8 Wrestlers Who Should Compete In A NXT Title Tournament

Who will benefit from Tommaso Ciampa's misfortune?

Tommaso Ciampa NXT Champion
WWE.com

Injuries are never good, especially when they rob hard-working wrestlers and match-hungry fans of surefire classics. That's the case with now ex-NXT Champion Tommaso Ciampa; neck surgery will take WrestleMania season away from the new main roster recruit, and it'll cheat him of approximately nine months of action on NXT as well.

Bugger.

So, what does this mean for one of the most credible titles WWE have in the short term? Dave Meltzer guesses it means WWE will run a tournament for the vacant prize, one culminating at TakeOver: New York on 5 April. There, if the Wrestling Observer chief's guesswork is correct, a new titleholder will be crowned and the belt will move on from its wounded master onto a new saviour who can lead the division for the remainder of 2019.

WWE have four weeks of television before they get to TakeOver, and they have to act fast here. The big questions facing them are many: exactly who would be in such a tournament, why do they belong there in the first place and who should ultimately win the thing to replace Ciampa as the new champ?


8. Matt Riddle

Matt Riddle NXT
WWE.com

Hey, Bro.

Indy fans already know what Matt Riddle's strike-heavy style is all about, and NXT diehards are starting to grow accustomed to his mix of laid back surfer vibes and blistering, MMA-laced offence. Right now, Riddle should be a definite contender for any tournament, but it's probs too early to think about giving him the belt.

Riddle has an upcoming run at the NXT North American Championship first, and it's likely he'll be working Velveteen Dream at TakeOver: New York in April. It wouldn't be wise to steal such a match away from the show during such an uncertain time, and so Matt should enter the tourney and come up short near the end.

In fact, it might be fun to book Riddle vs. Dream in the brackets and have them wrestle out a time limit draw. That, if handled correctly, could help build anticipation towards their rematch (with Dream's title on the line) at TakeOver.


7. Keith Lee

Keith Lee
WWE.com

Keith Lee's potential is untapped. In PWG, Evolve and elsewhere, Lee showed how impressive agility tacked onto a chunky, well-muscled frame can wow fans. Now he's in NXT, it's only a matter of time before he's able to show his natural, likeable personality too. This tournament could and should be the start of that.

Bring it on, big man.

Lee has become somewhat of an NXT house show stalwart over the past nine months or so. Lately, he's been trading wins with mid-carders like Kassius Ohno and Dominik Dijakovic, but that's not on TV. In other words, fans who only keep tabs on the televised product haven't seen much of what this guy has to offer yet.

A solid showing in a tournament centred around the brand's biggest title would aid Lee's cause and show the writers that he's ready for more. Although he'd likely be a first round elimination, that's fine if WWE at least attempt to weave a short story in there that'd give him more depth.


6. Roderick Strong

Roderick Strong
WWE.com

Speaking of weaving stories into the prospective tournament, it'd be a good idea to do that with the Undisputed Era lads. In this fan's opinion, keeping Bobby Fish and Kyle O'Reilly in the tag division is the best bet. That leaves Adam Cole (more on him later) and Roderick Strong as possible contenders in the tourney.

Wouldn't it be something if Strong started out with the goal of helping Cole win the title before realising he was coming close himself?

Now obviously this would rely on some teased tension within the Era ranks. That's manageable so long as WWE don't get carried away and knee-jerk a turn for somebody just for the sake of it. If Roddy's tale presents a realistic story of somebody only there to help another before growing in confidence and believing he can do it himself, it'll work.

Then, possibly after losing to Cole at the semi-final stage, Strong can snap out of his personal quest and once again be all for the idea of bringing gold home to his stable.


5. Ricochet

ricochet raw
WWE.com

Ricochet has been leaving fans slack-jawed with his flashy dives and unbelievably smooth 630 finish on episodes of Raw and SmackDown recently. In just a few weeks, he's gone from NXT hopeful to main roster favourite, and that was never a given. Still, Ciampa's injury means he's needed back 'home'.

