8 Horrible WWE Returns That Absolutely Nobody Asked For
May we never speak of James Ellsworth again.
Dean Ambrose's recent return was a well-played pro wrestling set piece that popped the crowd, added an extra layer of intrigue to Seth Rollins and Dolph Ziggler's SummerSlam bout, and set 'The Lunatic Fringe' off in an exciting new direction.
Fans were always going to go crazy for his comeback after eight months away, but WWE's execution was strong. Seemingly stripped of the wackiness that once plagued his babyface character, Ambrose swaggered out with a new haircurt, new muscles, and new attitude: refreshed, revitalised, and ready to go.
Such returns are a key component of WWE's moments-first storytelling mechanism. They generate an adrenaline rush unlike anything else in the sport, and are the kind of thing fans watch for in the first place. A positive reaction is usually a given, and screwing the return itself up is remarkably difficult, but do WWE hit the mark every single time? Of course not.
The company don't often succeed at reading their fans' desires, leading to dozens of miserable comebacks starring old faces whose legacies would've been best left in the past, and didn't need trotted out to an audience that had long since moved on from them. Here are the worst offenders.
8. Alberto Del Rio (2015)
Though Alberto Del Rio's surprise comeback made for a fun moment at Hell In A Cell 2015, this was down to a couple of factors:-
1. It came completely out of the blue.
2. He was facing the divisive John Cena, and deposed him as United States Champion in the ensuing bout.
Unfortunately, the run ran out of steam the very next night. Packaged with the awful, nonsensical MexAmerica gimmick with Zeb Colter as manager, Del Rio was doomed from the start. Here was a Mexican grappler alongside a mouthpiece best known for his Tea Party-esque, anti-immigration meanderings. It was horrible, nuked Alberto's chances of ever getting over again, and the man himself did nothing to dispel the criticisms that plagued his previous run.
Though ADR had gotten himself in incredible shape for the comeback, but his work was tedious. Though he can be a credible performer when motivated, Del Rio's tendency to cost through matches and angles in second gear made his work a slog. He spent much of his last WWE run stuck on this setting, eventually transitioning into the disastrous League Of Nations stable, before leaving for good in 2016.
7. Kane (2017)
As one of the most tenured performers in WWE history, 'The Big Red Machine' has starred in a myriad of comebacks over the years. Some, like his return to obliterate DX and the Radicalz on Raw back in February 2000, were electric, but others? Not so much.
This particular comeback was horrendous. The ageing 'Demon' burst through the ring during a steel cage match between Braun Strowman and Roman Reigns, Chokeslamming 'The Big Dog' to hell in an arena drowned in red lighting. From there, he predictably turned on 'The Monster,' setting up a feud that ultimately cooled Strowman off and halted what remained of his incredible summer momentum.
Kane even bantered his way into a Universal Title shot at the Royal Rumble, where he played pin-eater for Brock Lesnar. He promptly vanished after losing a Last Man Standing bout to Strowman the next night, but he needn't have bothered, as the return did nothing for anyone involved.
The good news for Mayor Glenn Jacobs is that his next return would go down significantly better. Team Hell No's reunion was a success, but casting an ailing, bloated 50-year-old as a fearsome monster in late 2017 was never going to work.
6. Road Warrior Animal (2005)
A tag team legend he may be, but there was no need for Animal to return for a legacy-denting run in 2005.
It began in July. WWE Tag Team Champions MNM challenged him to a title fight at the upcoming Great American Bash pay-per-view, and thus commenced the entirely destructive Legion Of Doom revival, as Animal aligned himself with the cumbersome Heidenreich.
Animal dedicated their inevitable title win to the deceased Hawk, proclaiming "this one was for you, brother!". A sweet sentiment, but the ensuing run was tedious. Wrestling had passed Animal by, while Heidenreich was never the most convincing performer between the ropes, even in a limited powerhouse role. Rather than honouring Hawk's legacy, his involvement sullied it.
The duo eventually split, allowing Animal to go heel for a solo run as The Road Warrior, though he gained little traction as a singles wrestler and was soon relegated to Velocity. Finally, in June 2006, he was released.
Likely brought back because his brother, John Laurinaitis, was Head of Talent Relations at the time, Animal was too physically diminished to make any kind of mark, and couldn't be carried by his goofy partner.
5. Jinder Mahal (2016)
When former 3MB jobber Jinder Mahal returned in 2016, few could have ever foreseen him becoming WWE Champion, let alone surpassing the likes of The Undertaker, Kurt Angle, and The Rock's longest reigns. But it happened, and yes, it sucked.
'The Modern Day Maharaja's' initial return was a head-scratcher. Seemingly brought back to fill space post-brand split, he wasn't even getting booked on the major independents after leaving 2014. Mahal left no mark on wrestling's second stages, and looked like he was in real danger of becoming a forgotten man, but WWE made the call, and he "won" his job back by beating former ally Heath Slater on an episode of Raw.
