8 Times TNA Tried To Be WWE
Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery.
It’s been very, very important for the professional wrestling industry in north America that TNA has been in business for the past fifteen years or so.
To begin with, they provided the NWA with a much-needed home to rebuild from - and later on, they continued to provide a haven for frustrated former WWE performers, who found themselves on a much smaller stage, but still a global stage of sorts.
They've always been a distant second to the WWE but second-ranked doesn't have to mean second-rate: however, one of the biggest bugbears that their detractors have is the insistence on slavishly following the fortunes of the WWE, as though desperate to replicate any success the bigger company might have had.
There’s nothing wrong with snapping up former WWE stars if and when they become available of course. However, there are other ways in which TNA has gone a little Single White Female on their biggest competition in the last few years.
Here are a few of the most glaring examples.
8. Abyss Imitates Mankind And Kane
The most famous example of TNA ripping off a gimmick wholesale is of course in the case of Chris Park’s masked alter ego Abyss.
To begin with, Abyss was clearly defined by his inspiration Kane. There’s the enormous size of course, and both wore the mask. Beyond that, there are their characters: both were mute, silent serial killer types, very much like horror movie villains Jason Voorhees and Michael Myers.
As the Abyss character progressed, he became a lot more like the original iteration of Mankind, the damaged, childlike personality at war with the monster he’d become, capable of extraordinary acts of violence.
Abyss even began to use a two-by-four studded with dozens of nails, a weapon he called Janice - which, in turn, was a deliberate fudge of Mankind’s barbed wire baseball bat, Barbie.
7. OVW Taken On As Developmental
For nearly a decade, Ohio Valley Wrestling in Louisville, Kentucky, had a close working relationship with WWF/E. Acting as their developmental and farm territory for much of that time, amongst many other successful WWE performers they were responsible for training the so-called ‘Class Of 2002’, which included John Cena, Brock Lesnar, Randy Orton, and Batista.
In 2008, WWE ended that aspect of their relationship with OVW, but continued to partner with them on various enterprises until 2010. The following year, TNA formed an exclusive agreement with OVW to take them on as their official training and developmental territory.
Leaving aside the fact that TNA wasn’t large or ambitious enough a promotion to require a developmental wing, it seemed clear at the time that this was once again a ploy to associate themselves with the actions of the WWE in the hope that something would rub off. It didn’t: two years later, the agreement came to an end, and any TNA talent working at OVW was asked to report to Orlando instead.
6. The Attitude Era's Signature Sound Ripped Off
American musician and vocalist Chris Warren was responsible for one of the most recognisable aspects of the WWF’s television programming over the course of the Attitude Era: he was the distinctive voice of what became referred to as The D-X Band.
Over a period of two years, Warren provided vocals to the D-Generation X theme, Triple H’s entrance song ‘My Time’, and even sang ‘The Star-Spangled Banner’ at WrestleMania XIV, for which he was so badly panned that he’s been edited out of all broadcasts of the show since then.
He also performed D-X’s theme to introduce the stable later that night, doing so again at SummerSlam that year, and was responsible for the shortlived theme to WWF Superstars, as well as a couple of other tracks that never saw the light of day.
In 2007, TNA signed Chris Warren and his band Bro-Kin to a deal to allow their music to be used at TNA events. Over the next two years, three of their songs - ‘Low’, ‘For The Vein’, and ‘Separate’ were used at various TNA pay-per-views, and various edits of other Bro-Kin songs continued to be used on TNA video packages.
5. The Katie Vick Angle Ripped Off
Incredibly, in 2012 TNA attempted their own version of the infamous Katie Vick garbage fire from WWE’s 2002 storylines. That story had seen Triple H go deep into Kane’s past to reveal that he’d once violated the dead body of a girl he’d had a crush on. This represented the benchmark for sh*t wrestling stories for ten long years until TNA, in their infinite wisdom, decided to have AJ Styles confronted by a woman from his past that claimed to be carrying his baby.
