8 Ups And 2 Downs From NXT TakeOver: New Orleans

NXT sets the bar really, really high with outstanding action.

ciampa gargano
WWE.com

The wrestling portion of WrestleMania weekend kicked off Saturday night, and the show might have been stolen already.

NXT TakeOver: New Orleans delivered an absolutely phenomenal show that has already garnered talk about being the best TakeOver special yet. If you weren’t entertained and didn’t like this show, you probably should crawl back under your rock and stay there. The worst match of the night was above average, while three of them were in the “great” range.

The centerpiece to TakeOver was of course the culmination of the long-simmering feud between Johnny Gargano and Tommaso Ciampa, a rivalry that began nearly a year ago. Ciampa had since cost Johnny a title match and his job at NXT, and Saturday’s match was his last chance to win back employment and exact revenge on his former tag partner.

The other four matches were title bouts, including a ladder match for the new North American Championship, which also served as introductions to two new NXT superstars, the debuting Ricochet and the returning/re-debuting EC3. That contest delivered several memorable moments, and nearly stole the show.

If you missed this show, watch it. There’s no excuse.

With that said, let’s count the ways this was awesome. Let’s get to it…


Downs...

2. Wasting Time

Bands playing a wrestler’s entrance music and accompanying them down to ringside are cool. Bands playing mini-concerts during the PPV to drag out the running time are not.

NXT misfired by having Cane Hill open TakeOver: New Orleans with a performance. It isn’t that the song was bad – though it wasn’t this writer’s favorite genre – it’s that you turn on the PPV at a certain time, and instead of getting a match, you have to sit through a performance that means nothing to you.

If Led Zeppelin reunites with Jason Bonham playing drums and they want to open a PPV with “Black Dog,” then let’s do it. But sticking a band out there to open the show… it just wasn’t a great way to fire up this fan. Sorry.


1. Find A Better Intro

damo ec3
WWE.com

Let’s make sure this is clear: EC3 did nothing wrong in his re-debut in NXT at TakeOver. He performed well, and looks like a major star poised to do big things this time around.

However, it really stinks that EC3’s big return match in NXT was in a six-man ladder match that he didn’t win. And while that shouldn’t be the deciding factor in whether it was a successful return, EC3 didn’t really do anything to stand out during the match, unlike the debuting Ricochet, who had numerous moments that sent fans into a frenzy. Others like Velveteen Dream and Killian Dain also had a couple standout moments.

Simply put, EC3’s return match should have meant a little more or at least had more focus on him or his skills. Instead, he was just part of the mix. It shouldn’t hurt him, but neither did it help him.


Ups...

8. Rise Of The Heel Manager

zelina vega
WWE.com

There was a time when the heel manager was everything in wrestling. Having a person on the outside who would distract your opponent and get physically involved was a big part of a wrestler’s success.

Zelina Vega made a case for being dubbed a top-class heel manager Saturday, interfering at will during the NXT Championship match. She hit two hurricanranas on Aleister Black behind the referee’s back, saved Andrade “Cien” Almas by putting his foot on the ropes after a Black Mass spinkick, and distracted Black a couple times.

And in true heel manager fashion, she got her comeuppance when she dove off the top and hit Almas instead, allowing Black to finish him off and win the title.

If Vega and Almas are headed to the main roster after WrestleMania, you’ve got to hope that they keep them together and keep this act going the way it is, because they’re clicking really well.


7. ‘F*** You Ciampa!’

Ciampa NXT
WWE.com

When you can get fans to chant that at you just by walking to the ring, you’ve done something right.

Tommaso Ciampa embraced being Public Enemy #1 on Saturday, doing everything he could to get booed even worse during his match against Johnny Gargano. Ciampa was a jerk throughout the entire bout, kicking Gargano low, gouging his eyes to break the Gargano Escape, and kicking Johnny in the back of the head repeatedly.

Ciampa looked and acted like a massive villain in this match. While a large chunk of the hatred stemmed from the Ciampa/Gargano rivalry, you’ve got to wonder if it could carry over beyond this feud.

Still, what awesome, off-the-charts heel heat.


6. Ricochet Doesn’t Disappoint

ricochet ladder
WWE.com

Those of us who have heard of but seen very little of Ricochet were hoping to see glimpses this Saturday of what made the high-flier so celebrated in the ring.

We weren’t disappointed.

