8 Ups & 2 Downs From WWE SmackDown (Dec 22 - Results & Review)

AJ Styles gets dark; 2 tag-teams return to SmackDown; More big WWE comebacks teased!

Roman Reigns AJ Styles
WWE.com

Something special is brewing on the blue brand.

A lot of praise has been hurled Triple H's way since he seized control of creative. Generally, Hunter's approach is more traditional pro wrestling than Vince McMahon's, and there's way less silly b*llocks on WWE TV than under the Vin-man. Of course, it's Christmas, so SmackDown was always going to feature a little festive silliness.

That was kept to a minimum though. The real purpose of this week's show was to ready fans for three things: A massive triple threat to determine who works Roman Reigns at Royal Rumble, this United States Title contendership tournament final, and possibly even another major return to kick off the new year.

SmackDown didn't mess around too much, and this definitely wasn't a placeholder show. WWE creative didn't sit back, stretch and say, 'This is pre-taped - let's phone it in'. Far from it. Instead, they pushed key angles forward, built towards the Rumble nicely, and even found time to line up some new alliances.

Things are looking good then. A few fleeting negatives certainly couldn't detract from what was an excellent, excellent two-hour helping of banging wrestling telly. Here's everything you need to know!


Downs...

2. Why Do They Keep Doing This?

Butch Pete Dunne
WWE.com

Let's get those 'Downs' out of the way pronto.

Butch has split from Ridge Holland, but he's seemingly right back to warring with Pretty Deadly anyway. This is something WWE keeps doing; they had Kevin Owens leave tag business behind on Raw, moved him to SmackDown and...immediately had him feud with a tag-team. It's weird to see the writers continue that trend.

Of course, this could all be setup for Sheamus returning, which would be the best case scenario. Being honest though, Pete Dunne probs needs to move on from the Brawling Brutes idea long-term regardless. His involvement with PD (Pretty Deadly, not himself!) is fairly unnecessary.

Perhaps that's unfair. Maybe it'd be fairer to wait and see how things shake out, but yours truly is just eager to see Dunne change back to his 'Bruiserweight' ways and become a stalwart addition to the midcard. His work is watertight, and he's capable of better overall.


1. One Off Title Shot > Story?

Michin WWE
WWE.com

There's nothing wrong with a match like Michin vs. IYO SKY on paper, but that doesn't tell the full story. "Story" is actually the key word here, because Michin's sudden ascent into the title picture has none to offer - at least not right now. That didn't stop WWE from booking The OC member to pin IYO in Friday's Christmas-themed brawl.

Hmm.

Yes, Triple H is clearly lining Mia Yim up for a one-off title shot, but why bother? It isn't all that interesting without any sort of context to speak of, and it's hardly like Michin has been fleshed out as a character lately. She's barely been around at all, in fact! Was Trips possessed by the spirit of Tony Khan this week, or something?

Personally speaking (and this is only an opinion), this guy thinks it'd be better if WWE avoided beating IYO SKY completely until they've got a proper storyline reason to help frame it. Otherwise, nobody will remember Michin's big moment when she's inevitably hit with the 50/50 booking trope and loses her one-off title match.


Ups...

8. It Worked Despite Some Concerns

Butch Pete Dunne Dragon Lee
WWE.com

Dragon Lee vs. Butch came out looking like the kind of match you'd see AEW book over on Rampage. That's not necessarily a complaint, but WWE surely has to be careful when using NXT titles on the main roster. All three brands need some separation to help them feel different from one another, after all.

The match itself was nifty though.

That was expected going in, because Pete Dunne and Dragon are both superb workers capable of maximising their minutes. Both guys have shown that a few times, so it was nice to see them get approx 10 minutes here. This, hopefully, is the kind of match that WWE will return to and hand 20 minutes on PLE in the future.

It's fair to say that Butch always excels in-ring despite concerns about where his character is heading in the short-to-medium term. He's one of the most dependable workers this company has right now, and that was evident throughout this North American Title effort.

Nice, momentum boosting win for Lee too.


7. The Unholy Return

Alba Fyre Isla Dawn Kairi Sane
WWE.com

Better late than never.

That was the thought which went flooding through this fan's mind when he saw Alba Fyre and Isla Dawn return to screens on SmackDown. The pair went AWOL after shining against Ronda Rousey and Shayna Baszler over the summer, and that was a real shame. Give 'em a chance to build something, please.

Fingers crossed that's possible now the Scots are back. Alba and Isla had been talking about putting a curse on the Women's Tag-Team Titles, but that's seemingly been dropped for now in favour of a feud opposite Kairi Sane and Asuka. Or, maybe WWE will come back to that plot. Time will tell.

For now, it's just great to see the pair back on programming. Best of all, it seems Trips fancies lining up a non-title rivalry, and that's practically unheard of in the women's tag division these days. Fyre and Dawn vs. Sane and Asuka could be epic if handled correctly. This was a top start.


6. That Roman Reigns & Nick Aldis Dynamic

Roman Reigns Nick Aldis
WWE

The body language between Roman Reigns and Nick Aldis was very promising during their short sit-down discussion this week. Big fan of Roman trying to big league Aldis by dismissively pretending to Paul Heyman he doesn't know who Nick is. Then, Reigns claimed he calls the shots on SmackDown, not the GM.

