8 Things That Doomed Seth Rollins WWE Title Reign From The Start

Was Seth Rollins Title Reign Doomed To Fail? It Never Had A Chance.

Seth Rollins Wwe Title Extreme Rules
WWE.com

At WrestleMania 31, Seth Rollins cashed in his Money in the Bank contract and became the WWE World Heavyweight Champion in shocking fashion. During a better than expected clash between Brock Lesnar and Roman Reigns, Seth Rollins did the unthinkable by turning the brutal main event into a triple threat match, and made history in the process. Michael Cole declared his triumph to be "the heist of the century." Little did we know, this was the zenith of Rollins run as the man in WWE.

In the following months, Seth Rollins made his way through a WWE landscape that wasn't designed for him to succeed as champion. With the unusual way he won the title, we all should have seen a shoddy reign coming. Months of being undermined as champion, weird PPV booking, and being stuck with retread opponents all contributed to Seth's underwhelming reign. 

While Seth has had minor successes such as his ladder match against Dean Ambrose, whispers of his reign falling short began as early as the night after Wrestlemania. When Daniel Bryan and John Cena showcased their newly won midcard championships in matches against Dolph Ziggler and the aforementioned Ambrose, it was clear Rollins would have to do something special with the companies top prize to justify his position. 

However, Rollins has come up so small, the storyline heading into SummerSlam focuses on Rollins ineptitude as champion. Even 2002 Chris Jericho would say Rollins has been a weak champion. But it hasn't all been his fault. Here's why.

8. He Cashed It In

Seth Rollins Wrestlemania Money In The Bank
WWE.com

As mentioned earlier, Seth Rollins cashed in his briefcase to become World Champion at WrestleMania. Throughout WWE history, this has been the cheapest and easiest path to the title, and one that rarely receives any respect. Furthermore, there have rarely been great post-cash in champions.

Looking back on former briefcase holders like The Miz, Alberto Del Rio, Edge, Daniel Bryan, CM Punk (the first time) Jack Swagger, and Randy Orton, those guys were booked as incredibly lucky punks who ran from fights, and ultimately lost the Championship rather quickly until they could win it in a fair fight. 

When it comes to Seth Rollins, his cash-in will be remembered as the biggest one ever, but ultimately it was hollow. The company had to invent a previously unheard of way to do it by turning the match into a triple threat.

It was the result of him being plan B to the failed ascent of Roman Reigns. While jubilation filled the hardcore community when Rollins got the nod, his future prospects dimmed following the initial shock because WWE likely didn't plan for the rejection of Roman Reigns, thus having nothing intriguing prepared for him. 


7. He Never Beat The Actual Champion

Brock Lesnar Seth Rollins Raw
WWE.com

A glaring reason Seth Rollins reign was doomed to failure was the fact HE NEVER BEAT THE CHAMPION. Instead, he pinned Roman Reigns, and stole the championship like a scoundrel. Paul Heyman warned us all in the lead up to Wrestlemania, that Rollins would be cheaper as champion if he cashed in. That ended up being a gross understatement, as Seth Rollins became the biggest paper champion since Union Kane in Rocky V. 

Following WrestleMania, it was like a reset occurred and the title was randomly assigned to him. When it came time to face Brock Lesnar like a man the night after, he ran out of the arena to set up Brock's mauling of Michael Cole. 

Not beating the champion is just a recipe for fans to look at Rollins as a fraud, and as the months have passed, it is easier to see he was never going to be a legitimate champion from the genesis of his reign. A reign that started with a defense against...


6. His First Challenger Was Randy Orton

Seth Rollins Randy Orton Extreme Rules
WWE.com

Randy Orton was the first challenger to Rollins newly won championship, and doom immediately followed. In an extension of their WrestleMania rivalry, Orton versus Rollins was the headline match of the post WrestleMania season. 

Yes, the 5th biggest Wrestlemania match was being expected to keep things hot after all the part-timers left. Randy Orton is one of the most honored champions of all-time, but at this point in his career he's not a legit top face challenger for a championship. 

Previously, WWE booked Orton to defeat Rollins at Wrestlemania to play the "well he's already beat him once" card. Their feud was over run by the heat vaporizing Kane, and Shield 2.0 members Joey Mercury and Jamie Noble. 

Unfortunately WWE had to turn to Orton when he wasn't the best candidate to be a new champions first opponent. As his career has gone on, Orton has shined in the role of being the guy someone faced BEFORE they went to the main event level. 

To start Rollins run off, there should have be a more exciting opponent who didn't need to win the belt, but would feel fresh, like Dolph Ziggler. Just imagine the matches. 


5. Weak Main Event Booking

Seth Rollins Dean Ambrose Ref
WWE.com

Secretly, Seth Rollins' PPV title matches have been an exercise in eye rolling. While Rollins is a great worker, interference and gimmick finishes have stifled many of his contests. Kane was tied in to his matches to a ridiculous degree.

Fans pretty much sat on their hands until Kane ruined whatever match Rollins was defending the title in, including his stellar role as "The Guardian of The Gate" at Extreme Rules. Also in that match, they banned only the most exciting move in wrestling, The RKO, while the steel cage ended up keeping no one out of it. 

From there, Kane and J & J pretty much turned the Fatal 4 Way match against Orton, Reigns and Ambrose into a Survivor Series match. Fans snoozed on Rollins vs. Orton to such a degree, two more guys were brought in to freshen things up. To top that, a Dusty Finish was used in his first match against Ambrose. While it was done well, it didnt do anything for Rollins as a champion. 