Ricochet was one of the six men vying for the new NXT North American Championship in a ladder match, and he immediately showed off his skillset, hitting a springboard shooting star press to the floor on Killian Dain and Lars Sullivan. From there, he continued to fly around the ring. At one point, Sullivan tipped a ladder Ricochet was climbing, so Ricochet simply moonsaulted off it to the floor, taking out Adam Cole and Dain.

While Ricochet didn’t capture gold on his first night in the company, he made a huge impression with fans, and hopefully he will get off and running in NXT proper soon enough.


5. Baszler Impresses In Title Bout

ember moon shayna baszler
WWE.com

After being less than impressed by Shayna Baszler in her first NXT Women’s Championship match, this writer has to give credit to the Queen of Spades after her turn in Saturday’s title bout.

Baszler overcame a (storyline) possible separated shoulder to beat Ember Moon and capture the title in a fierce and full-speed match. Whereas Baszler looked somewhat limited and one-dimensional before (a former MMA fighter striking and looking for submissions), she was forced to show pain and fight from underneath a little after a hyper-aggressive Moon stomped her arm and attacked her nonstop.

In the end, the Queen of Spades managed to lock in the Kirifuda Clutch, holding it until Ember passed out. Hopefully, Baszler will continue to show different facets of her abilities going forward.


4. Fade To Black

aleister black andrade cien almas
WWE.com

Let’s give some love to Andrade “Cien” Almas and Aleister Black. If they had been performing at almost any other PPV, their NXT Championship match would have been the talk of the night. But they had to compete with a ladder match and a bitter blood feud.

Still, Almas and Black had a pretty damn good match, one that did not take a pause the entire way and featured some serious strikes back and forth. Almas really has come into his own as a main-event heel, while Black managed to balance playing the cool, calm Dutch Destroyer while also having to battle through the pain his opponent inflicted.

Almas had some callbacks to previous matches, which were nice touches, and he had fans buying some false finishes. He relied on his manager/valet to give him the advantage, but he showed he was capable of hanging with his challenger. Black was crisp and had the fans behind him.

Really good match from the two, and hopefully great things are in store for both in the next phases of their careers.


3. Roddy Shocks The System

roderick strong nxt
WWE.com

Being a white meat babyface is boring. It’s so much more fun to be a villain.

Roderick Strong figured that out Saturday, turning on tag partner Pete Dunne to help (and then join) the Undisputed Era retain the NXT Tag Team Championship and capture the Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic.

There surely will be an opportunity for Strong to explain himself on a future episode of NXT, but the simple answer has got to be that he was tired of it being “Roddy versus the world.” Eventually, that wears on you, and if you want to be a champion, it helps to be with people who have your back.

Additionally, Strong fills the gap in the Undisputed Era created by Bobby Fish’s injury, so that helps as well. Plus, it could turn the heelish (but fan favorite) Pete Dunne into a bigger hero to fans.


2. Ladder Match Sets The Bar

ladder nxt
WWE.com

Ho. Lee. Crap.

Superkick parties. Purple Rainmakers galore. Vader Bombs on ladders. Multi-man car-crashes through them.

The North American Championship ladder match was a nonstop frenzy that highlighted all six men involved and still managed to look like organized chaos. As mentioned earlier, Ricochet shined in the match, as did Velveteen Dream, who hit a Purple Rainmaker off the top of a ladder onto Lars Sullivan.

In the end, it was Adam Cole capturing the title and becoming the first North American Champion. But everyone earned their pay in this match.


1. Gargano, Ciampa Raise The Bar

ciampa gargano
WWE.com

As great as the opening ladder match was, Johnny Gargano and Tommaso Ciampa blew right past it with their main event war.

The feud between the two has been perfectly executed, as Gargano is the extremely likable hero, and Ciampa is the despicable villain who turned on his friend and cost him a title match and his career.

Fans were absolutely molten during the entire match, with Ciampa brutally attacking Johnny Wrestling over and over, using cheap tactics to gain control, trying to suplex him onto exposed concrete, and using crutches to batter his former tag partner. He mocked Gargano and their former DIY finisher along the way, just to tweak the fans even more.

They had numerous near-falls, including a Project Ciampa from the second rope that had fans believing that Gargano’s career was over. Johnny also had several near-falls of his own, including a series of superkicks after lawn-darting Tommaso into an exposed turnbuckle.

The ending of the match was brilliant, as a battered Ciampa basically begged off, and Gargano went to sit next to his former friend. Sensing it, Gargano ducked an attack with Tommaso’s knee brace and locked Ciampa in an STF using the brace for the tapout.

WrestleMania, good luck topping this one.


Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.