8 Reasons Why Billy Corgan Buying TNA Is Best For Business

Love it or hate it, TNA going bust benefits nobody.

billy corgan tna
ImpactWrestling.com

What in the world is going on with TNA at the moment?

It seems that only Dixie Carter can answer that question. The company were in dire straits last week, and with it being widely reported that they needed to arrange a full sale of Carter’s 70% shares to survive beyond Sunday, it looked like they were finally going bust.

That didn’t happen, however, and for all the doomsaying, TNA were able to raise the funds necessary to progress not only with their Bound for Glory PPV, but several weeks’ worth of Impact tapings. Whether the money came from Carter, and outside investor, or one of the company’s other shareholders remains to be seen, but they pulled it off, and their existence continues for at least another month.

TNA’s future still hangs in the balance, though. It doesn’t look like a full sale has been concluded yet, particularly with Carter still involved with the company’s operations, and it’s only so long before the well runs dry again. WWE looked set to pounce last week, but the acquisition didn’t materialise, and TNA continues as is.

Sooner or later, somebody has to reach down and pull TNA from the muck, and the best option remains the company’s current President. He doesn’t have Vince McMahon’s financial clout, but Billy Corgan buying TNA is best for business for a host of reasons, and here they are.

8. No More Dixie Carter

dixie carter tna
ImpactWrestling.com

You could write a book on all the factors that have contributed to TNA’s demise, but much of the blame lies with inadequate leadership. Jerry and Jeff Jarrett were forced to sell to the Carter family when HealthSouth, one of their benefactors, were forced to withdraw their funding following a fraud case. The Carters paid just $250,000 for their 70% stake, and Dixie was installed as president.

Her reign has been a string of terrible mistakes kept alive by constant cash injections by her wealthy father. Throwing exorbitant amounts of cash at failed WWE stars, Z-list celebrities, and MMA fighters at the expense of the company’s younger stars bought a couple of cheap pops, but ultimately cost the company its reputation. 2009 saw Carter bring Hulk Hogan and Eric Bischoff to TNA and after four years of their free reign, TNA’s once-exciting alternative product had been ground to dust.

Carter’s failings as TNA’s president are too numerous to summarise. She’s become a laughing stock in the wrestling business, and her name is now a buzzword for professional wrestling failure. It’s under her leadership that TNA has becoming shockingly reminiscent of latter day WCW, and if the promotion’s ever to prosper again, she must leave. Immediately.

Corgan purchasing her shares will send her out of the wrestling business with a nice big payday. Does she deserve the $4-6 million her shares are valued at? That’s debatable, but it might be worth it just to get rid of her.


7. Impact Has Improved Leaps & Bounds

tna impact thursdays
ImpactWrestling.com

TNA’s flagship show doesn’t exactly provoke positive connotations. Impact has become a weekly symbol of the company’s failings, and after playing host to some of the most cringeworthy stories the business has ever seen, it’s perfectly understandable. The show was almost entirely unwatchable for a while, particularly under Hogan, and its reputation remains tainted today.

This is a shame, because Impact has quietly evolved to become one of the sport’s most enjoyable weekly television shows. Perhaps it’s through Corgan’s influence, but the stories are tight and purposeful, the characters are mostly well-presented, and the match quality has been relatively high. There are still a few missteps (hey there, Mahabali Shera) and some of the stories definitely overstayed their welcome (Maria as the Knockouts’ figurehead), but Impact has become a fun, breezy watch that’s a lot easier to consume than Raw most weeks.

By closing down or selling to WWE, this momentum would be cut-off at the knees. It’s going to be hard for the company to attract new viewers in the short-term, but Impact is finally finding its feet again, and it’d be a shame to see it cancelled before reaching full flight. Corgan’s investment will maintain the weekly show’s forward motion, and help build towards the future.


6. A Fresh Set Of Ideas

billy corgan dixie carter
ImpactWrestling.com

Whether through Hulk Hogan, Vince Russo, or Carter herself, TNA has played host to countless moments that are so memorably bad they’d make latter day WCW blush.

How about the decision to let a clearly intoxicated Jeff Hardy wobble down to the ring and attempt to wrestle Sting at Victory Road 2011?

Or the many failings of Aces & Eights, and the massive waste of time that their “takeover” angle gradually become?

Or the Sharmell vs. Jenna Morasca match at Victory Road 2009?

Or Claire Lynch?

The list goes on and on, and while these ideas probably didn’t come from Carter herself, she is responsible for empowering the writers that devised them. Ultimately, the blame for letting these shambolic affairs come to pass lies in her hands.

There’s no guarantee that Billy Corgan would exert tighter control over the company’s creative direction, but there’s no way TNA wouldn’t benefit from a fresh set of ideas. If Corgan was to takeover, he’d be the majority shareholder, giving him complete freedom to run the company however he sees fit. This could be exactly what TNA needs, because as long as Carter has a say, there’s always the chance something will go disastrously wrong.

Furthermore, if Corgan does buy TNA reports suggests he intends on completely rebranding the promotion, changing the name, and starting fresh. A smart move, as “TNA” and “Impact” have become toxic brands with huge perception problems among wrestling fans.


5. WWE Only Want The Tape Library

Tna Impactlive
tumblr

If nothing else, the lack of encouraging alternatives sees Billy Corgan stand alone as TNA’s only logical savior at this point. There’s always the chance that another bidder will emerge, but Ring of Honor’s parent company (Sinclair Broadcasting) appear to have left the race, leaving only two other options: the Carter family’s constant drip of last-minute funding, and WWE.

