15 Exact Moments WCW Booking Stopped Making Sense

WWE could have Roman Reigns reprise Bastion Booger and it still wouldn't be as illogical as WCW.

Hollywood Hogan Head WCW Nitro
WWE.com

Insert jokes about WCW never making sense from the off here.

In truth, the promotion was a barrel of laughs even at its worst. There are loads of misconceptions about what World Championship Wrestling had to offer, and a lot of that thinking was caused by relentless WWE propaganda over the years since WCW's 2001 demise. If Vince McMahon wanted to trade barbs and rewrite history, then someone needed to have a "propaganda" at the tripe he was peddling on occasion pre-'Attitude'.

There is merit to the chuckles at WCW's expense though. They booked some content so illogical, lifeless and spotty it'd make Tony Khan's treatment of the whole Devil storyline with Adam Cole and MJF over in AEW look world class by comparison. A lot of that came once Vince Russo took the helm in 1999, but not all of it. Russo should never be single-handedly raked over hot coals for everything.

He wasn't there for roughly half of the barmy shenanigans detailed in this collection. Bro was too busy feeding the WWF powerhouse as head writer and getting mentally fatigued at the mere mention of the word SmackDown. However, Russo did pack in his fair whack of ridiculousness once he joined WCW as an apparent new saviour in late-'99.

Anyone enjoying then-recent PS1 release Silent Hill had zero clue they were in for a pro wrestling-themed hellish landscape to rival it on episodes of Nitro and Thunder that same year. Not even Harry Mason could've survived into 2000! WCW's booking was sporadically all over the bloody place.

Here's exactly when some of the biggest creative culprits stopped making any sense whatsoever.

15. The Stretcher Match That Wasn’t

WCW El Gigante Sid Vicious Stretcher Match
WWE

Big Sid Vicious couldn't wait to be shot of WCW come SuperBrawl 1 in May 1991. The WWF beckoned, but Vicious had one more contractual obligation to see out on WCW's new pay-per-view. They'd booked him in a 'Stretcher Match' against El Gigante. It looked woeful on paper, and it'd wind up being even worse in execution live on air. Honestly, this might've been the worst combination possible at the time.

Get this: Gigante beat Sid in just over 2 minutes in the gimmick bout. To make things even funnier/more tragic, Vicious didn't even leave on the stretcher as planned. He simply marched out of the building and out of WCW until 1993. Work that one out. Bet the 'Card Subject To Change' small print on tickets came in handy on that occasion, because people didn't really get what was advertised.

This was so typically clumsy of the haphazard promotion.

Firstly, even putting El Gigante vs. Sid Vicious down on format sheets should've got somebody slapped. That was never going to be a winning combo, largely because Gigante couldn't work a lick, and an unmotivated, ready to leave Sid was never going to be the right guy to pull a decent match out of him.

Second, they didn't honour the stipulation. Looking back, this should've been booked as a simple 'Loser Leaves Town' match instead of the half-baked stretcher idea that Vicious clearly wasn't keen on anyway. The only thing needing hospitalised here was WCW's logic. They didn't really show any, and that hurt SuperBrawl's midcard.

Sid didn't care - he was off to the fed for money spinning matches with Hulk Hogan.


14. Lex Luger = Mind Reader

Miss Elizabeth Vince Russo
WWE Network

Into the breach with WCW 2000 we go, at least for now.

On the 15 May episode of Nitro, fans arrived for the show to see a steel cage dangling high above the ring. That was nothing new for a company that had 3 different names for cage matches (yes, really - WCW called them standard steel cage matches, "Caged Heat" and "House Of Pain" at various different points in time), so everybody likely figured they were in for a nifty main event inside the structure.

Instead, Sting wrestled Vampiro in a brief caged opener. Later, Vince Russo cornered Miss. Elizabeth inside the thing and threatened to have Madusa kick lumps out of her if she didn't do as she was told. In fact, Russo set up that very match. Then, Lex Luger dropped in through the top of the cage to put a stop to Vince's plans. Plans that he...couldn't possibly have known about in advance.

