8 Times The Wrong Wrestler Won The Royal Rumble
The wrong man in the right place at the right time.
To state the obvious, the Royal Rumble match is one of the most important matches of the year in WWE. Winning the match is a major feather in the cap of any superstar, and many true legends of the game go through their entire careers without managing to do it. Chris Jericho, Eddie Guerrero, Kurt Angle, Kane, and others will go down in history as some of the big names who were unable to outlast 29 other competitors.
Despite this, the Rumble has been won by some very worthy competitors over the years, and has often been seen as the final tick of validation a superstar needs before heading off into the stratosphere. Rumble wins solidified Shawn Michaels, Batista, Yokozuna, and others as true main event level stars, whilst confirming the likes of Steve Austin and The Rock as being at the top of the game.
WWE gets it right more often than not, but when they get it wrong with regards to the Royal Rumble they tend to get it very wrong. The last few years in particular have been rough for the Rumble, with a procession of winners who quite simply were the wrong choice, both for the fans and for business alike.
Here are eight times the wrong man won the WWE Royal Rumble match.
8. Sheamus (2012)
Sheamus' Royal Rumble win in 2012 seemed to be designed to confound fans' expectations, and much like his Money in the Bank victory in 2015, it was likely WWE springing a surprise for the sake of a surprise. The positives of Sheamus' win were accidental: his win led to the 18-second debacle at WrestleMania XXVIII, and the beginnings of Daniel Bryan's Yes! Movement.
Serendipity aside, Chris Jericho should have won the 2012 Royal Rumble. Jericho had returned just a few weeks prior, and promised to change the world as we knew it in the process. Of course, such claims in pro wrestling are to be taken with a pinch of salt, but having Jericho come back only to fall at the final stage of the Royal Rumble threw Y2J under the bus somewhat.
Sheamus was the right man in the right place at the right time, although it was a decision that didn't need to be made. The Sheamus/Daniel Bryan story could still have been told, and Jericho/Punk would have been more exciting if the two hadn't already come to blows inside the Elimination Chamber a month prior to WrestleMania.
7. Hacksaw Jim Duggan (1988)
Do we still count the first Royal Rumble as a true Royal Rumble? It contained just 20 men and had no real prize on offer, but it still goes down in history as the first in a long line of Royal Rumble matches. The bout was won by Hacksaw Jim Duggan, who outlasted Dino Bravo and One Man Gang at the end in what was then the highest viewed wrestling program on cable TV.
So whilst the winner was somewhat irrelevant, the question of whether Duggan was the right choice lingers. Watching the match back Duggan is far from the most popular combatant in the bout. When Duggan enters at number 13 he does so to a decent reaction, but that reaction is dwarfed by the man who entered at number five.
Jake 'The Snake' Roberts was far and away the most popular individual in the match, and as such a win for Jake would have made the crowd even happier, which was pretty much the entire point back then. Duggan was never going to be anything more than a middle of the card babyface, so a win for Jake would have been a feather in the cap of someone the company had big plans for moving forward.
6. John Cena (2013)
Fantasy booking warning, but John Cena winning the Royal Rumble in 2013 and taking on The Rock at WrestleMania 29 in Once In A Lifetime II may have set off a chain of events that WWE is still reeling from today. The 2013 Royal Rumble saw The Rock end CM Punk's 434-day WWE Championship reign, setting up the Cena/Rock rematch with the title on the line.
When Cena eliminated Ryback at the last, it was all but guaranteed that The Rock would be pinning CM Punk in the main event. Sure, some still held out for an improbable Punk victory, but that was optimism taken to new heights. Lost in all of this was the damage done to Ryback, who was still extremely popular at this time.
If the roles had been reversed, Royal Rumble 2013 would have seen Punk defend against John Cena and The Rock walk out as the Rumble winner. That way, Punk would have the 'Mania main event he deserved against The Rock, and Cena is freed up to take on The Undertaker at the Show of Shows.
Cena winning in 2013 was an eye-roller, to say the least.
5. Lex Luger (1994)
Having Bret Hart and Lex Luger co-win the 1994 Royal Rumble was bet-hedging at best, and downright lazy at worst. It was dangerous too, devaluing the Rumble match and the idea that only one man will prevail, and also putting a WrestleMania in jeopardy one year after the worst in the history of the event. Some will claim that WWE didn't have many options, but they certainly had better options than a draw.
