9 Ups & 2 Downs From AEW Dynamite: Winter Is Coming (Dec 2)

Winter came to AEW Dynamite in the form of Sting, a World Title change, and Impact Wrestling.

Sting AEW
AEW

Ahead of AEW Dynamite's 11 November episode, company president Tony Khan tweeted that wrestling's "balance of power" would shift that night. When PAC's return was the show's biggest development, the flak thrown Khan's way was earned: yes, PAC's comeback was cool, but "power shift?" Really?

The line would have been entirely more appropriate had Khan kept it on ice for another couple of weeks. Winter Is Coming was seismic for All Elite Wrestling - and the sport as a whole in North America.

Kenny Omega and Jon Moxley faced off in their highly-anticipated AEW World Championship match, battling for around 30 minutes in the main event slot, with the outcome and immediate aftermath standing amongst the most shocking moments in company history. This came in the same hour as WCW legend Sting, who appeared on a TNT-hosted wrestling show for the first time in close to 20 years. These two huge, blockbuster events made Winter Is Coming the most newsworthy weekly wrestling show in a long, long time, and while the delivery wasn't entirely perfect, it already stands as AEW's biggest non-PPV event so far.

Elsewhere, two new women's feuds grew, Chris Jericho issued an Inner Circle ultimatum, and the Dynamite Dozen Battle Royale reached a surprising conclusion.

Let's light the fuse.


Downs...

2. The Inner Circle's Ultimatum

The Inner circle
AEW

Frankie Kazarian and Chris Jericho worked a slick, professional bout early in the night. Going one-on-one for the first time in their careers, Jericho and Kaz meshed well, with the babyface forced to contend with Jake Hager and Ortiz at ringside. Constantly battling the odds caught up with him in the end: he was pinned after a Judas Effect.

What happened with The Inner Circle is the real story, though.

MJF came out near the end, a white towel in his hand. Ready to throw it in as he did for Cody Rhodes against Jericho last year, MJF had it yanked away by Sammy Guevara, who was brandishing the surrender rag when 'Le Champion' came to. Afterwards, Jericho broke up an Inner Circle shoving match by getting in the middle, yelling that he'd had enough of their sh*t, and issuing his ultimatum. Next week, the stable will either work together as a team or break up forever.

While the execution of everything described above was on point, it feels far too early to be teasing a full-on Inner Circle breakup. The Las Vegas trip was just a fortnight ago, while last week presented them as a dangerous, swarming unit for the first time in a while. Even if they don't split, the Ultimatum would resonate better with at least another month or two of build, playing on existing tensions, creating new ones, and working towards a more satisfying conclusion.


1. Shida Gets Spooked

Hikaru Shida Alex Marvez
AEW

So far, Hikaru Shida vs. Abadon is a wack WWE-style feud that presents the AEW Women's World Champion in a weak light at a time when she desperately needs to shine and assert her identity on a wobbly division.

This continued last night, as Shida was interviewed by Alex Marvez. She claimed she was unphased by Abadon, calling 'The Living Dead Girl' a zombie cosplayer, before getting spooked by a clang in the background, asking to reshoot the interview, and running away.

There's no difference between this and last year's stinking Seth Rollins vs. 'The Fiend' feud over in Vinceland. Shida, the champion, looks week when over-selling a good too silly for its own good, and AEW must find new ways to incorporate Abadon's character into its wrestling universe without compromising others. Reducing a 'Full Mention Champion' to a cowering wimp isn't the move.


Ups...

9. Baker Battles Through Hirsch

Britt Baker Leyla hirsch
AEW

Perhaps Leyla Hirsch vs. Britt Baker could have benefitted from being a tad shorter, but this was a fun encounter between the division's strongest personality and a believable technician with huge upside, and served as a functional bridge to Baker's more important storyline.

A pre-match promo saw Baker claim she was clearing out the division's riff-raff and giving Hirsch a one-way plane ticket back to Russia. She almost paid for this on several occasions, as Leyla continually got the better of her in grappling exchanges, bettering the good doctor with superior skill and expertise. Leyla continually used her strengths to counter and reverse into advantageous positions, even diving onto Reba when Baker used her as a meat shield, though too much damage was done to her back by the end. A twisting neckbreaker and Lockjaw ended her night.

