8 Ups & 2 Downs From AEW Dynamite (18 Oct)

Jon Moxley retains, Hangman Page suffers nasty injury, MJF calls his shot, Riho returns.

Jon Moxley MJF
AEW

The Wednesday Night Wars were briefly reprised on a Tuesday this week, with Warner Bros. Discovery bringing AEW Dynamite forward by 24 hours due to MLB playoff coverage, putting Tony Khan's flagship in direct competition with WWE NXT.

But the night's discourse ultimately revolved around concern for one AEW protagonist's health rather than which brand "won" this one-off ratings tussle. Best wishes to 'Hangman' Adam Page, who suffered a concussion in Dynamite's main event, taking an ugly bump while wrestling Jon Moxley. Fingers crossed his time on the shelf is a matter of weeks rather than months.

Beyond Moxley and Page's World Title match, Women's World Champion Toni Storm defended against her division's greatest title-holder, Hikaru Shida, Dalton Castle challenged for Chris Jericho's ROH belt, and Death Triangle put their World Trio's Titles on the line against Orange Cassidy and Best Friends. Four matches, four belts: all killer, no filler.

How did it go down in Cincinnati, Ohio, where the audience took a while to warm up but were hooked early on, staying with this busy show and its many developments throughout?

Let's light the fuse...


Downs...

2. Garage Door Dreck

Jay Lethal garage door
AEW

AEW's "no physicality" ruling had no meaning in Darby Allin, Jay Lethal, and Sonjay Dutt's backstage interview segment with Alex Marvez, which transcended the verbal realm from the moment the wrestlers shooed the broadcaster away.

Calling Darby's previous win over him a fluke, Lethal wanted a rematch. Allin, in response, asserted that he would beat Jay again and again and again. Alex exited the scene after Dutt claimed "a friend of ours" had clued them in on Allin's weakness, leading to a two-on-one brawl when Darby shoved the heels, leading to him being trapped under a garage door while Lethal applied a Figure Four.

Which looked rough. Gently and softly, the shutters descended upon Allin, lending little in the way of believability to the idea his ribs had been "crushed". This not only looked weak, but gave Darby ample time to credibly escape.

A poorly-executed decent idea, this didn't look good on television.


1. Heal Up, Hangman

Hangman Page concussion
AEW

Best wishes to 'Hangman' Adam Page, who was stretchered out of the arena after suffering a concussion in his match with Jon Moxley.

Their AEW World Title match was very good and trending towards greatness when the accident happened. This is of secondary importance, though. What matters most is that a young man with a young family now faces an indefinite spell on the sidelines, having been knocked stiff in one of the most worrying scenes this show has ever had to broadcast.

AEW has issued a statement clarifying that Page was taken to a trauma centre following the incident. While he has been discharged, he remains in the company's concussion protocol.

This was nobody's fault, but stands as an unfortunate, troubling reminder of the dangers inherent in this sport. The team, including referee Paul Turner and Dr. Michael Sampson, deserve credit for their swift, decisive response, which, as Chris Nowinski put it, "gives us the best chance for a good outcome."

Again, Hangman is what matters most here. May his recovery go well.


Ups...

8. FTR Finally Go For AEW Gold

FTR Swerve In Our Glory
AEW

That FTR have been number one contenders for the AEW World Tag Team Championships since the turn of the century became a meme months ago, so it was good to see the company finally scratch that itch on Dynamite.

Swerve In Our Glory feel they have an equally justifiable claim to face The Acclaimed following their loss to Anthony Bowens and Max Caster at Grand Slam. They accosted FTR mid-interview, interrupting their conversation with Renee Paquette, ultimately resulting in Keith Lee and Swerve Strickland being booked to face Dax Harwood and Cash Wheeler next week. The winners shall then advance to challenge The Acclaimed.

Yes, this featured the tiresome backstage interruption trope (a supplemental Down, if you wish), but FTR's elephant in the room had been ignored for too long. Their AEW Tag Team Title challenge is overdue - and this should be a fine match.