Let's get this straight: Lex dressed up as a member of the ring crew putting the cage together for the night on the off chance that Vince would corner Liz and put her in a match? That's a tad far-fetched, isn't it? How in the name of 'Narcissususususus' could Luger have even known what Russo was plotting ahead of time?!

Being fair, WCW also booked handicap matches, an 'Ambulance' battle pitting Kevin Nash vs. Mike Awesome and a World Title change on this same episode, so logic and restraint went hand in hand as absentees in the creative process. Horace Hogan also beat his uncle Hulk and Billy Kidman in one of the weakest Triple Threats ever.

Luger's mind-reading took the cake though.


13. Abdullah The Butcher Is Electrocuted

WCW Halloween Havoc 1991 Abdullah The Butcher
WWE

Pro wrestling has booked a number of stupid on screen kayfabe "deaths" over the years. Many of them took place in mad promotions like Lucha Underground, but Vince McMahon's TV character was also supposed to snuff it when his limo exploded in 2007, and WWE has even booked murders on episodes of NXT more recently.

Then, there was WCW's Halloween Havoc 1991 pay-per-view. The show opened with a wild ‘Chamber Of Horrors’ match that saw Sting, The Steiner Brothers and El Gigante beat Cactus Jack, Big Van Vader, Abdullah The Butcher and The Diamond Studd in one of the most crummy brawls going. Come the end, Abdullah was going to get electrocuted and apparently die.

Yay! What a way to set the tone for the rest of your card.

Sadly, pesky logic had to go and spoil everything. WCW's cameras clearly showed that the on/off switch was set to "on" for most of the match, yet there were no sparks flying from the chair. For the finish, Jack accidentally pulled the switch on his own partner, but he had to first put it to "off" before doing so. Oops.

Then, an unconvincing pyro display you'd see in a family's back garden or at AEW Revolution 2021 erm...erupted and eh...thrilled the live crowd in Chattanooga, Tennessee. It was all very low budget and crappy, but the biggest problem was that the switch's lever had been going heel for the entire duration of the gimmicked match.

Good on big Abby for twitching and selling actual death to kick things off on this trick or treat nightmare of a show.


12. Non-Cruiserweights Are Cruiserweight Champ

Oklahoma WCW
WWE

The main selling point for TNA's X Division upon launch was that it didn't have weight limits, "it had no limits". Did you know? WCW actually beat Total Nonstop Action to the punch a few years before the likes of AJ Styles, Jerry Lynn, Low-Ki and Amazing Red were putting that belt on the map. It's true. Sort of - and they did it by taking insulting digs at serious health battles the beloved Jim Ross was going through.

Starrcade 1999 saw Madusa become the first female WCW Cruiserweight Champion in history. On the plus side, she likely fit the weight parameters. On the negative side, this was somehow even worse than seeing Three Count's Evan Karagias with the title. What happened next should be used as a metaphorical stick to beat Ed Ferrara and Vince Russo with until the end of time.

Ferrara's cheap JR wannabe character Oklahoma won the strap at Souled Out in January 2000, but he'd vacate it mere days later on Thunder due to his failure to meet the Cruiserweight gold's weight limitations. So...why did WCW's board of directors agree to put OK in the match on pay-per-view in the first place? Surely that's one of the first things they should've checked out.

Good lord, this was just awful stuff. As if it wasn't bad enough that Oklahoma was making light of Jim's Bell's Palsy, now the gimmick as trodding all over a belt best-known for vintage battles between the likes of Rey Mysterio, Chris Jericho, Eddie Guerrero, Dean Malenko and others.

What a load of bull.


11. Ric Flair’s Elaborate Black Scorpion Scheme

Black Scorpion
WWE.com

Just who could the mysterious Black Scorpion be? He said he was someone from Sting's past heading into Starrcade 1990, so many wondered if a brand new wrestler would debut. Or, impossibly, maybe WCW had flexed their muscle to bring The Ultimate Warrior over from the WWF! That'd be outrageous. So outrageous, in fact, that it was never going to happen in a million years.

