8 Ups & 2 Downs From AEW Dynamite (Nov 30 - Review)
Hangman Page returns and MJF does the impossible on stunning show loaded with stunning details.
Last week's edition of AEW Dynamite was an incredible two hours of television.
The splinters within the Blackpool Combat Club have formed at such an intriguing time. They can't fall apart now and let sports entertainment win after eight months, can they? That was about the only flaw in the unbelievably fantastic main event between Chris Jericho and Tomohiro Ishii; Jericho was too good a pro wrestler. But is that where the story is heading?
A close loss to Claudio Castagnoli at ROH Final Battle, followed by a respectful handshake, to which Sammy Guevara takes issue? Perhaps Guevara begins to question who Jericho really is, and why he has spent the last three years of his career in his shadow.
For the first time since All Out, AEW is fascinating within the parameters of its own fiction now that the last details we might ever read about Brawl Out have long echoed around the content-sphere and the Elite have returned. They have returned by trailing 0-2 to Death Triangle in their best of seven series. Would a 0-3 result create too predictable a comeback? Would it suggest the idea that the Elite are no longer Elite, which...did not go well in 2019?
Tony Khan is at last posing the right sort of questions - as opposed to "Has he lost the dressing room and indeed the plot?" - as 2022 draws to a close...
Downs...
2. A Convoluted Missed Opportunity
#1 contender fo the World title Ricky Starks is one the of the best promos in AEW, and that is enormous praise given the company standard.
With such a verve and spark to the main event scene elsewhere on this show, perhaps it was a better idea to keep his segment simple and give Starks five minutes to establish his championship credentials and sell the crowd on his winning the match. It was a guaranteed success.
Instead, Starks won a pointless squash against Ari Daivari before which he was confronted by Ethan Page in a bizarre and unfocused scene that spent too long reminding fans of the dog sh*t Matt Hardy indentured servitude story. Khan was clearly in the mood to show off his ability to storyboard and coalesce various plot lines, as will be covered shortly, but if you stain a good story with a sh*t one, the good story will smell like sh*t.
Tony Khan had an opportunity to build the biggest match of Ricky's life here, but instead, coupled with MJF's talk of Bryan Danielson, a Reign of Terror and being a special attraction all but exclusive to PPV, it felt as though Winter Is Coming had already happened, and Ricky was settling old midcard business to end the year on a high note.
The wrinkle of the Dynamite Diamond Ring acting as an instant cash-in device isn't not interesting, but this would all surely be better as a simple story in which the babyface challenges the heel backed by the support of the Texas public who watched him on the ground floor of the game.
Also: is the insinuation here that Starks wants to win the Diamond ring, thereby racking up a second anywhere, anytime title shot, so that in the event he loses at Winter Is Coming he can simply try again?
It's hardly unadulterated all-or-nothing drama or great babyface behaviour, is it?
1. No Idea What That Was To Be Honest
The Jade Cargill TBS title celebration was a brutally flat and confusing mess.
It was a shame too, because her delivery was significantly better than...whatever the story is meant to be. She looked even more like a superstar than normal and spoke with unshakeable conviction about her great she is. When whatever the story is meant to be was explored, the segment - which hardly looked like a VIP party, it was so poorly staged - fell apart. Really, her entire act has upon the introduction of the Baddies. The Cargill act was so much better when she was an invincible and self-reliant killing machine. Going over that version of Cargill might have meant something; now, it feels like a full year might have been wasted.
The Baddies looked unimpressed by and impatient with Cargill in the background as she negged them. Are they going to turn on Jade, and is that remotely a good idea when Jade, at the exact same time this was teased, cut an unmistakable heel promo?
Bow Wow's interruption was as fake as it was weird. Clearly, no inter-gender match is happening; this is all a thin excuse to have Bow Wow represent a TBS title challenger in a bid for mainstream press.
An unnecessary one too.
Ups...
8. A Wild, Unexpected Start
If there's one pedantic complaint to be had over the best Dynamites, it's that the show can feel regimented. You literally know what you're in for, given that every match and promo segment is announced in advance (as it should be). If this makes any sense, if something unexpected happens, you know when to expect it.
A true bolt from the blue rarely happens.
For example, were the Elite to have returned at any point after All Out, it was going to unfold when Death Triangle were onscreen. If Death Triangle weren't booked on a particular Dynamite, the Elite were not going to appear on it. Massive shocks have occurred - KENTA first opening the Forbidden Door is a great example of that - but that trope is now overdone. Khan needed to reframe his approach to the surprise, and he did with a superb, unexpected angle that was made even better deeper in the show.
