9 Failed Wrestling Attempts By Non-Wrestlers

Sometimes the business just isn't for you.

Whether or not you choose to think of professional wrestling as a sport, entertainment, a mixture of the two (or something else entirely), one thing is certain: wrestlers are highly-trained experts at what they do, and the endeavour is not something to be taken lightly. Which is why, on many occasions, when non-wrestlers have dared set foot into the squared circle, the majority have failed. That's not to say that celebrity cameos or athletes from other sports don't have their place in pro wrestling, but rather that, for the most part, they should be kept out of active competition. And for good reason: not only is wrestling a dangerous business, but it is also a very difficult one to master, and all too often, amateurs look exactly that - completely amateur in the ring. That hasn't, however, stopped various promotions from trying to bring non-wrestlers into the action anyway. With the hopes of big media coverage and inflated ratings, the WWF/E, WCW, and others have continually tried to cash-in. And for every Ronda Rousey or Mr. T, there has been a Denis Rodman, or worse. Now, buckle your seat belts, down some Dramamine, and prepare for the nine worst non-wrestlers to give pro wrestling a go.


9. Lawrence Taylor

Lawrence Taylor's pro wrestling experiment wouldn't qualify as such a failure were it not for the fact that it came in a main event. Generally, putting non-wrestlers in a main event is a very, very bad idea, and Taylor's appearance against Bam Bam Bigelow in 1995 was no exception. What made matters worse was that the main event in question was for WrestleMania XI. Ouch. The one thing you should never, ever do - there really should be a rule book somewhere stating this - is have a non-wrestler in the main event of WrestleMania! It's the pinnacle of the industry, not a place for freakshows. However, the WWF at the time was really pushing for the business to go mainstream, and to have it go mainstream, you need some mainstream stars. Taylor fit the bill, since he was a legit NFL legend. He wasn't terrible, but wasn't particularly great either. He was willing to take some bumps, and had this match happened on RAW, or even on the undercard of WrestleMania, it might have been forgivable, but as a main event, it was just awful booking.

8. Drew Carey

Drew Carey frankly has no business being in a wrestling ring, and that's coming from a Drew Carey fan. Carey's a likeable guy who had a great sitcom for a while, and went on to host Whose Line Is It Anyway? which will live on in syndication pretty much until the end of time. Plus there's that whole show where they guess prices and stuff... In any case, Carey has done a lot throughout his career, but the one thing he needn't have bothered with was showing up in the WWE. And facing off against the likes of Kane. And looking foolish doing it. Carey was Vince McMahon's entry in the 2001 Royal Rumble. Yes, the Royal Rumble. Coming to the ring in a track suit, his trademark glasses, and chewing his chewing gum, he got to spend a little bit of time in the ring by himself after the Hardy Boyz eliminated each other, but lasted just seconds once Kane arrived in the ring, followed by Raven (who frankly saved Carey). Carey then eliminated himself and, for this brief appearance, was inducted in the celeb wing of the WWE Hall of Fame. When asked recently if he would make any more WWE appearances, Carey answered "Oh hell no haha. I hate being boo'd".

7. Snooki

Snooki's wrestling attempt didn't fail because she was terrible in the ring. She was actually surprisingly athletic. The hand-spring elbow she pulled off? Pretty solid. No, it failed because she was Snooki, and was just never going to be taken seriously at any WWE event, let alone WrestleMania XXVII, which is where she showed up alongside John Morrison and Trish Startus. While having celebs at the big show is tradition, Snooki's status as a celeb even then was questionable (read: her fifteen minutes were about a second away from being up), and putting her in a match was a crime against the industry. Then again, at least they didn't book her in the main event.

6. Akebono

Akebono's appearance in the WWE was just... bizarre. And while he's a professional wrestler now, at the time he showed up in the squared circle for Vince McMahon's promotion, he was anything but. Keep in mind that Akebono was a legit Sumo champion who would later try out mixed martial arts and kickboxing, failing handily at both. With his sumo career over, he was looking for his next endeavor. Then in 2005 he briefly joined the WWE to take on The Big Show in a (worked) sumo bout at WrestleMania 21. Now, if it was just a sumo match, Akebono wouldn't be appearing here. However, he also had a couple of actual matches, first taking out jobber Eddie Vegas on Smackdown prior to WrestleMania, then, after the event, teaming up with The Big Show at a couple of house shows. None of these appearances were particularly good, and it's mostly forgotten that he ever did more than the sumo bout with Big Show in the WWE. He would eventually go on to a successful pro wrestling career in Japan, where he has been a citizen since 1996, but he has mostly been forgotten by western wrestling fans. You have to wonder, had he got some experience in the business and came to the WWE later, with proper training, whether things might have been different.

5. Kevin Federline

If the idea you're pitching has Keven Federline anywhere in it, then it's not a viable idea. Unless you're selling it to the WWE as a storyline, and including the concept that Federline feud with John Cena. In which case, they apparently think it's gold. Yes, a K-Fed vs. John Cena feud actually happened (some of us are still in disbelief), and we were all worse off for it. This all went down in the fall of 2006 to coincide with the release of Federline's Playing with Fire album. Over several weeks he beefed with Cena and interfered in his matches, until finally the two had a no disqualifications match on the New Year's Day edition of RAW. Federline actually won this bout, thanks to interference from Umaga and Johnny Nitro. Well, at least he didn't win clean. Still, think about the implications: Keven Federline holds a win over John Cena. Cena would get his revenge later in the night, mind you, giving K-Fed the FU (now called the Attitude Adjustment) twice.

