8 Ups & 5 Downs From Last Night's WWE SmackDown (10 Sept)

Chadison Square Garden.

Sami Zayn The Undertaker
WWE.com

It's all change on SmackDown soon, with the blue brand just a month away from moving back to Friday Nights, celebrating its 20th Anniversary and hopefully - for the sake of WWE's financials - doing big numbers on big new home Fox. The lingering pressure of the shift hasn't quite started to show, but some particularly potent editions of Monday Night Raw have recently left Tuesday's sister show looking a little underdone.

Heading into the second consecutive night at Madison Square Garden, WWE were hoping another powerful edition of the flagship could convince those on the fence from the local area to treat themselves to one of the many tickets still available ahead of time, not least with the promise of seeing The Undertaker in the flesh and the possibility of seeing Bray Wyatt's evil Fiend tear at that very flesh following a tantalising Firefly Fun House tease.

Or, not quite. Bray's alter-ego did dark match duties against The B-Team, presumably so fans could nod sagely about the Rotundo brothers going to war, but what else instead emerged from Tuesday's event?

Serving also as the go-home show for Sunday's Clash Of Champions, there was plenty to address before the titleholders strode into the weekend supercard, but could the company make it two for two in the 'World's Most Famous Arena?'

(Don't fret, Andy Murray will be back next week)


Downs...

5. Deadman Talking

WWE.com

What a crushing multi-pronged disappointment this was to kick off what had all the potential of being one of the most historic episodes of the show in its clunky 20-year history.

After laying the legacy of WWE's relationship with Madison Square Garden before and during the event, the company trotted The Undertaker out to...do the same and then simply f*ck off. The mere spectacle of him walking slowly to the ring is undeniably enough to pop the crowd, but why wouldn't the company and the competitor himself want something a little bit more for the night?

Stone Cold Steve Austin's captivating involvement on Raw provided the template. Bray Wyatt provided a tease. Undertaker himself - via his unbelievably entertaining Graveyard Dogs pairing with Roman Reigns earlier this year - provided a reminder of what he was still capable of between the ropes.

This episode only provided another excuse for (more literally, in this case), burying Sami Zayn. And that knackered the next segment too...


4. Silence Over Violence

WWE.com

Sami Zayn at least earned his beating from The Undertaker after a delivering a slew of decent lines towards 'The Deadman'. This wasn't an interruption on par with AJ Styles of Stone Cold Steve Austin, but 'The Underdog From The Underdog' requests to replace 'Taker were charmingly in keeping with his delusions of grandeur. As are most of his asides when working as Shinsuke Nakamura's sidekick. Which...he subsequently couldn't do because of the prior segment.

SmackDown Live's roster is loaded with warm bodies that probably a) would have enjoyed talking themselves into a sh*tkicking from The Undertaker and b) been grateful of the promo time in the 'World's Most Famous Arena', yet that role was given to Zayn exactly one segment before he was required to play the role he's worked diligently on over the past few weeks.

A man who probably wouldn't have asked for a microphone was Shinsuke Nakamura, based on the language barrier gag with Corey Graves the company had to craft. WWE's table is bullish enough without having to try and interject in a second language, but this wasn't any kind of canvas for the so-called 'Artist' to work on ahead of Sunday's tepid scrap with The Miz.


3. Something's Mizzing

Andrade The Miz
WWE.com

The Miz will take on Shinsuke Nakamura at this Sunday's Clash Of Champions to try and win a record-setting Intercontinental Title and was successful here against Andrade to set up the encounter and blah blah blah and etc and that sentence was only slightly less boring than this supposed iron-sharpener between the two.

Your writer is a Miz apologist, but this babyface run only partially works in the modern era because of the vast improvements in working style. Andrade's thrilling offering belongs beyond selling half-baked knees and kicks from an 'A-Lister' well adjusted to WWE style but not so hot with 2019 rhythms and beats.

A sloppy finish before the Skull Crushing Finale summed it up - fans weren't too bothered over the botch because they didn't have to be that bothered about the match, or the stakes, or the competitors, or 'The King Of Strong Style's post-match attack. This was Kickoff fodder on a main show, a mistake WWE hopefully don't make on Sunday.


