8 Wrestlers Who Quit On Top

Quit the job before doing the job.

Becky Lynch speech
WWE

There's a time-honoured and much respected tradition in the wrestling industry that you exit on your back. As an aging star's career reaches its conclusion, they're expected to lie down for the next generation of talent before finally calling it a day, having given something back on their way out.

However, it rarely takes the form of a marquee, torch-passing moment. Tradition holds that you also exit on the bottom, shunted down the card to work the circuit with unproven talent on the rise. By the time the boots are hung up for good, a wrestler's relevance is often already depleted. How many legitimate retirement matches can you remember? Conversely, how many stars of yesteryear can you recall who just gradually dwindled from prominence?

The majority of performers fall into the latter category, their glory days long past as they stare at the lights night after night. The addictive nature of the business means that many end up outstaying their welcome by a considerable margin.

Glittering retirements are scarce. Not many have the privilege of saying goodbye to their adoring fans whilst they still care. But there are some exceptions. And in nearly every case, they inevitably came back.

8. Brock Lesnar

Brock Lesnar 2004
WWE.com

There comes a point in everybody's career when they just have to say no to that $45 million contract offer, and put their happiness first. For Brock Lesnar, that meant walking away from his position as WWE's breakout star and returning to his farm in Minnesota, ahead of an ultimately failed tilt at pro-football.

Just two years after becoming the company's youngest ever champion The Beast Incarnate, tired of the gruelling schedule and having accomplished pretty much everything in short order, decided it was time for a change of scenery. He couldn't accept the fact that despite being only being 27 years old, he was in perpetual agony on his weekends off. His employers, meanwhile, couldn't accept the fact they were about to lose their first true new megastar in yonks, and so offered him a preposterous contract extension from the same dream chequebook as Bret Hart's reneged 1996 deal.

Brock was having none of it, and after his marquee match with Goldberg at WrestleMania XX, quit the business. It wouldn't stick; his football dream was ended by a motorcycle crash, and he was back between the ropes - albeit in Japan - by 2005.


7. Edge

Edge Retirement Wwe
WWE.com

Come WrestleMania XXVII, Edge's flag was firmly planted on the wrestling mountain he'd worked so tirelessly to ascend. Though he wasn't in the main event - that, obviously, was reserved for John Cena's angle with The Rock - he was nevertheless one of WWE's two top champions, emerging from the show with the World Heavyweight gold still in tact. But behind the scenes, the view from the summit was not as magnificent as it seemed.

They say, if you're Everest conqueror Sir Ranulph Fiennes, or an incompetent prime minister mumbling metaphors instead of giving direct information, that the descent is even harder than the climb. For Edge, it was utterly heartbreaking. Just a week after besting Alberto Del Rio in Atlanta, the Rated R-Superstar suddenly announced that the gig was up. A fused spine and a brittle neck meant he'd reached the top and had to stop.

His championship was vacated that same week, and within a year came a bittersweet induction into WWE's Hall of Fame, paying tribute to his career but confirming its end.


6. Bruno Sammartino

Bruno Sammartino George Steele
WWE

After keeping an iron-clad grip on the WWWF Championship for 2,803 days during two reigns across an astonishing eleven years, it seemed as though Bruno Sammartino's irrepressible popularity would never wane. By this point, his legacy self-perpetuating his appeal, only the intervention of fate or time could dislodge him from the top.

And that's just what happened, as a legitimate neck fracture suffered in a 1977 MSG match against Stan Hansen finally heralded the end of Bruno's north-east hegemony. The crowds were as strong as ever, but the Living Legends' limbs weren't; a year later he told Vince McMahon Sr. he'd have to step down as champion.

Sammartino promptly dropped the strap to Superstar Billy Graham - bringing his current three and a half year reign to a close - but he continued to fill the house even as his career wound down. In 1980, he embarked on an unforgettable feud with mentee Larry Zbyszko; the culmination of their bad blood drew an astonishing 36,295 fans to New York's Shea Stadium. Despite the emergence of Hulk Hogan - who appeared on the same show against Andre the Giant - Bruno was still the most popular star in wrestling when he called time on his career within a year of the Showdown at Shea.


5. Trish Stratus

Trish Stratus Unforgiven 2006
WWE

Trish Stratus, a WWE Hall of Famer whose legacy, though slightly exaggerated, as a women's division trailblazer paved the road for the modern era's Women's Evolution, was just 30 years old when she called it quits, having achieved all the limited scope of the era would allow. For the sake of some scarcely believable context, that's the same age fellow Canadian great Bret Hart was when he competed in WrestleMania III's mid-card as a member of the Hart Foundation.