Having added a large amount of muscle mass in his time away from the ring, Jinder was given the Zen-like 'Man Of Peace' gimmick he recently revived on Raw. WWE did little with him aside from a brief run as Rusev's partner in 'The Bulgarian Brute's' rivalry with Enzo Amore and Big Cass. Then, at Fastlane 2017, Mahal did something remarkable: he had a bad match with Cesaro of all people.
Still, at least his abs looked swell.
4. James Ellsworth (2018)
Fair play to this in-over-his-head goober for somehow hustling a fun jobber spot against Braun Strowman into a full-time WWE contract, but the company stretched the James Ellsworth character way beyond its natural lifespan.
Ellsworth's number should have come up long before he'd devalued the WWE Championship by beating AJ Styles thrice in 2016. What little goodwill remained was wiped off the face of the earth when he snatched the first women's Money In The Bank briefcase the following June. Finally, 'The Chin That Eats The Pin' was binned in November. It was long overdue, and it seemed inconceivable that he'd ever return... but he did, and helped tank the career of one of WWE's brightest female stars in the process.
Make no mistake: the Asuka vs. Ellsworth and Carmella feud was a catastrophe. Rather than protecting 'The Empress,' Ellsworth made he look like an idiot for falling for his obvious heel shenanigans. So diminished was Asuka that her Extreme Rules beatdown of James (clearly designed as a crowd-popping moment) drew nothing from an audience who'd already lost interest in a once special talent.
3. Tensai (2012)
It's a shame that Matt Bloom's last in-ring run collapsed the way it did. He was always an underrated big man, particularly outside of WWE, and transformed himself into an effective monster gaijin during his New Japan Pro Wrestling run. Vince McMahon leaned heavily on this experience upon bringing Bloom back as Lord Tensai in 2012. This probably seemed like a great idea at the time, but it yielded nothing but ridicule for the former Albert.
During his most famous WWE run, Bloom was literally named after a penis piercing. When he left, his nickname was 'The Hip-Hop Hippo.' The fans naturally dumped all over his reinvention as a Japan-inspired badass, and while the company tried to push him hard (even handing Tensai victories against John Cena and CM Punk), it soon fell on its backside.
Tensai was taunted with chants of "AAAAAAAALBERT!" from day one. His previous runs meant nobody could take him seriously, and with his credibility undermined, Bloom's in-ring career fell by the wayside. Still, at least he was able to transition into an influential role as the Performance Center's head trainer. He has never been as important to the company as he is today.
2. Kevin Nash (2011)
With apologies to WhatCulture's self-confessed Vinnie Vegas Stan Michael Hamflett, who'd pop harder than an over-inflated balloon if a 59-year-old Kevin Nash were to re-emerge in WWE next week, the sentimental office favourite had no business gate-crashing the main event scene in 2011.
That year's Royal Rumble appearance was fine. As Diesel, Nash got a surprisingly great pop, providing a rare highlight in an otherwise bang average over-the-top battle royal. It was the right way to utilise an over-the-hill veteran and his shiny new Legends deal, but his involvement later in the year stunk.
A number of factors ultimately contributed to the Summer Of Punk's demise, but the storyline ended with Nash texting itself. It was the lamest payoff to a white-hot angle ever, and after a quick-fire stream of botched booking decisions, it created an equally sh*tty bout between 'Big Sexy' and Triple H at TLC.
Nash remained semi-active in WWE, appearing occasionally on NXT. He has since participated in a number of D-Generation X/New World Order puff reunions, but never anything as unwatchable as the tedious hijacking that was his last in-ring run.
1. The Ultimate Warrior (1996)
The fact that Warrior worked his way back into Vince McMahon's good books on several different occasions, after all the daft things he'd said and done, is proof that you can never say never in professional wrestling, even when you definitely should.
The wrestler formerly known as Jim Hellwig was let go as part of a steroid crackdown in 1992. He was originally supposed to return and re-capture the WWE Championship, but as an admitted PED user, this wasn't going to work. Thus, with Vince McMahon under heavy federal scrutiny, the Chairman had to cut him loose, with Warrior no-showing a series of events in the lead-up.
WWE brought him back from four years of semi-retirement in 1996, but the industry had long since moved on from characters of Warrior's ilk. So although he returned to a pretty thunderous pop, Warrior's nostalgia act soon wore off, and his old baggage reared its head on his very first night back. Him squashing Triple H at 'Mania 12 was funny, but he was so uncooperative that it spawned a years-long grudge with 'The Game,' and soon, Warrior had fallen afoul of Vince again too.
The run ended when - surprise, surprise - Warrior was binned for missing house show dates, having lied about his father's death as an alibi.