8 More Former WWE Stars Who Need To Return To NXT

Out with the new, in with the old!

Chris Masters Tajiri NXT.jpg
WWE

One of the best things about NXT, outside of its often thrilling in-ring product, is that just about anyone can show up there at any given time.

In recent times we've seen the arrival of TNA alumni Samoa Joe, Austin Aries, Bobby Roode and Eric Young. Before that, everyone from Rhyno and Jushin Liger to Too Cool and James Storm showed up on NXT TV. It keeps things exciting and ensures that eyes are always on the product because, hey, you never know who is going to crop up out of the blue.

Not only are these guys good for a nostalgia pop and a bit of internet buzz, they're also talented in their own right and can contribute to the show and help the brand grow. Rhyno was a revelation in NXT, a guy that left WWE as a directionless midcarder made himself a player in the so-called 'developmental' league. 

There are lots of guys (and girls) like Rhyno, former WWE stars who still have something to give back to the business and would be right at home in NXT. 

A little over a year ago, in the wake of Rhyno and Brian Kendrick showing up at a set of NXT TV tapings, I posited ten former WWE stars who should return to the fold. Only the Dudley Boys did (and that wasn't even on NXT). 

Perhaps these eight will have a better chance...

8. Tajiri

Tajiri WWE.jpg
WWE.com

The highly entertaining Tajiri is, in my mind, one of the most underrated WWE midcarders ever. Seriously, nobody even talks about the Japanese Buzzsaw anymore. What gives? Tajiri was great, you idiots, and was a constant highlight of the midcard scene between 2001-05, whether he was playing William Regal's comedy sidekick or tearing it up with Rey Mysterio.

Tajiri left WWE in late 2005 and has been working as a freelancer ever since. He even showed up in TNA not too long ago and looked good there. He's only 45 years-old, works regularly and really hasn't changed much at all in the decade or so he's been away from the 'E.

Whilst it's unlikely that he'd have the inclination to work a Japanese dream match against Hideo Itami or Shinsuke Nakamura, perhaps Tajiri could be drafted in to tag with his countrymen? Failing that, a short and fun match against some NXT up-and-comer on a Takeover special would do. As long as we got some stiff kicks, a handspring elbow and, of course, a little bit of green mist it'd all be gravy.

Or, you know, WWE could just wheel him out for a little bit of surprise interaction with NXT General Manager and real-life friend Regal. There's a lot to work with here and, with the NXT brand touring Japan this summer, we might get to see the former United States, Tag Team and Cruiserweight Champion in a WWE ring once more...


7. ECIII

Ethan Carter Star
impactwrestling.com

Well, this one might have been blown due to his recent 'shoot' promo at an Evolve show, where he took aim at former NXT trainer Bill Demott and Triple H but, on the other hand, maybe that was a setup for ECIII being the next (former?) TNA guy to find his way in NXT, after Samoa Joe, Eric Young and Bobby Roode.

Perhaps this is all part of a storyline and Carter was simply furthering it. WWE do have a working relationship with Evolve, after all, one that I very much doubt Gabe Sapolsky would want to jeopardize for the sake of a cheap pop and a little bit of Internet buzz.

ECIII was a part of the NXT system before but, unfortunately, that was before it was taken over by The Game. It was still in its gameshow phase then and Carter (wrestling then as Derrick Bateman) wasn't able to stand out. Since being let go and moving over to TNA, he's really found his feet as a performer.

He has a great look, is good in the ring and can cut one hell of a promo. There's no reason why the 33-year-old shouldn't be brought in once TNA reaches its inevitable demise, although his past negative comments might be a stumbling block.


6. Molly Holly

Molly Holly 2004.jpg
WWE.com

One of the reasons for Molly Holly leaving WWE in April 2005 was that she was sick and tired of being ridiculed for her supposedly comical appearance (Jerry Lawler and other WWE performers incessantly ridiculed her for having a big butt).

Another was that she was getting used less and less as WWE took the focus away from actual women's wrestling and began to focus more on things like the Diva Search. For the last six months of her WWE tenure, Molly barely even featured on WWE TV. When she did, it was usually losing efforts on weekend show Heat.

That's a damn shame, to be honest, because Molly was one of the most talented female performers WWE had at that time. She had great matches with everyone from Victoria and Trish Stratus to Lita and Gail Kim and was committed to the company, even having her head shaved bald at WrestleMania XX (although that was her own idea).

She deserved better. She deserved what the women of NXT and WWE are getting now, i.e. proper promotion, respect and a spotlight in which to best display their talents. It would be great to see the 38-year-old Molly return to NXT for a short feud or one-off match with someone like an Eva Marie, Nia Jax or Alexa Bliss.

She's still in great shape and is on good terms with the company, having recently made an appearance on an episode of Table for Three and showing up during WrestleMania 32 weekend for the Hall of Fame. Could happen, you never know.


5. Al Snow

Al Snow and Head
WWE.com

What does everybody want? Al Snow in NXT! What does everybody need? Al Snow in NXT!

Snow hasn't been in WWE since 2008, when he was used as an enhancement talent for the ECW brand as well as a trainer for OVW, WWE's old feeder/developmental system. Snow's credentials as a trainer speak for themselves, which is one of the main reasons WWE should consider bringing him back to work in NXT.