2. No Fire, No Desire

Mandy Rose
WWE.com

A stinking turd of a promo to set up an only-slightly-less odorous match, Mandy Rose's verbal takedown of Nikki Cross was, again, an infuriating case of talented women being scripted by utterly talentless men.

In the previous segment, did The Miz want a piece of Andrade because Andrade's a piece? If he did, it certainly didn't come up in conversation. Just like how Sami Zayn didn't have a stab at The Undertaker's age as Cross' partner Mickie James did during one of their storylines.

These double standards will not do, especially considering the quality of the wrestlers being underserved here. Alexa Bliss and Nikki Cross have been tasked with restoring credibility to the Tag Team Titles, whilst Fire & Desire are comfortably the best set of challengers for said gold. But "YOU'LL NEVER LOOK LIKE ME, LOL" is what matters more to these athletes, because that's what some d*ckhead writer will always think.


1. Killing Owens

Shane McMahon Kevin Owens

What an absolute f*cking shambles.

Kevin Owens was neutered as a top babyface two weeks ago when the ravaged dog he'd recently become suddenly bowed to his master due to a $100,000 fine levied on him. Rather than rebounding from that, the 'Prizefighter' was taken out back and shot in an appalling angle that saw him kowtowing to Shane McMahon and still getting beaten up and fired (single handedly, no less) despite selling out Chad Gable and his babyface values just a few minutes earlier.

This is worse with Becky Lynch apologising to The Authority to get her WrestleMania match back only to be screwed seconds later, because Owens got the sh*t kicked out of him when he got the shaft.

Yes they're "telling stories" and "let it play out" and all that contrite cr*p, but this is a bad story being told poorly that hasn't earned the patience. Owens, just a month earlier, was a man possessed and seemingly back on track out of nowhere. Succumbing to the whims of his bosses (both on and off screen) yet again, 'KO's eventual redemption will always come with the stench of the sellout he was willing to be before he had no choice.


Ups...

8. Daydream In Blue

WWE

A very quick note on Madison Square Garden, because the company tragically isn't there enough for us to enjoy this more.

As it did on Monday Night Raw, the venue looked stunning - a beautiful, timeless theatre for WWE's theatre of conflict that couldn't be harmed by the company's strategic homogenisation of venues. That roof bathed in blue looked powerful, as did the sea of people packed in to the venue for the show.

Ticket sales weren't looking particularly strong ahead of the event, but WWE's production team as usual deserves the praise for masking the lower-than-expected turnout, particularly for the wide beauty shots of the venue that would have been criminal not to capture.


7. Canny Shanesmanship

Chad Gable Shane McMahon
WWE

The unfortunate news of Elias' injury snuck through hours before the show, though the strumming irritant will hopefully be able to appear on TV in his talk-heavy role despite the ankle damage. Performing as SmackDown's Baron Corbin in the King Of The Ring thus far, his in-ring work as been atypically rewarding, making this unexpected exit more of a sucker punch than it once might have been.

In an act far more satisfying than that laboured pun in the title of this entry, Shane McMahon inserting himself into the King Of The Ring semi-final was a logical bit of booking from the company for a character that has some previous with this sort of sh*t before.

The controversial Crown Jewel World Cup kickstarted Shane's heel turn late last year when 'The Money' strolled into action as the latest possible replacement for finalist The Miz. As an arrogant, braggadocious bully authority figure (who'd later hatch a plan to try and cruise to the final), McMahon was - for a welcome change - the right replacement for the injured star.


6. Blue Moon

Ember Moon Bayley

This useful backstage meeting between recent rivals Bayley and Ember Moon spoke both to the SummerSlam programme and Bayley's character shift.

A total shift from the wretched Mandy Rose/Nikki Cross verbiage earlier in the night, this made continued effort to explain the motivation behind Bayley's recent turn, worked on ensuring Moon wasn't the total loser she was presented as earlier this year, and teed up their clash later in the night as something more than match for a match's sake.

