9 Reasons WWE Draft 2016 Was A Colossal Failure

Anyone actually excited about this thing?

seth rollins dean ambrose
WWE.com

For an event that WWE spent so much time and effort promoting as the dawn of a new era, the SmackDown Live's brand split draft was little more than an underwhelming affair that left many fans scratching their heads in confusion.

Due to Raw being an extra hour in length, the flagship show received three picks to every two of SmackDown, and outside of the first two wrestlers selected the names being tossed out and the positions they were chosen were quite surprising.

Most opinions on the second attempt at a brand split seem to range from lukewarm trepidation to outright cynicism, and we all went into the draft hoping to have our fears assuaged. Unfortunately that doesn't appear to be the case, and the social media response from the Universe isn't shaping up to be very positive.

Let's take a look at the draft and analyze what went wrong.

8. The Overall Presentation Was Bland

WWE Draft
WWE.com

When the draft was announced fans immediately began thinking about ways the company could improve upon years past. Treating the event as more of a sporting affair along the lines of the NFL or NBA is what most people seemed to want. When it was announced that the Network would be hosting a Live Draft Center second screen experience it felt like WWE would be capitalizing on their platform to make this a unique experience.

Unfortunately for those only viewing SmackDown - something that the USA Network has made clear is to be a priority for WWE - the show felt like a rushed episode with inconsequential matches similar to one of the the throwaway holiday episodes.

SmackDown kicked off with the first round of picks being thrown out in rapid fire succession, and we weren't even given live reactions from the stars selected. A name was read, a brief highlight clip was shown and then they moved on to the next pick.

Even the banter between Raw brass Stephanie McMahon and Mick Foley and SmackDown figureheads Shane McMahon and Daniel Bryan felt awkward and forced. All of the superstar reactions were relegated to the Network special, and while I understand the desire to want to drive people to that platform to complete the viewership experience, the reality is that a fraction of the people watching the USA shows are also Network subscribers and for those people the entire thing felt empty.


7. Raw Has No Marquee Babyface Star

seth rollins roman reigns
WWE.com

This is a surprising development considering the focus was clearly on stacking the talent toward WWE's man show, but there's simply no big name face star for the fans to get behind that is capable of carrying the brand.

Regardless of everyone's opinions of John Cena, the guy moves merch, sells tickets and pulls in ratings as the polarizing babyface who the women and children support unconditionally. WWE obviously wants that with Roman Reigns, but just as obvious is the fact that it simply isn't happening and may never happen if they don't change course on him upon his return. Stubbornly digging in and forging ahead is not going to work, but what do I know. Nosediving ratings, disappointing house show ticket sales and unimpressive merchandise numbers are clearly no indicator of someone's success, I suppose?

So with no Cena on Raw, and Seth Rollins continuing on as a hell - at least for the time being - who does that leave? There are some obvious choices for potential talent to fill that role. Sami Zayn and Finn Balor are clearly great options, but that's going to take some work.

Raw needs someone ready RIGHT NOW, and short of turning Rollins face - possibly a double turn with Reigns at Battleground? - there's a gaping void that is going to need to be filled and quickly.


6. Splitting Up The Women's Decision Was A Mistake

Sasha Banks, Charlotte, Becky Lynch
WWE.com

For all the effort made to make improvements in the women's division and have them taken seriously, there's a justifiable fear that all of that hard work has been undone by the results of the draft. While the ladies' roster may feature more talent than it has at any point in the company's history, there still aren't enough main roster-ready women at WWE's disposal to afford to split them up.

When it was announced that the newly-revived cruiserweight division would remain Raw-exclusive, many assumed that the women would be relegated to one show as well. When Charlotte was chosen with the surprisingly high pick of #3 overall, it appeared that the women would also compete solely for Raw. But Daniel Bryan and Shane McMahon brought an end to that assumption when they chose Becky Lynch with the 14th pick.

Even with the addition of NXT talents Nia Jax, Alexa Bliss, Eva Marie and Carmella - none of whom are ready for the main stage at this point in their careers, by the way - there simply aren't enough women on the roster to justify having them split between two shows. SmackDown is depressingly devoid of females, with just Lynch, her rival Natalia, Naomi, Bliss, Eva and Carmella to carry their end of the vision over on the blue brand.

Meanwhile over on Raw, Charlotte, Sasha Banks, Jax, Paige, Summer Rae and Alicia Fox round out their half of the women roster. No depth whatsoever.

And yet Bayley is STILL down in NXT while people with a fraction of her skill and marketability see an increase in their paychecks.



5. Raw Is Stacked With Champions

The New Day
WWE.com

I think we all fully expect some shenanigans to take place in the triple threat match at Battleground, leading to the splitting of the WWE world heavyweight championship so that each show can have its own champion. Ideally the title holders would be able to float between brands and defend their belts on each show, but that's not how WWE decided to do things last time and the booking seems to be heading toward a similar setup once again.

When you take current champions into account, Raw ended the night with the United States champion (Rusev w/Lana), the tag team titlists (New Day), and the women's champion (Charlotte). There will obviously also be a cruiserweight champion crowned, and eventually their own version of a World/WWE kingpin as well.

On the blue side of things, SmackDown held onto the most important title by drafting Dean Ambrose, although it'll be surprising if he holds on to that past Sunday's Battleground, and Intercontinental champion The Miz. Outside of those two Raw managed to bring in all the champions, and if there's not show-specific versions of those titles created then SmackDown competitors have no chance to win those belts.

