9 Huge Problems With Big Show Vs Shaquille O'Neal At WWE WrestleMania 33
This isn't seriously going to happen, is it?
The ongoing and confusing rivalry that has developed between WWE stalwart Big Show and NBA icon Shaquille O'Neal is poised to reach fever pitch after Shaq accepted a bold challenge for a WrestleMania 33 match.
Amongst some awkward-yet-manly hugs of appreciation, the man mountains addressed each other on the red carpet of the ESPY Awards where Big Show threw down the gauntlet for a meeting on April 2, 2017 in Orlando.
Show and Shaq have been scrapping at each other since 2009 when the former NBA star was guest hosting Monday Night Raw. Seven years after Big Show ate a Shaquille clothesline, the pair resumed hostilities in the WrestleMania 32 Andre the Giant Battle Royal, eventually leading to their eliminations.
Now, less than nine months away from WrestleMania 33, Vince McMahon and his band of merry men have some contemplating to do.
The company's social media accounts have already embraced the match-up, indicating that the fantasy bout is heading for an inevitable reality. After all, it would be difficult for WWE to deny an opportunity to break out into mainstream media.
However, just because it could happen doesn't mean it necessarily should. Understandably, WWE Universe members have a barrage of questions in regards to the potential match, most commonly 'why?'.
As fun as the concept may seem, there are some giant holes in the logic behind booking this match for 'Mania - or at all...
9. NBA Fans Won't Go Out Of Their Way To Watch
It seems as though WWE is overcompensating for the amount of people who will actually care about this match. It might have been a hot ticket on face value 10 years ago, but certainly not now. Not to rag on Shaq, but someone within WWE has to see a spade for a spade before this gets too out of hand.
Shaquille O'Neal is undoubtedly a name that is synonymous with elite professional basketball, but he has been retired since 2011 and his only major contribution to sports media is tongue-in-cheek analysis for NBA on TNT. Of course he will still have his fans, but how many of those are willing to pay money to watch him perform on a platform they may have little, if any, familiarity with?
It doesn't help the case when Shaq's opponent is a man in the twilight of his career who hasn't exactly been a prominent figure on WWE programming, especially in recent times.
WWE is clearly playing on the fantasy match-up factor but it's hard to get hyped about a contest between two competitors who are past their best years. Maybe if WWE pitted John Cena against LeBron James then this kind of dream match would draw a crowd.
8. No Justifiable Rivalry
Even in the modern wrestling world where fans pride themselves on knowing the real relationships between performers, there has to be some kind of on-screen rivalry that fuels a story. As far as we're led to believe, Big Show and Shaquille O'Neal want to have a match at WrestleMania 33 just 'cause.
Since their first altercation back on Raw in 2009, when Show was the recipient of a Shaq-sized clothesline, the pair have been public with their admiration for each other. Between teaming up in the Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal - albeit before being eliminated - and being chummy on the ESPYs red carpet, what exactly is the motivation for a fight?
It's hard to even begin fathoming Big Show vs Shaq as a genuine WrestleMania match with a detailed backstory but that would at least be tolerable. If the duo are to meet at WrestleMania just for the sake of it then why the hell are we even considering this? Even the Akebono and Floyd Mayweather matches had reasoning behind them.
In typical WWE fashion, some kind of ridiculous story will likely be contrived if the contest is given the green light, but the build-up is already off to a poor start and doesn't exactly fill the skeptics with surety.
7. The Match Stipulation
Okay, let's skip forward to WrestleMania and imagine this proposed abomination of a match actually goes forward. Amused media moguls and sports fans alike have their interest piqued and have decided to subscribe to the WWE Network solely to view this contest, as WWE clearly believes will happen. The stage is set and two icons of their respective industries meet face-to-face inside the squared circle.
What happens then? It's all fun and games in the build-up, but when the focus is squarely on Big Show and Shaquille O'Neal alone in the middle of the ring, what in the holy hell is going to happen to make it worth anybody's time?
As stupid as they were, at least Big Show's WrestleMania meetings with Akebono and Floyd Mayweather had some direction to them. Akebono? Sumo wrestling. Floyd Mayweather? Boxing. Shaq? I don't know, a dunk contest or something? Maybe see who can sink a three-pointer first?
As much of a stretch as it was, Akebono and Mayweather were somehow linked to physical competition at least comparable to professional wrestling. What in the hell do wrestling and basketball have in common aside from trash talking and dimwitted referees?
6. The Focus Is Taken Off The Talent
If I'm not mistaken, WrestleMania is all about showcasing just how fantastic WWE can be. It's the one show every year that fans of varying interest in the product make sure they don't miss in some capacity, potentially even seeking a reason to be drawn back in. Tell me, how in the hell does Big Show vs Shaq achieve that?
If time dedicated to non-wrestling personalities in the past is anything to draw off, WWE would be sacrificing as many as 30 minutes on promos, entrances and match events for a contest that makes little to no sense. That's 30 minutes of fans' lives that they can never get back. Have mercy, Vince.
Sure, WrestleMania is a long enough show that the match could fit in seemlessly, but just because it's possible doesn't mean it should happen. Even if the main show exceeds the four-hour marker as it has done in the past, it's still a segment that takes the shine off the wrestlers who have worked their arses off just to be featured on the card.
Further than just the show, think of how much WWE programming time will be wasted hyping up this atrocity. Is taking the focus off your main focal point - the performers - really worth another one of these publicity stunts we've grown used to?
