9 Times WWE Booked Impromptu Matches At WrestleMania
WWE has increasingly offered surprise 'bonus' matches' at its biggest show - to mixed results.
“Card subject to change” long has been a phrase used to explain why wrestling show lineups might look different than advertised, whether it’s due to illness, injury or politics.
But for WWE’s biggest show of the year, one would think that the card is set in stone heading into WrestleMania weekend.
In recent years, however, WWE has taken “card subject to change” as an aspirational message rather than a protective clause. Looking at the cards heading into WrestleMania versus what actually transpired, it certainly feels like WWE has welcomed the last-minute changes to its lineup as a way to surprise fans and generate an in-the-moment buzz. 'Mania attendees and viewers can almost expect to see an impromptu challenge, surprise opponents or a late addition to a match.
Results have been mixed – in some cases, the surprise has been hiding in plain sight and was welcomed by fans and critics alike. In other instances, the shock of the moment wore off quickly and was replaced by a collective groan.
Skimming through 40 years of history, it’s clear that WWE values the surprise nature of impromptu matches and will clearly continue to employ them – there were five such bouts during the last three WrestleManias – going forward. Whether they are celebrated or reviled will depend on the circumstances surrounding each one.
For now, let’s look back at the impromptu matches that have graced a WrestleMania ring and see how they stack up.
Let’s get to it…
9. Adding A Dance Partner
While not technically impromptu matches, WWE has regularly added someone surprise entrants to matches or had qualifiers that solidified opponents later during the same WrestleMania. They all deserve a special mention here.
The most famous example of a surprise add-on has to be Seth Rollins cashing in his Money in the Bank briefcase to make the WrestleMania 31 main event between Brock Lesnar and Roman Reigns a triple threat. At WrestleMania 33, the Hardy Boyz made a shock return to WWE and were added to the triple threat ladder match for the Raw Tag Team Championship, making it a four-way battle that they won.
Surprise opponents have ranged from the incredible – Cody Rhodes returning to WWE at WrestleMania 38 to face Seth Rollins – to the ridiculous – Braun Strowman recruiting Nicholas as a partner to challenge The Bar for the Raw Tag Team Championship at WrestleMania 34.
And then there are the “fight your way into a title match” examples. Daniel Bryan beat Triple H to open WrestleMania 30 to earn a spot in the main event triple threat against Randy Orton and Batista. Kane won a battle royal to earn an ECW Championship match against Chavo Guerrero at WrestleMania 24. And Tamina and Natalya won a tag team turmoil match on night one of WrestleMania 37 to challenge Nia Jax and Shayna Baszler for the Women’s Tag Team Championship the following night.
All of these matches were on the card, but the participants changed on the night of the match.
8. Rock Comes Dressed To Fight
When The Rock teamed with Roman Reigns to defeat Seth Rollins and Cody Rhodes at WrestleMania 40, it was the first real Mania match the Great One had wrestled in 11 years, when he lost to John Cena at their second “Once in a Lifetime” main events at WrestleMania 29.
However, there’s a blink-and-you’ll-miss-it “match” at the disappointing WrestleMania 32. Fans should be forgiven if they don’t remember this one.
Rock came out with a blowtorch, igniting a giant sign bearing his name, then strode to the ring to announce the (fake) attendance record for Dallas’ AT&T Stadium. His routine was interrupted by the Wyatt Family, who were sitting on the sidelines for that year’s Mania.
After a bunch of back-and-forth, Rock stripped off his clothes, revealing his wrestling gear. He challenged the Wyatts to a match right then and there, with Erick Rowan stepping up… and launching right into a Rock Bottom at the bell, losing in a Mania record six seconds.
The match was a joke, only serving to give Rock screentime and set a more legitimate Mania record for quickest match, given that the 31-year-old record set by King Kong Bundy at the first WrestleMania actually lasted more than 25 seconds.
7. The Most Infamous Impromptu Match
The first truly impromptu WrestleMania match also is the most notorious one on our list.
At WrestleMania 9, Bret “Hitman” hard defended his WWF Championship against Yokozuna in the billed main event. It also served as the first Mania main event to not feature Hulk Hogan in some capacity (he was ringside for WrestleMania 4’s closing bout)… or so we thought.
Mr. Fuji used salt to blind Hart, allowing Yoko to topple the Hitman and win the title. Just like that, a heel was walking out of WrestleMania with the world title after winning the main event for the first time.
Not so fast though… Hogan appeared at ringside to protest the chicanery, when Fuji started badmouthing Hogan (who had lost a tag title match alongside Brutus “The Barber” Beefcake earlier in the night). Inexplicably, Fuji challenged Hulk to a world title match on the spot, and Hogan agreed after a still-blinded Hart waved him on.
One leg drop later and Hulk was a five-time WWF Champion. The good times would not last, and Hogan would be gone from WWF by that summer.
6. Crazy Septuagenarian Embarrasses Self, Entire Industry
From the infamous to the flat-out insanely embarrassing, cast your memories back a mere three years to WrestleMania 38 and the most clear-cut sign that Vince McMahon had completely lost it (even more so than that ridiculous mustache).
Vince had taken Austin Theory under his wing as a modern-day Chosen One, trying to elevate the brash upstart through a variety of means that included a stolen egg (no, seriously) that was in reality (and storyline) a prop in a movie starring The Rock.
*ahem* Sorry, got sidetracked by the stupidity.