Come bell time at Starrcade, the Scorpion wrestled a hell of a lot like Ric Flair. That's because it was the 'Nature Boy' who assumed that character. He'd even arrived in what appeared to be a giant spaceship for the occasion. Oh yes, Ric was sparing no expense to fool the Stinger into thinking he was anyone else. It's just a pity he decided to wrestle exactly like Flair would during the match.

He would've gotten away with it too if it weren't for those pesky, meddling 'Little Stingers'.

The pair's Great American Bash '90 effort over the summer had been everything right with WCW. It was a hard-hitting main event with psychology coming out the ears (Sting's knee injury played a huge part), excellent action and pulsating commentary from Jim Ross in particular. Starrcade's steel cage match proved to be everything wrong with the promotion's approach.

Flair had gone to extreme lengths to wrestle Sting again, and it made next to no sense. He looked like a fool for playing The Black Scorpion, and WCW's 'guy from Stinger's past' angle proved to be a misnomer. This was someone from Sting's present, and a rival he knew all too well.

What a waste of time and money. Spaceships weren't cheap in 1990, y'know.


10. Dustin Rhodes Badmouths Seven

Dustin Rhodes Seven WCW
WWE.com

Dustin Rhodes shocked the world by going all in on the controversial Goldust character in 1995. It was something radically different for the WWF at the time; Goldust was cartoonish and over the top in a different way, and it pressed prickly buttons related to homophobia and androgyny. Nobody in '95 was quite sure what to make of the guise, and Rhodes liked it that way.

By 1999, shock value had worn off and the Goldust gimmick had gone through notable changes. Away from the ring, Dustin was also struggling with personal problems that affected his in-ring career. Seeking sanctuary back in WCW, he and the braintrust there concocted the brand new Seven concept. It'd be a more supernatural take than Goldust, but looked like it had potential.

They killed it on opening night.

Following weeks of creepy vignettes, Seven floated to the ring on the 8 November 1999 Nitro to explain why he was in WCW and what he hoped to achieve. Or not. Instead, Rhodes ridiculed the look and said he just wanted to be himself. This was more half-cocked 'worked shoot' nonsense from Vince Russo and troops, and it left fans baffled by what they were seeing.

If Dustin didn't want to be Seven, then why did he sit in the makeup chair, put on an outfit that was akin to The Undertaker and work a flashy floating entrance come show day for Nitro? None of this was adding up at all. The lack of logic on display was staggering. Again, what a waste of valuable airtime and cold hard production cash.


9. Hulk Hogan Has Superhuman Vision

Hulk Hogan The Wall WCW Nitro
WWE

"That's The Wall, brother. It's The Wall!".

Hulk Hogan was fabulously dramatic on the 27 March 2000 edition of WCW flagship Nitro. He was in a right pickle about spotting The Wall overlooking the 'Spring Breakout' outdoor set housed at South Padre Island in Texas. Inside the ring, 'Mean' Gene Okerlund looked to the entrance for Wall, but couldn't see him. Neither, mind you, could any of the fans in attendance for the show.

Then, WCW's camera crew got on the case to show the heel standing atop a building in the background. What happened next should've won an award for accidental comedy genius. The cams zoomed out to show that The Wall was a tiny speck far off in the distance. There's absolutely no way anybody could've spotted him from that far away. 

Apparently, Hogan had some red and yellow super-vision, dude. He could see Wall clear as day, but nobody else could. Maybe if the cameras hadn't zoomed out to reveal that he was practically in the next state, then things wouldn't have looked so illogical. Hulk's sell job and fear was too much considering that could've been literally anybody standing in a white shirt on top of the building bathed in spotlight.

Hell, even the spotlight was tiny. That's how far away The Wall was from Nitro's set. What was he gonna do? Catch a Shawn Michaels zip line (WrestleMania XII style) down to the ring and chokeslam Hulk? It was ludicrous. Fans fell silent as they tried to figure out what Hogan was babbling about, and Tony Schiavone noted that Wall was "15 storeys in the air" like that meant anything.


