8 Wrestling Heel Turns That Were Immediately Reversed

We immediately regret this decision.

Jim Ross Heel Steve Williams
WWE

One of the most important decisions a wrestling booker faces in their daily work is whether a given performer should be a face or a heel.

Imagine if Stone Cold Steve Austin hadn't become a good guy in 1997, for instance. WWF might never have kick-started the Attitude Era, instead losing the Monday Night Wars to ratings rivals WCW, and in turn going out of business in the early 2000s (granted, that's worst case scenario - and was never actually likely).

Here's a more recent example: imagine if WWE had spent the last three years trying to push a man who the fans absolute loathe as their next franchise player, passing up a number of presentable opportunities to turn him heel because of sheer, wrong-headed stubbornness on the part of their chairman.

In fairness to Vince, you can kind of see why he's reluctant to pull the trigger on Roman's long-awaited character shift. There have been several instances in the company's past where they've changed the alignment of a wrestler one week, only to go cold on the idea after a negative crowd response a short while later.

Here are eight examples.

8. Eugene

Moving Eugene over to wrestling's dark side never really seemed like a particularly good idea. The guy had spent the first part of his WWE run carrying a teddy bear and jumping around on bouncy castles.

To his credit, Nick Dinsmore - the once-promising indie star tasked with playing this dead-end character - actually pulled off the initial turn pretty well. Launching an unprovoked attack on former partner Jim Duggan, he genuinely looked like a man in the throes of a dramatic character transformation.

But then that was part of the problem. You couldn't really hate a guy who didn't know what was happening to him. He was the victim of a sudden burst of anger rather than a villainous double-crosser.

Anyway, none of that really mattered in the end because they dropped the angle altogether within just a couple of weeks. With no explanation, Eugene was back to being a baby-face - for about five minutes. And then he was released.


7. Jim Ross

Jim Ross Michael Cole
WWE

While you can just about get away with a bad guy colour commentator, turning your play-by-play guy heel always seems like kind of a risky move. You can't really call it straight and applaud villainous tactics at the same time.

That said, the appeal of using JR as the driving force of a storyline instead of just the man who describes it is obvious. He's clearly got a great nose for the business, and he spent years sitting next to Vince McMahon too (some of that evil had to rub off). Unfortunately, the fans didn't see it the same way.

After watching JR berate and then physically attack a young Michael Cole - who had stepped into his announcing shoes while he was away for medical reasons - the crowd applauded rather than admonished.

They could have persisted with it, but given that Cole wasn't yet ready to permanently replace him in the Raw hot seat (and, if you listen to some people, still isn't), it didn't really seem worthwhile. Soon enough, he was back on the side of good.


6. Ron Simmons

In the kayfabe world, there are few wrestlers as inoffensive as Ron Simmons, whose primary role over the last 15 years has been occasionally popping up during comedic backstage segments to say the word "damn".

He did, however, have a very brief run as a heel in 2002, shortly after splitting from long-time running mate Bradshaw. It was a pretty radical 180 too: he went from drinking and playing cards to getting right with Jesus, joining up with Reverand D-Von for a short-lived tag team.

But since the whole Reverand D-Von thing itself was never likely to last more than a couple of months, Simmons was promptly turned back into a face, taking a short break from TV before returning to reboot The APA.

And that run too lasted a matter of months, before Bradshaw remembered that he was actually a self-made millionaire worthy of competing for the WWE Championship. Some people just can't catch a break.


5. Jeff Hardy

Jeff Hardy as a heel has never really worked, if we're honest. Even after a brilliant turn in TNA eight years ago - after which he joined forces with Hulk Hogan and Eric Bischoff - he still struggled to turn the fans completely against him.

These same problems followed his initial switch to the dark side in 2003, where a falling out with kindred spirit Shawn Michaels (who had offered to take the young star under his wing) saw him develop an uncharacteristic arrogant streak.

The fans weren't really buying it though, perhaps because Jeff was only a couple of months removed from that epic Ladder Match showdown with The Undertaker, from which he came away with bucket loads of goodwill.

There was another problem too: HBK's primary focus around this time was Chris Jericho, whom he would go on to face at WrestleMania XIX. The Hardy thing just felt like a transitional storyline (and ultimately that's all it was: the latter was back fighting the side of good a month later).


4. Goldberg

Goldberg Vince Russo Eric Bischoff
WWE Network

In truth it's been a total disaster almost any time that Golberg has been divorced from the tried and tested formula of having him walk through a cocky heel opponent in three minutes or less.

Given that, it's not really clear why WCW thought it was a good idea to move him over to the dark side in June 2000, other than the fact that it was WCW, a company that turned every single one of its wrestlers from face to heel and back again at least once.

Costing Kevin Nash victory at The Great American Bash, Goldberg formed a short-lived alliance with the cast of The New Blood (including, appropriately, the presumed architect of his character shift, Vince Russo), before reprising his good guy role two months later.

In an appearance on Stone Cold Steve Austin's podcast, the former football star later admitted that he didn't enjoy turning his back on the fans one bit, especially the younger ones who saw him as a real-life superhero.


3. Sting

Like Goldberg, Sting also had a brief stint as a bad guy during the dying days of WCW, switching to the dark side after a dramatic, baseball bat-aided turn at Fall Brawl in Setember 1999.

To be fair, this one definitely made a lot more sense from the perspective of story and continuity. Though he was hugely popular, Sting regularly employed tweener tactics in his ongoing fight against the New World Order.

But therein lies part of the problem. He was a force of WCW good for so long that it felt jarring to see him fight on the side of evil, especially since the baby-face against which he was then pitted was the always detestable Hulk Hogan.

In the end, they had to cave to public pressure, and The Icon was turned back into a baby-face a couple of months later, a role he has remained in (barring another short-lived heel stint in TNA) ever since - in three different promotions.


2. Stone Cold

Stone Cold Vince Mcmahon
WWE.com

You would have thought that, having made the boldest heel turn in professional wrestling history, WWE would at least have had the cajones to stick to their guns for more than a couple of months.

It's a mere footnote in the overall story, but that's not strictly what happened. Shortly after Stone Cold's mega turn at WrestleMania X-Seven, he was back fighting the side of good in time to captain to captain Team WWF at InVasion in July.

Granted, the U-turn only lasted a couple of weeks before they once again had a change of heart. This time, he left his teammates in the lurch by delivering a Stunner to Kurt Angle in the match's climactic sequence, thereby joining up with The Alliance.

None of that really seems completely necessary given that the plan was always for him to join up with Shane and Stephanie, but then InVasion is the highest-grossing non-WrestleMania pay-per-view in the company's history, so you can't really argue with the results.


1. Eddie Guerrero

Eddie Guerrero was arguably one of only a handful of wrestlers in history who was in equal parts effective as a face and a heel - so you can understand why WWE tried to switch him to the dark side in mid-2003.

The timing, however, was all wrong. Fans were still waiting for Latino Heat to break out as a main event star in his own right. They had no interest in booing him until he achieved his life's ambition of winning the company's top prize.

Attacking Tajiri probably wasn't the right way to do it either. Everyone loved the Japanese Buzz Saw, but he was by some distance the second most popular member of this short-lived two-piece, and therefore a poor choice to play the role of the fall guy.

Fortunately, despite having Guerrero brutalise his partner after he inadvertently put a dent on his limousine, the two quickly made amends a couple of SmackDowns later, and the whole thing was resolved.


In this post: 
Jim Ross
 
Posted On: 
Contributor