8 Wrestling Angles Which Exploited Real Life Deaths
Frequent winners of Meltzer's Most Disgusting Promotional Tactic award.
The wrestling business sure is a funny one. It's an entertainment product that blends physicality of sports, live performance and theatrical storytelling all in one, unique hybrid.
The majority of these constructed storylines consist of many of the basic tropes you see in any fictional show, like Game of Thrones or The Walking Dead. There are bad guys and good guys. There are love triangles and break ups. There are betrayals and unions. It's all there.
Unlike the world of TV and cinema, wrestling can incorporate real life elements into its show, like a couple dating in real life being written to partner each other on screen, or a wrestler's other sporting achievements being inserted into their character's arc.
However, every now and then, for some inexplicable reason, those in charge of writing these stories dive into one pool too many, a pool that's far too deep to swim back out of. That metaphorical pool is filled with deceased relatives.
It sounds about as bad as it actually is. Over time, the wrestling industry, with all their creative might, thought it was a good idea to include actual dead people in stories to further a rivalry or character arc.
It's pretty much always absolute s**t.
8. Batista Reminds Rey That "Eddie's Dead"
Unfortunately, this isn't the only time Eddie Guerrero's name appears on this list.
At Bragging Rights 2009, Batista and Rey Mysterio both lost a Fatal 4-Way for the World Heavyweight Championship. During the match, Rey broke up a pin attempt from Big Dave that would have netted the future Drax the belt, swiftly prompting Batista to turn heel after the match and beat down his long-time friend.
While his perfectly delivered line on that night, "I'm gonna rip your head off," was very much on point, his line on the following SmackDown while explaining his actions was not.
With Mysterio imploring Batista to think of what they'd been through together, and how their mutual friend Guerrero would see what was happening, Dave simply fired back with two words:
"Eddie's dead!"
It was cheap heat on a feud that was already firing on its own accord. Guerrero wasn't a key part of the angle; he wasn't a part of it at all. It was the one and only time he was mentioned.
It was four years after Eddie had passed and it just looked like a lazy one-liner to get more heat on Batista. It was unnecessary, it didn't further the story at all. It was just poor taste for the sake of a groaning crowd reaction.
7. Big Show Riding His Dad's Casket
The image of a seven-foot Big Show hanging on to his deceased father's casket, while the Big Boss Man towed it out of a cemetery, is a lot to take in, even for the wacky world of wrestling. It was all the wrong kinds of car crash spectacle that defined the Attitude Era.
Paul Wight's father had in fact died a few years earlier, as opposed to during the feud, but it was a very real exploitation of Big Show's undoubtedly painful loss.
It's one thing to mention a dead relative, but for Big Show, he had to re-enact, and relive, his own father's funeral for a strangely written segment used to build a dead-in-the-water feud.
Big Show would go on to beat his coffin-stealing rival very comfortably on two occasions in the following months, once for the WWF Championship, but no one really remembers anything other than the aforementioned casket ride poor Show had to endure.
It was a strange, twisted way to draw heat on Boss Man, which kind of worked to an extent, but it was so silly, painfully acted out and pointless considering the shelf life of the feud, that it just came off all wrong by the end of it.
Some of the Big Boss Man's jibes like, "unless you want to be six-foot deep like your daddy," made it really difficult not to cringe. The whole thing was a real kick in the nuts for Show, and no doubt his family.
6. Jim Neidhart On A Table
Jim Neidhart, father of Natalya, took part in one final WWE storyline alongside his daughter in 2018. The only problem is that The Anvil had passed away a few months prior.
During her feud with Ruby Riott, and the rest of the Riott Squad, the leader of the stable had already begun using Neidhart's death as fuel for the flames.
While Natalya was using her father as inspiration moving into Survivor Series of that year, and an eventual Raw Women's Championship match against Ronda Rousey, Riott was smashing The Anvil's iconic glasses to get at the veteran of the women's division.
The cherry on top of the cruelty cake was Riott's Christmas present for Natalya.
With the two slated to face each other in a tables match at TLC, Riott revealed a special table that she would be using for the match. As you could guess from the image above, the table had a life sized Jim Neidhart plastered across it.
Thankfully, Natalya was never put through it, but the third-generation star has since defended the angle, saying that her father would have understood, having lived and breathed the wrestling industry himself for decades.
Still, making a wrestler work a program with their dead dad on a table isn't exactly pleasant.
5. Michael Cole Taunts Jerry Lawler's Mother
There's really nothing good about the entire Jerry Lawler and Michael Cole feud that took up far too much of 2010 and 2011. The commentators had a stinker of a match at WrestleMania XXVII, and don't even mention the Kiss My Foot match at Over The Limit later that year.
In among all the rubbish and overbooked nonsense, Lawler's mother passed away during the build to WrestleMania, leaving their feud in doubt as the King rightly took some time off. Being the professional that he is though, Lawler was quickly back in the hot seat, running commentary and battling Cole at every turn.
At Elimination Chamber, Lawler was unsuccessful in defeating The Miz for the WWE Championship, so the next night on Raw, Cole used this as ammunition to attack The King.
Cole went full on s**tbag heel on Lawler, telling him that his mother had the best seat in the house to see him lose to The Miz. He even asked him how it made him feel knowing that he'd let his deceased mother down.