8. David Flair’s Skewed DNA Test Logic

David Flair Stacy Keibler
WWE Network

The 9 October 2000 Nitro took place in Australia, so there was a bit of vigour about the weekly show that didn't exist back home in the United States. Fans in Brisbane were excited to see WCW's product live for the first time ever, and that gave Nitro a buzz. Naturally, some of the booking dulled that buzz by simultaneously sucking the life out of the live crowd and making some workers look so stupid it almost gave viewers a headache.

Look, David Flair was supposed to be zany and unpredictable, but his segment with Stacy Keibler was ridiculous. Dave hit the ring to demand that Stacy give him a blood sample so they could take a DNA test. This was all part of the ongoing storyline involving Keibler - she was trying to find out who the father of her unborn child was. Infamously, the likes of Vince Russo and David's father Ric were in the running to be outed as daddy dearest.

WCW thankfully didn't pull the trigger on either of those.

Announcer Mark Madden interrupted David to clue him in on the silliness of his request. They already knew that Stacy was the mother, so she didn't need to give blood for any testing. "We already know she's the mother, Einstein", he said. Indeed. This and a 4 minute hardcore bout between Flair and Mike Awesome likely had fans in Australia wishing the WWF's Raw had visited their country instead of WCW.

The joke (David Flair was an idiot) didn't really land, and the story wasn't gripping people anyway.


7. Sting Is “Fast Counted” (Except He Isn’t)

WCW Starrcade 1997 Hulk Hogan Sting
WWE

Starrcade 1997 was going to be it. That pay-per-view, WCW's biggest to date, would be the night Hollywood Hogan and his power mad nWo faction received ultimate comeuppance from a dark knight who'd stalked from the shadows but could stay silent no more. Sting had transformed into Brandon Lee's The Crow for this very moment, and it was going to be perfect.

Surely, WCW would do everything they could think of to protect the Stinger's fresh coat of paint and stick the World Title on him without any hiccups. Come on now. Behave. You know by now that wasn't going to happen. The company were always going to find new ways to scupper their own carefully-constructed booking and chip away at the heroic babyface's exterior so Hogan and the nWo could continue reigning supreme.

The story of the match called for evil New World Order ref Nick Patrick to fast count Sting following a Hulk pin, but he didn't. No, Patrick used his normal cadence, which only made Sting look like a loser when he couldn't kick out and stay in the match. Once things got restarted, he rallied to win the belt from Hogan, but the damage had already been done. 

Why on earth did Eric Bischoff, Hogan and WCW as a whole think this was a grand idea? It's possible that Patrick made a mistake, but nah - his count was far too deliberate. Something was up here, and it didn't do much to make the Stinger look capable against the head of the nWo menace when push came to shove.

They had one job: Make Sting look unstoppable.


6. It’s Not Hot!

Dungeon Of Doom
WWE.com

Funny side story time: This writer's friend was a late in the day wrestling fan and missed the entirety of WCW's run. So, he wanted to go back and watch some old stuff. A nightly ritual of hot baths and World Championship Wrestling followed. One evening, he texted yours truly to say that he'd just watched Hulk Hogan stumbling upon the Dungeon Of Doom's lair.

Said mate had to check the temperature of the bath water, because he thought he was imagining things.

Hogan meeting the Dungeon Of Doom/Alliance To End Hulkamania in 1995 was unintentional comedy at its finest. Once he was teleported into the belly of the beast, a rather confused 'Hulkster' spewed nonsensical lines like: “There are no Hulkamaniacs here” (why would there be?!), “I’ve never been here before” (Hulk clearly assumed he'd visited every location in the world) and, “It’s not hot” (a puzzling observation considering he'd literally just said that he'd never been there in his life).

Meanwhile, Kevin Sullivan and The Master giggled like schoolchildren that they'd perplexed the biggest star of the 1980s by creating a place free from Hulkamaniacs, Pastamania and all things red and yellow. Real American? No, Hogan was in real trouble if they had their wicked way.