Britt's personality is really leaping off the screen again, and her in-ring work is catching up with it as well. It's time to build the rest of the AEW women's division around her.


8. Building A Division

The Young Bucks The acclaimed
AEW

While nothing blowaway, The Young Bucks' backstage interview and beatdown by The Hybrid 2 was a neat bit of business to dollop extra heat on next week's tag clash.

The Jacksons pointed out that while they were fighting champions, Angelico and Jack Evans are unranked and don't deserve a shot at the World Tag Team Titles yet, offering to give them one if they're able to better the Bucks next week. In walked The Acclaimed. Max Caster rapped about d*cks, which he does a lot these days, providing the necessary distraction for TH2 to jump the Bucks and beat on them until SoCal Uncensored made the save.

As well as building to the Bucks vs. TH2, AEW established The Acclaimed's new relationships with SCU and the Jacksons here, as well as aligning them with the challengers. That's deft.


7. Sweet Revenge For Allin & Rhodes

Darby Allin
AEW

Darby Allin and Cody Rhodes vs. Team Taz's Powerhouse Hobbs and Ricky Starks wasn't the all-out popper one may have expected from looking at the lineup, but was still an effective tag bout that succeeded in its primary goal of making Hobbs look like a beast.

Taz's Powerhouse entered a good performance here. His usual strength spots hit like they always do, but his heel character is coming together nicely as well, with Hobbs sneering and flexing his way through the bout, pausing for press-ups early on.

Hobbs was wiped out for the finish. Cody dived on him after Darby had sneakily tagged in without the heels noticing, leaving Starks alone with Allin, who quickly scaled the top rope for the Coffin Drop. Job done.

We'll get to the aftermath later, but this worked. Revenge must have tasted sweet for Rhodes in particular, given what Taz did to him last week, though there was no sign of Hook here.


6. A Well-Booked Battle Royale

Orange Cassidy
AEW

AEW doesn't always do battle royales well, so it was nice to see them deliver a multi-layered Dynamite Dozen clash last night, building and developing multiple storylines in a match that was occasionally a little too cluttered for its own good, but definitely succeeded incorporating its moving parts well.

Matt Hardy's villainous turn continued through his eliminations of ally Isiah Kassidy and fan-favourite Hangman Page. Speaking of Page, The Dark Order recruitment drive continued for much of this, as John Silver celebrated wildly with him, before the rest of the group caught him on an elimination, returning the 'Anxious Millennial Cowboy' to the safety of the ring.

Miro looked like a monster, eliminating four wrestlers in a row during a well-booked rampage. Scorpio Sky eliminated rival Shawn Spears then got blasted by 'The Chairman's' loaded glove. The Inner Circle trio of Sammy Guevara, MJF, and Wardlow played it smart, flying under the radar until the end, when MJF "accidentally" eliminated Sammy with Jungle Boy, seemingly winning the match.

Orange Cassidy, who had never been eliminated, popped back up, stunning Wardlow to throw him out, earning a shot at the ring vs. MJF on next week's show.

That's a lot of ground to cover in less than 15 minutes of airtime, so props to AEW for piecing everything together. This was an objective success.


5. Thunder Rosa Vs. Britt Baker Is On Fire

Thunder Rosa attack
AEW

Britt Baker vs. Thunder Rosa is the feud the women's division needs at the moment, particularly with Hikaru Shida trembling before the zombie cosplayer elsewhere.

These brawls are hot. The first one demonstrated that Rosa and Baker already have excellent chemistry, and it continued again last night, as the former NWA Women's Champion leapt on Britt after the win over Leyla Hirsch, engaging in a fight that was pulled apart twice before the wrestlers were eventually split for good.

Rosa vs. Baker are delivering big, intense angles every time of asking. These set pieces are simple, effective, and right on the money, with Baker's promo prowess and Rosa's electricity guaranteeing the next step will be just as satisfying.


4. Look How Far We've Come

Jon Moxley
AEW

Jon Moxley's contractually-obliged great weekly promo went down before Winter Is Coming's main event, with the AEW World Champion in reflective form ahead of his clash with Keny Omega.