5. Neither Deserves A Marquee WrestleMania Spot
As touched on, there is not a soul in the world that could genuinely believe Shaquille O'Neal deserves a marquee WrestleMania spot. Even if he was in his prime, it would still be hot garbage and a violent slap to the face to those working multiple shows on a weekly basis.
It was silly enough to see Shaquille O'Neal participating in the Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal, but that sort of celebrity involvement is justifiable at the very least. His appearance didn't take the shine off anybody else and didn't waste a whole lot of time. Having an entire segment or a match is a completely different story.
Big Show, as great of a servant he has been to pro wrestling, is not one of the guys whose name belongs up in lights anymore. Even if the proposed match were to be treated as a farewell match - which seems unlikely given Show's stated intentions to continue wrestling beyond WrestleMania 33 - it would still be difficult to wrap your head around.
WrestleMania is a spectacle, but it's a wrestling show first and foremost, one that acts as validation for those who have dedicated themselves to excelling over a 12-month period. Show has had his fair share of WrestleMania moments already, whereas Shaq shouldn't even be in the discussion. Don't waste a top-billed spot on a celebrity appearance.
4. Other Crossover Attempts Have Failed
Does anyone else see the direct link between Big Show and failed crossover matches? It's not like placing Show in this position is a new concept and it's unlikely to succeed where other have failed either.
Back at WrestleMania 21 in 2005, Big Show was billed against a Sumo Grand Champion and nearly 500-pound behemoth Akebono Taro in a predetermined (gotta keep some aspect of pro wrestling) sumo wrestling match. The contest, intended to capture the untapped market of Japanese pay-per-view buyers, featured some unnecessary jiggling, titty slapping and eventually an Akebono atomic-wedgie maneuver known as a koshinage to toss Big Show from the rope-less ring. Total success.
As outlandish as Big Show's match with Floyd "Money" Mayweather, Jr was, it was somewhat entertaining at the very least. The match made some kind of sense since it pitted the tiny (in comparison), undefeated Mayweather against a genuine giant who could not be separated by weight class, as with boxing.
The build-up was fun, with Big Show legitimately getting his nose broken in an altercation with Mayweather, and the match playing out in the best way it could.
That still didn't make the match a success as its intended purpose was not achieved. WrestleMania XXIV achieved 1,058,000 pay-per-view buys, down from 1,188,000 the previous year, while Akebono's appearance generated just 78,000 more buys than the year previous.
Not that those numbers can be attributed to Akebono and Mayweather, of course, but it shows no real improvement either way.
Why would that trend change this time around in an era where fans are more inclined to voice their discontent when wrestling is put on the backburner for pointless theatrics?
3. Fans Don't Want It
Seriously, who in the world is asking for this match to happen? More importantly, why it supposedly so important that it needs to happen on the Grandest Stage of Them All?
I feel confident in stating that not once since Shaq's WWE cameo at WrestleMania 32 has a single person (not contracted by WWE) lobbied for this match without at least the slightest hint of sarcasm. Big Show isn't the reason WWE fans watch WWE and Shaq isn't the reason NBA fans watch NBA - why on earth would both supporter groups both go out of their way to make sure they don't miss this pile of crap?
The vast majority of WrestleMania 33 viewers will undoubtedly be passionate wrestling fans, as is the case each year. Although it's a generalisation, it's safe to assume that those fans want to be treated to a professional wrestling showcase featuring the best of the best, not some one-off gimmick sideshow.
If this match becomes a reality, it will really ram home the point that WWE isn't all that interested in what the fans would prefer to see.
2. The Crowd WILL Turn
In the modern era of super smart fans, wrestling viewers want to see exactly that: wrestling. Who woulda thought?
Big Show vs Shaquille O'Neal is not wrestling in every sense imaginable. The duo could shed a few hundred pounds between them, don blank trunks and start pulling off moves that would put Dean freakin' Malenko to shame and it still wouldn't be wrestling. It's a publicity stunt, and if the recent past has taught us anything, fans will reject it like the plague.
Thinking back on all the cross-promotional celebrities WWE has featured, the only ones who weren't mercilessly booed that come to mind are Jerry Springer and Ronda Rousey. That realisation paints a very sad and stereotypical picture of wrestling fans, mind you.
Not to mention that Shaq's two altercations with Big Show on WWE programming were already rejected, most notably during WrestleMania 32's Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal. But then again, that was the same WrestleMania that featured 100,000 people cheering for Roman Reigns' world title victory, remember? (wink, wink)
1. So... What Now?
Further than pondering the manner in which they will compete, what is it that Show and Shaq can do in the ring exactly? It's safe to assume that a display of technical wrestling mastery is off the cards.
As much of a professional wrestling mainstay he has been over the past two decades, Big Show is getting a little long in the tooth. By his own admission he is within reach of the end of his career and wrestling more than a five-minute match is quickly becoming a stretch, as you'd expect for a 44-year-old, seven-foot, 450-pound guy who has wrestled for over 20 years.
Accross the hypothetical ring, you have Shaquille O'Neal, a man in similar rundown shape as Big Show but without any professional wrestling experience. Albeit over 100 pounds lighter, Shaq's 19 years worth of running up and down the floor have done a number on his body, especially his already surgically repaired left knee.
What happens when it comes down to just Big Show and Shaq, two mammoths tasked with appeasing a smark-filled Camping World Stadium in Orlando?