Perhaps the most egregious booking when it comes to Rollins was his match against Brock Lesnar, where he was mauled for nine minutes while managing to unleash enough super kicks to make Young Bucks jealous, until The Undertaker caused another non-finish. 

If you were counting, Rollins has only defended his Championship cleanly once, in a match with no rules, where he fell down with the title, while yanking it from another mans grasp during the descent.


4. John Cena Setting The Midcard Ablaze

John Cena US Title
WWE.com

The same night Seth Rollins won the WWE World Heavyweight Championship, another champion was crowned with hopes he would inject life into a title. That man was John Cena, and his prize was the downtrodden United States Championship.

Immediately after winning it from Rusev, the John Cena open challenge became required viewing, and is consistently the most exciting part of RAW. It was a place where careers were born, and rebirthed. Cena's matches and promos benefited from being tucked away from the main event picture, while Rollins struggled with adjusting to life on top.

In a way, Bryan and Cena winning the mid-card titles showed the company didn't really trust Rollins as World Champion, and slowly the best matches in the company were being contested for the United States Championship. Imagine if Daniel Bryan didn't get injured.

In theory, it would be easy for him to anchor these stacked cards with legit stars holding things down underneath, but with John Cena submitting perhaps the best year of his career, some have called for Cena to be the rightful World Champion.

At SummerSlam, the world will be waiting to see what Seth Rollins is capable of, and he will do it against the man who has stolen his spotlight...John Cena. 


3. Kane

Kane, Seth Rollins, Featured, Features, Lists
WWE.com

Throughout Rollins alignment with The Authority, he's been joined at the hip with Kane, a dude that's been in WWE since 1995. Whatever you would like to call Kane at this point is fine. Lately I've preferred Groan Inducing Kane, as opposed to Corporate Kane. 

Nevertheless, his association with Rollins has seen them be boss and employee, friend and enemy, and finally protector and protected. During it all, the threat of a Kane vs. Rollins feud was bubbling, as it seemed Seth was one slick sentence away from being booked against The Big Red Machine. Rollins vs Kane wouldn't have drawn a dime.  

If Randy Orton was a lacklustre challenger to Rollins, Kane would have been a disaster. His character is so destroyed at this point, it can only be justified by shrugging and running down his entire history of foolishness. 

As previously mentioned, Kane was involved in finishes to WWE World Heavyweight title matches....IN 2015. Why WWE has decided to make a guy who is 15 years past his prime a key player in the story of a man who's been called "The Future Of WWE" has yet to be defined. Whatever the reason is, we'll surely get an answer after SummerSlam.

While you guys watch that, I'll walk in traffic. 


2. Only One Fresh Opponent

Brock Lesnar Suplex Seth Rollins
WWE.com

When Seth Rollins took his busted up cadillac on a road trip to Suplex City to face Brock Lesnar, it was his first opponent he defended the title against he hadn't faced 1 on 1 before. The Ultimate Warrior was also undone with similar booking way back in 1990, when he faced retreads like Rick Rude and Mr. Perfect. 

In Rollins case, he was thrust into an immediate rematch with Randy Orton who he wrestled twice previously on major broadcasts. Roman Reigns was brought into the scene to round out a Fatal 4 Way match. As his reign went on, his rivalry with Dean Ambrose was re-ignited to a lesser extent than their 2014 rivalry, which featured all time moments such as The Eulogy of Dean Ambrose, the curb stomp on cinderblocks, and Dean Ambrose jumping out of anything he could hide in.   

While those match ups held some appeal, giving Rollins fresh challengers would have made for more interesting TV. Instead of just coming off as just another chapter, these new rivalries would have been the beginning of an entirely new book. 


1. WWE Struggles Booking Non "Monster" Heel Champions

seth rollins wwe title
WWE.com

If the booking of Seth Rollins since becoming WWE World Heavyweight Champion was to get a grade, it couldn't get much more than a D. Thus far it would be hard to picture Seth Rollins beating anyone cleanly in a fair match situation. Perhaps this was their goal the whole time, but they are leaving so much on the table by pigeonholing him into the standard chicken sh*t champion role.

Historically, WWE has struggled to book non-monster heel champions since the end of HHH's mid 2000's run. With such strong face champions like Cena, Batista, and CM Punk (as a face), most of the heels end up as the same guy. Here are a few names that had similar runs of mediocrity as weasel punk champions: The Miz 2011, CM Punk, Alberto Del Rio (heel) Christian 2011, Daniel Bryan 2012,  and Chris Jericho 2002. 

Seth Rollins has been undone by a system he totally could have challenged as a heel champion. Instead, WWE has relied on their common weak champion trope to establish Rollins as a reviled heel, when a badass Seth Rollins could have been dominating the roster from day one as champion. 

If we are near the end of Seth's first reign as champion, it will be remembered for the ratings slide, and the fact he seemed beatable at any time. Hopefully, WWE will look inward rather than at Rollins when evaluating his time on top. 


In this post: 
seth rollins
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Rich Latta II is a lifelong wrestling fan. He also writes for PWMania.com & SocialSuplex.Com....find all his links at RichLattaWrestling.com Reddit name RichLatta32 He thinks of wrestling as the 3rd Major Sport, Follow him on twitter @RichLatta32 He Runs a Podcast called @OneNationRadio (follow that too) with his buddy James Boyd, that covers WWE, Music, Sports, and Pop Culture. http://onenationradio.podbean.com/ Or Type One Nation Radio into the Podbean App Comment the articles & Tweet Him Now!! Rich also is an aspiring hip hop artist and proud member of the #WrassleRap Community & Music Producer