9 Live Observations From ROH Supercard Of Honor XV

Tony Khan labels it a "new era" and SAMOA JOE kicks that era off with a bang!

Samoa Joe ROH
ROH

It couldn’t be understated just how big a night this was for Ring Of Honor.

Supercard Of Honor XV had been on the docket even when ROH announced, with a heavy heart, that it would pivoting from financially backed organisation to super-indie in late-2021.

Set to return almost entirely to its fiercely independent roots, ROH may not have relaunched with the game-changing zeal of 2002, but the plan to exist as a contemporary wrestling show with a legacy brand on the marquee felt pointed. Where they could run shows and pay talent, they would. But if they couldn’t, for any logical and logistical reasons, they wouldn’t. It wasn’t growth, but at least it might not have looked as in decline as it had done by comparison to the newer, fresher and almost instantly beloved All Elite Wrestling.

All good. Ish. All until, oddly enough, AEW president Tony Khan announced on the March 2nd edition of Dynamite that he’d bought the company, and followed up in the days and weeks with news that he intended to have a big hand in the management of his new purchase.

This was enormous news, not least with Supercard on the horizon. Every match took on some additional heft, especially with AEW talent peppered throughout the show. How would this all look and feel, and would it prove an end of one era, or the hastened start of a new one?

Answers to these questions and more were provided on a chaotic night in Garland, Texas…

9. Swerve Strickland Vs. Alex Zayne

As Isiah "Swerve" Scott in NXT, Shane/Swerve Strickland was one of the most dynamic performers on a show that constantly felt like it was slipping into wet cement.

Bone dry, paced poorly with no light at the end of the physical and mental tunnel, the once-proud black-and-gold band needed the likes of Swerve to make it feel as young and relevant as it professed to be.

Perhaps the new ROH will offer him a bit of that as well? That certainly seemed to be the case here, particularly after a poisoned 'rana from the apron to the floor by Zayne that took both guys out. After beating the count, the final act took delicious shape.

Zayne levelled Swerve with double knees off the shooting star, but only found two. As did Swerve off a top rope one of his own, leading to a series of reversals and kickouts that culminated in Swerve hitting his finisher for the win. Everybody went apesh*t for almost all of this - the omens were good for the night ahead.


8. The Briscoe Brothers (c) Vs. FTR

Briscoes FTR
ROH

This was every bit the dream tag match it was sold as. And f*cking then some.

It's still unknown if The Briscoes will make it into AEW due to TBS/TNT having various concerns with their prior ill-advised remarks, but the 12-time ROH Tag Team Champions did at least get this monster cross promotional booking with Dax Harwood and Cash Wheeler after the duos got into a brawl at Final Battle.

What followed was part-fight, part dramatic and artistic masterpiece. A bloody southern style tag that somehow fused all the modern aspects of both pairs' offence, the building became a furnace from the first seconds, with the roof finally being blown to smithereens when the wrestlers simply locked up.

The absorbing war that followed immediately became part of Match Of The Year discussion, particularly when a mid-match mutual respect scene resulted in FTR pivoting from situational heels to babyfaces all to tee up running of The Young Bucks when they committed a post-match assault.

FTR took the titles, but it didn't even feel like a headline at the end compared to Young Bucks heat-seeking run-in. That sequel will play out Wednesday. Hopefully a wait for a sequel to this minor classic doesn't take so long to sort.


7. Jay Lethal Vs. Lee Moriarty (with Matt Sydal)

Jay Lethal
ROH

Another Tony Khan pre-show announcement, the Jay Lethal/Lee Moriarty match made for yet another unique scenario on a night that was already something of a one-off.

Lethal and Moriarty (and Moriarty's corner man Matt Sydal) both returned to their old ROH stomping grounds as AEW employees made their presence felt up and down the Ring Of Honor roster.

A cavalcade of amazing near falls resulted in Lethal finally choosing the different way he'd alluded to on prior AEW shows. After using a referee distraction to hit a desperation low blow, he nailed the Lethal Injection for the win. After briefly appearing to doubt himself for a second, he went all in on his turn by kicking away Matt Sydal’s crutch.

Sonjay Dutt attempted to talk him to the back, but the turn was as good as confirmed. Dutt's position would become clearer as the night wore on, but the crowd made no secret of their fury with the two.


6. Ninja Mack Vs. Brian Cage

Brian Cage
ROH

Ninja Mack realised what he was in for the second Tully Blanchard introduced Brian Cage as his brand new charge.

Launching himself at 'The Machine' with a dive following multiple backflips, Mack tried in vain to get an advantage but trying was all he could do as Cage ripped him limb from limb in an outstanding re-introduction of a character that had been iced in AEW for months.

The Dallas fans roared their approval for his violence in a way he hadn't received during his feud with Team Taz, suggesting that Tony Khan's decision to move him to his new company rather than his first one was fairly inspired. Likewise for Blanchard, who felt refreshed in the role away from FTR and the crumbling Pinnacle.

