8 Ups & 2 Downs From AEW Dynamite: Fyter Fest Night 2 (Jul 8)

Wrestling, bloody hell.

Orange Cassidy Fyter Fest
AEW

Night one of AEW Fyter Fest 2020 was fantastic.

MJF and Wardlow Vs. Jurassic Express was a symphony of a professional wrestling TV show segment. An electrifying match - a seamless hybrid of a banger and a hoss fight - it developed the legacy rivalry between MJF and Jungle Boy and elegantly furthered the tensions between the heel tandem. That legacy rivalry demands improvement and escalation with each beat to earn itself, and their work was even better than Double Or Nothing's undercard show-stealer.

With one incredible spot and an even more impressive match, Hikaru Shida and Penelope Ford battered, with the force of a lunging knee strike, the fading take that Kenny Omega doesn't know what he is doing. Cody Vs. Jake Hager was the best possible version of itself: an immaculately paced and told story of savvy vs. brute strength in which Cody fulfilled his own remit for the TNT Championship. This was a superb bell-to-bell performance. Santana and Ortiz Vs. Private Party, the lowlight of the show, was still a lot of fun.

Tony Khan again waved his baton throughout a main event segment that distilled the joy that is AEW Dynamite in 2020. The Best Friends' entrance was as hilarious as it was sweet, the closing stretch of the match was white hot, and the post-match angle was sumptuously deft. FTR cut a tag team in half, much less the ring, with a tremendous heel tactic at once clear in its intent and open to misinterpretation, furthering an intoxicating episodic storyline. Storylines plural, actually.

As for night two...?


Downs...

2. Lance Archer Vs. Joey Janela Just Barely Does What It Needed To Do

Joey Janela Lance Archer
AEW

There was a sense that Lance Archer Vs. Joey Janela didn't quite fulfil its ghoulish thrill of a premise.

Is this a macro concern for Janela, who is a better performer on the unbridled Independent circuit than what is a very expressive product, but still very much a TV show?

He's exponentially more than a deranged living apron bump, and he took a nasty, killer bump through a table, but this was unbalanced. It was much more of a competitive match than the inevitable death Janela did miraculously well to stave off for as long as he did, though the interference of Sonny Kiss, as a babyface, did put over the any-means-necessary premise of survival. It worked better as an end-to-end, net-result presentation than a match.

The little detail of Janela looking for his friend in the tunnel - before being confronted with what was left of him - is the sort of deft, immersive touch with which this show excels in 2020. And that finish was awesome and earned, if you're generous, since Janela introduced the table that ended him.

The timing of the commercial hurt it, but it wasn't a bad match. It was a good match, boasting two good performances.

It was just the wrong match, and it didn't really restore Archer's aura.


1. Too Strong A Tell

Darby Allin
AEW

This is a minor and conditional flaw. If the Fight For The Fallen main event bangs this memory out of the viewer, and indications are that it will, it won't matter.

But AEW almost played it perfectly.

Ahead of Double Or Nothing, Taz attempted to mentor Darby Allin following his loss in the TNT Championship tournament semi-final. Taz misread Allin's past and ability level, and Allin, feeling patronised, rebuffed his help. This pissed Taz off, and so Taz in response hired a preposterously muscled badass goon to take Allin out - and to take himself back to the top of the wrestling world. Brian Cage wrecked Allin at the finish of the Casino Ladder match. Allin hasn't been cleared for in-ring competition since. This is a natural, built programme, but it had lurked in the background so as to not to diminish the drama and importance of the big Cage push.

Until last night's Darby Allin latest medical update/not-great Jackass-adjacent skit, in which he explicitly called Cage out.

This felt like atypical exposition from a company that operates best when it respects the intelligence of the audience. They had foreshadowed this programme very well, but they've telegraphed it now. What was once organic is now obvious.

It could always materialise as an AEW World Championship match, of course, but that doesn't feel at all likely.


Ups...

8. A Very High-Quality Opener

Hangman Page Private Party
AEW

Perfectly timed, paced and judged for a television opener, the brief jolt of electricity that was Kenny Omega & Hangman Page Vs. Private Party worked as a means of ungluing the audience at home and, quietly, as a story.

At 11:32, it didn't reach for an epic, nor did it ask too much of the challengers (though, as challengers to the World Tag Team Titles, perhaps it ought to have). That concern aside, the duration made perfect use of a dynamic understandably thrown together when AEW lost out on/WWE's negligence ruined the original main event.

The narrative centred on Private Party drawing on their exuberance, athleticism and aerial skill to completely overwhelm the Champions, layering a fun spot-fest with a psychology informed by Fyter Fest Night One, at which Page and Omega were taken to near their limit. Marq Quen and Isiah Kassidy capitalised on their physical and emotional fatigue, stemming from the tense post-match of the main event, with a blitzkrieg series of spots before the resolve and quality of the Champions snatched the win. Fans of Being The Elite were also serviced by the feisty exchanges worked between Page and Private Party, but not to an extent that would have mystified the casuals.

