8 Recent WWE Repackagings That Were Doomed From Day One
RIP Grizzled Young Veterans.
The repackage is always a lottery in wrestling. A wrestler's next gimmick can save them from mediocrity, catapult them to new heights or give them a refreshing new edge that makes them feel brand new. On the other hand it can halt their momentum or waste their potential.
Throughout the many decades of WWE there have been countless examples of both, but for every truly great character change there is an equally terrible one to match it. It's a tale as old as time and, because you can never quite guarantee how an idea will play out until it happens, it will be a part of the business until the heat death of the WWE universe.
The McMahon sports entertainment landscape has had seismic changes in the last few years; mass hirings, swaths of releases and plenty of developmental call-ups. Naturally, as is the nature of the beast, this much going on means many wrestlers having their gimmicks tweaked in order to find them a suitable place on the gargantuan WWE roster.
This list will focus purely on recent examples of character changes of the bad variety; so bad in fact that you knew it wasn't going to work out from the instant you saw it.
8. Max Dupri
Whilst already a wrestler with an impressive enough resumé, NXT at least gave LA Knight a chance to strut his stuff to fans who might’ve not been aware of his greatest Impact moments. Instantly he stood out from the brand’s roster which, whilst technically proficient, sometimes lacked true charisma on the microphone.
It wasn’t long before Knight was one of NXT’s most highlighted attractions, but the shift to the young and vibrant NXT 2.0 signified that he was not long for Full Sail University.
Instead of just letting LA Knight continue his holier-than-thou gimmick with all of his cemented catchphrases, WWE defied the entire point of their developmental system yet again and decided to reset the clock. Knight was no more, instead we had Max Dupri.
WWE have had this strange fascination in recent years with “soft debuts”, having characters come out and tell us how we as an audience aren’t ready for them and rarely ever do they land. This was yet another example of a debut that began not with a bang but with a whimper.
Dupri did a decent job with the scripts given but WWE's writing is worlds away from the heights of his improvisational skills. Simply using the former LA Knight as a mouthpiece for catwalk modelling segments is a terrible misuse of a solid in-ring worker with a great personality.
7. Doudrop
Piper Niven was an excellent addition to the NXT UK women’s roster. With an indie background in brutalising her opponents, she gave the division an extra air of legitimacy as Viper and her years of experience and unique look meant that she was prime for that accelerated call to the main roster.
Fans watched with dismay as Viper was drafted to Raw in 2021 and dropped under the wing of the consistently hated and mind-numbingly talentless Eva Marie. It was almost distasteful to team up such a solid wrestler with the company’s prized model if not the fact it was just painfully on brand at this point.
Changing Viper’s name to Doudrop didn’t help but it at least felt part of the act. Doudrop was Marie’s protégé and she was being pushed around and mocked from the very beginning.
Gladly, the turn came quickly and Doudrop dropped her “mentor” like a stone. Worryingly however, for whatever reason, she decided that she perhaps liked the name and decided to keep it rather than the clearly much cooler, and much more established, Viper.
Considering that in her first year Doudrop has done very little outside of winning the 24/7 Championship a couple of times, fans’ worries that she was dead on arrival have rung true.
6. Keith Lee
The signing of Keith Lee to NXT almost felt unavoidable in a sense. After years toiling away on the independent scene, Lee was something that the WWE’s scouts could no longer ignore. The developmental arm of the company did indeed bask in his glory and it was only a matter of time until he won gold.
Keith Lee became the first man in history to hold both the NXT North American and NXT Heavyweight Championships at once.
Whilst Lee assured fans that he was doing his best to make sure he got the treatment he deserved, his main roster debut upset and concerned many. Vince’s obsession with only one kind of physique put Lee in an awkward singlet, and one of NXT’s best ever theme songs was swapped for something far lesser. In his first nine months on Raw, Lee was used sporadically and rarely had any solid storylines to get his teeth into.
A repackaging saw further changes that were the nail in the coffin. Whilst some saw the “Bearcat” moniker as a way to honour the history of black wrestling, it was just another thing that replaced more of Keith’s already proven greatness.
WWE had signed The Limitless One because of his track record and propensity to organically get over with the fans but every change felt like a roadblock to slow him down every step of the way.
5. Edge
The Rated R Superstar’s Royal Rumble 2020 appearance is right up there as one of the most exciting returns in wrestling history. Fans are fickle however and two years into his revived run the novelty had begun to wane. Edge needed a refresh to stay interesting and leading a stable wasn’t necessarily a bad direction.
This darker turn gave Edge some new music for the first time in 18 years, as well as some moody purple lighting. However, it was when Adam Copeland began to speak that things fell apart. Early The Judgement Day promos were rambling and aimless, making reference to Edge’s time with the Brood as well as taking cheap potshots at local sports teams.
