9 Ups And 10 Downs From Last Night's WWE Raw (May 6 )

An awful episode that showed WWE's creative bankruptcy and pettiness.

Roman Reigns Vince McMahon Daniel Bryan
WWE.com

If you thought Raw hitting its lowest ratings for a non-football week would spark some smart booking and captivating television, you’ve been deluding yourself.

You’re probably the type of person who thinks more McMahons is the solution to these ratines woes. You probably enjoyed The Revival’s struggles with icy hot gel. You probably thought nothing of Sami Zayn getting tossed in a trash bin for calling fans stupid losers. You probably love when authority figures book opponents as tag partners.

Maybe you’re a huge Shane McMahon mark. If so, you got to see Super-Shane show off his immunity to chairshots.

If you’re that type of person, congratulations. You’re part of a dwindling audience, so more power to you.

But for this writer, it is becoming difficult to defend programming like this. Had a friend been over when the entire Revival/Usos segment was on TV, there would have been no way to overlook writing that is too juvenile and stupid for most kids’ movies.

This episode is being graded pretty harshly because it was supposed to be an all-hands-on-deck show, with Vince McMahon helming it and several SmackDown superstars showing up to juice the ratings. This should have been WWE’s best foot being put forward.

Instead, the foot we got had a bad case of gangrene, and it’s still in need of treatment before it spreads.

Let’s get to it…


Downs...

10. No Match

lars sullivan no way jose
WWE.com

It happens from time to time that a scheduled match doesn’t take place.

But when it happens in back-to-back segments? That’s just lazy booking.

First, we were robbed of an interesting bout between The Revival and Luke Gallows & Karl Anderson due to a stupidity that will be mentioned later. And so Gallows & Anderson were just stand-ins for opponents, as they weren’t needed at all. But hey, they got on TV, right?

Then, No Way Jose danced out for a match, only for Lars Sullivan to invade from SmackDown, come down and run through the entire jobber phalanx, er, conga line and take out Jose himself.

It’s not a horrible crime for this to happen, but it literally was one right after the other, which just was poorly done.


9. Roman As Fans’ Avatar

roman reigns vince mcmahon
WWE.com

Before we start, this isn’t a knock against Roman Reigns at all.

Flash back to December, when ratings hit then-all-time lows. The McMahon family came out to claim responsibility (sort of) for the poor showing, which came after Seth Rollins trashed the show (and then-GM Baron Corbin) and many of the bad booking decisions they were making.

The McMahons promised change, which we got… for about three weeks.

Fast-forward to Monday night, and Reigns was out there in the Seth Rollins role, pointing out the McMahons’ failings, that Vince and his “spoiled children” were running things after promising no more “authority” holding people down.

And this is why this is a “down:” No one is buying it this time. We were fooled once before when Rollins trashed the product and the McMahons broke the fourth wall to promise a better product – and then we did… for all of three weeks. Does anyone actually believe that the Wild Card Rule is going to shake things up and make it all better? NO.

It was a nice sentiment to have Roman try to talk about taking orders from the fans, but we all know Vince is gonna do what Vince is gonna do. A cantankerous 73-year-old man isn’t going to suddenly make bold changes to his product. (Prove us wrong, Vince.)


8. ‘Love To Have Fun’

lucha house party
WWE.com

This column is going to harp on WWE admitting that its ratings are in the tank, and then falling back into the same traps and tropes it always does.

WWE loves to describe its happy, positive wrestlers (who also don’t seem to take winning matches very seriously) as loving to have fun. This has been going on since the Attitude Era, when the Godfather was often described as “a fun-loving guy who loves to have fun.” (No, seriously.)

Michael Cole made sure to describe Lucha House Party thusly as they ran through a jobber team in six-man tag action, beating up one guy with repeated triple teams that was actually impressive, squashing him for the easy win.

They could have tried to reboot the luchadores as good-natured guys who get down to business in the ring, but all the announcers could do was talk about how fun-loving they are. It’s a fallback that gets used way too often to describe wrestlers without doing them any favors.


7. Tag Champs Past Sell-By Date

war raiders zack ryder
WWE.com

That silence you heard, following an “already in the ring” moment, was the death knee of Zack Ryder & Curt Hawkins as Raw Tag Team Champions.

It has to be the case, right?

You could almost hear a pin drop during the champs’ match against the Viking Raiders, with fans barely reacting to any Ryder/Hawkins comeback. This can’t bode well for the accidental champs, who lucked into a win at WrestleMania and have managed to win a few more matches since then.

The story of breaking Curt Hawkins’ epic losing streak was a nice one, but the storyline has long since run its course. No one cares about the duo any more, and they’re not being booked seriously. Given the results of Raw, they’re time on top has got to be drawing to a close, right?

It might actually be a safe bet to make at this point.


