8 Decisions That Pushed WCW Towards Ruin

Looking back at crazy decisions that ultimately contributed to WCW's demise.

Kevin Nash Goldberg
WWE.com

Going back to the wrestling heyday of the Monday Night Wars, once WWE overtook WCW in the ratings, the latter went down faster than a balloon hit with a rocket launcher.

About eight million YouTube videos tell you that people like to poke fun at pantomime villains Vince Russo and Eric Bischoff for business decisions they took that would have embarrassed a child. At key points in the company's run they and other individuals could have steered the ship back in an almost logical direction.

Unfortunately because of politics and bad strategy, WCW set themselves up for their ultimate doom in 2001.

This generation will never have the option to flick between Raw and Nitro on Monday nights, a real shame if you want to get away from Stephanie McMahon on a microphone. Let's dive into these dreadful decisions.

8. Using Vince Russo On Camera

Vince Russo WCW
WWE.com

You can't scroll through the internet without seeing some form of abuse being hurled at Vince Russo. Yes his infatuation with poles is slightly disturbing, and yes we all know he has an ego the size of a blimp. However, if someone had managed to lock him up in a room and vetted all of his insane ideas, they could have got some return on their investment.

Russo is credited with some good angles during WWE's 'Attitude Era', but finding that one good idea out of so many ludicrous ones was like trying to find a wedding ring swallowed by a dog two days later.

Looking back at the terrible examples of this, we were subjected to terrifying moments like Russo winning the historic big gold belt, then losing it to David Arquette, both of which are moments still ridiculed today.


7. Goldberg Winning The WCW Title On Nitro

Goldberg World Heavyweight Champion
WWE

I have a theory that many of the people at WCW were like a different breed of vampire, needing ratings to survive instead of blood.

The most glaring example of this was WCW not realising they had one of the greatest opportunities to make big money they ever had, if they had built Goldberg vs 'Hollywood' Hulk Hogan for a pay-per-view. Sadly not, as the craving for ratings kicked in again and they took the decision to put the match for the World Heavyweight Championship on Nitro.

Given everything that happens on TV is supposed to build to a hopefully massive conclusion at a pay-per-view, it was a baffling decision. A colossal pay day opportunity that would have really helped the bank balance was lost forever as a result.


6. Established Talent Blocking Midcard Development

Chris Jericho WCW
WWE.com

Rey Mysterio, Eddie Guerrero, Chris Jericho, Disco Inferno... wait scratch that last one. I think you'll get my point about the treasure trove of midcard talent WCW had at their disposal.

If they had utilised some of these guys in the right situations, then we know through watching WWE in the following years that they had superstars waiting in the wings. If they had managed to get around the massive egos of the top guys, there were ready made marketable superstars already on their books.

Unfortunately the established veterans couldn't be persuaded, and the story of 'Macho Man' Randy Savage wanting to squash Chris Jericho in under a minute tells you all you need to know about what they were up against. An over reliance on the older talent meant a glass ceiling for development.


5. Using Eric Bischoff On Screen In The Wrong Way

Eric Bischoff WCW
WWE.com

I love Eric Bischoff. He's the cool uncle we all wish we had. Bischoff increased the heat for the nWo with genius promos where he would constantly tell a nuclear crowd he loved them, and play the cowardly heel.

It was great foresight from Bischoff taking himself away from the commentary desk, and turning on WCW. Bischoff has said that Vince McMahon stole his evil authority figure persona, but even if that were true McMahon did it better. Going up against the anti-hero 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin, he helped build an iconic character through their feud.

If Bischoff had gone into a one-on-one story line with someone instead of only being in the nWo, they could have made a star. That person may not have reached the popularity of Austin, but it was another chance to increase the promotion's popularity.

The fact Bischoff was the one who fired Steve Austin from WCW makes it even harder to stomach.


4. Booking A Terrible Finish To Starrcade 1997s Main Event

Sting Hogan Starcade
WWE.com

This one still has me tearing my hair out twenty years later.

Starrcade 1997 had the potential to be one of the greatest pay-per-views in wrestling history. A year's worth of build up saw Sting and 'Hollywood' Hulk Hogan finally square off. Sting's 'crow' gimmick was red hot, off the Nando's scale. The stage was set for him to destroy Hogan, take all of the nWo with him, and win for WCW.

What we actually got was a dominant performance from Hogan, beating Sting clean. The whole thing ended up such a mess no one knows for sure what went wrong even today.

Bret 'Hitman' Hart's first WCW night was ruined with bizarre interference, as Sting was only able to win because Hart restarted the match after the world saw Hogan pin him.

Booking this right would have catapulted Sting and WCW to new heights, but it wasn't to be. There are plenty of reasons why this pay-per-view is still talked about today, and none of them are good.


3. Ted Turner Approving AOL Time Warner Merger

This would have needed a lot of forward thinking back at the time, which was as unlikely as Ted Turner sending Vince McMahon a Christmas card.

From interviews with Eric Bischoff it's clear once the merger of AOL Time Warner happened, the handcuffs were put on WCW in terms of spending and content. WWE were always going to win with more mature programming and characters they were allowed to showcase. Ted Turner ended up losing $7 billion in stock due to the merger, losing control and the financial means to back WCW.

Bischoff's attempt to pick up the pieces in 2001 came too late, with the removal of the product from television ending hopes of a rescue. If Turner hadn't approved the merger and continued to back WCW financially, they would at least have had a fighting chance of avoiding peril. Instead they were boxing with both hands tied behind their backs, whilst blindfolded, and on fire.


2. Kevin Nash Ending Goldberg's Streak

Kevin Nash Goldberg WCW Starrcade 1998
WWE Network

Of all the people who should have ended the famous Goldberg undefeated streak, Kevin Nash would have been near the bottom of the list.

Having Nash defeat Goldberg after a taser attack from Scott Hall did nothing to enhance Nash's reputation, and totally destroyed all of Goldberg's credibility. This was the biggest opportunity the company ever had to develop a new star, by having them beat the only real home grown talent WCW ever had.

Pushing someone like Chris Jericho or Rey Mysterio to take down Goldberg would have been an extremely satisfying conclusion, giving them instant momentum to push a new young champion. Having one of them take a spear and jackhammer, before going on to win and end the 173-0 streak would have been an historic moment. Instead the politics got in the way and they shot themselves in the foot with their booking once more.


1. Not Pushing Bret 'Hitman' Hart In 1997

Bret Hart WCW 1999
WWE.com

Coming off an incident in 1997 so famous that I don't even have to name it, Bret 'Hitman' Hart was the hottest and angriest performer in wrestling. Hart didn't really want to go to WCW, but the manner of his arrival gave him huge momentum.

WCW had a limited window of opportunity to push him to the moon immediately. They needed to get him in the main event scene every week, but instead all momentum was lost. In contrast, WWE didn't make that mistake when they pushed the 'Mr. McMahon' character at the same time.

The heat on Hart's side slowly faded away and although he eventually became a WCW Triple Crown winner, the chance to have him as the top man at that historic time was never going to present itself again. Failing to give Hart a platform to use his drive after WWE had screwed him over was WCW setting themselves up for a massive fall down the road.


Contributor
Contributor

Fun loving and opinionated. Full of random facts, many of which are completely irrelevant. I think I'm funny, hopefully at least one other person agrees. Love dissecting movies, television and video games for others to enjoy.