Ricochet has formed a tag-team with Aleister Black over the past few weeks, and that has extended to NXT's Dusty Rhodes Tag-Team Classic as well as the main roster. This is little more than an introductory point for Rico though; he's still a singles star at heart, and he should be allowed to light up the early rounds of the tournament.

There's no pressure either.

If he falls at the first hurdle, so what? There's no shame in losing to someone like Matt Riddle or Roderick Strong, especially when he's then going to excel on Monday and Tuesday nights anyway.


4. Aleister Black

Aleister Black
WWE.com

The exact same goes for Aleister Black.

As a former NXT Champion in his own right, Black would bring some prestige to the tournament if it happened and he was involved. Plus (and this is a big plus), he was the one who shockingly lost the belt to Tommaso Ciampa on an episode of NXT TV last July. It makes sense that he'd want another crack at glory.

Black could even cut promos about how he wants to mimic Kevin Owens in 2015 and take the NXT Title to the main roster with him for a while. To him, this tournament would represent the chance to raise the stock of NXT as a brand, and proudly fly the flag for what WWE's alternative style can do in front of a bigger audience.

That's another natural story in a tourney that should be stacked with them. Between the mini-Undisputed Era battle, Riddle vs. Dream and this, the brackets would have enough juice.


3. Velveteen Dream

Velveteen Dream
WWE.com

Call him up, Vince, but please wait until he's had a chance to soar as NXT North American Champ and work the tournament.

Earlier, it was said that Velveteen Dream is heading for a showdown with Matt Riddle at TakeOver: New York, but that both could feasibly still enter the NXT Title tourney to further their burgeoning feud there. Hopefully, that's the case, and hopefully WWE seize the chance to tease that Dream could make brand history.

His main objective would be winning the whole thing and thus becoming the first ever dual NXT and North American Champion in the company. That sounds huge, and it'd speak to Velveteen's star-soaked aura. He'd crave the opportunity to become a history maker.

Temptation will be there to have him go all the way. Note to WWE: don't do it. TakeOver specials deserve both World Title and secondary belt matches on the same card, and that's why Dream should just come up short in his bid to become a legend.


2. Johnny Gargano

Johnny Gargano Venom
WWE.com

'Johnny Wrestling' is another who has started to gravitate towards the main roster as of late. Until internal news spread about Ciampa's neck troubles, he and Gargano looked to be doing so together as a tag-team. So much for that. Now, it's all about one half of DIY and his own bid to replace his partner.

Spotting a pattern throughout this article? Story, story, story.

Powerful narratives are a strength of NXT's product, and there's no reason why this fantasy tournament should be any different. If Gargano dedicates his run in the thing to a fallen partner, it'd give fans even more of a hook to grab onto. That's why Johnny must temporarily cancel his main roster aspirations and give NXT another whirl.

If he was announced, fans would get seriously excited. People would start to believe that this is part of another lengthy plot designed to have a returning Tommaso cut his on/off buddy down upon his return in around nine months.


1. Adam Cole

Adam Cole
WWE.com

Not so fast, bay bay.

Dave Meltzer believes Adam Cole is the most viable candidate to replace Tommaso Ciampa as NXT Champion, and there's a crap ton of merit to his argument. Cole, who was the first North American Champ and has yet to taste the top prize, has been ready for a good while now.

Picture this: Cole beats someone like Ricochet or Keith Lee in the first round, overcomes his Undisputed Era pal Roderick Strong in the semi finals and then goes head-to-head with Johnny Gargano at TakeOver: New York for all the marbles. Then, Strong can show his allegiance to Cole by helping him win and NXT has a brand new baron.

From there, Gargano can waltz off back to the main roster and work his tail off to make a splash there. It's a win-win situation. Cole beats the former champ's best friend, Gargano has another TakeOver classic to further arm himself with and NXT has a champion again.

Do you agree with these choices to work the NXT Title tournament? Let us know down in the comments section below!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.