There is precisely one argument in favour of a WWE takeover: getting the TNA tape library on the Network. That’s it.

There’s a chance that the McMahons may take-on a couple of TNA contracts, but for the most part, they’ll shut TNA down as soon as the deal goes through. They’re a cutthroat organisation hell-bent on strengthening their monopoly status, and maintaining Impact Wrestling as a going concern makes no financial sense to them.

Corgan can prevent this from happening, however. As great as it’d be to have TNA’s vast library available on the Network, the negatives of a WWE takeover greatly outweigh the positives, and such a move would only be bad for business.


4. Dozens Of Jobs Will Be Saved

TNA Impact 2016
Impact wrestling

TNA’s eventual demise will likely be met with some celebration. Wrestling fans can be a savage bunch, and after all the company’s been through over its lifespan, certain sects will take great pleasure in its closure, such is the level of disdain for Dixie Carter and her role in making TNA the laughing stock it has become.

Sure, TNA ceasing to exist would effectively remove her from the business, and you can argue that it’s no more than her mismanagement deserves, but what of the others? What about the talent who rely on their TNA paycheques to make a living, and may find it difficult to score a full-time wrestling gig elsewhere? What about the commentators, interviews, and referees? The agents, producers, and office staff?

Dozens of people are going to lose their job if the company goes bust, and that’s never a good thing, regardless of what you think of the figurehead. Though Corgan would likely make a few cuts and bring-in some of his own people in the event of a takeover, this is a lot less damaging than WWE shutting the whole operation down, or bankruptcy. From a purely human standpoint, TNA’s continued existence is worthwhile because it keeps a big group of people from the unemployment line.


3. Alternatives Are Good For Business

Tna For Sale
tumblr

You can make a pretty credible argument that WWE’s takeover of WCW was the worst thing to ever happen to the wrestling business. Hindsight’s 20/20, of course, but the business has never recovered from it, and the lack of competition has allowed WWE to sink into a mind-numbing comfort zone without any real incentive to improve the product. At this point, it’s hard to see any company ever building enough strength to challenge WWE’s mighty reign, even with Raw’s ratings scraping an all-time low last week.

TNA aren’t going to be in direct competition with WWE any time soon, and yes, there are times when their product closely resembles WWE Lite. This doesn’t eclipse the fact that they’re a genuine alternative to Raw and SmackDown, though, and if Billy Corgan doesn’t buy them out and the company passes out of existence, it’s one less viewing choice for professional wrestling fans.

How can fewer viewing alternatives be a good thing? Regardless of all the bad things we can say about TNA, there are still people who enjoy Impact above all else. Some fans just aren’t into Lucha Underground outlandish storylines, ROH’s spotty presentation, and NJPW’s language barrier is just too great to cross. TNA is their prefered alternative, and without it, they might lose interest in the business all together.


2. The Broken Brilliance Continues

Broken Matt Hardy
impactwrestling.com

Few wrestlers have ever pulled-off a late-career resurgence quite like Matt Hardy, and even fewer have done it in such a unique manner. Broken Matt Hardy is a weird, ridiculous, over-the-top, and utterly daft idea, but it’s one of the most talked-about angles in professional wrestling today, and rightly so.

Broken Matt and Brother Nero are viral sensations. The Final Deletion brought more buzz to TNA than the company has seen in years, and Delete or Decay and Bound For Glory’s Great War only amplified the hype. In tapping into his inherent weirdness, Matt has created brilliance, and TNA is the perfect stage for his act.

The Broken saga has been so successful that WWE are allegedly interested in bringing Matt back once his TNA contract expires, and if McMahon does end-up buying the company, he’ll be one of the few wrestlers he looks at retaining. Can WWE really be trusted not to ruin everything that makes the act so special, though? History suggests not, and with the majority of his creative freedom stripped away, Broken Matt will flounder on Raw or SmackDown.

Should Corgan buy the company, one of his first acts should be securing Matt to a new long-term deal. The Broken Brilliance would continue, and fans wouldn’t be forced to sit through whatever watered-down version WWE’s writers would serve-up.


1. Closing Means One Less Place For Wrestlers To Work

Aron Rex
Impact Wrestling

Whatever way you look at it, TNA closing would be objectively bad for the wrestlers. It has been argued that the company shutting down would open open new doors for current TNA wrestlers, and while that’s true for a handful, most of the company’s roster would suffer immensely.

Drew Galloway and EC3 would be prime candidates for a WWE return, and the likes of Trevor Lee, Davey Richards, and Eddie Edwards will never have trouble securing independent bookings but what would WWE’s incentive be to match Drew & EC3’s current terms? Why would The Wolves want to go back to the indie wrestling grind after putting-in years of hard work to secure a full-time contract in the first place?

TNA’s pre-taped shows offers its employees an incredibly easy schedule. Their full-time performers need only work for the company a couple of times each month, and while most are free to perform on the indies, the lighter schedule remains a big pull for free agent talent. Yes, they’ve often struggled to pay their talent on-time, and that’s completely unacceptable, but guys like Aron Rex chose to work there for a reason.

Wrestlers like Rex and Cody Rhodes have only just left WWE, while Baron Dax and Basile Baraka are fresh out of NXT. For these men, there is no immediate pathway back to the wrestling mainstream. If TNA closes, where are their “exciting new opportunities?”

Ultimately, TNA closing down means one less place for wrestlers to work, and one less way for them to make a living. Corgan’s investment will prevent this from happening, and ideally end the late paydays en route to re-establishing TNA as a credible employer away from WWE and the indies.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.