8 Ups & 5 Downs From WWE Raw (18 Sept - Results & Review)
Jey rejects Judgment Day, McIntyre's slow burn, Rollins loses his mind.
Raw on Monday night was a great example of WWE doing a lot of little things right, nailing a couple of big things, and still managing to light a couple of dumpster fires along the way.
The World Heavyweight Championship feud between Seth Rollins and Shinsuke Nakamura is careening off the rails, with the champ giving deranged promos while selling an injured back that still doesn’t prevent him from flying around the ring like normal. Rollins claiming to lose control Monday night was high comedy as they’ve completely lost the thread on a once-promising title feud.
On the flip side, everything surrounding Jey Uso seemed to click Monday night, with his presence triggering strong emotions among wrestlers wronged by the Bloodline through the years, most notably Kevin Owens and Drew McIntyre. Both men are deep into their feelings on this one and reacting strongly, slowly losing their grip on normalcy and pushing back against others.
The highlight for Raw has to be the surprisingly incredible match between Kofi Kingston and Ivar, as two tag wrestlers had a fun, energetic battle that did more to spark interest in their tag feud than anything else has to this point. Just a joy to watch as it ramped up and hit a fever pitch.
Let’s get to it…
DOWNS…
5. Back-To-Back DQs
It’s one thing to watch a match that drags on for nearly 15 minutes before an unsatisfying end, but a self-inflicted disqualification is about the dumbest finish imaginable.
Ricochet and Shinsuke Nakamura were having what could best be described as a “gentleman’s three,” a perfectly acceptable wrestling match that will be forgotten in a week’s time, when the action spilled to the outside. Nakamura grabbed a chair and swung wildly and missed.
Then Ricochet grabbed the chair, looked around and waffled Shinsuke, causing the DQ after nearly 15 minutes of action. Worse, Ricochet then started arguing with the referee for disqualifying him (which led to Nakamura sneaking up and attacking him), as if there was a justification for using the chair.
The very next match was the women’s tag match that ended after about five minutes of action when Nia Jax attacked everyone, causing another DQ. While it was a different type of disqualification, it still was poor placement, and nearly 20 minutes of in-ring action was rendered moot.
This wasn’t a high crime or misdemeanour, but it still felt like a booking misfire.
4. Another Opportunity For Nattie
Becky Lynch seemed poised to give young, hungry superstars an opportunity at her newly won NXT Women’s Championship Monday night… and then Natalya came out and accepted the challenge.
Absolutely nothing personal against Natalya, but the minute her music hit, it was Eyeroll City. Becky talked about NXT representing the future, hope and passion… so a 15-year WWE veteran tromped out to take the first defense.
While that in itself can be a storyline, Nattie hasn’t exactly been someone fans have gravitated toward, either as a face or a heel. In fact, it’s difficult to tell week to week whether she’s supposed to be cheered or booed, so fans typically do neither.
Natalya complained about how hard she’s worked and that she deserves a chance, which was her third title match in the past four months.
And then she lost clean and sat distraught in the corner. Surely, this will lead to some deep and meaningful character introspection that will be the evolution Nattie has long needed to freshen up her image.
You always hope to be wrong about this, but 15 years of history tells you otherwise.
3. A Deranged Promo
There’s more to say about the overall World Heavyweight Championship feud in a bit, but Seth Rollins’ backstage promo later in the show was comically bad.
It was bad enough that Seth was wearing ridiculous sunglasses as he was trying to portray how seriously hurt he was, limping along and holding onto surfaces as he gingerly walked through the halls. But Rollins’ “acting” as he said he was losing his mind and that Shinsuke Nakamura was pushing him to a place he didn’t want to go was abysmal stuff.
Sure, the goal here was to show that the champ had lost control of himself and now was especially vulnerable, both physically and mentally. But Seth has always been an emotional, goofy, fiery individual. He’s not some cool, collected and calculating machine.
Had this been Gunther getting pissed and venting about losing control, it would be believable because he’s almost always in control of his emotions. But Rollins wears his feelings on his sleeve, so this was just bad acting, not character development.
2. Still A Bridesmaid
That high-profile SummerSlam match against Logan Paul sure elevated Ricochet to a new level in WWE, didn’t it? From jobbing to a talented part-timer to getting laid out by the next sacrificial lamb to Seth Rollins.
Ricochet can say all he likes in his pre-match promo that he’s “nobody’s pawn,” but then he goes out and becomes a pawn in Shinsuke Nakamura’s “mindgames” with Seth Rollins, thereby making him both a liar and a dope simultaneously.
And WWE wonders why people like Ricochet can’t truly get over despite being insanely talented.
