8 Ups & 2 Downs From AEW Dynamite (January 3 - Results & Review)
The first AEW Dynamite of 2024 has a new stable, new stories and a new star making a big debut!
December 30th's World's End pay-per-view (and elements of its controversial press conference) was 2023 All Elite Wrestling distilled.
Flashes of a generally well-received in-ring product were undone and/or compromised by excess, tired booking tropes and a feeling that everything that could be done with this massive roster now...has been. Stars on the rise held their ground, but by association they felt colder on a less-than-electric evening on Long Island. Meanwhile, reality was proving more powerful than any fiction AEW could hope to craft, with some deeply unpleasant allegations (and a lack of much direction about how they might be dealt with going forward) overwhelming one match in particular and understandably casting a hefty shadow over the rest of the night.
How any of that shakes out remains to be seen, but following the crowning of a brand new World Heavyweight Champion, the conclusion of an absorbing Continental Classic tournament and the wrapping up of the divisive "Devil" mystery, AEW had an opportunity to move quickly into January with the (storyline) pitfalls confined to another era entirely.
New Year, New AEW?
Let's light the fuse...
Downs…
2. The New (And Improved?) Outcasts
Did Harley Cameron pass The Outcasts test?
Watch #AEWDynamite LIVE on TBS@itsdanni_ellexo | @Saraya | @realrubysoho pic.twitter.com/zMpFBugok4
— All Elite Wrestling (@AEW) January 4, 2024
2023 was the year All Elite Wrestling lost grip of its "let it play out" privileges, and when it comes to the booking of the women's division, did the company ever really have any?
There was much to praise in that regard elsewhere on the show, but a follow-up interview with Saraya, Ruby Soho and new Outcasts recruit Harley Cameron didn't feel much like a giant leap for the league. Having pulled a massive knife out at random on last week's show, Cameron's ker-ayzy was toned down a little this week, but not enough to stop Soho from rightfully pointing out that they may have just added one deluded psychopath to the group to replace the former one. Saraya, with little care for the logic, seemed convinced of the supposedly great plan to keep Cameron around, but offered almost zero explanation why.
Wafer-thin characterisations, a dated and fake-feeling persona for the malleable former QTV star and the apparent dropping of Saraya and Soho's beef in exchange for keeping a dead stable alive. The story has yet to walk let alone run, and it already feels on its last legs.
1. What Next For The Continental Championship?
Wait, did Danhausen's curse work?
Watch #AEWDynamite LIVE on TBS!@trentylocks | @bountykeith | @briancagegmsi | @vikingo_aaa | @DanhausenAD pic.twitter.com/Z26dmarw30
— All Elite Wrestling (@AEW) January 4, 2024
Eddie Kingston becoming the first Modern American Triple Crown winner and Continental Champion at All Elite Wrestling was - in the moment at least - far more than just 'The Mad King' grafting his way through a tournament to win the company's latest randomly-arrived-upon singles title.
Because what is this new belt if it's not an era defining recognition of unreal determination and the old-fashioned meaning of work rate? What is it if it's not the life's work of the person holding it aloft? The symbol of excellence in an era as battle-worn men pose for magazine shots draped in the trappings of their gritted-teeth success?
These are sadly not rhetorical questions.
Apparently, it is a belt that can and will be defended on television against opponents that win random multi-mans. Just like the TNT Championship was and often is. Just like the International Championship was and is despite Orange Cassidy's attempts to subvert the bit. Trent was successful in being the first to follow that formula, in what was justifiably the coldest match on the show. Fans came up for Danhausen's interference and it was telling that he helped his Best Friend stablemate despite being back-jumped in the World's End pre-show battle royal for another title shot (see?) less than a week ago.
Kingston will beat Trent, and there's always got to be awkward first defences and stat-padding. But the Champion was best flying to Japan to toast his successes in the Tokyo Dome rather than sitting ringside seeing his work trivialised by booking that left some with a sinking feeling.
Ups…
8. The Patriarchy's State Of The Union Address
Christian Cage shares #ThePatriarchy's plan for 2024.
Watch #AEWDynamite LIVE on TBS!@Christian4Peeps | @Luchasaurus | @TheNickWayne pic.twitter.com/YKTWlYUCXk
— All Elite Wrestling (@AEW) January 4, 2024
Putting the fun in functional as he always does, Christian Cage was a riot leading his Patriarchy through a heat-drenched celebration following him "retaining" the TNT Championship at World's End.
Denying the original result ever happened, Cage insisted that his run started when he won it on the first episode of Collision, which of course also wasn't the case. Reminding viewers that Killswitch has now been responsible for Cage holding gold twice, this also played nicely into a predictable but enjoyable payoff where the titleholder thanked Shayna and Nick Wayne and himself rather than giving any kudos to the wrecking machine over his shoulder.
