrior - if you squinted your brain - and he moved like Warrior. He was even pushed like Warrior, almost immediately beating Arn Anderson for the Television Championship. But this wasn't Warrior, and WCW's fans rightly rejected the lame gimmick.

When the real McCoy contacted several magazines to dispel any suggestion that this significantly smaller and significantly crapper copy was him, the game was up. Their scheme exposed, WCW quickly took the TV title off Renegade and sent him plummeting down the pecking order.


6. The Demon

Kiss Demon Wcw
WWE.com

WCW gave up on Dale 'KISS Demon' Torborg's WCW push the very moment they were no longer contractually obliged to it.

The product of Eric Bischoff's increasingly debilitating self-indulgence, The Demon emerged amidst hubris in 1999 as part of a deal which saw Gene Simmons' aging rockers ("the greatest band in the world!" according to Tony Schiavone) slaughter a segment of Nitro. For the use of his likeness, the expy was guaranteed a main event PPV contest, and there was to be a number of other demons representing the other band members.

The achingly terrible 'Warriors of KISS' project was canned alongside Bischoff, the only man - in the world, not just in the boardroom - who liked the gimmick. Shortly after the KISS concert drew one of the lowest ratings in Nitro's history, Easy E was dismissed, before the Demon could even make his in-ring debut. Yet WCW still had a deal to honour. The Demon was haphazardly plugged into a 'Special Main Event' against The Wall at Superbrawl - actually the fourth match on the show - and after being defeated, was quickly and quietly relegated to the bottom of the card.


5. Berlyn

Alex Wright Berlyn
WWE.com

WCW were so confident that Alex Wright's repackaging as Europunk heel Berlyn was going to be a roaring hit that they tied the German down to a frankly preposterous $375,000 per annum contract at the turn of 1999. Keep in mind Wright had previously portrayed a dancing wunderkind of zero consequence as context for that figure's excess.

It goes without saying that with such financial backing, WCW were going to go all out to ensure Berlyn unified fan opinion. A debut promo for the ages ensured the Teutonic terror did precisely that - but not at all how the company envisaged.

Gene Okerlund squirmed in his shoes as Berlyn delivered one answer after another in German, each line translated by interpreter Uta Ludendorff, a woman with all the acting skills of David Hasselhoff. The awful, awkward segment met the derision of fans, and when WCW further noticed their new character bore inadvertent resemblance to the perpetrators of the recent Columbine high school massacre, Berlyn was shelved.

He later returned in September, but the company was clearly no longer interested. His first major programme was a shambles; original opponent Buff Bagwell refused to lose, and replacement Jim Duggan refused to sell. WCW eventually decided that bodyguard The Wall (yes, hilarious) had more upside than the Rivethead rotter, and that meant it was (iron) curtains for Berlyn.


4. Chris Jericho

Chris Jericho WCW
WWE.com

WCW didn't so much give up on Chris Jericho as never bank on him in the first place, making it pretty much the one company he worked for where he didn't become an undeniable star - despite his undeniable talents.

The future Y2J was caught in Eric Bischoff's talent dragnet in 1996, as the WCW honcho looked to saturate Nitro with the world's finest technical wrestlers. Unfortunately, this policy gratingly clashed with the star-studded portrait at the top of the card, meaning Eric's Fledglings were exclusively restricted to the undercard.

Lost in the shuffle was 'Lionheart' Chris Jericho, a generic babyface with less colour than a Humphrey Bogart noir flick. Although Bischoff reckoned Jericho could be the next Sting, his retrograde character - one who refused to take a countout victory - had been made passé by his peers in the nWo. Going heel was the only solution - and in taking matters into his own hands, WCW lost all interest in any Jericho push.

This was despite the fact that, under his own steam, the Canadian became the most entertaining part of Nitro, as he was given fifteen minutes every week to more or less fill as he saw fit. Over time, Jericho became dangerously over, and as soon as he started tapping on the ceiling with a challenge to Goldberg, WCW took notice.