7. Blackpool Combat Club Tension

Bryan Danielson Wheeler Yuta
AEW

Wheeler Yuta and Bryan Danielson's sitdown interview with Renee Paquette could - and should - have been longer. Paquette is great at this. Why minimise her impact, and why not give Danielson and Yuta more room to weave their tense story?

Nonetheless, the core content is strong. Danielson was smarting from the previous week's ROH Title loss to Chris Jericho but still has hopes for Daniel Garcia, who he thinks can become an all-timer on a technical level. This didn't sit well with Garcia's career rival, Yuta, who saw Red Death's betrayal of the Blackpool Combat Club coming.

Having fought and bled for the stable's colours, Yuta positioned him alongside Claudio Castagnoli and Jon Moxley, saying Danielson was the only one to home the BCC didn't mean anything. It was telling, too, that while Yuta sat in his stable-branded hoodie, Bryan wore a blue number.

A wide-reaching storyline drawing on Yuta and Garcia's pre-AEW history, Garcia and Yuta's shared reverence of Danielson, and everything AEW has done with the Blackpool Combat Club in 2022, this looks like an effective elevator for Yuta, whose stock continues to rise.


6. Jericho & Castle Peacock & Throw Bombs

Jake Hager Chris Jericho
AEW

Dalton Castle and Chris Jericho's ROH Title fight was a boatload of fun, drawing as much on the challenger's expressive character as hard knocks and big bombs.

Living up to his nickname, Castle peacocked around the ring early on, leading The Boys around the squared circle after some early exploratory exchanges. Back inside, he threw Jericho around like an empty bottle. Slams and drops led to a gutwrench showboating spot while The Boys cheerled from the outside. When Jake Hager tried to interject, he hulked up only when The Boys messed with his purple hat, continuing his recent comedic tilt.

Castle pushed towards what would have been a believable win with German suplexes and the Bangarang. Ultimately, the Judas Effect felled him after an entertaining, dramatic fight.

Afterwards, Jericho claimed to have successfully desecrated ROH's legacy, titles, champions, and ring announcer. His attempt at going after its commentators were thwarted when Jerry Lynn saved Ian Riccaboni from an assault on the stage, however, with the ECW icon (and former ROH Champion) eating a Tombstone Piledriver onto the belt for his troubles.

Is... AEW teasing Chris Jericho vs. Jerry Lynn?!

2022 wrestling is wild.


5. Shida & Storm Fight Like Hell

Toni Storm Riho
AEW

AEW's women have been kicking a lot of *ss lately, using their weekly Dynamite slot to full effect, fighting hard and snug, suggesting, perhaps, a brighter future yet lurks beyond the cloudy horizon.

Hikaru Shida vs. Toni Storm continued this trend. While short, with its eight-minute runtime gobbled up by a picture-in-picture break, the wrestlers made the most of it. Tie-ups and jostles for position and control took them to the mat, then back to their feet, before Shida got cooking, delivering her usual fiery performance. A Hip Attack sent her to the floor before nice, starchy strikes came out, with the wrestlers hooking a crowd that, up to this point, sounded likely they were either poorly produced or in poor song.

A brisk, no-fat encounter concluded shortly after Shida blocked the swinging DDT and hit a version of a Gourd Buster. The Storm Zero won it for Toni in her latest successful Interim Women's World Title Defence. A hoot of a match that could have touched greatness had it gone 15 minutes.

Storm was beaten down by Rebel and Jamie Hayter after the bell. Britt Baker's entrance was then interrupted by Saraya, whose own arrival preceded Riho's return to AEW for the first time since May. A welcome re-addition, the Japanese star aligned herself with Storm, setting up a ripper of a TV match with Hayter for next week in the process.


4. Before The Accident...

Jon Moxley Hangman Page
AEW

While Jon Moxley vs. 'Hangman' Adam Page will be remembered for its unfortunate conclusion, the action preceding this was great, suggesting the duo were on the verge of crafting an awesome main event before the accident.