Of course, it was all totally bonkers. If The Master and Sullivan had the power to trap Hulk like this, then why did they need to wrestle him on WCW programming or pay-per-views at all? There's something uniquely charming about this time period. It was like Power Rangers meets Goosebumps, but with Hulk Hogan in the middle of it all.

What goes bump in the night? Curtis Iaukea falling off that big throne, probably.


5. Announcers Get Hyped For…New Writers?

Tony Schiavone Bobby Heenan
WWE

Imagine Tony Schiavone welcomed fans to the latest episode of AEW TV by gleefully announcing on air that Michael Hayes and Ed Koskey had jumped over from WWE. They'd be writing Dynamite and Collision from now on, or at least helping Tony Khan put together the shows creatively. It'd be rather daft if Schiavone tried to use that as a means to get fans tuning in excited, right?

Yeah, well WCW did that on the 18 October 1999 Nitro with a pair of other ex-WWF/WWE writers.

Schiavone and Bobby Heenan were tasked with putting over how clever, witty and transformative both Vince Russo and Ed Ferrara could be to WCW's product. In effect, they were basically saying: 'Look, we know Nitro and Thunder have been a little worse for wear in 1999 than they were in 1998, but now guys responsible for Raw's success are on our team, so things will definitely turn around soon'.

It was a weird way to go about things, and it was actually very big-headed for Russo and Ferrara to write this into the show. Honestly, who cares about what's happening behind the scenes to that degree when they're sitting down to watch wrestling TV? This sort of backstage stuff should be reserved for docs like the WWE Unreal series on Netflix. It'd have no place on Raw or SmackDown, for example.

You wouldn't have seen cast members from Friends pause mid-episode to let you know that somebody else was writing jokes for the show now. That level of self back-patting is hard to stomach. WCW was a mess by this point, it really was.


4. The Giant’s Cobo Hall Fall

WCW Halloween Havoc 1995 Giant Hulk Hogan Cobo Hall
WWE

The Giant was WCW's big heel hope in 1995. Originally, the promotion told fans that he was Andre The Giant's son, but that eventually faded once the first chapter of his feud with Hulk Hogan had ended. It was a silly plot point anyway, but even that was no more or less silly than what transpired at Halloween Havoc 1995. There, Giant survived a fall off the top of a nearby building to wrestle in the main event later that same night.

Made of stern stuff, Andre's boy.

WCW promoted a monster truck battle between vehicles representing Hulk and Giant earlier in the pay-per-view. It took place atop the nearby Cobo Hall (Havoc was inside Detroit's Joe Louis Arena), and it was Hogan's truck that took the 'W'. Knowing WCW, it's a slight surprise they didn't immediately deem this truck the new number one contender and have it challenge the winner of the headliner.

Hulk vs. The Hulkster Truck could've been huge for World War 3. Huge. It wasn't to be though. Post-Twisted Metal lite, Hogan and The Giant began brawling. That's when Paul Wight fell to his apparent doom off the side of Cobo Hall. Remarkably, he was perfectly fine to work a near-15 minute WCW World Title bout vs. Hogan less than a few hours afterwards.

Giant won that match by disqualification. Of course he won - if he wasn't going to sell for concrete and gravity, then even big Terry was getting nothing out of him. Seriously though, why did they book someone to fall off an actual building and survive to wrestle the same night?

The world may never know.


3. Goldberg Won’t Take Moves As Scripted

WCW New Blood Rising 2000 Goldberg Kevin Nash
WWE

Behold one of the most bizarre bits of build towards any wrestling pay-per-view ever.

Before New Blood Rising 2000, on screen power broker Vince Russo refused to tell Kevin Nash, Scott Steiner and Goldberg who'd be going over at the show. That caused everybody to flap, but even mixing real life with scriptwriting wasn't enough for WCW. They had to crudely insert a motorcycle accident side quest for Goldberg, then had him show up mid-match come NBR.

The commentators were then left stunned that Bill wouldn't do as he was instructed and take Nash's powerbomb. He was called unprofessional for refusing to "follow the script". Yes, statements like this were literally said on WCW TV and pay-per-view in 2000. Once Goldberg left the ring, the same announce squad commended Nash and Steiner for "improvising" a new finish to the Triple Threat.