It was clear from this that the wrestling dinosaur finding his voice and confidence to fight back is the eventual end to all of this, but Adam Copeland was shunted to the back of the line too. He'll inevitably get his revenger sooner or later, but Cage seemed intent to try and stop that for as long as he can get away with.
7. Orange Cassidy Vs Dante Martin
Has anyone checked Dante Martin for wings?
Watch #AEWDynamite LIVE on TBS!@OrangeCassidy | @lucha_angel1 pic.twitter.com/8nTL2Vmrit
— All Elite Wrestling (@AEW) January 4, 2024
The Orange Cassidy International Championship formula doesn't feel quite as fresh after trading the title with Jon Moxley and Rey Fenix in late-2023, but perhaps that's why it was tinkered with here in the first Dynamite match of the new year.
Cassidy had already been called out by Roderick Strong via Adam Cole (more on that later), and his plate was only fuller after picking up the victory against the game Top Flight challenger.
Beyond his usual aerial offence, Martin's other strategy was to deprive Cassidy of (literally) getting comfortable. The simplicity of the Champion not being permitted to put his hands in his pockets was a great touch, even if he eventually managed it and made Martin pay double for being made to wait.
Early match frustration led to an uncharacteristic heel control portion to put over Martin's fire, and nothing but the match itself was lost for the Top Flight man. In a surprise addendum to the action, a six-man post-match stand-off between the respective run-in buddies was broken up by a returning Private Party, seemingly separated from Matt Hardy at long last.
They couldn't have felt fresher in their promo, even if seeing will be have to be believing second time around.
6. Swerve Strickland Vs Daniel Garcia
Are you watching Samoa Joe?
Watch #AEWDynamite LIVE on TBS!@GarciaWrestling | @SwerveConfident pic.twitter.com/3zmb7y0aNL
— All Elite Wrestling (@AEW) January 4, 2024
A statement of intent following decisive wins for both men at World's End, Daniel Garcia Vs Swerve Strickland headlining the first flagship show of the year made AEW feel bold and interesting all over again.
For better and worse, there are wrestlers people tune into All Elite Wrestling to see, and these are two of them right now. Strickland in particular has been making no secret of his desire to fight for the World Heavyweight Championship, and Garcia's turned a loss-heavy Continental Classic run into the spark that will light the way far removed from Chris Jericho and the other distractions that have sat in his way. Searing action, good chemistry and the live audience's belief in 'Red Death' as the underdog put gave everything the vaunted big fight feel. The promotion was and is still fighting for this title.
Swerve picked up the win in the end, but not without Garcia kicking out from a Swerve Stomp before succumbing to the JML Driver. If not for an awkward botch that saw both men tumble off the announce table during a Dragontamer attempt by Garcia, this would have been one of those No Notes Dynamite main events, especially considering what followed in the post-match.
A furious Hangman Page had arrived shortly before the main event threatening to beat up anybody in his path, and Strickland became the perfect target after he and Prince Nana low-blowed and assaulted Garcia after the bell. The pull apart was yet another example of their exhilarating chemistry, and with Revolution more than two months away, this feels like something to spice up Dynamite rather than be pushed back to pay-per-view.
5. Giving The Devil His Due
There was a lot of pressure on Adam Cole to follow up on the big World's End reveal of himself as the one responsible for torturing MJF (and stealing his Devil mask) over the last few months. The former NXT Champion managed the spot, and the "Undisputed Kingdom" roll-out well.
Explaining just enough about the hows and whys without going so far to remind you that wrestling can fundamentally be quite stupid, Cole highlighted that sooner or later one of them was going to end the friendship in brutal and heartbreaking fashion so it might as well have been him. Laying out the intent of all the individual members of the stable (and rebooting the original MJF/Wardlow dynamic without realising he's become everything he hates), Cole brought all his usual poise despite still being unable to physically interject himself until his broken ankle has recovered.
This caused problems when the new group had were outnumbered by Bullet Club Gold and The Acclaimed, but multiple strange bedfellows now have it out for Cole, Wardlow, Roderick Strong, Matt Taven and Mike Bennett after all their misdeeds.
It provides a strong return for MJF too, unless the words about his demise already spoken by the new Champion prove to be true...
4. COLD Open
Don Callis Family has issued a HUGE challenge for #AEWDynamite NEXT WEEK at the home of #AEW @dailysplace.
Watch #AEWDynamite LIVE on TBS@TheDonCallis | @Takesoup | @TrueWillieHobbs pic.twitter.com/u86zpCtzro
— All Elite Wrestling (@AEW) January 4, 2024
Delivered from the backstage area of World’s End presumably just minutes removed from him dethroning MJF, new World Heavyweight Champion Samoa Joe ended his 2023 by serving up the first great AEW promo of 2024.
‘The Samson Submission Machine’s powerful first address was all the better for its staging and show placement too. Joe cut a proud and defiant figure with the strap slung over his shoulder as he explained why he needed to break the former Champion mentally and physically following their original match at Grand Slam.