How are fans supposed to receive the One and Only when he loses to a guy who’s had fewer than 10 matches, then disappears from TV for a month, only to resurface and become Nakamura’s punching bag as Shinsuke goads his true target, the world champion?
Ricochet has all the trappings of a geek, no matter how amazing he is in the ring, and fans will receive him in that manner. He deserves better, and one can only keep hoping for better for him.
1. Still Doesn’t Correct Past Mistakes
The Shinsuke Nakamura/Seth Rollins feud started with so much promise, and then it all went off the rails at Payback when Nakamura lost clean as a sheet in a mediocre match.
Then it continued to careen into the ditch with Shinsuke “playing mind games” by refusing to take advantage of an injured Rollins and accept his challenges for the World Heavyweight Championship, demurring multiple times.
Monday, Nakamura taunted Rollins and eventually goaded him into a fight where his back was knackered once again. The premise here seems to be that Nakamura wants to injure the champ more before a rematch… because that worked so well the first time.
The problem here is that they’ve employed this exact scenario just last month, and while Rollins sold the back for much of their title match, he just shrugged it off several times to hit his usual offense before pulling out the win with a surprise stomp.
WWE has lost the thread with this rivalry, spinning their wheels in their second month of the same plot: Rollins’ back is wrecked, but not enough that he can’t pull out a mid-match Phoenix Splash for a Shocked Face Kickout.
UPS…
8. Sure, Why Not?
With Chad Gable losing Monday night, there was an open spot for Gunther’s next challenger for the Intercontinental Championship.
And Tommaso Ciampa has entered the chat.
Ciampa toppled Giovanni Vinci Monday night, tapping him out to make a statement to the Ring General that he should be next up for a title match. While Tommaso hasn’t exactly boasted a strong presence on WWE programming, he’s at least been very clear that he is making a statement to force an opportunity, hence why he stepped up to back up Alpha Academy last week.
Interjecting himself into Imperium’s orbit was a clearly calculated move on Ciampa’s part, and Monday was the next phase of that strategy. It seems that he will continue to press the issue until Gunter grants him a title match, which could be a really fun, hard-hitting contest.
Even if it’s just a one-month diversion for everyone, it certainly beats being Miz’s understudy or just sitting in catering.
7. Never A Dull Moment
There’s a non-zero chance that Nia Jax’s return will eventually blow up in some fashion – someone will get injured, fans will tune out, diminishing returns or some other consequence.
But the ride should be anything but boring, and that’s enough to warrant an “up” here.
Jax laid out the WWE Women’s Tag Team Champions and their opponents, Shayna Baszler and Zoey Stark, on Raw Monday night, putting the women’s division on notice. That’s a total of six women flattened at Nia’s hands in two weeks, and all of them are featured players (it’s not like she attacked Tegan Nox and Xia Li in the middle of a random match).
It’s unclear why they feel the need to have a known quantity like Jax squash numerous talent to get across she’s a threat – that should already be established just by her previous run with WWE. But watching her steamroll women in her haphazard way is both legit terrifying and perversely entertaining.
It might all fall apart in the next week or so and Nia dominates the “downs” for the rest of her stay. But those who crave chaos should be pleased regardless.
6. Chelsea Plays Her Part To Perfection
Top hats off for Chelsea Green, who has perfected her brand of comic relief.
One-half of the WWE Women’s Tag Team Champions, Green has found a way to strike a balance between her “Karen” character, a vain champion, and an actual competitor.
Monday, Chelsea tried to sell herself and partner Piper Niven as best friends, which fell apart when she guessed the Scot hailed from England, Ireland and then Florida. Their tag match against Shayna Baszler & Zoey Stark saw Green absorb a ton of punishment from both, but also dish out some offense, looking proud of herself every time she connected with a kick or missile dropkick.
It was a fun performance from the tag champ Monday night, right up until Nia Jax squashed her.
Say what you will, but Green has figured out the cheat code for being entertaining. There’s no denying that she commands your attention when she’s onscreen, whether she’s complaining to Adam Pearce, verbally flailing about with Piper, or getting abused in the ring.
5. Trust The Process
The knee-jerk reaction to Chad Gable losing cleanly to Bronson Reed would be to scream at the television that Vince McMahon has clearly grabbed the reins and is wondering why Shorty G is getting so much TV time.
But WWE and their fans have invested a lot into Gable in recent months, with the company telling some good stories with the former Olympian, so it’s only fair to grant them some leeway.
Gable was overmatched by the much bigger Reed, failing to suplex him as he promised, then getting squashed by a Tsunami splash. But this was far from a squash match.