The “cult” identity felt forced and incomplete. Phrases like “mountain of omnipotence” meant absolutely nothing.
It was a mess and whilst we all hoped it would take better shape, more so for the others members Damian Priest and Rhea Ripley, who desperately needed something to do, it was evident that it wasn’t working.
Edge’s time as leader of the group lasted less than four months before he was betrayed, apparently leaving The Judgement Day because of “creative differences” backstage. This might explain why it had such a tough time connecting with fans, as it was being pulled in multiple different directions from day one.
4. Lacey Evans
If wrestling wasn’t scripted, you’d have plenty of reasons to worry about Lacey Evans because through the spring of 2022 she had some startling identity issues.
The last time fans saw Evans was February 2021 where she was playing a villainous character who had apparently been sleeping with the geriatric sack of bones called Ric Flair.
Her return from maternity leave in April 2022 saw her try to get away from that mess as much as possible. An emotional vignette showed the superstar telling a distressing story about her childhood in order to garner sympathy. Strangely, the video aired on SmackDown but Lacey suddenly returned on Raw as a generic heel. In June, she made her promised SmackDown re-debut as this strong, honourable woman who earned a spot in the Money in the Bank ladder match.
What happened when she was unsuccessful in grabbing the briefcase? Why of course, she turned heel again the following week.
Despite being a Mother and a former Marine with a tough upbringing, it was immediately obvious that Lacey wouldn’t connect as a babyface. Having a tough childhood isn’t necessarily enough to make fans sympathetic to your cause and Lacey’s attitude was just better suited as a dastardly villain.
The company was hesitant to commit to the idea for good reason and had to do a full about-turn when it wasn’t working out.
3. Karrion Kross
Some of Karrion Kross’ last days in NXT centred around a story where the division’s other main eventers called his bluff. Yes, his entrance was impressive and he had a great aura about him… but he was merely on a hot streak and didn’t have the work rate to back it up. It was an interesting take, and allowed NXT to reflect Kross’ real world naysayers on TV to try and sway them with a convincing title retention.
When Kross came to Monday Night Raw he was diluted, his valet Scarlett was nowhere to be seen and his entire presence was completely different. All it served to do was give the NXT roster and his detractors validation of their criticisms.
The cheap BDSM gimp mask he was forced to wear didn’t help things either.
The current NXT Champion who, until that point had been undefeated on his own brand, lost to Jeff Hardy on his first night in 90 seconds. Fans were in uproar. What did veteran Hardy have to gain from this? What did this say about the NXT Championship? Whilst some expected this shock to turn into a longplay story, it became immediately obvious that WWE had no idea what they were doing with Kross.
Karrion Kross was released a few months later, before Vince McMahon could repackage him yet again. God only knows what that could’ve been.
2. The Dyad
One of the greatest tragedies across both NXT Black & Gold and 2.0 is the mistreatment of the Grizzled Young Veterans. Whilst they were used on a frequent basis, it always felt like they had the potential to be the top of the tag team division for a long time if only they would be given the chance.
Not just superb in the ring, both Drake and Gibson knew how to be hateable and funny. From the legendary chants of “if you hate Gibson, shoes off” and Zach’s furious reactions to the absolutely bonkers golfing segments with LA Knight and Cameron Grimes; the pair showcased over and over again that they were a worthwhile commodity.
In July 2022, with the release of Harland, cult leader Joe Gacy needed some new muscle and who better than the Grizzled Young Veterans? Apparently…
All of the personality that Drake and Gibson had displayed over the last few years was gone and instead they were being asked to wear goofy contact lenses and speak in drones. A role any one of NXT’s up-and-comers could not only fit but possibly profit from, as opposed to an established tag team who found themselves spiralling back to the starting point.
1. Ciampa
In an interview in 2019, Tomasso Ciampa said that he would rather “retire” than get called up. Of course, in the following years he back-pedalled and claimed that it was about the intensive schedule more than the booking of the main roster but it’s hard to trust that from a man who once promised he would “spend the remainder” of his career in NXT.
And why wouldn’t he want to? Ciampa organically rose from the tag division with his partner Johnny Gargano to put on the brand’s greatest feud and some of the best matches in WWE over the last decade. For many, he was the first name that came to mind when they spoke of NXT.
In April 2022, Ciampa dropped his first name and joined the ranks of Monday Night Raw with very little pomp and circumstance considering how integral he had been to the company’s developmental brand. A few weeks later he turned heel and then aligned himself with The Miz.
The Blackheart, the man who needed no alliances and only cared for Goldie, was suddenly little more than a heater. Out of all the things he could’ve gotten from the gamble of a call-up, it's highly unlikely that "scrapping with Logan Paul" was something he was predicting.
Ciampa fell from the graces of the top of the NXT to, so far, a booking afterthought on Monday Night Raw.