By January 1994, it was clear that the Lex Luger experiment was failing. By not putting the title on Luger at SummerSlam 1993, the then-WWF was more or less saying that it wasn't convinced by the idea of Lex as the number one guy in the company. All the work made in the summer of 1993 was for nothing.
The WWF was also haunted somewhat by the main event of WrestleMania IX, a main event that saw Yokozuna defeat Bret Hart before Hulk Hogan came out to save the day. That 'Mania was a shambles, and management could be forgiven for wanting to avoid the same main event. Even so, Bret winning was the best option, and the big show itself could have gone ahead much the same with a solo winner.
At least WWE got this sort of call correct in 2005, albeit at the expense of Vince McMahon's quads.
4. Stone Cold Steve Austin (1997)
Another year, another controversial Rumble match, and another messy finish that led to a convoluted road to WrestleMania. Stone Cold Steve Austin won his first Royal Rumble match in 1997, although he did so after being eliminated from the match. Austin was tossed out by Bret Hart but the referees didn't manage to see it, and thus Stone Cold was able to head back into the ring to pick up the win.
It was a somewhat creative finish, but if the company wasn't planning on going ahead with Austin challenging for the title at WrestleMania 13 then why give him the win here? Stone Cold could still easily have come back into the ring to toss Bret over, continuing the build to their inevitable battle at the Showcase of the Immortals.
Why did company officials wait an entire day to decide Austin's victory wasn't going to stand? You would assume that all high-ranking officials would be in the arena for one of the biggest shows of the year, so there is no reason why it couldn't have been overturned that night. Failing that, The Undertaker winning the Rumble clearly made the most sense.
3. Roman Reigns (2015)
Oh WWE, when will you learn? The WWE Universe collectively took a dump all over the 2014 Royal Rumble when it was clear that Daniel Bryan wasn't going to be involved, so the company decided to avoid a similar situation a year later by having Bryan enter the match. Somehow they managed to make things worse, by having Bryan limply eliminated early on before Roman Reigns overcame the combined might of Kane and Big Show to win it all.
Why oh why WWE think this was a good idea? If the plan was to extinguish all hope related to Bryan early on, the plan was an absolutely abysmal one. To make matters worse, the rest of the match saw hero after hero vanquished at the hands of Kane and Big Show, two veterans who hadn't been relevant in a long while.
Then, to have them be defeated by Roman Reigns was the final straw, a decision so poor that it led to the live audience booing The Rock - and The Rock never gets booed. You can question whether or not Bryan should have won, but Reigns clearly wasn't the right move here.
2. Mr. McMahon (1999)
The 2015 Royal Rumble must be pleased that the 1999 Royal Rumble exists, because without the final Rumble of the millennium 2015 would be the dirt-worst. The 1999 Royal Rumble made the same mistake the 2016 Rumble only just managed to avoid, in that it was a one-story Rumble with that story starting the whole thing off.
Stone Cold Steve Austin and Mr. McMahon got things going, and the same two ended up being the final two combatants. This was after they fought all over the arena, at the expense of the other 28 performers in the match who were completely forgotten. Looking back, it is amazing to see just how much of then-WWF TV time was taken up by the Austin/McMahon saga.
To make matters worse, Mr. McMahon came out on top. Would he go on to main event WrestleMania? Would he heck. That honour still went to Austin, who clearly should have won this Rumble. You can still tell the same one dimensional story, but Austin winning would have made this Rumble a whole lot less sucky.
1. Batista (2014)
Will there ever be a more despised Royal Rumble winner? I'd wager not. Going into the 2014 Royal Rumble match, everyone knew that Batista was returning to the company, and rumours were already swirling that WWE was going to go ahead with a Batista vs. Randy Orton match for the main event of WrestleMania XXX. This despite Daniel Bryan being the most popular pro wrestler on the planet at the time.
Were WWE really going to go ahead with an Orton/Batista main event, or was Bryan getting into the match always on the cards? Whatever the plan was, having Batista win this match was an absolute shambles of a decision. When Rey Mysterio was thrown under the bus as the number 30 entrant the crowd collectively checked out, deciding to boo anything and everything that happened from there on out.
How anyone believed that babyface Batista would be cheered in this environment baffles many to this day. Daniel Bryan was so clearly the right man to win the 2014 Royal Rumble it wasn't funny. You could maybe make an argument for a few other individuals in the match (CM Punk, ironically Reigns, who was super-over), but Batista? No, certainly not.