Theory faced Pat McAfee at WrestleMania 38, where the former NFL punter triumphed, thus rendering Austin’s push meaningless. But it got worse – miles worse – when McMahon dragged his 76-year-old carcass into the ring and challenged McAfee to a match right then and there, stripping off his shirt.
Crazy old man Vince managed to actually defeat McAfee (with some help from Theory), negating the announcer’s victory and undercutting his protégé completely by beating the guy who defeated him.
Four months later, McMahon was forced to resign in disgrace (for the first time), kicking off a new era in WWE.
5. Shane’s Still Got It… *Clap Clap ClapClapClap*
Not to be outdone by his father, Shane McMahon had his own impromptu WrestleMania match the following year, though it didn’t go quite as planned. Thus, this is a double entry of unannounced matches.
The Miz and Snoop Dog hosted WrestleMania 39, which really was just an opportunity for the duo to stand in the ring and prattle until Miz talked himself into getting squashed by a surprise opponent. (Bear in mind Miz was two years removed from being WWE Champion and one year away from being a World Tag Team Champion.)
On night two of WrestleMania, Shane McMahon entered the chat, coming down to challenge Miz. The two got just seconds into the match when Shane blew out his quad on a drop down/leapfrog spot, effectively ending the match.
Not content to just end the embarrassment there, WWE called an audible and had Snoop clock Miz and drop and elbow to pin the A-Lister in what was essentially a second impromptu match in the span of two minutes.
What’s worse for Miz is that this wasn’t even his first foray into getting his a** kicked at WrestleMania 39…
4. McAfee Returns For Another Surprise Match
Looking to avenge his loss to Vince McMahon the year prior, Pat McAfee made a surprise appearance at WrestleMania 39 to challenge an unlikely foe.
As mentioned earlier, The Miz and Snoop Dogg were hosting Mania that year. On the first night, McAfee came out to face Miz in an impromptu bout. During the match, Miz tangled with San Francisco 49ers star George Kittle, who punched the A-Lister behind the referee’s back, enabling McAfee to pick up the win.
As “comedy” matches go, this was simultaneously inoffensive and not funny. It provided fans with a pop for the returning McAfee and silenced the loudmouth Miz, but that was about it.
3. A Main Event Under Normal Circumstances
On paper, John Cena versus the Undertaker would be an easy call for a major PLE match, a main-event clash between era-defining superstars.
But at WrestleMania 34, the match was little more than a three-minute squash gag.
Cena had failed in his attempts to secure a world title match via the Royal Rumble and Elimination Chamber, so he began calling out Undertaker on Raw repeatedly, to no avail. Without an answer, Cena decided to attend Mania “as a fan.”
On the night, Cena sat in the crowd, hanging out with the fans until a referee told him that 'Taker had arrived. Cena sprinted to the back and would make his entrance later in the evening. After a confrontation with Elias, Cena was stymied by Undertaker effectively un-retiring (he left his jacket and hat in the ring after his disaster of a match at WrestleMania 33, and the hat and coat reappeared here).
Instead of a competitive surprise match, the Deadman pummelled Cena, who managed the barest of offense before being chokeslammed, Tombstoned and pinned. Just like that, a WrestleMania dream match was over. Bell to bell, the match was shorter than Taker’s entrance.
2. A True Mania MITB Cash-In
The history books correctly identify Seth Rollins as the first wrestler to cash in their Money in the Bank briefcase at WrestleMania, using it to join the already-in-progress main event at WrestleMania 31. He would capture Brock Lesnar’s WWE World Heavyweight Championship by pinning Roman Reigns.
However, Damian Priest made history of his own at WrestleMania 40 when he became the first person to execute a more traditional cash-in, initiating a new, impromptu match by turning over his briefcase.
During the opening match on night two, Drew McIntyre defeated a wounded Rollins to win the World Heavyweight Championship. However, the Scottish Warrior incited CM Punk, one of the best wrestlers in the world even when he's on the shelf, who was seated at ringside doing commentary, by celebrating on the announce desk. Punk battered McIntyre, leaving the new champ laid out.
Cue Priest, who raced to the ring with his briefcase to trigger a fresh world title match on the spot. Damian would quickly topple McIntyre, stealing his WrestleMania spotlight and ending his World Heavyweight Championship reign after five minutes.
1. Austin Unretires To KO Owens
If everyone sees a match coming a kilometer away, is it really an impromptu match?
That was the scene for the first night of WrestleMania 38, where Kevin Owens hosted the KO Show in the main event slot with his guest “Stone Cold” Steve Austin. Owens had spent weeks exchanging heated words with Austin, leading to the long-retired Hall-of-Famer to agree to appear on the talk show.
The two verbally sparred, with the war of words escalating until a challenge was thrown down and both agreed to an impromptu match, sending Dallas into a frenzy. After all, Austin had been retired for 19 (!) years and remained retired from in-ring competition.
Questions about whether Austin would just “play the hits” were answered moments into the match when he took a suplex on the stadium floor. The Rattlesnake and KO brawled around the arena and back into the ring, where Austin would hit a Stunner, which could be the best wrestling move ever, to pick up the win.
The build to a main event match masquerading as a talk show segment was simultaneously impressive and frustrating. Everyone had a strong feeling the match was inevitable on the night, but the announcement of a match might have built anticipation even more. Perhaps the reason for this was to avoid expectations that Austin might not have been able to meet.
Either way, Austin/Owens is the pinnacle of WrestleMania impromptu matches – a truly exhilarating surprise that delivered in the ring and sent fans home happy.