Since his WWE release he's worked on the independent scene and found work as a performer/producer in TNA. He's also gotten into the best shape of his life. The 52-year-old is ripped to shreds and looks about ten years younger than the last time he was on WWE TV.

Snow is someone fans remember fondly and who younger, inexperienced guys would benefit from working with. He can guide anyone to a good match and he's over enough so that the fans will be invested in it. Really, besides his connection with TNA (who seem pretty close to shutting up shop anyway), there's no reason why Al couldn't work a set of NXT tapings.

He'd need to bring Head with him, of course, but it'd be a fun nostalgia moment for longtime fans and also a valuable experience for whoever he gets to work with.


4. Juventud Guerrera

Juventud Guerrera WWE Cruiserweight Champion
WWE.com

Juventud Guerrera's WWE career didn't exactly end in the best of ways. Initially brought in with a lot of hype in an effort to revitalise a stagnant cruiserweight division, 'The Juice' let his ego get the best of him and managed to alienate pretty much everyone in the locker room, as well as piss off management.

He was shown the door in January 2006 but has been active since his firing, wrestling around the world. He's still in shape, still pretty fast on his feet and, strangely, has reverted to sometimes wrestling under his mask again (which he lost in WCW).

It would be nice to see a masked (or unmasked) Juventud show up in NXT, possibly with former Mexicools tag partners Psicosis and Super Crazy. I'm sure they and Blake & Murphy or American Alpha could do some fun stuff together.

Alternatively, perhaps Guerrera could be brought in to work with the highly-rated former La Sombra, Manny Andrade. A victory over someone with the reputation of Guerrera in his debut would make him out to be a big deal from the off, and it would no doubt help for him to work with someone so adept at the lucha style.

Could things get a little bit 'Juicy' in NXT? Well, WWE did recently do a 'Where are they now?' feature on Juventud recently so they at least know what the 41-year-old is up to and have his number.


3. Sabu

Sabu WWE
WWE.com

Sabu is almost certainly in the winter of his wrestling career now. In fact, it's pretty incredible that the 51-year-old veteran is still going, considering the abuse he's put his body through over the past quarter century. Few have given more to the wrestling business, that's for sure.

And he deserves to be recognised and rewarded for that. He's not going to get a full-time gig with a major organisation, but he'd be a hit with the knowledgable and appreciative crowd at Full Sail. Even if it's just a one-shot deal, it'll be a nice surprise for them and a great way to pay tribute to someone who has given his all for the business.

The suicidal, homicidal, genocidal one is still pretty active on the indie scene these days and he's looked alright (at least from what I've seen). What best way to use Sabu? I'm not entirely sure. He could work matches with Finn Balor or Samoa Joe. They'd be good bouts and very different from the norm for those two. A welcome change of pace.

It might not be on the cards considering how badly the Sabu/WWE relationship ended in 2007, but the hardcore icon deserves at least one more shot in the big leagues (yes, NXT is the big leagues now) and if I can still go he should be in with a shout.


2. Steven Richards

Stevie Richards WWE
WWE.com

Who doesn't like Stevie Richards? He's one of the most likely guys in the wrestling business, a hard worker with a great attitude who does his job to the best of his abilities. This is the type of guy that needs to be around the Performance Center, working with the guys and gals of NXT.

The 44-year-old Richards never really rose above the midcard in WWE but he had a hell of a run there, between the Right to Censor, his partnership with Victoria and finally his run on the revamped ECW. He's someone that fans remember fondly, a kind of cult hero that would go over well with the NXT fans.

Big Stevie Cool is still in great shape and, what's more, he's proven that he can hang with the younger guys over the past nine months working for Ring of Honor against the likes of Jay Lethal, Roderick Strong and Adam Cole. In my opinion, he's worth bringing into the fold in a role similar to Rhyno's.

He'll show you. You'll see.


1. Chris Masters

Chris Masters Flex Pose
WWE.com

Chris Masters had everything WWE were looking for when he burst onto the scene in 2005. He was young, had an impressive look and, after a couple of ropey months, really came into his own as a worker. A couple of Wellness Policy violations and stints in rehab convinced the company to cut ties with him in 2007, however.

He hit the indie circuit and worked all over the world, constantly evolving and improving as a performer. WWE were keeping an eye on him and brought him back in 2009. And then he did nothing but wrestle good but ultimately meaningless matches on Superstars, where he displayed just what a great worker he'd become.

In the five years since his 2011 release, The Masterpiece has only gotten better and has received glowing reviews for his work on the indies, in particular his superlative series with the late Kris Travis in England's PCW. Oh, and he also saved his mother from a burning building by pulling a tree out of the ground with his bare hands.

So this guys is a great worker, has a phenomenal physique and is a real-life superhero? Seriously, why isn't this guy in WWE? Considering he failed to receive a push or make much of an impact in his last spell there, perhaps NXT would be the place for Masters to go.

He'd work thrillers with the likes of Balor, Joe and even Nakamura. He's credible, fans recognise him and he's still only 33 years of age. This one seems like a no-brainer to me.


Contributor
Contributor

Student of film. Former professional wrestler. Supporter of Newcastle United. Don't cry for me, I'm already dead...