'The Purveyor Of Violence' put the occasion over huge. He acknowledged the magic in the air, called it the biggest night in Dynamite history, and said he and Omega - the two best wrestlers in the world - were destined to battle on the mountaintop. The stakes couldn't be higher, and all that was left was to go out and "make them go absolutely banana[s]."

An expert salesman, Moxley always does an excellent job of using his promos to promote. You should walk away from these things feeling more excited for whatever he was talking about than when you entered. Here, Mox did a grand job of making an already important bout feel even more so.


3. Big Fight Feel

Jon Moxley Kenny Omega
AEW

Kenny Omega vs. Jon Moxley never threatened to break into the Match of the Year many had hoped for ahead of Winter is Coming, and there's a lot to be a said about a finish that didn't quite feel earned (that Paradigm Shift onto the heater wasn't particularly impactful), but it was still a strong, strong match between two leading Wrestler of the Year candidates.

Coming off more like an early chapter in a long-term feud (which it was), the match's slower pace and spacious layout gave the impression the performers were deliberately leaving room to explore in future bouts. Attritional, exploratory opening exchanges led to a walk and brawl. Eventually, Moxley grabbed a couple of chairs, set them up in the ring, and demanded Omega sit down and trade strikes with him. When Kenny was hit so hard he stumbled away from his charge, he blasted back, magnificently, with a V-Trigger.

Don Callis was excellent on commentary and again in his role in the finish, sliding Omega the microphone that busted Moxley open. A V-Trigger flurry and One-Winged Angel ended Mox's night and crowned Kenny the new World Champion.

Not emptying the tank was a smart move if Moxley and Omega are to clash again, though the bout could have used another gear to take it up a notch. Still, Omega violating his "gentlemen's agreement" by cheating to win, one week after urging Moxley to "beat him with skill," magnificently ties up months of villainous teases, establishing Kenny as AEW's alpha heel.

As for Moxley? His vengeance will be ugly.


2. See You Next Tuesday!

Don Callis Alex Marvez
AEW

Even if you dislike the Don Callis/Impact Wrestling deal and would have preferred Jon Moxley vs. Kenny Omega to finish on a truly clean finish, the effectiveness with which AEW built to this must be acknowledged.

Callis first appeared for AEW at Full Gear 2020, where his existing relationship with Omega was the connective tissue. A great commentator in his own right, he entered a strong, cordial performance, putting 'The Cleaner' over huge while staying professional throughout. In kayfabe, this earned him an invitation to return last night.

The Impact Executive Vice President repaid Tony Khan's trust by f*cking him over. Not only did he screw Jon Moxley out of the World Title in Khan's clean finish promotion, but he has drawn 'The Cleaner' to Impact. Whatever form this takes, whether it is a full-on invasion or something smaller, Callis is taking the jewel in AEW's crown to a rival network.

That's great stuff - and AEW vs. Impact opens the door for all kinds of mouthwatering matches. Between this and the AEW/NWA relationship, it feels like the wider wrestling world is coming back together beneath its biggest promotion.


1. STING!

Sting Darby Allin
AEW

Yes, Sting is 61 years old.

Yes, his AEW debut kind of came out of nowhere.

And yes, he probably can't take a bump or work another match.

But to hell with all that, was 'The Icon's' arrival one of the most hair-raising moments in AEW Dynamite history.

The lights cut as Team Taz stood over a downed Cody Rhodes following his tag match. Black metal imagery hit the big screen and an epic soundtrack filled the building. With the atmosphere built, Sting's named slowly spread across the screen, and out he came, baseball bat in hand.

A more pure reaction than Tony Schiavone's you will not hear all year. "It's Sting!" he screamed. "Sting! Back on TNT for the first time... oh my god, since 2001". Having called so many of 'The Icon's' biggest matches and moments for decades, this must have felt incredible for the AEW announcer - and his passion enhanced an electric moment.

Team Taz bailed. Sting shared glances with each of the babyfaces, lingering on Darby Allin. Appropriate, given how frequently Darby has been compared to the legend.

Now signed to a full-time, multi-year contract, Sting will break his silence on next week's episode of Dynamite. He should prove to be an excellent signing even on reputation alone. That he wrestled the last ever wrestling match on TNT before Dynamite's launch, has the Allin relationship to explore, and has ties to Cody through Dusty, makes this 2020's most poetic debut.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.