8 Ups & 0 Downs From AEW Dynamite: Blood & Guts (29 Jun)

Blood & Guts II outdoes the first, Sammy Guevara plummets, Jade Cargill has had enough.

Eddie Kingston Sammy Guevara
AEW

A second red-hot show in a row for All Elite Wrestling last night, with a fantastic, 11,000-strong Detroit crowd buoying the first Blood & Guts match to take place before a full audience 13 months after the original unravelled inside a half-empty Daily's Place.

Forbidden Door was the electric, buzz-generating pay-per-view it needed to be following a middling build ravaged not only by injuries, but rushed booking (under difficult circumstances, admittedly). Following it was an enormous stipulation-driven event that needed to at least outdo some of the original's wrongs while not coming off like a disappointing Anarchy in the Arena sequel. No small task, despite the obvious talent spread across the Jericho Appreciation Society, Blackpool Combat Club, and their Eddie Kingston-led associates.

In the end, this was a very, very good professional wrestling show. Everything that aired at least pushed its featured storyline forward in a meaningful and engaging way. Blood & Guts II occupied the entire second hour, but there was no shortage of material for fans to sink their teeth into elsewhere.

On a night where Sammy Guevara took an almighty dive, several wrestlers bled like pigs, Scorpio Sky's next TNT Title challenger was made official, and Jade Cargill went 34-0, AEW a second successive course-correcting card.

Let's light the fuse...


Ups...

8. TNT Title Redemption?

Scorpio Sky Wardlow
AEW

A brief backstage segment hosted by Tony Schiavone saw Scorpio Sky put TNT Title contender Wardlow down, saying that he wasn't one of the security guards the big man had spent the last few months destroying, then pointing out that last them they met, Wardlow was felled. 'The War Dog' responding that he would treat any American Top Team members who showed up like those security guards got Sky fired up, prompting him to suggest a Street Fight - which seems unwise for his physical wellbeing.

As goofy (and fun, in this columnist's eyes) as Wardlow squashing 20 guards the other week was, him battering a few ATT fighters before conducting his Symphony on Sky could be a lot of fun. The stipulation admittedly opens the match up to overbooking, given interferences will be legal, though a one-sided, roughhoused shellacking of several trained killers, including Sky, would be a great way to set Wardlow up for a dominant TNT Title run.

The belt needs it. After several wobbly months following Sammy Guevara's win over Miro, a long run of Wardlow looking like the baddest man in the company by scoring dominant, decisive wins (how he got over in the first place) is the way to go.


7. Jade Cargill Has Had Enough

Leila Grey Jade Cargill
AEW

You couldn't brew a cup of coffee in the time it took Jade Cargill to thwart Leila Grey's TBS Championship challenge, but there's plenty to talk about here.

The squash itself was effective. Jade looked confident and in control. Seizing the doomed challenger's arm early, she battered Leila with forearms and knees, then put her up in the air and down on the mat. Grey's first attempted comeback was thwarted when Cargill caught her into a fallaway slam and kipped up.

In complete control (and totally feeling herself), a sh*t-talking Jade got a little too into it, allowing Leila to fire back with a few shots and a running knee in the corner. Cargill then countered the bulldog that followed, hit Jaded, and scored the win.

So far, so simple - but context is key.

Now 34-0, the TBS Champion is bored of wrestling enhancement talents with no realistic chance of beating her. She wants a challenge - and snatched the microphone away from Stokely Hathaway to make her point. With the stick returned to him, Big Stoke pointed out that he'd issued the open challenge at 11:49 PM the night before, calling Athena and Kris Statlander lazy when realistically, they had no chance of responding. Only the desperate, opportunity-starved Grey (deliberately positioned as a dead-on-arrival, unworthy challenger at 0-15) had time to respond. Great, subtle heel work that shouldn't be missed.

When Hathaway talked Grey into assisting Cargill and Kiera Hogan against the onrushing Athena and Statlander, Jade didn't want to accept the aid of somebody she considers beneath her. The TBS Champ swatted her defeated foe's helping hand away.

A babyface turn or step up in competition feature on the list of things this Cargill character direction could be forecasting. There's more to it than Jade (who came off incredibly here) "turning" on Stokely and The Baddies, which would be premature.


