8 Weirdest Wrestling Matches From Every Major Promotion
Allow the talent to move, people, we cannot stress that enough.
It's been A Year for deeply weird match graphics.
When the King Of The Ring tournament commenced, did you expect a Shane McMahon vs. Chad Gable semi-final? Probably not, since Shane wasn't scheduled for the tournament, and the last time he entered one, unannounced and at the last minute, everybody absolutely hated it. And not in a 'Heel Heat 101' way, but a 'Perhaps it's time I moved on with my life' sort of way.
When the King Of The Ring tournament ended, did you expect a Baron Corbin vs. Chad Gable match graphic? Most certainly, since uninspired rematches are mandatory - but did you expect a Baron Corbin vs. Shorty Gable match graphic? Probably, since expectations are so low that if CM Punk were to come back, he'd steal one from Bobby Lashley two weeks into his three week push. Every match was a Two out of Three falls match for a while. Alicia Fox was chosen to go 50/50 with Becky Lynch weeks after her major 'Mania Moment. Alicia Fox.
Is 2019 the weirdest year even in WWE's batsh*t history? Paul Heyman has a degree of creative control on RAW (!) and it's even more of a soap opera (!).
Competition is fierce, within its own history and beyond...
*"Major" here is classed as those traditionally considered by such by the WhatCulture readership.
8. NXT: The Authors Of Pain Vs. TM-61 - TakeOver: Toronto Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic Final
NXT is such thrilling tonic at its best because it isn't sports entertainment.
This part of its appeal doesn't feel like it's there anymore, for several reasons, but the NXT of 2016 felt vital. It was so drastically different from and superior to the main roster and, because the main roster once dominated the conversation in totality before the Elite changed everything, it was the escape. And then, because WWE went shark cage batsh*t around the same time, the territory-influenced Triple H, in order to pay tribute to the Last Battle of Atlanta, had to borrow a toy Vince McMahon only bought to trigger Enzo Amore's acrophobia.
"I'm a vile piece of sh*t, and you can't teach that. And this right here? This is Kevin Dunn, and his teeth are seven foot tall, and you can't teach that. And this right here? This is Stephanie McMahon, and she's hot as hell, and you can't teach that. Bada boom, highest guy in the room: how you doin'?"
The Authors' manager Paul Ellering was suspended above the ring to prevent him from interfering, even though he was mostly an American mouthpiece used to connect Akam and Rezar to American crowds. Akam and Rezar deceptively caught Shane Thorne's massive dive from the base of what was an IRL toy set - this being NXT, that was weird, too - and when Ellering threw down a chain to assist his men, that chain didn't play into the story of the match at all.
Genuinely, it was as if an actual child with no attention span had laid this thing out with the actual toy.
7. Ring Of Honor - Rush Vs. PCO - Final Battle 2019
Ring Of Honor is a company without identity in 2019.
Much like 2001 ECW, the ideas it was built on have been subsumed by the mainstream, the talent that built it have transcended it, and the company is in the midst of a death spiral from which there is no escape. Moreover, the complexion of the roster is very strange, comprised as it is of enduring veterans and enterprising rising stars who are using ROH to increase their value by signing lucrative one year deals.
All of which led to the bizarre main event of this year's Final Battle, pitting twilight-years madman PCO against lucha libre standout Rush for a Championship that once, so gloriously, lived up to its name of determining the best wrestler in the world.
At one point, as he tends to die quite often, PCO died. He was recharged by a car battery, and, alive once more, choke-slammed Rush onto the bonnet of the hearse. Both incidents were sold with about the same conviction, rendering the entire spectacle a farce. It was difficult to receive it as even that, because the pace was so plodding, the clash of styles so incongruous, the brawling even less convincing than the gimmickry.
It was a nice moment for the legendary PCO, but that's what a celebratory WrestleMania Weekend match is for: here, ROH leveraged their future on a niche veteran, and no car battery can jolt it back into existence.
6. Reverse Battle Royal - TNA/IMPACT Wrestling, 24 October 2006
Bro.
Bro.