Hangman Page returned, interrupted Mox's show-opening promo, and in a lovely and considerate detail on a night full of them, the audience was told that he's yet to be cleared. This enhanced the danger and excitement of a tremendously-worked brawl. Mox again hinted at the awesome prospect of a heel run by burying Page for suffering a concussion, which incited a wild scene that disrupted the format wonderfully.
This is why the format exists; it makes sense within the context of an emulated sports broadcast, and when Khan does play with it, it means something. It really does feel like a proper, heated conflict that cannot be contained.
7. Fantastic Match, Tremendous Foresight
Bryan Danielson Vs. Dax Harwood was a sumptuous professional wrestling match in and of itself, and it existed as a signpost of yet more brilliance to come.
The minutiae even within an early submission exchange was liquid professional wrestling. Rarely will you see the balance of fight and theatre struck so well; Dax teased the Sharpshooter just long enough for the audience to register it before Danielson, selling it big, frantically struggled out of it. They made every small detail matter with millisecond precision. Without ever abandoning its dramatic principles, they effectively obscured that they were working a match.
At Dax's urging, the match descended into a chop-heavy battle, which might have scanned as a pale comparison to last week's main event if the sound of smacked flesh wasn't so harrowing. Dax didn't account for the willing masochist within Danielson, who stepped forward with each blow. Danielson didn't account for the determination within Dax, a man who simply will not be told, ever, that he isn't the best wrestler on the planet. Their defiant nose-to-nose, headbutt-for-headbutt exchange was electrifying. Danielson won, as he often does, by suddenly cinching in a submission. He is the master who can get it done against anyone at any point in storylines. This will prove useful in a few months.
MJF made pointed reference to Danielson later in the evening. The Dragon is being set up a for a major attraction at Revolution, so expect more TV dream matches booked to remind you just how much of a genius he is.
6. Inspired Matchmaking
Being a great wrestling booker isn't just limited to telling absorbing long-term storylines. A great booker is also an astute matchmaker with the ability to select the best opponents for a featured star.
While this wasn't quite as inspired as Keith Lee Vs. Isiah Kassidy or Darby Allin Vs. Satnam Singh, Samoa Joe Vs. AR Fox was an intelligent match choice. Joe isn't the monster he once was, and this is all too often brought into focus when paired against the next generation of monsters. His excellent showing therefore is no guarantee that the upcoming singles match against Wardlow will be a great bit of business, but he raised the level of expectation here.
He noped a typically brilliant AR Fox aerial move after the first attempt bit him on the ar*e in what was a neat transition into a hope spot, and in general, Fox's arsenal worked so well here. His short cutter meant that Joe didn't have to take the sort of punishing bump that often leaves him gassed, and Fox's own tremendous bumping ability got Joe's pounce over big.
Wardlow's post-match challenge wasn't actually all that strong, in another worrying marker of his waning star power, but Joe's aura went some way to being restored here after a middling effort at Full Gear.
5. The Return Of An Old Favourite
Tony Khan brought back an old cult favourite AEW device, one that really should be a regular fixture on Dynamite: Technique By Taz.
It's another small yet important detail that adds to the vital notion that AEW is the sports-oriented alternative. His insightful breakdown of effective pro wrestling technique is the sort of thing that only a trained master can illustrate to the audience. This short segment barely eats up any airtime but functions very well to get talent over in a unique and authoritative way that might otherwise go undetected.
It should be a weekly feature, in fact, because it deepens the appreciation of a wrestler's approach to the craft.
4. MJF Is Able To Turn Heel Again, Because Of Course He Is
John Cena couldn't drown out the jeers as a babyface. Nor could Roman Reigns and Cody Rhodes; when the crowd wants to do something, they will do it. The crowd wanted to cheer MJF, but they didn't last night because his promo and the resulting angle was masterfully performed on multiple levels.
Good matches happen every week. The standard is so high in promotions of renown that great matches happen so often that it's easy to forget good matches that happened three weeks ago. They are almost unimpressive in some warped way. A good angle is altogether more difficult to execute.
It requires more in the way of true creativity. Shocking an arena into stunned silence cannot be achieved the via the Pavlovian conditioning of a finisher kick-out. Tony Khan and MJF stunned the Indianapolis crowd into silence with a mind-blowing swerve of an angle that actually made sense: you only didn't think about it before last night because AEW, at its best, is a level above.