By 2006, despite her relatively tender age, there was nothing left for Stratus to accomplish in wrestling. Having just wed her childhood sweetheart and with TV offers landing in her in-tray, she decided it was time to pursue fresh challenges.

Rather than bury the departing star, WWE demonstrated rare gratitude in allowing Trish a champion's send-off. The Torontonian captured her final Women's Championship in a greatest hits contest with perennial rival Lita, before a hometown crowd at Unforgiven 2006. She retired shortly after.


4. Shawn Michaels

Shawn Michaels Retirement
WWE.com

In the sage words of serial debunker Jonathan Frakes, Crown Jewel 2018 never happened. That Last of the Summer wine re-run between D-Generation X and the Brothers of Destruction? It's a made up tale. A total fabrication.

Everybody knows Shawn Michaels retired in the most glittering of circumstances possible some eight years earlier, bowing out in an all-time classic against The Undertaker at WrestleMania XXVI. Few people exit the industry on their own terms, but The Heartbreak Kid, still in fine fettle, had the chance to show one last time - a year on from his similarly stellar outing with the same opponent - why he's considered one of the greatest of all time.

Unlike the 25 vintage, which Triple H and Randy Orton inexplicably thought they could top, Michaels' swansong went on last. You can't go out any higher than headlining WrestleMania.


3. Becky Lynch

Becky Lynch
WWE.com

The most recent example on this list is up in the air somewhat. Who knows when we'll see Becky Lynch again? Though the Irish Lass-kicker didn't formally announce her retirement, there's no guarantee that she'll waltz back into the ring any time soon after becoming a mother.

And nor does she need to. Becky's emotional announcement on Raw was the apex of a career in which she has nothing left to prove. Not only was she the unassailable champion of the red brand, but twelve months prior had made legitimate professional wrestling history in becoming the first woman to close WrestleMania as the promotion's top star. If this is the end, Lynch walks away knowing she left the industry in a better place for all the women who follow in her footsteps.


2. Verne Gagne

Verne Gagne AWA Champion
WWE

There was once a special class of wrestling champions turned promoters who were like old chewing gum stuck to the bottom of a school desk: practically impervious, and almost impossible to dislodge. Hardy Minnesotan bone-bender and inveterate AWA impresario Verne Gagne was cut from that particular obdurate cloth, a world champion of one sort or another from the outset of his career until his eventual retirement in 1981, aged 54.

Gagne's first taste of the gold came in 1953, when Fred Kohler Enterprises earmarked the handsome and preternaturally gifted youngster to carry the newly-fashioned NWA Detroit World Heavyweight Championship. A star of the Dumont Network, Verne became one of the highest-earning wrestlers of his era, raking in enough to dictate his own dates, and eventually, set up his own promotion: the American Wrestling Association.

As old school as they came, Gagne knew the best way to protect his new territory was to name himself its champion. He awarded himself the strap in 1960, and kept almost sole possession of it across the next two decades. His ninth reign, beginning in 1969, lasted an astonishing seven years. Gagne was still the champion in 1981, when advancing age forced him to finally hang up his boots.


1. Batista

Batista 2010
WWE

At Elimination Chamber 2010, WWE gave Batista what they thought he wanted, as he easily dispatched of John Cena in ninety seconds to claim the WWE Title.

That wasn't what he wanted. He wanted out.

Although big Dave and big John were mirror images across their respective brands of Raw and SmackDown, the former was not afforded the same money-making opportunities as the latter. Like Cena, Batista wanted to use his position at the top to branch out into lucrative commercial endeavours: specifically, films.

WWE firmly told him "no", so he told them where to go. In May 2019, he gave the company a year's notice for his departure.

Wanting to get the most out of their star whilst they still had him - and in a desperate attempt to persuade him to stay - Batista won his first world championship a month later. He'd be given a second run on top the following February, as the clock ticked down on his time.

Though he lost the strap back to Cena, Batista was still every bit a top draw when the date of his contract's expiration arrived. He featured in the main event of Over the Limit on 23 May; a day later, his time with WWE was up. He'd eventually return as the Hollywood star the promotion had prevented him becoming.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Becky Lynch
 
Posted On: 
Editorial Team
Editorial Team

Benjamin was born in 1987, and is still not dead. He variously enjoys classical music, old-school adventure games (they're not dead), and walks on the beach (albeit short - asthma, you know). He's currently trying to compile a comprehensive history of video game music, yet denies accusations that he purposefully targets niche audiences. He's often wrong about these things.