Page fired up immediately by confronting Moxley on the floor during his entrance. Mox ended up busted open before the bout had officially begun, with the duo brawling around ringside. From there, Hangman went after the wound, egged on by Moxley, who was on the backfoot and made to claw his way back into it. The AEW World Champion was his usual defiant, resistant self, initially mounting fleeting comebacks before getting knocked down, though his willingness to get dirty helped level the playing field.

Moxley bit Hangman's forehead and called at his back. He ate a Dead Eye on the apron and survived, kicking out of a top rope Fallaway Slam. Seconds later, as the match was heating up, Hanger was concussed by the King Kong Lariat gone wrong.

Again, get well soon, Hangman. His and Moxley's efforts pre-injury deserve acknowledgement, though, and they will hopefully be able to run this back before long.


3. Death Triangle Drop The Hammer

Death Triangle Best Friends
AEW

Storyline considerations boosted a very strong television match between Death Triangle and Best Friends/Orange Cassidy, aiding the sixsome to a memorable conclusion to their long-running, interconnected feud.

These two sides collided for the World Trios Championships in the immediate aftermath of AEW stripping The Elite of the belts post-All Out. Here, they outdid that first match. Best Friends and Cassidy were stymied early on, their continued attempts at crafting openings foiled by the champions, whose trident dive helped the match run through the gearbox. Later, the sides delivered a new take on the pop-up Destroyer spot, with Chuck Taylor and Trent Beretta catching Penta El Zero Miedo, nailing the Strong Zero for a close two.

PAC, talked out of using the bell hammer by Rey Fenix, was given food for thought by the finish. Fenix pinned Beretta after hitting his over-the-shoulder sitout piledriver, proving him correct in his stance that 'The Bastard' doesn't need weaponry to win.

Nonetheless, the Death Triangle tension will likely continue beyond this.


2. William Regal Pulls Fire From MJF

MJF William Regal
AEW

William Regal and MJF's in-ring segment was one of the best pieces of pro wrestling theatre all year. That it is listed second amongst our Ups is purely cosmetic, as the next entry came directly from this - and it's impossible to discuss how the show ended without first mentioning the seeds sown here.

MJF interrupted Regal's planned in-ring segment with Tony Schiavone. He spun a lengthy, passionate yarn about attending a WWE tryout at 19, being told to keep in touch with Regal when he was decreed too young to land a contract, only to be cut off by the Englishman. Having held onto the very email sent by Regal and used it as fuel ever since, Max delivered a rich, detailed story of beef with that veteran that, whether real or manufactured, was entirely believable. This is what it's all about.

Regal separated himself from MJF. His early wrestling start was one of blood and thunder, fighting for his life as a teenager against grown men, landing his position not by knocking people like Schiavone down, but by earning it. MJF, he claimed, had shortcutted his way to the top. He implored the prodigy to become 'The Devil' not by looking for easy routes, but by beating everyone that stands in front of him, no matter the liberties he had to take.

When MJF couldn't knock Regal down after the Brit's open invitation to do so, William took the hesitation as a sign that Max isn't there yet. In his eyes, he still has a lot to prove.


1. Called Shots & Admirable Improvisation

Jon Moxley
AEW

It can't be easy filling television time after an unexpected, horrible injury, but AEW did an admirable job in doing so. The announcers filled in the gaps while Jon Moxley readied himself for an in-ring promo. Once MJF was out to call his shot, the AEW World Champion continued, perhaps going for longer than originally intended, though not once did the situation feel artificial or contrived.

MJF's shift is what matters most here. Having spent the past month or so teasing the idea that he might cash in his All Out chip at any second, he called his shot. Jon Moxley vs. MJF for the AEW World Championship will headline Full Gear.

Seemingly spurred on by his earlier interaction with William Regal, this was a fired-up, focused MJF, who promises to "earn it" for the first time in his life on 19 November. Whether or not this results in an earnest victory or a heinous screwjob, the outcome is fascinating - and appropriate for the challenger's current character direction.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.