It transpired that this ‘Claire Lynch’ was a junkie and Styles’ ex-girlfriend… and that, if her baby was his at all, it was because she’d violated him while he was asleep. Just as Triple H had produced video footage of himself pretending to be Kane pretending to indulge in necrophilia, so too ‘Claire’ produced photographs of herself posing next to Styles’ unconscious body.
Styles, never exactly Mr. Personality, wasn’t able to infuse this unbelievably dodgy storyline with any life, and - given that he’s a deeply religious and happily married family man - it was probably inappropriate to ask him to participate.
4. Feast Or Fired Rips Off Money In The Bank
In 2005, the WWE innovated the Money In The Bank ladder match, a bout in which a briefcase containing a contract for a WWE singles championship title shot was held above the ring.
The winner of the briefcase has a year to cash it in and hand over the contract to have an immediate shot at the title. However, this match could be anytime and anyplace; usually, babyface or heel, the winner would select an opportunistic time to do so, for example immediately after another particularly debilitating match.
In 2007 TNA created the Feast Or Fired match, involving four briefcases. Three contained title shots, and (in typically TNA thinking), the fourth a pink slip meaning that that ‘winner’ would be fired when they tried to cash in their briefcase.
Yes, the company still called the use of the briefcases ‘cashing in’, even though the Feast Or Fired gimmick didn’t have anything to do with money or any word or phrase that related to banks or cash.
3. Sting Rips Off Undertaker's Vignettes
In WWE in 2011, a series of video vignettes were shown to viewers depicting a mysterious figure in a long black coat walking in a sinister fashion through the rain, and concluding with a date appearing on the screen in flaming text: 2.21.11 - February 21st 2011.
Naturally it referred to the Undertaker’s return for upcoming WrestleMania storylines, which this year involved a challenge from Triple H.
Literally only one week after the Undertaker returned to WWE television, TNA broadcast a vignette showing a mysterious figure in a long black coat walking in a sinister fashion through the rain, and concluding with a date appearing on the screen in flaming text: 3.3.11 - March 3rd 2011.
Watch the videos. The resemblance is absolutely hilarious. Funnily enough, some of the people speculating about the WWE’s version said that it could be Sting debuting for the WWE after all these years. It turned out, however that the return of Sting was in fact what the TNA video was about.
2. AJ Styles Rips Off The Second Summer Of Punk
Two entire years after CM Punk blew up in the WWE by teasing leaving the company with the WWE Championship upon expiry of his contract, TNA ran an identical angle with AJ Styles.
In the photocopied storyline, Styles too was booked to vent his frustration with company owner Dixie Carter by delivering worked shoot complaints about TNA to the viewers, but - being AJ Styles - he didn't remotely have the promo skills to ape CM Punk’s revolutionary, firebrand style.
Styles won, of course, and did walk out with the title, which was promptly vacated. Styles returned to face the new champion in a title unification storyline about five weeks or so later.
Unlike the WWE’s version, in which Vince McMahon got cold feet and ordered Punk to return only a week or so after the Money In The Bank event, Styles actually got to defend the TNA Championship in Mexico and Japan.
1. Eric Young Rips Off The Daniel Bryan Underdog Champion Angle
In a moment of astonishing storyline theft the likes of which had not been seen since… well, AJ Styles the previous year, TNA took bearded comedy act and underdog babyface Eric Young, and transformed him into a fiery, never-say-die contender for the TNA Championship - right after Daniel Bryan won the title at WrestleMania XXX.
Young was, like Bryan, a fine popular but underappreciated performer for the company, but simply hadn’t been main event material until someone thought to check out what the competition were doing.
A nonsensical effort to cash in on the popularity of the Daniel Bryan storyline, this one came out of left field. There were no angles that built up to it, with the number one contendership position being won by Young on the same episode of free television that his title shot took place on.
TNA had already developed a reputation for half-inching gimmicks and stories from their distinguished competition, but this… this was the icing on the cake.