The crowd ate it up immediately, booing Cole out of the building as he ran The King down.
Lawler had stated soon after his mother passed how professional The Miz and Cole were backstage on a personal level, both saying they didn't want to use the situation for cheap heat during their running feuds.
It would appear that Cole was overruled.
4. Paige Says Reid Flair "Didn't Have Much Fight"
This was a nightmare for the WWE, all for the sake of cheap babyface sympathy for one character and heel heat for the other.
In the build up to their Survivor Series match in 2015, Paige and Charlotte Flair had the obligatory contract signing segment that ends in a brawl.
Before said brawl could take place though, Paige spewed out an absolute shocker of a line on her opponent, after Flair had used the premature passing of her brother as motivation moments earlier.
Reid Flair sadly passed away two years prior due to a drug overdose, a devastating real-life tragedy for the Fliehr family.
So when Paige wanted to bite back at Charlotte after her promo had come to an end, she told Charlotte that her "little baby brother, he didn't have much fight in him, did he?"
It's one thing to suggest that a dead person might be disappointed in the targeted wrestler, or to use their name to get the opponent fired up, but to insinuate that someone that struggled with, and sadly lost to, drug addiction was weak for losing that battle is beyond a step too far.
WWE understandably received plenty of backlash for it, and making matters worse, Ric Flair, along with his ex-wife and mother of Reid, weren't aware of it. They both came out swinging at the company for using their son's name in such a fashion without even letting them know about it or asking for permission.
It was a PR disaster.
3. WCCW Cashing In On Von Erich Deaths
The tragedy of the Von Erich family is well documented, with the devastated family being dealt blow after blow throughout the 1980s and '90s.
During the early-to-mid '80s, World Class Championship Wrestling was in a boom thanks to the Von Erich brothers, the sons of owner and promoter Fritz Von Erich, who dominated the main event scene.
When one of the brothers, David, died prematurely in 1984 on the cusp of battling Ric Flair for the NWA Heavyweight Championship, Fritz put on a memorial show where David's brother Kerry would win an emotionally charged title match against Flair for the same belt, with the build revolving largely around David's passing.
It's when another memorial show was put on the following year, and the one after that, that people started getting a little uncomfortable, as David's death was constantly used to garner heat and sympathy leading into each show.
Fritz could see that the first memorial show was one of the company's most successful, so in the eyes of a businessman and promoter, he saw dollar signs.
The tragedy was dragged out over years, often resulting in the next Von Erich using their emotion to take a big win at each Memorial Parade Of Champions, as they were billed.
Unfortunately in 1987, the family lost another when Mike committed suicide, so the next memorial show was fired up once again. Oddly enough, the main event was somehow a six-woman Mud Pit match.
2. Punk And Heyman spread Bearer's Ashes
When one man is dressing up as a dead person and the other is spreading that dead person's ashes, you've probably jumped the shark.
William Moody - aka Paul Bearer - died of a heart attack in 2013, whilst his long-time client, The Undertaker, was embroiled in a WrestleMania feud with CM Punk. Because the Bearer character had been associated with the Deadman for nearly his entire career, it was a given that it might impact 'Taker and his arc.
WWE seemingly did all the right things in the beginning, putting on a memorial episode of Raw for Moody and letting The Undertaker pay tribute to his former manager. Then CM Punk interrupted.
He ran down Big Evil and poked fun at Paul Bearer's passing, giving a taste of what was to come in the following weeks. Punk would steal the urn made famous by Undertaker and Bearer, using it to attack him and his kayfabe brother, Kane.
The icing on the cake came when Punk's manager, Paul Heyman, came out on Raw dressed as Bearer, white face and all. While Punk beat down on The Undertaker with the urn, he poured Bearer's ashes out over him, laughing alongside a mocking Heyman.
WWE had asked Moody's sons if it was alright to use their father as a part of the build, to which they agreed, but they would come out later stating their anger at the way they were misled on exactly how their dad would be incorporated with the story line.
1. "Eddie's Down There, In Hell"
Was it ever going to be anything else? The shining example of how NOT to use a real life tragedy to further a story line.
The entire run that Rey Mysterio took from winning the Royal Rumble, into his World Heavyweight Championship win at WrestleMania 22, was fueled by Eddie Guerrero-based sympathy. Some people thought it fit Mysterio's character arc, others thought it was shameless exploitation. It was a polarising period of time.
No matter your thoughts on how Rey utilised references to Guerrero, everyone is on the same page when it comes to Randy Orton's use of the Guerrero tragedy. The night after he was eliminated last in the Royal Rumble, Orton came out to interrupt Mysterio, himself celebrating his win with Eddie's entrance and attire.
Orton challenged his smaller foe to a match, with Mysterio's championship match on the line, but when Mysterio looked to the sky for an answer, Orton wasted little time in picking him off.
"You're looking to the heavens, you're looking for Eddie. Let me tell you something, Eddie ain't in heaven. Eddie's down there... IN HELL!"
It had barely been a month since Guerrero's passing, and while many other wrestlers were using his name around Raw and SmackDown, Orton's use was a mile out of line for all the wrong reasons.