What's their motivation to wrestle without the opportunity to win a title in their respective divisions?


4. Factions Were Broken Up For No Reason

The Club
WWE.com

WWE has a terrible habit of splitting up tag teams and factions for no reason, and long before it's actually time. The Shield is a perfect example of this. While the trio has had tremendous success on their own, they were white hot as a unit and could have run for quite some time before pulling the trigger on the breakup. It's like WWE writers don't know how to tell a story for a team past a certain time frame and then it becomes time to split them up, often with no direction in mind.

The Wyatt Family fell victim to this scenario when they were inexplicably broken up last year and "set free" by their leader, Bray. It quickly became apparent the experiment was a failure and they threw them back together with no storyline explanation, adding Braun Strowman to the group.

The draft has now done the same thing, splitting Strowman away from Wyatt and Erick Rowan. While Braun may have more potential than his fellow Family members, he also has the least amount of experience and was really benefiting from being a part of the group. There's no telling where Luke Harper will wind up when he returns from injury. Does WWE put him on Raw with Strowman or have him rejoin his original brother on SmackDown?

Another faction split apart by the draft was The Club. AJ Styles becomes one of the top pics for the blue brand while Karl Anderson and Luke Gallows end up on Raw. A decision like this is puzzling considering The Club are in the midst of one of the biggest feuds in the company and getting over with the fans.

The obvious answer is that they replace AJ with Finn Balor, but with Raw in dire need of top faces, putting him with the villainous club without turning Anderson and Gallows seems counterproductive.

Other groups that seem to have come to an end are The Social Outcasts. Both Bo Dallas and Curtis Axel are on Raw while Heath Slater remains undrafted, and the Lucha Dragons are no more, with Kalisto possibly in line for a push.


3. Back-To-Back Shows Is Asking For Burnout

raw smackdown
wwe.com

Is WWE oblivious to the multitude of complaints regarding the length of Monday Night Raw being too much for fans to consume? When a majority of your audience moans about your show being too long, whose bright idea was it to follow it up the next night for another two hours?

Five hours of wrestling on two consecutive nights is a lot to ask, even of the most diehard of wrestling fans. As someone who tunes in faithfully each week despite the fatigue I'm sometimes overwhelmed with, it immediately became apparent within the first half hour that the additional Tuesday night SmackDowns are going to be asking a lot for me to sit through/

With WWE interest at one of the lowest points it's been, I just don't see anyway this is a good idea. And rather than names like John Cena and Dean Ambrose luring fans to turn on to the show that hasn't been viewed as must-see TV for wrestling fans in a long time, what's more likely to happen is that these extremely talented superstars will suffer for it when the audience begins to drop off in droves.


2. Not Differentiating The Brands

daniel bryan shane mcmahon stephanie mcmahon mick foley
WWE.com

During one of the brief times that SmackDown and Raw both earned equal amounts of success was during Paul Heyman's run as the booker of the blue brand, and he did so by going out of his way to set the look, feel and style of the two shows apart.

SmackDown became known as the home of the hot young upstarts and hungry rookies with a mixture of the best veteran workers in the business, going out each and every week and busting their *sses to put on the best show possible. The "SmackDown Six" had the entire wrestling world captivated and there was a real danger of the WWE's flagship show being superceded.

With the way the 2016 draft played out, it doesn't appear that there will be any real difference between the two shows, outside of the cruiserweights being exclusive to Raw, a fact that wasn't emphasized in any way on the draft special.

Daniel Bryan and Shane McMahon should have done more to set their brand apart from Raw rather that just putting together a roster that attempts to be a balanced version of the rival show's.

Anything to differentiate the two is a positive, whether it be making one the more serious, workrate-heavy show while the other focuses more on sports entertainment or what have you. There just needs to be noticeable differences.


1. There Aren't Enough Tag Teams For Two Separate Rosters

american alpha the revival
WWE Network

In much the same way the women's division is going to suffer for being ruptured between the two shows, the tag team roster is also going to be facing the exact same dilemma. WWE was already floundering from a lack of credible teams as it stands, with several of them - The Vaudevillians, The Shining Stars, The Ascension - being nothing more than glorified jobbers.

The few standouts among the division were a step in the right direction, but that handful of entertaining teams with potential have now been split right down the middle.

Raw's tag team roster consists of the current champs The New Day, the massively popular Enzo and Cass, Karl Anderson and Luke Gallows, The Dudley Boyz, Golden Truth and The Shining Stars.

SmackDown features NXT callups American Alpha (who are going to be breakout stars on the main roster), The Usos, The Ascension, The Vaudevillains and Breezango. It's hard to get excited about the arrival of the amazingly talented Jason Jordan and Chad Gable when outside of The Usos - great guys and workers who have admittedly grown stale - they have no one to work with other than a bunch of jabronis.

Obviously we'll see new teams put together and some will assuredly be split up, but the shallowness of the tag team roster in WWE is yet another reason why the brand split feels like it's destined to fail.


Contributor
Contributor

Brad Hamilton is a writer, musician and marketer/social media manager from Atlanta, Georgia. He's an undefeated freestyle rap battle champion, spends too little time being productive and defines himself as the literary version of Brock Lesnar.