It was the worst thing that could happen. Goldberg refused to answer the call, and Jericho was admonished for his impertinence. He knew there and then he'd never accomplish anything in Georgia.


3. Konnan

Konnan Hulk Hogan
WWE

Much like his cosmological Max Moon gimmick had crashed on entry in WWE, Konnan's WCW push was cancelled before he'd even stepped in the ring.

After a brief, weeks-long stint in Georgia at the turn of the decade, the AAA and ECW star returned to WCW as part of the same talent drive that'd seen the likes of Chris Jericho, Eddie Guerrero and Dean Malenko try to play with the big boys. Only Konnan was originally slated to play with the biggest boy: Hulk Hogan.

That's according to the man himself, anyway. As Konnan tells the story, booker Kevin Sullivan promised that he and Hogan would contest a series of matches in the United States and Mexico, hence why the newcomer and the Hulkster posed for an unlikely belt-tugging promo shot. However, it obviously never transpired, with Konnan speculating that as soon as WCW found he could only work the Mexican style, they immediately lost interest.

That said, he still entered the company with a bang, claiming the United States Championship from One Man Gang within a week of his arrival. It just wasn't quite as loud a bang as he'd hoped.


2. Bret Hart

Bret Hart WCW
WWE.com

After his WWE execution in the infamous double-crosshairs of the Montreal Screwjob, Bret 'Hitman' Hart arrived in WCW as the most talked about talent in town. Only, despite being handed the biggest pink and black gift horse in the world, WCW didn't seem to have any particular interest in their solar-hot commodity.

Case in point: Hart's first port of call in Atlanta was as a referee, just about calling the shots in the long-awaited showdown between Sting and Hulk Hogan at Starrcade '97. Although a component of what was supposed to be the company's apex, Bret came off as tertiary, hardly helped by the match's underwhelming delivery.

Though WCW did endeavour to position Hart more appropriately after his tepid debut - he was given a run with the top title and picked to lead yet another nWo reincarnation - it felt half-hearted. That's because it was; for as long as the Hitman was in the main event picture, he was always flanked by the old guard, made to look prominent but rarely essential.

WCW eventually let Hart go - just three years on from his huge signing - when a concussion suffered at the clumsy boot of Goldberg restricted him to promos. The company's closure months later made the decision immaterial, but it was telling how far they'd diminished his stock that he could quietly exit the industry so soon after making the biggest move in its history.


1. Steve Austin

Stunning Steve Austin Wwe With Hair 2085453606
WWE

Although he obviously never reached the heights of his industry re-defining run as 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin in WWE, it's something of a misconception that previous employers WCW never got behind the Texan.

'Stunning' Steve was the most talented component of the early '90s' most threatening stable, Paul E. Dangerously's eponymous, hairy-chested Dangerous Alliance, a group regularly pushed to the main event picture. Even after he left the group, Austin's stock remained high: WCW's tag scene wasn't the shambles we see in WWE today, and his shift into the doubles division alongside Brian Pillman saw the pair enjoy similar high-profile matches against the likes of Ric Flair & Arn Anderson.

A knee injury sidelined Austin for the early part of 1995, but when he returned, he found any renewed push blocked by a barrier in the shape of Eric Bischoff. The recently promoted Executive VP simply didn't see 'Stunning' Steve as a star, and furthermore, found him fractious. A FedEx soon winged its way to the (considerably smaller) Broken Skull Ranch, informing a recuperating Austin of his dismissal. You could say it inspired him somewhat.


Watch Next


In this post: 
The Renegade
 
Posted On: 
Editorial Team
Editorial Team

Benjamin was born in 1987, and is still not dead. He variously enjoys classical music, old-school adventure games (they're not dead), and walks on the beach (albeit short - asthma, you know). He's currently trying to compile a comprehensive history of video game music, yet denies accusations that he purposefully targets niche audiences. He's often wrong about these things.