As Blanchard and Cage celebrated their victory, they were joined by fellow Tully Blanchard Enterprises members Kaun and Toa Liona, allowing the group an undefeated and undeniably excellent first night on the job.


5. Mercedes Martinez Vs. Willow Nightingale

Mercedes Martinez
ROH

Belt collector and ROH Women's World Champion Deonna Purazzo was so in demand over WrestleMania weekend that she couldn't make this historic event for making history of her own.

Set to work the Multiverse Of Matches for Impact at WrestleCon, Purzzao's absence necessitated this interim women's championship bout, with Mercedes Martinez and Willow Nightingale serving as the first two performers to test Tony Khan's mettle booking women's wrestling second time around.

It was a huge leap in the right direction.

This was a big night for Willow Nightingale, and she capped it off with an unbelievable moonsault that probably should have been the finish. Martinez kicked out and locked her in a submission for the win, but despite her victory being well received, the finish felt tacked on to the contest’s apex. Minor complaint aside, the body of the match ruled hard, and comments later on from Tony Khan spoke to just how important the likes of Martinez will be in the division's continued growth.


4. Rhett Titus (c) Vs. Minoru Suzuki

Minoru Suzuki
ROH

Another late announcement right at the time when the buzz was already maximised by the imposing presence of one of the competitors in Dallas, Rhett Titus' TV Title defence against Minoru Suzuki was rich in the now-familiar feeling of Tony Khan spotting a potentially electrifying pairing and running with it.

The real genius revealed itself in the card placement.

With it having to follow what’s sure to be one of the matches of the year, Suzuki and Titus started hot with an almighty slap battle that foreshadowed the latter’s guts in the face of the ‘Murder Grandpa’ himself.

Though excellently worked, it struggled to pull the fans fully back into the action. Those that hadn’t gone for a breather or a drink anyway.

As a WrestleMania weekend special attraction, the bout was perfectly placed to do so. Suzuki flattened him with a gotch piledriver and called it a night after just X minutes. His TV Title reign might not be an epic one, but it started in fun fashion.


3. Josh Woods (c) Vs. Wheeler Yuta

Wheeler Yuta
ROH

Ahead of Tony Khan's purchase of Ring Of Honor, the future didn't look bright for the Pure Championship.

It had been made public that the intent of company heads was just to focus on the top singles title for men and women and the tag belts, but Josh Woods and Wheeler Yuta were perfectly place to pull the belt back from the brink.

Khan presumably wanted to help them here, and judging from the response from the live crowd for the gripping action, keeping it around feels wise. There may have been some in the building that might not have been aware of the specific rules, but the booking of the match focused so heavily on them (limiting rope breaks to three only, no hitting in the face) that they added unique wrinkles of drama that kept the match fresh amongst other rippers elsewhere on the show.

Yuta's win marked yet another intriguing crossover bit of business between both AEW and ROH too, and his style suits his position within each role.


2. Jonathan Gresham (c) Vs. Bandido (c)

Bandido Jonathan Gresham
ROH

Seeking to unify the original ROH World Championship belt with title held by Bandido, Jonathan Gresham arrived at Supercard Of Honor with the most mainstream momentum he'd ever had - not least because of the attention his attendance backstage at AEW shows had also generated.

Bandido's Final Battle bout with the Terminus owner couldn't go ahead when the former contracted COVID-19, but the timing couldn't have worked out better for the two to meet here - especially with ROH's new owner adding fuel to various speculative fires.

At points, communication ever so slightly broke down, but the complex exchanges were being established in the middle to justify the closing stretch. And to provide gaps for fans to note Chavo Guerrero’s sh*thousery.

A 60-count stalling suplex from Bandido was a mid-match high point before a Guerrero interjection was too much for Bandido himself to take. He insisted his own second get the boot, resulting in a thrilling climax that saw Gresham secure gold after a raft of electrifying near falls.

But the night, as we had all been told in advance, wasn’t destined to end there..,


1. Samoa Joe Returns To Ring Of Honor

Jonathan Gresham Samoa Joe
ROH

…and signs for All Elite Wrestling too!

Returning to a monstrous babyface reception, Joe stomped out to send Jay Lethal and Sonjay Dutt packing after they’d laid a beating on Jonathan Gresham and Lethal’s earlier opponent Lee Moriarty.

’The Samoan Submission Machine’ looked dominant, helped the babyfaces up (with partial endorsements, for now) then cut a promo about how thrilled he was to be back in Ring Of Honor.

Tony Khan returned to the stage to greet him as he left, with the two toasting Joe‘s return to the place where he first made himself a major wrestling star. But this all turned out to be more than just a one shot deal or nostalgia kick.

Khan announced on Twitter before he headed out that Joe had also signed for AEW, with the signature #AllElite graphic as is now tradition. Delivering on the promise of a surprise as well as providing a hot start to ROH’s “new era”, the show’s conclusion set a promising stall out for the months ahead.


 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.