8 Amazing Wrestlers That FLOPPED In WWE

Not every superstar fulfills their promise at the home of Sports Entertainment.

Ricochet WWE Promo
WWE.com

Harboring the largest reach of any wrestling promotion on earth, WWE is regularly seen as the promised land for superstars with the grandest of ambitions. While thankfully it's no longer the only viable option for both fans and wrestlers alike, there's no disputing that WWE remains the world's most instantly recognizable wrestling promotion. For all the adulation a performer can gain on the independents or the prestige of any of history’s other great federations, any wrestler who steps foot in a WWE ring exponentially multiplies their fame, finances, and star power upon arrival. 

When a performer makes a leap to the WWE, it's something of a lottery as to how it all shakes out. For the lucky few who strike gold, this means a push to the moon and living their dreams to the fullest, but the glitzy world of Raw and SmackDown doesn’t bring riches and infamy for everyone. There are those whose time in WWE is a blip on their career, and even a few who had their entire careers derailed entirely by wrestling's biggest juggernaut. 

There are a host of reasons any given superstar might not fit the home of Sports Entertainment, and these are history’s most notable misfires.

Get 76% off and three months for free when you sign up to NordVPN here: https://go.nordvpn.net/aff_c?offer_id=704&aff_id=3013&source=WCWRE

8. Dean Malenko

Dean Malenko
WWE.com

It’s not hyperbole to suggest Dean Malenko was one of the most respected in-ring workers of his generation, with PWI naming the New Jersey native the best wrestler in the world back in 1997. While ECW is inaccurately painted as a "blood and guts" promotion, fans were also exposed to technical in-ring action that was head and shoulders above the competition. Dean Malenko was among the very best proprietors of this style.

With a superb tag team run with Chris Benoit and one of the best feuds in ECW Television title history with his beloved friend, Eddie Guerrero, Malenko made the jump to WCW, where he would become a cornerstone of the company's then-incredible cruiserweight division, holding the championship an impressive four times. It would be the last time his career would hit such heights.

Despite debuting in WWE alongside WCW alumni Perry Saturn, Chris Benoit, and Eddie Guerrero in The Radicalz faction, Malenko was almost entirely overlooked. When he was factored into plans, it involved treading water in WWE’s far less revered Light Heavyweight Championship picture, and the less said about his role in the “definitely Vince McMahon-approved” James Bond parody gimmick, Double Ho Seven, the better.


7. Hideo Itami

Hideo Itami
WWE

Arriving in an era when wrestling’s global infrastructure meant that fans were less able to plug into the Japanese indie wrestling scene, Kenta Kobashi's exposure was low, but his reputation was high. Having enjoyed a short run in Ring Of Honor (including an excellent encounter with Samoa Joe), WWE signing Kenta for their burgeoning NXT brand was presented as a major coup back in 2014. 

Despite regularly receiving rapturous receptions at Full Sail University, the rebranded Hideo Itami was never fully pushed to the top of the card by the Black and Gold brand. He had sensational matches with Tyler Breeze and began to build momentum, including earning a spot in WrestleMania 31’s Andre the Giant Battle Royal, but that would prove to be as good as it got for Itami. 

Disaster would then befall Hideo when a shoulder injury sidelined him for a full calendar year. When he eventually returned, the NXT roster was almost unrecognizable, and Itami found himself out of the shuffle and feeling like yesterday’s news. The originator of the GTS never significantly recovered his standing with fans and was then only used as a makeshift opponent for the likes of Bobby Roode and Aleister Black, before eventually being released just over three years after signing with the company.


6. Sin Cara

Sin Cara 2011 WWE Debut
WWE.com

This is a bizarre case in which WWE used multiple in-ring performers wrestling under the Lucha mask of Sin Cara, and eventually ruined the reputation of the man known as Mistico. 

Considered a legend in CMLL, Mistico built his name with big-time performances in Mexico and New Japan Pro Wrestling, with WWE desperately trying to sign him multiple times throughout the mid-2000s (with Eddie Guerrero said to be leading his backstage cheerleaders). When he did finally sign with Vince McMahon’s behemoth in 2011, it was presented so grandly that WWE even held a special press conference in Mexico about the significance of his signing.

A mixture of wellness policy violations didn't help matters, but a series of high-profile in-ring botches by both Mistico and the myriad of other performers who wrestled under the hood led to Sin Cara being reduced to a global punchline for most of his time in the company. Since returning to the independents, Mistico has recovered his reputation in a huge way, rediscovering his mojo in CMLL and being embroiled in a recent feud with MJF in AEW.


5. Diamond Dallas Page

DDP WWE
WWE.com

Please allow for the dated reference, but there’s something a little Ferris Bueller about Diamond Dallas Page. Wrestling is filled with self-centered rogues, but not one of these famously sociopathic creatures will ever say a negative word about DDP, neither inside nor outside of the ring. With a legitimate fairytale story of breaking into the business later in his life, then defying the odds again to become one of the most beloved performers in WCW history, Dallas even delivered gold in the dying embers of that company’s tragic final 18 months. 