Efficient Sports Entertainment television, the acting wasn't great but the content was. Both female leagues have thus far benefitted from Bayley's switch, and segments and setups like this only highlight why the Four Horsewomen should always be the still points in the divisions' turning worlds.


5. The World's Most Famous Caterpillar

WWE.com

Heavy Machinery's squash win over the luckiest local goobers in wrestling was joyous for more than just the two jobbers gifted the opportunity of examining the Madison Square Garden ceiling.

Otis' Caterpillar was perhaps the most over incarnation yet - the fans popped huge for the mini-monster popping out of his top and slip-sliding across the mat, all soundtracked to Corey Graves' typical disgust.

Knocking around the nerds before sealing the deal with the Compactor, much to the joy of the New York crowd. They should donate half of their payslips to Daniel Bryan for becoming such a relevant pair of sh*kickers on the blue brand - months of working those matches earlier this year still look good on the directionless duo.


4. Erick Roman

Erick Rowan Roman Reigns
WWE.com

A worthy effort to rebadge Erick Rowan as a misunderstood misanthrope during a p*ssed off promo was thankfully interrupted by Roman Reigns

Rowan was creeping close to an "each and every one of you" spiel before 'The Big Dog' finally appeared and the pair kicked the f*ck out of each other in a wild arena-wide brawl. Chucking a planted fan at security was slightly silly, but it didn't take away from the heat that has thankfully peaked at just the right time.

An angle that has, at times, been absolutely p*sspoor might yet yield a decent match at Clash Of Champions, and even better ones when Daniel Bryan interjects. As a teaser for the carnage still to come, this was the best thing either have been involved with since the start of the angle.


3. Ten! Ten! Ten?

Bayley Charlotte Flair

"Bayley has never beaten me without Sasha Banks" was a fairly succinct summary from Charlotte Flair ahead of 'The Hugger's match with Ember Moon built from their hostilities earlier in the night. Her overriding sentiment was as clear as her intention to take back the SmackDown Women's Championship on Sunday, but the heel titleholder clearly offers a substantially different proposition than before.

Bayley's work again subtly reflected her shift, much as it had done in the fabulous Four Horsewomen tag team match 24 hours earlier. Replacing confidence with cockiness and working like a jerk with a smirk throughout, she's rapidly taken to the role, including the timing of how she backed off from Flair in a post-match confrontation.

Enjoyable Clash Of Champions go-home fodder much like the segment that set it up, this couldn't have been further away from the build for the Tag Team Title feud.


2. Re-Living The Dream

Randy Orton Kofi Kingston
WWE.com

This segment - and the wood-smashing payoff - was always the one saving grace of the Kofi Kingston/Randy Orton feud continuing on past the dreadfully dull SummerSlam match.

Before The New Day changed the lives of all three members, Kingston's 2009 Madison Square Garden attack on 'The Viper' looked for many years like it would be the high point of his career. Orton's "the two things you've done in the last ten years" line was a killer set-up to his character assassination of Kingston that played on this. The WWE Champion heading out to face Orton head-on in an enjoyable retread of their famous former brawl was the only natural outcome.

Fair play to the pair for not panicking when the table appeared to break early in the pre-bump brawl, too. Using the second without worrying for the fallen first, the duo pulled off the planned spot perfectly as a last visual before their Clash Of Champions contest.


1. A Break In Chadition

Chad Gable Shane McMahon
WWE.com

Perfect booking for the brilliant Chad Gable at very least, the King Of The Ring final serviced the tournament, if not the others in the match with the finalist.

An exceptional worker and believable babyface, Baron Corbin Vs Chad Gable was the payoff fans had been permitted to crave thanks to the separate stories of both men's trials and tribulations throughout the tournament, and the former American Alpha man can hopefully deliver the best of Baron's bangers from the last month when the two square off on Raw next week.

Bumping the final from the pay-per-view robs both of their Sunday showcase, but that might prove to be for the best - an (as of writing) 11-match card threatened to overwhelm the pair compared to the spotlight they'll receive on what should be the main event of the flagship show. King Of The Ring 2019, somehow, continues to be one of the best ever iterations of the show.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.