Battle Royals are boring. bro. Bro: what if we do it in reverse, bro?
That was the extent of Vince Russo's pitifully on-brand thought process. With the Reverse Battle Royal, his hatred of pro wrestling manifested as doing literally the opposite of it, and the gaping plot hole didn't pass through the narcissistic recesses of his mind, because bro: why didn't they just sprint into the ring?
The objective, initially, before the Match Beyond Sense, was to actually enter the ring. Seems easy enough: simply gather the requisite momentum, and slide right into the sucker, as evidenced via run-in on virtually every pro wrestling event ever promoted. But here, the TNA roster had trouble. The idea was to subdue the opponent before getting in, which necessitated a mass brawl, but this being TNA, it was coordinated terribly; at various points, some wrestlers, actively looking to not win, apparently, just stood without a clue at ringside, looking to exchange half-hearted punches with their fellow entrants. At this and indeed most points, they could have just won by walking up to and climbing through a rope. Russo is fond of telling his base that the wrestlers of today are too busy memorising their spots to get over with the crowd in the throes of a naturalistic performance. None of them got over here because they couldn't get over the middle f*cking rope, something that didn't even vex Kelly Kelly or Giant Gonzalez.
The Reverse Battle Royal was a running race that - swerve! - nobody ran.
5. ECW: Ric Flair Vs. The Big Show - July 11 2006
The early days of ECW yielded some bizarre matches one wouldn't expect to see from the promotion, but it literally wasn't the same promotion; it was Eastern Championship Wrestling, the temporary home of the out-of-work, abandoned traveller.
As the real ECW, the company promoted itself as the antithesis of the mainstream by putting on blood, guts, and internationally-flavoured "workrate" bouts, drawing in the process the ire of several old school vanguards.
Ric Flair loathed Mick Foley's influence on the game, at King Of The Ring 1998, but less than a decade later, as WWE revived the league as a soulless exercise in proto-super-served-content, Flair's declining profile saw him hypocritically flail around in thumb tacks and scrape the Big Show's head with barbed wire.
And it was awesome: amid the jumbled mess of ideas and philosophy that was WWE in 2006, Flair and Show underpinned their blood-and-guts sideshow with classic, building storytelling; Show made Flair bleed, and Flair, older and frailer, timed his comeback to typical perfection. Even his chops couldn't compete, and so, with his skills deserted, he fired back from being swatted aside, with a barbed wire baseball bat and steel chair shots, in a wild, weird match with genuine drama, pathos and logic powering them over the line.
4. WCW: The Mega Powers Vs. The Alliance To End Hulkamania - Uncensored 1996
This is more intimidating than starting an undergraduate dissertation. WCW normalised Pole matches, for f*ck's sake.
Really, the weirdest, most off-brand match in WCW canon was Bret Hart vs. Chris Benoit's tribute to Owen Hart on 4 October 1999; a raw, technical powerhouse of a match with volleying, grief-driven stiffness, it took place deep into the inexorable LOLWCW period, but for 27 emotional, masterful minutes, Hart and Benoit operated beyond and transcended the chaos.
But really, the weirdest match in WCW history was probably the one with the multiple cages, frying pans and Arn Anderson-as-mystical ninja. Hulk Hogan and Randy Savage faced the 'Alliance To End Hulkamania' - comprised of the Dungeon of Doom and some erstwhile Four Horsemen, who were somehow the Beaver Boys to the Dark Order in this scenario - at Uncensored 1996. Flair and Anderson applied stereo leg locks to our intrepid heroes, but nobody reacted, because they were looking at a still image in almost complete darkness. The dynamic, production, performances: everything was super super, sh*tty, and that's before Hogan attempted to kill Kevin Sullivan and a jobbing actor outranked the greatest professional wrestler of all time.
In the end, The Booty Man arrived on the scene to even the odds - it was now eight versus three (!) - by handing out frying pans for use as weapons. Lex Luger used a weighted glove to hit Randy Savage. Savage ducked, but Luger didn't "accidentally" hit Flair.