They'd managed to think on their feet and keep the fans entertained by doing business together when Bill wouldn't. Meanwhile, Russo bawled at Goldberg for being so unprofessional and stitching up fans who'd ordered New Blood Rising. Many of those people wouldn't be foolish enough to order another WCW pay-per-view again after seeing this, so it was counterproductive to say the least.

However, if Russo had refused to clue anyone in on the finish to begin with, then how did the commentary team know that Goldberg was supposed to eat Nash's Jackknife for the pin? Further, how was any of this 'it's real...honest!' rubbish supposed to draw TV ratings or create more fan interest in a dying product?

It didn't make a lick of sense then and it still doesn't now.


2. Agony-Inducing Blood Leaves Fans Unaffected

Kevin Nash WCW Blood
WWE

New Blood Rising is all well and good, but how about New Blood falling? The WWF had been working a "blood bath" gimmick with Gangrel and The Brood for a few years by the time WCW started getting in on the whole 'liquid falling from the ceiling' act. Russo played a part in that, and so did his New Blood faction as they warred with the more established Millionaire's Club on TV.

Numerous episodes of Nitro and Thunder throughout the second half of 2000 saw a blood-like substance fall from the ceiling and hit various wrestlers. This wasn't ordinary claret though, it was poisonous, painful plasma that caused workers to writhe around in agony or claim they'd been blinded. That premise fell (ha) apart once production miscues became rife.

Incredibly, WCW's blood pouring staffers missed their mark more than once. Russo and New Blood dropped the stuff on Kevin Nash several times, or at least tried to. 'Big Sexy' was either standing in the wrong spot or the spill went wrong, because it landed beside him on the mat or on top of the front few rows of ticket-buying punters. They had to be delighted with that. Just as well their briefs weren't as expensive as WWE's today!

Fans were obviously unaffected by the liquid, which made the gimmick look laughable. Speaking of which, those who did get covered in the goo laughed it off or busily cleaned it from their clothes and seats so they could sit down again. Presumably on their hands or something worthless like a Wildcat Willie t-shirt.

To make matters even more OTT, wrestlers who were hit with the blood after all of this still sold it like they'd been coated in skin-melting acid.


1. Hollywood Hogan Can See Warrior

Ultimate Warrior Mirror
WWE.com

WCW eventually got their hands on The Ultimate Warrior, but he wasn't Ultimate by the time he reached Atlanta. Eric Bischoff brought Warrior in to feud with Hollywood Hogan so the duo could reprise their timeless WrestleMania VI battle at Halloween Havoc 1998. That pay-per-view would become infamous for going off the air before Goldberg vs. DDP in the main event slot was even finished.

That might've had something to do with Hogan and Warrior going over their allotted time. "Might've".

Before the pay-per-view, WCW gamely tried to portray Warrior as a supernatural magic man who could play various parlour tricks on Hulk and his nWo cronies. One of the most memorable examples came on the 5 October 1998 Nitro. During that episode, Hogan was horrified when he could see Warrior staring back at him in a dressing room mirror. 

There was just one problem: Eric Bischoff couldn’t see what his buddy was seeing, but fans watching on big screens in the arena and those watching Nitro at home could. Huh? This was done to make it seem like Warrior was inside Hogan's head, but did it mean he was also inside the minds of fans too? Or, did it mean that Bischoff was the one who had issues?

Warrior's tricks would come back to bite WCW too. Davey Boy Smith was reportedly injured after he landed badly on a trap door in the ring during one of his matches, and precisely nothing about Warrior's vanishing tricks helped him out come Halloween Havoc. Then, he disappeared from the promotion for real and was never seen in WCW again.

Just be careful next time you look into the mirror, folks.

What other WCW moments made no sense whatsoever? For more wrestling, check out 10 Worst Excuses For Terrible Wrestling Moments and What REALLY Happened To WWE's 16 Tallest Wrestlers Ever?


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.