MJF talked in a deliberate, steady rhythm and low tone. For this to work, he could not allow the fans to get high on his charisma. Without being boring, since it is impossible for MJF to be boring, it went long. It went long by ingenious design; he wants you to resent him, and in threatening a Triple H 2003-style title reign, he may have located the thing that the millennial AEW base hates and fears the most. The custom Burberry World title is far more elegant than he must have realised, so the reveal didn't quite generate the reaction intended, but the twist did: MJF, who has told you he is a snake this entire time, out-heeled William Regal and brayed him in the back of the neck.
Regal's selling was superb. He made the gravity of the situation feel unsettling. MJF used Regal's words against him, issuing a sick callback to their phenomenal face to face confrontation as he crowed over his prone body. He never did forget that email all those years ago, and, in a great moment of foreshadowing, Regal said last week that an email would form the crux of this week's segment. Also last week, it was established that nothing can be done to William Regal as a result of his dire medical history. At most, it was thought, Regal could get "attacked" offscreen, a la Dean Malenko when the Pinnacle dusted him up.
Instead, AEW delivered a phenomenal and unexpected twist in what might be the angle of the year.
3. Yes, AEW Shows DO Flow Together
This angle wasn't just sensational on its own terms.
Apparently, AEW's TV shows suffer from a lack of flow. The shows "do not connect", according to WWE Producer 'Road Dogg' Brian James. This is primarily because AEW operates within a sports-oriented narrative framework, as part of which the matches are meant to exist as fixtures for the sole purpose of determining challengers for little things called "championships" before heated conflicts emerge.
Things aren't meant to necessarily "flow" in the context of a professional wrestling show, but when the occasion demands, storylines should overlap. The dovetailing across the Jon Moxley and William Regal storylines was deft. Mox, uncontrollable, had to be ejected from the arena. AEW needed a logical reason to get him away, otherwise, he wouldn't be the picture of integrity that he is. This means of removing him from Regal's orbit also happened to be a red-hot way to build an emotionally charged rematch in and of itself.
This was supreme narrative elegance on the part of Tony Khan, who, now that he doesn't have several crises to manage for the first time since June, incredibly, is on trademark deep-thinking form as a booker. This was a significantly better method of "connecting" stories than a match going to a numbing non-finish leading to an impromptu tag. That isn't flow.
That's sh*t.
2. Belt Willow Nightingale
Willow Nightingale Vs. Anna Jay AS was a fine and, by the finish, dramatic match. It was unpredictable in the closing stretch of finisher reversals, which is some credit to the work. With two heel champions, a Willow win was all but certain. It didn't feel so foregone as it happened, however.
Everything Willow did looked impactful, her manipulation of the crowd was as savvy as ever, and she worked as if in a moment that felt real to her. She's not too dissimilar to Eddie Kingston in that respect; she boasts the amazing skill of losing herself in her performance entirely.
The crowd was really into her, which is very encouraging. They usually die altogether when Khan puts anybody but a select few in the death spot before the main event. Willow graduated to that select few last night, and the fans bit on the idea that Tay Melo's interference might dictate the finish. The discipline elsewhere helped here. No other match was plagued by this over-used trope.
Willow Nightingale Vs. Jamie Hayter II is a cracking prospect, since their Rampage match was a sleeper hit, and look at Tony go: he, with the well-received return of Ruby Soho, is also furthering a programme outside of the title picture!
1. The Elite Are Called The Elite For A Reason
The idea that the Elite and Death Triangle couldn't work a best-of-seven series was always preposterous, and they proved it within literally seconds.
The Elite attacked Death Triangle immediately, which made sense as an in-ring strategy. They are behind, desperate, and needed to get a win on the board. This sparked a wild brawl by the entrance set, from which PAC and Matt Jackson threw themselves to the floor. This was so immediately captivating that, in addition to crafting the match with its own identity distinct to their previous two encounters, the crowd weren't allowed any time to decide whether or not they wanted to chant for or against CM Punk. His name wasn't uttered. He was no distraction. The layout made certain of that.
They are called the Elite for a reason.
When the match hit the ring, it wasn't quite as pulsating as the first nor as outrageous as the second, but it was still very exciting underpinned with strong storytelling elements. Death Triangle proved over-reliant on the hammer, and the fractures within the unit continue to show, but, as expressed with a gorgeous triple moonsault to the outside, when they're in sync, they are totally formidable.
Weirdly, since they have the best chemistry out of every permutation of all six men, Nick Jackson and Rey Fénix almost got lost, which threatened to break the immersion.
The finish was excellent; Matt Jackson got his knees up to counter the Black Arrow as Kenny Omega, a details genius, frantically stopped himself from entering the ring lest Fénix push him into a save.
The decision to go 2-1 makes the next match far more interesting too, and the decision to take a break next week was also sound, since fans need to miss this to savour it.