This worked well above Private Party's recent fun but even output because it was their tightest performance in a long while and it didn't rely on the same high spots; Kassidy executed a particularly stunning feat of balance with his jaw-dropping springboard cannonball to the outside.


7. Dr. Britt Baker, D.M.D Appreciation Slide

Big Swole Britt Baker
AEW

You know what's fantastic about Dr. Britt Baker, D.M.D?

There are levels to just how much of an obnoxious egotist the character is. She has a catchphrase, but she doesn't rely on it. She's a great promo, but she doesn't just have to tell you how arrogant she is, even if she rather enjoys it. She will, like the best storytellers, show it.

In this perfect bit - another maximised-minutes symphony - she again passed a note to Tony Schiavone, who plays the long-suffering role incredibly well, but is too wholesome to suffer, directing the heat towards Baker like an oxy-acetylene torch.

In the note, she exclaimed - interrupting the broadcast that is lesser than her in the process - that Hangman Page's pyro caused her significant burns. That was total b*llocks, and total hyperbole, and the hilarious implication is that Page should simply move or outright abandon his pyro, lest this happen again. Baker's safety and mere presence is more important than the spectacle of a Champion's entrance, even though he sort of has to be there, and she doesn't.

Later in the night, her economic programme with Big Swole continued. Swole returned after being served and kicked out to throw one (1) scrunched up piece of garbage at "Reba". Reba's hand lightly deflected onto Britt's face. Baker sold her nose as if it was broken, which was funny enough in itself, but even funnier when you recall that she actually broke it a few months back. The audience knows her reaction to be bullsh*t twice over. Layers.

Baker feigning pain was so terrifically annoying that it made you want to see Swole have a real go down the line.


6. Nostalgia With Substance

taz ftw
AEW

This was fabulous: the sort of "Of course!" booking that evokes a massive smile from the face of the long-time wrestling fan.

With his ECW World Champion Shane Douglas shelved, Paul Heyman in 1998 created for Taz the FTW (F*ck The World) Championship. It represented a deserved slap in the face of the Champion's cowardice. Taz was the self-appointed "real" World Champion, and got the belt over as a more in-character take on the interim titles created in the legitimate sporting world which, by way of Jorge Masvidal's UFC Bad Motherf*cker Title, have also taken inspiration from the old Taz custom.

It's not the old custom anymore; in what was a great heel move more than it was mere fan service, Taz brought it back and declared Brian Cage the new holder. This was a tremendous subversion on what the belt once meant that services this particular storyline very well. Moxley isn't a coward.

He isn't ducking anything. He has stayed home for the most noble of reasons, and those reasons actually benefit Taz. But Taz is a miserable prick, and won't see it that way.

This was a strong, inspired segment accentuated with another outstanding Taz promo that Jon Moxley, watching it home, would have f*cking hated - and will use as fuel.

Magnificent.


5. An Absolutely Incredible Match That Was Pretty Much Wrestling Perfected All At Once

Matt Jackson Fenix
AEW

The Young Bucks & FTR Vs. The Butcher & The Blade & The Lucha Bros. was just transcendent. Wrestling, bloody hell.

The Young Bucks are the best pro wrestling storytellers in the world.

They are about one million f*cking times better at telling stories than Vincent Kennedy We Make Movies McMahon.

Cry about it.

Fail to understand it.

Doesn't make it less true.

This was the second chapter in a long-term storyline, the storytelling was fantastic, and the storytelling was germane to - and driven by - an absolute turbo banger of a match that incorporated a spot so demented, creative and blow-away spectacular that a crowd didn't need to get it over.

When Fénix annihilated Matt Jackson with a Canadian Destroyer onto the other six men to the outside, your writer legit sputtered. A spit take without the spit. But it wasn't about the spots. It was about the story.

It was about Dax Harwood responding to the outrageous rope work that led to Nick Jackson drilling Fénix with a hurricanrana by turning away from the apron with hats-off incredulity - or was that barely contained disgust? Was Harwood, with one awesome detail, putting the Young Bucks over, or burying them?

Or, thrillingly, both?

It was about FTR and the Bucks furthering the strand of mutual respect in a series of incredibly timed tandem spots - Matt Jackson's blind tag to Dax Harwood was storytelling so layered it usually takes months to unfurl - or was each team flexing on the other?

A perfect match with...


4. The Perfect Result

Lucha Bros
AEW

The result was perfect.

But first, something else about that match that ruled, because that match absolutely f*cking ruled: did you notice how much Pentagon laid it in to Dax Harwood?