Nick stood up to that and reinforced himself as a different kind of GM to Adam Pearce. That led to rising tensions between both men, but WWE smartly kept powder dry and didn't script things to boil over. Could Aldis be a future opponent for Reigns in 2024? Don't rule it out, people.

There's some chemistry, that's for sure.

The whole Bloodline saga cut its teeth in segments exactly like this one. Roman is a master of making seemingly insignificant promos mean something later on, and that causes fans to sit up and take notice of everything he does.

Great character work from both.


5. Job Done!

Kevin Owens Carmelo Hayes
WWE.com

It's been pretty obvious since the start that this United States Title contenders tournament is a vehicle to get Kevin Owens in front of Logan Paul at Royal Rumble. Being fair though, the tourney has showcased some cracking matches to date, and KO vs. Carmelo Hayes was just the latest example.

SmackDown successfully put some shine on the NXT man and pushed KO towards LP in one fell swoop. There was a fresh feeling to the bout, and it showed how ready Hayes is for the main roster. Also, and this is rather impressive, the match was taped on the same night Owens wrestled Austin Theory and Carmelo worked Grayson Waller.

Double duty was no sweat to these dudes, apparently.

Kev endorsed Hayes post-match by embracing him with a handshake, and the announcers did well to explain that Carmelo hopes to make his own splash on Raw or SmackDown soon. A match like this will stand Hayes in good stead when he eventually moves on from developmental.


4. Another Winner For This Tourney

Santos Escobar Humberto Carrillo Angel Garza
WWE.com

Santos Escobar vs. Bobby Lashley didn't disappoint either.

Arguably, it wasn't as good a match as KO vs. Hayes, but the scrap did do a hell of a lot to push Escobar's new heel run as something you must pay attention to. The ex-LWO member enlisted the aid of Humberto Carrillo and Angel Garza as his new heavies, and they helped him defeat Lashley.

Now, Santos is in the final vs. Owens and has backup in his quest to tear down Rey Mysterio's LWO. The knock-on side effect of this is that an overlooked tag (Carrillo and Garza) also has some purpose again too. Good times all round, gentlemen. It's about time the former Los Lotharios had some direction.

WWE will surely book Escobar, Humberto and Angel vs. Lashley and The Street Profits on TV over the next month or so as well. That has a cool, competitive vibe to it, but it'll be interesting to see where Bob and his own faction goes next.


3. AJ Styles Gives A Reason

AJ Styles Randy Orton LA Knight
WWE.com

He's not a perfect person. There's many things he wished he didn't do, but he continues learning. OK, who had using lyrics from Hoobastank's 'The Reason' down as a way to contextualise AJ Styles attacking LA Knight on last week's episode of SmackDown? Nobody? Not surprising.

This week's opening promo was really, really solid. Sure, it was standard WWE revolving door stuff, but all four workers involved can talk and played their roles to a tee. AJ explained that he went after Knight last week because LA capitalised on his injury to team with John Cena and thus get a crack at Roman Reigns.

That made sense, and is a valid-enough reason for the sudden ambush.

Styles is p*ssed off that someone else benefitted from his misery, basically. That led to LA and Randy Orton coming out for some chatter of their own, and GM Nick Aldis strolling out to keep the peace whilst simultaneously making a mega-match for later on.


2. A Huge Main Event Is Coming

AJ Styles Randy Orton LA Knight
WWE.com

SmackDown will get the subtitle treatment with a special 'New Year's Revolution' episode in two weeks. There, AJ Styles, Randy Orton and LA Knight will meet in a bumper triple threat to establish who wrestles Roman Reigns come Royal Rumble. That, dear readers, is a massive match.

Credit to Nick Aldis for framing it properly and making the announcement more impactful too. He delivered the news well, and the live crowd was right into the idea of seeing these headliners go at it. They'll have to wait, but that wait will be worth it in the end. This really is a colossal tussle (hope someone out there gets that!).

As the intro says, something special is brewing on the blue brand.

AJ is annoyed at LA for stealing "his" shot vs. Reigns, Knight is angry at Styles for ambushing him, and Orton is in the middle already knowing he fired out a challenge to Roman. There's a lot of meat on the bone here, and it'll come to a head in the new year.

Bring it on.


1. Shaking Off Ring Rust (And A Hot Finish!)

AJ Styles Solo Sikoa
WWE.com

AJ vs. Solo Sikoa was as hard-hitting a main event as you'd expect, but it didn't end clean. Styles got to shake off some ring rust (similar to Randy Orton vs. Jimmy Uso on last week's show), then Roman Reigns poked his nose in. That led to The Bloodline taking a powder so AJ, Orton and LA Knight could brawl.

Roman told his troops to stay back, which was smart booking. It put the spotlight on a coming three way, and avoided Reigns or his Bloodline backup taking a beating as the good guys (if Styles still is a good guy) stood tall. WWE went the more interesting route rather than than predictable one.

Everything about the match-turned-angle worked.

It's also awesome to have AJ back on TV regularly. He remains one of the best workers in the biz on his day, and he's capable of working really enjoyable matches in his sleep. Next week's SmackDown looks like a "Best Of 2023" edition, so this was WWE's last chance to add spice to the triple threat before it happens.

Mission accomplished.

What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more like this, check out 10 WWE Stars Triple H Will NEVER Use Properly and 10 Things WWE Wants You To Forget About Roman Reigns!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.