Having faith in WWE to not abandon a midcard push that was really working is difficult after years of being burned, but it would be a bit rash to give in to histrionics after one week. Trust the process and see where the story leads in the coming weeks as Gable tries to find his way back to Gunther and the Intercontinental Championship.
4. A Reasonable Conversation
Professional wrestling is not known for characters having rational, reasonable discussions about issues much like the average person has out in the real world.
That’s why it might have seemed a bit jarring Monday night when Kevin Owens had a heart-to-heart with Cody Rhodes and Sami Zayn about his displeasure surrounding Jey Uso being brought to Raw. KO laid out his gripes in very real, logical terms, and Cody and Sami responded politely as to why they were giving Jey a second chance.
Owens gave a great rant about forgetting about all the times Jey and the rest of the Bloodline cost all three of them title matches against Roman Reigns, justifying his distrust of Main Event Jey. But he said he trusted Cody and Sami, so that was enough for him.
This slow burn of a breakdown between babyfaces has some serious potential if handled correctly, and it’s far better than just having KO flip out and turn on his friends. Fans have invested in these characters because of how well-formed and three-dimensional they are. It’s nice to see WWE continuing to treat them as such when it would be so easy for them to give in to tropes and paper-thin characterizations.
Whether they follow through on this start remains to be seen.
3. Jey Turns Down The Judgment Day
It wouldn’t have made much sense to have Jey Uso turn on Roman Reigns and his family just to join another heel stable, but WWE certainly cast as much doubt as possible in the lead-up to Monday night’s climax.
Since arriving on Raw, Jey has faced a lot of criticism, harsh words and dirty looks from wrestlers he wronged as part of the Bloodline, isolating the former tag champion. Then he had Judgment Day making overtures toward him about joining their ranks, because there’s safety in numbers. And credit to WWE, if Jey accepted the offer, it would have been a logical move on his part given everything he had faced to date on Raw.
But Uso rejected the purple warriors with a trio of superkicks Monday night, giving Damian Priest his answer with a sneaker to the face. That didn’t stop him from eating a Claymore to lose the main event against Drew McIntyre and then suffer a three-on-one beatdown, but he at least made his decision clear.
While Drew didn’t see fit to save a man who once battered him with a chair, Cody Rhodes proved to be Jey’s only friend in the building, making the save. That also was a nice little piece of the story, with Rhodes going out of his way to bring Uso to Raw, then sticking up for him.
The question is, will Jey return that favour when it counts most?
2. Drew’s Slow Burn
Drew McIntyre has been long overdue for a character shift of some sort, whether that’s a heel turn or an edge he hasn’t had for some time.
Seeing him lose his cool multiple times, grow frustrated with those around him, and seethe at a former rival being welcomed to Raw with open arms has been an enjoyable arc, as you can feel the Scottish Warrior becoming increasingly angry at his situation. It seems like he’s getting closer to blowing his stack on someone, and not just with an errant chair toss like he did to Xavier Woods several weeks ago.
Monday, McIntyre defeated Jey Uso after Jey had super-kicked the entire Judgment Day off the apron. But when Uso was facing a 3-on-1 beatdown, the heroic Scot couldn’t bring himself to save a man who cost him title matches and attacked him as part of the Bloodline. He certainly seemed torn, but ultimately McIntyre decided to walk away rather than help.
Inaction will eventually give way to action, and that’s when things will really shift for McIntyre. For now though, he’s certainly on a path away from the Drew fans have known for the past several years.
1. Tag Wrestlers Shine In Singles Match
Whether Erik’s injury was real or not, the decision to kibosh a two-out-of-three-falls match an instead do a Kofi Kingston/Ivar singles match might have been the best thing that could have happened to this flagging rivalry.
New Day and Viking Raiders have been embroiled in a mostly forgettable feud that sometimes has involved Drew McIntyre & Matt Riddle, with the three-team squabble seemingly serving more as a vehicle for a McIntyre heel turn. A 2/3 falls match between the two long-established teams seemed a bit lacking.
Instead, Kofi and Ivar tangled in a one-on-one bout that started slowly and ramped up into a frenzied slugfest, with the former world champion standing toe-to-toe with the much bigger Viking. The two executed a fantastic series with Ivar ducking a Trouble in Paradise, Kofi ducking a spinkick, and Ivar blocking an SOS and hitting a butterfly powerbomb for a near-fall.
Ivar pulled out a moonsault for another close 2 count before Kofi nailed a sunset powerbomb and Trouble in Paradise for the win. If anything, this battle made the eventual tag match more intriguing rather than just tossing it on TV and letting fans sit on their hands until the final three minutes.
Of course, that still could happen, but at least fans got a fantastic singles match out of it, one that easily was the highlight of the night.