He's a snug striker, but there was something else behind those slaps. He pasted the sh*t out of Harwood's face to a level that stunned the commentary team because FTR had buried the supposed lack of stopping power in the Lucha Bros.' game. Long-term targets of FTR's rhetoric, Pentagon very clearly issued a receipt in the glorious parameters of the narrative.

Matt Jackson took the fall, but it hardly buried him. It did in a literal sense, under a delicious pile of bodies after that deranged Canadian Destroyer, but the pure insanity of the spot protected him. Matt's loss here allows FTR to subtly and slyly underscore their credentials as the greatest tag team of the century. Nothing is definitive, and it won't be until that dream match finally materialises, but this is a compelling means with which to very gradually heat it up.

The result also elegantly put FTR in frame to face the Lucha Bros. at Fight For The Fallen in a match that should hold very important ramifications for the World Tag Team Championship match at All Out. Meanwhile, this high-profile win may also enable the Butcher and the Blade to challenge Kenny Omega and Hangman Page under the lesser lights of Dynamite.

Perfect, purposeful wrestling and booking working in synergy.


3. Interest In The Women's Division Deepens

Nyla Rose
AEW

A modest Up, the return of Nyla Rose nonetheless opened up a mystery and developed her character in a manner that was consistent and not uninteresting.

The handicap squash match was only functional - the first opponent tagging out immediately was a nice touch between the show reel of moves - but it was only pretext to an announcement that makes sense and drops a hook for the weeks to come. The Nyla Rose character is a destructive elemental force that has nonetheless struggled with her temperament and suffered from a lack of consistency. This is something she is to address with the appointment of a manager, the identity of whom was left, astutely, to the imagination.

AEW last night created a dialogue around the future, not the quality, of a division.

Awesome Kong is a name doing the rounds on Twitter - she is a hoss with great presence AEW can still maximise - but irrespective of who it is, this is another key development in a Women's division that feels less like tokenism the deeper we settle in to 2020.


2. An Intriguing Midcard Storyline Advances Neatly

Dark Order Colt Cabana
AEW

This was a nice bit of business, perhaps dulled slightly by the fact that it aimed to do that which the unreal eight-man tag had just blown away: advance a storyline via a kinetic multi-man tag team match.

It was still very good and very savvy in its escalation of the story beats. The Dark Order are attempting to recruit Colt Cabana into their organisation. First, they preyed on his vulnerability. Now, with his head turned, they have tested his loyalty: it was SCU that Cabana aligned with when he debuted with AEW, bringing his arc full circle in a deft booking touch.

Mr. Brodie Lee was quietly brilliant here, showing why the likes of Arn Anderson rave about his ring IQ; he arranged the match to both favour and test Cabana, manipulating him all the way, stepping in only to demonstrate the power he wields with a disgusting/beautiful German suplex. It was a treat to see the explosive Grayson back in action - he is incredible - and the old pros of SCU have an uncanny knack of losing but never resonating as losers.

Cabana won - the Dark Order made it so - but the question now, and it's an interesting one, is no longer if he gets in, but how he gets out.


1. Orange Cassidy Breaks Through In A Superb Main Event

Orange Cassidy Fyter Fest
AEW

Orange Cassidy is incredible at that for which he is buried.

Really, that's the beauty of the punchline: he isn't just really good when he tries, he's an elite-tier professional wrestler, excelling within an elite-tier global standard, and this was an elite-tier professional wrestling match.

It was a different match to that which one might have expected. Less of a meme match and more of a dream match, it retained enough of the irresistible personality of the dynamic - Cassidy was blinded with orange juice before the comeback, Jericho was priceless in his impersonations during the heat - but never to the detriment of the serious core of the story. If the Revolution match proved Orange Cassidy could hang, this match proved he could hang at the main event level.

This was a match devoid totally of kitsch.

It was a literal blood feud. Cassidy only threatened to lean on his comedy act to lull Jericho into a Superkick, and what a goddamn spot that was. It was a moment of searing high drama, but it was more than that. Orange Cassidy is the wrestler, apparently, who makes a mockery of AEW's early, sports-oriented messaging.

But this wasn't so much a move as a play from a wrestler who, in the sense of the kayfabe he apparently breaks, is one of wrestling's most intelligent strategists. Cassidy sold and registered everything he did here immaculately, and this tremendous breakthrough performance was structured perfectly by Chris Jericho in masterful big match form. It was so well put together: Cassidy, mat wrestling dynamo, had the beating of Jericho, who had to rely on all of his dark arts to get through the challenge.

A triumph of a match to cap off a triumph of a show. If Revolution was the greatest big-time PPV in an age, Fyter Fest was the best B-level PPV in an age, too.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!