He paused, and did it anyway, presumably as confused as every f*cker else.
3. NJPW: Antonio Inoki Vs. Masa Saito - Ganryujima Death Match, 1987
It hasn't happened yet, but Jushin 'Thunder' Liger's first retirement match is wild.
Set for 4 January 2020, the combined age of Liger's four-man squadron is 217. 65 of those years were accumulated by the legend Tatsumi Fujinami, a man who is 19 years older than the promotion. It's going to be an absurdly heated and emotional smoke and mirrors masterclass, in which the sprightly Ryusuke Taguchi will take a dragon suplex from a grandad received as a God, but yes. It's nuttier than Daniel Bryan's sh*t.
What has already happened is the Ganryujima Island Death match between company founder Antonio Inoki and Masa Saito. Indebted to Japanese folklore, and promoted as the ultimate, only battleground brutal enough to bring their violent blood feud to an end, prior to it, Inoki and Saito had smashed one another's faces into jelly in absorbing spectacles, which this absolutely was not. It was 'the 'Mania XII Iron Man match, only slightly less tedious, and grapple-f*cked on a field.
There might be some decent action in the middle - people have only pretended to watch it in full, so we'll never, ever know - but in the end, Inoki threw Saito into some fire.
Boring bullsh*t + lots of nothingness = fire, WWE later borrowed the formula for SummerSlam 2013.
2. AEW: Casino Battle Royale - Double Or Nothing
The Michael Nakazawa vs. Jebailey match was at least halfway excusable: it was a sweetener to the money mark AEW partnered with that serviced that particular crowd, even if it was the most dark match to ever dark match.
The Casino Battle Royal was the first official AEW match, if not the first canonical AEW match, and it was a beyond bizarre choice: Cody has sold the promotion as a wrestling "buffet", but this was a pure comedy match that falsely advertised the premise of AEW on the free-to-air pre-show ahead of its first-ever pay-per-view. Elements of it were incredibly entertaining, and it was a successful star vehicle for MJF, who of course battered bilateral amputee Dustin Thomas immediately.
This was an inspired ghoul-pop, but that same bilateral amputee eliminated Cody's next big show opponent Shawn Spears, 55 year-old Glacier was in it, the inclusion of Sunny Daze was Garrett Bischoff-level nepotism, Michael Nakazawa smothered himself in baby oil, and Tommy Dreamer ran through his old E-C-Dub bit years after his TNA runs invited widespread this f*cking guy scorn.
Ultimately, it didn't affect the buy rate, nor the company's impressive TV launch, nor the prestige of Chris Jericho's AEW World Championship - but this was cheeky. If this match was a Tinder profile pic, AEW made itself look like a d*ck pic-sending creep, as opposed to a handsome bastard with cheekbones to die for.
Less Cody, and more James Ellsworth.
1. WWE: The Undertaker Vs. The Dudley Boyz - Great American Bash 2004
This abomination headlined a pay-per-view, which hands it the advantage over a billionaire torturing his daughter, in a possible cat-kicking exercise after refusing to participate in an incest storyline (Vince vs. Stephanie McMahon, No Mercy 2003).
This abomination headlined a pay-per-view in an era in which you were expected to pay a fortune for the privilege.
In a bid to use The Undertaker as his personal instrument of destruction, Paul Heyman sought to control him via the urn he... won several World Championships without. 'Taker acquiesced, reluctantly, but Heyman wasn't done. He wanted his greatness, not the urn's power, to hold control over his will, and he used the help of those d*mn Dudleys to do it. This wacky pretext informed a 'Handicap Concrete Crypt Match', and those four words in sequence somehow didn't give anybody pause.
The stipulation?
Paul Bearer dies if The Undertaker does Old School! Hot, suffocating cement thickens and chokes Bearer's throat, if 'Taker does a big boot!
Imagine the crowd's reaction to all of this, had they actually reacted.
"I like cool moves from the '90s, but I don't want anybody to die. I'm not that much like Mohammad bin Salman, jeez."
And then Bearer did die, because The Undertaker killed him, live on pay-per-view.