4. The Miller Lite Girls

When you're obviously being used as eye candy - as part of a pillow fight, no less - wrestling skill shouldn't matter, right? Right? Only, for some strange reason it did when the Miller Lite "Catfight" Girls appeared at WrestleMania XIX in a pillow fight involving workers who were actually trained, namely Torrie Wilson and Stacey Keibler. Wilson and Keibler, who were used to the spotlight and had some wrestling experience, managed to look natural, while the Miller girls looked, frankly, awkward and out of place. Tanya Ballinger and Kitana Baker (the latter also part of Eric Bischoff's infamous HLA - Hot Lesbian Action) were the girls in question and after this appearance. Neither set foot in the WWE again. Now, as noted, it really shouldn't have mattered. This was a filler/titillation bout. If it was the second hour of a three hour RAW it would be forgivable, even welcome. However, it was WrestleMania, so no place, really, for this sort of time waster. Plus, Rob Van Dam, Kane, Val Venis and Lance Storm all got bumped to the pre-show so that this could go down.

3. Kevin Greene

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1uxeo7ObZSA There's no denying that a lot of football players have found success as pro wrestlers. The Rock, Goldberg, and Roman Reigns all made the jump and went on to become huge stars. In the 90s a couple of football players, Steve McMichael and Kevin Greene (one of whom was still active in the NFL), decided to try their hand at pro-wrestling and received offers from WCW. While McMichael's football days were behind him, Greene was still making tackles on the gridiron and would continue to do so until after the 1999 season. Greene originally debuted as the partner of McMichael, then feuded with him until the pair split. After being off TV for a while, in 1998 he returned and partnered up with Goldberg to take on the nWo. His gimmick... well, it was basically that he was an NFL guy. Not that he came to the ring in full football gear, just that people knew who he was, and WCW was happy to cash-in on his sports status. In short, it wasn't a gimmick at all, really. There was also one other problem in that the NFL wasn't exactly happy about an active player moonlighting as a pro wrestler, and had to create a "no wrestling" clause in player contracts to put a stop to it. That ended the Kevine Greene experiment and his NFL career would finish up soon after.

2. Dennis Rodman

Just like with Kevin Greene, Dennis Rodman in WCW was an attempt to exploit outside celebrity and the fanbase of another sport. In this case, Rodman (a.k.a. The Worm) had been suspended by the NBA for a good chunk of the 96-97 season, and decided to turn to his love of wrestling and actually get in the ring. He would appear with pal Hulk Hogan at a Monday Nitro in March 97 and quickly wound up in the nWo. Of course, eventually everyone joined the nWo, but Rodman's appearance was really pushing the limits of credibility. Rodzilla would tag with Hogan against The Giant and Lex Luger that July at Bash at the Beach, then return to basketball - only to return to wrestling a year later at Bash at the Beach 98, where he took on fellow NBA star Karl Malone in a tag match. Rodman was paired with Hogan, and Malone with DDP in what was generally regarded as one of the worst WCW matches in years. The match marked the end of Rodman in WCW, though he would wrestle off an on a couple of times for other promotions over the years. Besides the fact that he couldn't really wrestle all that well, Rodman in wrestling failed for one simple reason: as Roddy Piper later recalled, WCW workers were instructed "not to touch" Rodman - which meant he couldn't take any big bumps. It made sense given his basketball career, but if you can't take bumps there's no point in trying to work a wrestling match.

1. David Arquette

WCW was more or less a fountain of bad ideas when it came to bringing outside talent into the promotion. Dennis Rodman? Kevin Greene? Not great. Yet its lowest point? Putting a championship belt on an actor. Now, utilizing Arquette wasn't the issue. He had a WCW themed film coming out in 2000 with Ready to Rumble, so a tie-in for the sake of marketing was a given. Writing him into storylines? That was a particularly bad decision by creative. Still, if it stopped there, it could be forgiven - but it got worse. After a storyline confrontation with Eric Bischoff and an initial match between the two, Arquette was put in a three-way match with Bischoff and Jeff Jarrett, with the WCW Heavyweight Championship on the line, open to whoever scored a pinfall. Arquette got the pin over Bischoff, and the belt. After that he was used for comic relief for the most part - which honestly was completely disrespecting the belt. While pro wrestling has always been about entertainment, the title needs to get its proper due, or it will no longer matter within the various storylines. In short, you want fans to believe that someone would actually want the belt, and that it will be hard fought for - not that it will be handed off to just anyone. However, the angle, which Arquette was himself against, was reportedly insisted upon by Vince Russo. For Arquette's part, he donated all his earnings from his WCW run to the families of Owen Hart, Brian Pillman (both of whom had passed away), and Droz (who had been paralyzed in the ring). The experiment would last mere weeks, with Arquette dropping the title to Jarrett after turning on DDP (who had been an ally), but the damage to WCW was done.

Contributor
Contributor

Primarily covering the sport of MMA from Ontario, Canada, Jay Anderson has been writing for various publications covering sports, technology, and pop culture since 2001. Jay holds an Honours Bachelor of Arts degree in English from the University of Guelph, and a Certificate in Leadership Skills from Humber College.