All of this must have passed everyone on WWE’s creative team by, as one of the easiest slam dunk signings of all time was dismantled immediately, debuting as The Undertaker’s wife’s mystery stalker in an eye-wateringly ill-advised move. He was later saddled with a career-low motivational speaker gimmick that was antithetical to everything great about him and only served to alienate fans further. 

This is all made even more baffling by the fact that the man is a natural real-life babyface, loved by fans and performers everywhere for just being the man he is. Despite WWE's inability to showcase Page's brilliance, his work in rehabilitating the likes of Jake Roberts and Scott Hall away from the ring ensures that he is still revered to this day.


4. Toni Storm

Toni Storm WWE
WWE.com

After capturing hearts on the British wrestling circuit, and a legendary run in Japan's Stardom that saw her hold the SWA World Championship for a record-setting 612 days and the prestigious Cinderella Tournament, WWE came knocking and Ms. Storm answered the call. 

It initially felt as though WWE was going to position Toni Storm at the head of the NXT women’s division. After defeating Iyo Sky (then Sharai) in the final of the Mae Young Classic in 2018, Storm's NXT run involved plenty of high-profile matches, including great encounters with Rhea Ripley and a sensational NXT Women's Championship match loss to Shayna Baszler, and yet she only ever felt peripheral. It would only go downhill from here for Toni, as following her call-up to SmackDown, she would be humiliated soon after her debut with a custard pie to the face by then WWE Women’s Champion, Charlotte Flair. 

Five days after losing her sole title match against Flair, Storm would ask for and be granted her release, later admitting in an interview with Renee Paquette that the company had “crushed her love for wrestling”, before her phoenix-like glow up to becoming 'Timeless' Toni Storm in AEW.


3. JC Mateo

Jeff Cobb JC Mateo LA Knight
WWE.com

Given that JC Mateo has been on WWE television for less than six months, this may seem a little premature. However, ask yourself this question. Do you have any faith that WWE will tap into the violent magic that made the artist formerly known as Jeff Cobb so loved by wrestling fans around the planet? 

Thriving as the muscle in Will Ospreay’s NJPW stable, United Empire, Cobb is a man who operates best in devastatingly brutal encounters. His glittering career has led him to holding major titles in Ring of Honor, NJPW, Lucha Underground, and PWG. A physical freak, his greatness can be found in a bone-crunching arsenal of slams, acrobatics, and suplexes that have rightfully earned him his reputation as one of the toughest SOBs on planet Earth. 

Tragically, none of that has been evident on SmackDown in his current role as “the one who gets pinned” in Solo Sikoa’s MFT group. There are plenty of performers who have the chops to put on banger matches with Mateo. Whether or not WWE fans will get the opportunity to enjoy his greatness is another story altogether.


2. Steve Williams

Dr. Death Steve Williams
WWE.com

Revered for his work in All Japan Pro Wrestling, ‘Dr. Death’ Steve Williams signed for WWE in March 1998, with the promise of a push to the moon. This allegedly even included a clause that he would work a six-month feud with 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin. 

Known for being a tough-as-nails badass, Williams was thrown straight into the infamous shoot fight tournament, the Brawl For All, in which wrestlers would attempt to beat each other up for real on Monday Night Raw. This hair-brained Vince Russo creation saw Williams suffer a second-round loss to Bart Gunn that included him tearing a quad, being knocked out, and also tearing his hamstring. This put Doc on the shelf for seven months, essentially rendering him dead on arrival in the audience’s eyes. 

The WWE half-heartedly tried to resurrect his career upon his return, but the toll of his injuries and the fact that fans had witnessed 'Dr Death' having the snot beaten out of him for real on camera meant Williams never recovered. He was let go less than a year after the Brawl For All incident.


1. Ricochet

Ricochet WWE Promo
WWE.com

To look at Ricochet's list of achievements within WWE and dismiss the notion that he flopped under their stewardship is to grossly underestimate the buzz the high-flying maverick had before being in the clutches of Vince McMahon’s creative. 

Alongside Will Ospreay, Ricochet represented a new breed of high-flyer as part of a buzzing independent scene that captured the imagination of fans worldwide. His accolades during this time are many, but defeating Kenny Omega, Roderick Strong, and Johnny Gargano on the road towards one of the best Battle of Los Angeles wins of all time at PWG in 2014 paints a good picture as to just how revered he was in this era. 

When Ricochet joined NXT during one of the hottest eras in the brand’s history back in 2018, he fit like a glove. However, it’s impossible to look at his ability and not think he deserved better across the six years he was with the company, especially during his time on the main roster. WWE never found a character or angle for him that complemented his in-ring ability, and it’s impossible to argue that they ever made him a priority. Now that he’s showing character and personality in AEW, the evidence looks even more damning.

Get 76% off and three months for free when you sign up to NordVPN here: https://go.nordvpn.net/aff_c?offer_id=704&aff_id=3013&source=WCWRE


In this post: 
Ricochet
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Terry Bezer hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.