6. Danhausen & Some Pretty Good Wrestlers

Danhausen FTR
AEW

The Acclaimed/Gunn Club split was accelerated here, as Anthony Bowens accidentally whacking Colten Gunn with his crutch (having risen out of his wheelchair to a surprisingly huge pop) cost the heels a match with Danhausen and FTR.

Max Caster rapped about "beating the sh*t out of a Juggalo" on his way to the ring. In response, said Juggalo claimed to have found some partners who are "pretty good at wrestling", bringing out Cash and Dax. FTR, who are noted Gunn Club proponents on Twitter, did a particularly good job with Austin and Colten, who are coming along nicely as prospects, though the over-as-hell Danhausen was the featured wrestler here. Selling for an extended period before eventually tagging out, he came back in for the pinfall after the crutch shot.

Though house show-like in execution, the match hit every note it needed to - and FTR smashing Bowens' wheelchair up afterwards was a humorous nod to their destruction of The New Day's hotdog cart years ago. Subjectively, though, it'll be a shame to see Gunn Club and The Acclaimed split. Who wants to live in a world where we no longer hear Bowens screaming "SCISSOR ME, DADDY-O!" to a gigantic, jacked 58-year-old man every week?


5. Vignette Sets The Tone

Dean Malenko
AEW

Blood & Guts II was preceded by a slick video package that succeeded in putting extra weight on the bout, with talking heads Dean Malenko, Ruby Soho, Tony Schiavone, and Excalibur telling the match's story and stressing its potential consequences.

American wrestling promotions have a habit of producing overlong preambles that are polished, well-made, and professional productions, but ultimately succeed only in holding up the show. AEW kept this one brief, which was welcome. Those paying attention already know the events that led to this match. Only a quickfire recap was necessary, along with a rundown of the deeply complicated interpersonal dynamics (mostly involving Eddie Kingston) and an acknowledgement of the physical and mental toll WarGames-like bouts typically take on their combatants.

And that's what we got.


4. Christian Cuts Jungle Boy To Pieces

Luchasaurus Christian Cage
AEW

"Dark" Luchasaurus, as a concept, threatens to get a little hokey, but we're not there yet. That a man as slick-tongued as Christian Cage could manipulate the big lad into turning on Jungle Boy is believable, particularly after a failure as crushing as the World Tag Team Title loss, when both Jurassic Express members are mentally vulnerable.

Could it have used a little more time on the stove? Absolutely. Luchasaurus deliberating for at least another week or two following Cage's incendiary heel promo would've added additional heft.

This remains an area of improvement for AEW's stories and angles across the board.

Nonetheless, Cage's second big promo on Jungle Boy and his family, in which the only apology he gave was to say sorry that the prospect's entire family wasn't dead (except his mother), was tremendous. Few wrestlers are as loathsome and despicable as a locked-in, heel Christian. Following this was a note-perfect Luchasaurus squash of Serpentico, who was terrified by the big man's mere presence and put down by Jungle Boy's Snare Trap combined with a nerve hold.

Cage has often delivered great work when shielded by a gigantic, domineering opponent, and Luchasaurus is a better wrestler than Travis Tomko was. This new duo should be allowed to be complete pricks together for at least a month before Jungle Boy returns heroically.


3. Ethan Page Gets Flustered... But Not THAT Way

Ethan Page Orange Cassidy
AEW

Orange Cassidy's gameplan is to get inside his opponent's head, throw their own strategy off, get them flustered, then take advantage of their lapses and, usually, win. Behind the slacker aesthetic, Cassidy is calculating. It's why his gimmick complies with accepted professional wrestling psychology - and it helps that he keeps the act three-dimensional by continually finding new ways for it to work.

Ethan Page considered himself a step ahead of Cassidy by refusing to fall for his mindgames. The American Top Team man wasn't going to get wound up by Orange's slow kicks and pocket spots, demonstrating this by mocking his signature mannerisms.