Joe left ‘The Salt Of The Earth’ with nothing, putting himself over as a man who will follow through on the worst and most dangerous of intentions and the former Champion over as a man almost impossible to beat for the belt in a straight one-on-one situation.
It was confirmed he’d appear live at the company’s spiritual home of Daily’s Place for the first time next week too. The 6’2 monster will likely look ten times that in the amphitheatre when he holds his newly-won gold aloft.
3. Mariah May Vs Queen Aminata
“The Virtuosa” Deonna Purrazzo is here to ruin Mariah May’s debut on #AEWDynamite!
Watch #AEWDynamite LIVE on TBS!@DeonnaPurrazzo | @MariahMayX pic.twitter.com/MoL2J3G9LU
— All Elite Wrestling (@AEW) January 4, 2024
Mariah May Vs Queen Aminata was everything the performers and promotion could have hoped for. A good match that established exactly what Mariah May can and will offer, agented in such a way to allow the touted Queen Aminata to maximise her valuable Dynamite minutes, the company earned the reactions the wrestlers generated through earnest character development for May as the latest addition to the Toni Storm cinematic universe.
Aminata's kicks and strikes looked stiff enough to rattle May before she hit her May Day sit-out slam for the win, and May followed her idol's lead and celebrated in spite of the locale. Earlier in the night, Storm had revealed that she wasn't there to watch. The AEW World Champion had already decided to attend a seance with the late Steven Sondheim in Manhattan rather than stick around in New Jersey, and May had little nice to say about the place as a way to trigger Deonna Purrazzo making her surprise AEW debut.
'The Virtuosa' was hugely over in her home state, and was targeting May in order to make a statement to the absent Champion. May herself noted that she was no messenger to trigger the brawl, which was yet another wrinkle in her unique relationship with the 'Timeless' star.
Given a hot spot on the show with multiple characters teasing multiple directions, this was rich reward for a company that has previously done so little to earn one.
2. A Happy New Year For AEW Fans?
Don Callis Family has issued a HUGE challenge for #AEWDynamite NEXT WEEK at the home of #AEW @dailysplace.
Watch #AEWDynamite LIVE on TBS@TheDonCallis | @Takesoup | @TrueWillieHobbs pic.twitter.com/u86zpCtzro
— All Elite Wrestling (@AEW) January 4, 2024
Possibly!
2023 was the year AEW were comfortably and consistently creatively outstripped by WWE for the first time since the challenger brand took root in 2019. The glory days and Tony Khan himself felt finished beyond repair, and while it'd be naive to use one strong edition of the broadcast as proof that a corner has been turned, it'd be less so to suggest this has been going on for a little longer than that.
The Continental Classic restored a lot of AEW hardcores' faith in being able to produce the sort of in-ring action they liked, and the roll-out and follow-through of the Devil drama has calmed some of the criticisms towards that particular brand of storytelling. The new calendar year and all the optimism that brings following such developments gave this airy edition of the show a sense of freedom the shackled Autumn/Winter period desperately lacked.
Between the booking of key new acts in the women's division, the short and longterm matchmaking and a much-needed gap between now and the next pay-per-view, this Dynamite felt like a chance for the company to reclaim the conversation on fantastic matches and interesting dynamics on the road to Revolution.
Case. In. Point...
1. Konosuke Takeshita Vs Darby Allin
Konosuke Takeshita was ready for Darby Allin!
Watch #AEWDynamite LIVE on TBS!@DarbyAllin | @takesoup | @TheDonCallis pic.twitter.com/jRJKiYRStf
— All Elite Wrestling (@AEW) January 4, 2024
Darby Allin Vs Konosuke Takeshita was much more than just a glorious festival of wrestler-on-wrestler violence, but what a festival it was.
Yet more evidence that the company might have been looking at the turning over of the calendar as an excuse to just rip up what didn’t work in 2023, the agenting of Takeshita as the latest Darby-killer was a giant leap even more pronounced than the top rope German suplex he folded Allin’s body up with. Patience with praise should be extended here - many wrestlers have their best night in AEW smashing Allin half to death - but it was impossible to hold back screams of joy watching the action itself. Great wrestling has never been more normalised than right now, but this broke through the rote stylings in the first 20 seconds and didn’t stop to check itself as it roared along.
Almost as encouraging as the match itself was the booking. Takeshita went over strong here, and riding a wave of momentum Don Callis offered up a tag match for next week’s show featuring Sting and Powerhouse Hobbs as the respective partners. In this, he noted the babyfaces’ unbeaten record, and how the Callis Family were ready to snap it. The power, and Takeshita and Hobbs are tentatively back.
They won’t get it done of course, but the mere mention of all of this drives yet more speculation towards whatever captivating choice the company makes for Sting’s last night in March. FTR? The Young Bucks? Ricky Starks & Big Bill for the belts? If it means a return to a rankings-based product, beating the latter duo and retiring on top would be a wonderful way to close out ‘The Stinger’s iconic and legendary run.