This wasn't a problem for 'Freshly Squeezed.' Instead of throwing Page off his game with mockingly soft strikes, Orange got under his skin by being a world-class counter wrestler. Any advantages Page gained by rising above the taunts were negated by Orange's superior defensive work. This culminated in an Orange Punch and the bodyslam (in Detroit, no less!) Cassidy had been working towards the whole match, after Dan Lambert had had orange juice spat in his face.

Lambert was a great pest outside the ring while this very, very good television match was playing out. The Cornette Cultist will no doubt be raddish red at the "145lb down with his hands in pockets" winning with such a foundational wrestling move.


2. Better Than The Original (With Caveats)

Jon Moxley Matt Menard
AEW

Blood & Guts II was a net positive with plenty to love, so let's start its appraisal by acknowledging the not-so-good points.

AEW is yet to truly master the WarGames format it first implemented last year. The Pinnacle vs. Inner Circle was marred by problems beyond the framing of Chris Jericho's bump from the top of the cage, though the sequel did much to address them. Still, whether the initials are written in Stamford or Jacksonville, the stipulation's modern instalments are yet to capture the magic of the best WCW bouts.

The opening sequence between Claudio Castagnoli vs. Sammy Guevara was visually stunning and technically impressive, but lacked bloodthirsty heat. WarGames continues to chase the dragon of Steve Austin vs. Barry Windham. Elsewhere, that the cage has now been broken out of in two consecutive bouts is an issue (as is Jim Ross once again employing "Jezebel" when describing a female wrestler) that undermines the match's lock and key aspect. The idea is that the opposing forces are stuck in the cage with each other and therefore have little choice but to inflict awful violence on one another. Breakouts should be the exception, not the rule.

But the bout still succeeded, which is made all the more impressive by the Santana injury. His knee giving out within seconds of his entrance forced the wrestlers to adapt on the fly. While there were a couple of understandable moments where it felt like they were stalling to do so, that they were able to in this high-pressure environment (with so many moving parts) is admirable.

The pre-Blood & Guts stages were all about the escalating levels of violence. As new wrestlers entered, so too did new weaponry. Jon Moxley was the chief perpetrator of this, carving Daniel Garcia up with a fork and later piledriving Angelo Parker onto broken glass. Santana's arrival brought a barbed wire bat and table. Chris Jericho brought Floyd along.

Castagnoli's throwdown with former Real Americans partner Jake Hager was received extremely well by Detroit, who chanted "we the people!" loudly. Parker's chickensh*t work when realising he was walking into a woodchipper upon entry was another highlight. Multiple wrestlers bled like stuck pigs, too, including Matt Menard, whose forehead was briefly pierced by Mox's handful of skewers.

Guevara's fall from the cage and through the timekeeper's table will go down as the biggest aesthetic highlight. This, in particular, felt like a make-good. As easy as it is to feel desensitized by spots like this in 2022, AEW at least outdid Jericho's widely-criticised bump from last year. This, and Claudio's Giant Swing to Menard atop the cage, may have justified breaking out of it to many.

And the finish, like many other moments in this match, wasn't executed to perfection.

But...


1. Conceptually, A Brilliant Finish

Eddie Kingston Claudio Castagnoli
AEW

... the idea was brilliant.

Eddie Kingston technically scored a colossal victory here, outdoing Chris Jericho and his Appreciation Society in one of the year's grandest, bloodiest, and most personal matches. He did exactly what he said he was going to. After the fireball, Anarchy in the Arena, and everything else, the team captained by Chris Jericho lost to the one with Kingston's burning spirit coursing through it.

But Kingston's victory wasn't Kingston's. It was Claudio Castagnoli's Sharpshooter on Matt Menard, not Eddie's Stretch Plum on Jericho, that secured the tapout. The moment, the match, and the payback belonged to one of the men Kingston hates most.

The duo's issues are well-documented, particularly from Kingston, who it often seems can barely go an interview without calling Castagnoli a coward (or worse). Now, he must live with knowing that Claudio took this moment away from him, even if it was ultimately to his benefit.

"Bittersweet" doesn't cover it.

There are plenty of interesting directions to take this. Smug Claudio taking immense pleasure in outdoing Eddie, thus winding Kingston up even tighter, is as compelling as 'The Mad King' eventually being talked into seeing the bigger picture by Jon Moxley, who'd made the perfect mediator.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.