6. Schizophrenic Announcing

sami zayn
WWE.com

No one these days expect WWE to be internally consistent in storylines and characters over a long period of time. We’ve just grown accustomed to the writers having the attention span of a gnat and changing their minds week to week. You either accept it or you don’t.

But when an announcer literally changes their opinion in a matter of 30 seconds of airtime, you’ve got a serious problem.

Sami Zayn came out for another weekly rant against the fans, and Renee Young was happy to see him, calling it her “favorite part of Monday Night Raw” and noting that you can’t make everyone happy because sometimes you have to serve up the truth.

Fast-forward to 30 seconds into his rant, and Young blurted out that “someone’s gotta shut this guy up.” She also called Zayn’s comments – which were no different than what he’s been saying for weeks – insane. But she was happy to see him initially and even went to high-five him when he came out.

Can we be internally consistent for one segment? Good God.


5. Two Chairshots

the miz chair
WWE.com

Miz hit Shane McMahon squarely with two chairshots to the back Monday night.

Shane shrugged them off and slugged Miz back, brawled with him and got away by kicking him low once. And then Shane dove into his limo and sped off, escaping his Money in the Bank opponent.

But let’s repeat: Shane shrugged off two chairshots like they were love taps. If any other wrestler no-sold that in the ring from someone like JBL, he would have tortured the poor soul, and deservedly so. You can say McMahon is tough every week. You can have him dive through tables, off cages and onto opponents, but that’s just ridiculous.

There’s no way Shane should be brushing off chairshots and then felling his opponent with one kick, even if it was to the groin. But hey, gotta keep the McMahons strong!


4. Wacky Tag Partners Trope Strikes

AJ Styles Seth rollins
WWE.com

One of the worst tropes is when an authority figure forces two at-odds wrestlers to team up in a tag match. Nothing good ever comes of this sort of thing. Either the team manages to co-exist and then defeat an established tag team, or one person stabs the other in the back, or there’s a miscommunication to further the rivalry. If you’ve seen it once, you’ve seen it 100 times.

The only saving grace is when they add a stipulation that they have to get along or lose a title shot – or something like that. But that wasn’t the case with AJ Styles and Seth Rollins. They were jawing with each other, and Vince McMahon decided to just stick them in a match together.

They were doing well against Bobby Lashley and Baron Corbin, but Styles missed Corbin with a Phenomenal Forearm attempt and hit Rollins – and then walked out on the match. Shocking! Rollins, the WWE Universal Champion, then ate an End of Days and was pinned by Corbin.

Because we needed the wacky forced tag partners cliché to further this feud. Because WWE.


3. Trashing Zayn

sami zayn
WWE.com

This column has mostly reserved judgment on Sami Zayn since his return to Raw last month, mostly because this writer didn’t know what to make of his new role as Vince McMahon’s avatar, bellowing out insults at the fans.

And then this week, we got our definitive answer.

A couple minutes into Sami’s rant, Braun Strowman came out and chased Zayn to the back, catching him and tossing him into a Dumpster. That was bad. Then a trash truck drove up and hoisted the bin and dumped the contents into the back as Braun just shrugged. (To be fair, it was a top loading truck, so it might not have been a compactor.)

But this is what they’ve got for Sami Zayn? Welcome back from double shoulder surgery, you’re going to bash the fans and get tossed in the trash after four weeks and one televised match.

And WWE wonders why its ratings are in the toilet. See Exhibit #117 right here.


2. ‘Ucey Hot’

the revival
WWE.com

If you’re looking for reasons why Raw’s ratings are in the gutter and superstars are turning down big-money contracts, look no further than the stupidity, pettiness and channel-changing magic that was the Revival segment with the Usos.

The entire segment was insane stupidity from beginning to end, and it only served to turn two teams who should be cornerstones of the Raw tag division into utter jokes. The Revival got over by being no-nonsense technical wrestlers who were throwbacks to the duos of the 80s. The Usos reinvented themselves as a hard-edged, streetwise tag team.

Monday night was an abomination. The Revival was reduced to “comically” selling icy hot being inside their tights, and the Usos were turned into a “comedy” duo with props.

But hey, Vince McMahon was laughing it up backstage, right? That’s all that matters. That’ll show Revival for whatever transgression they’ve allegedly committed.

Just an awful, awful moment that left the live audience silent. If this writer wasn’t doing this column, this would have been the moment he turned Raw off and didn’t come back to it for a good, long time.


1. Vince McMahon

vince mcmahon wwe raw
WWE.com

The buck stops with the man at the top. Whether you want to believe Vince McMahon is deliberately burying his talent or any conspiracy theories/rumors out there is immaterial.

The simple fact is that this episode of Raw was terrible. WWE came into Monday knowing that last week’s episode of Raw hit its lowest non-football rating in modern history, and that they needed to stop the bleeding.

The solution? Lead off with Vince McMahon and then have three SmackDown wrestlers “invade” Raw, showing how unpredictable Raw can be.

And then the show fell back on every trope and petty, juvenile move we’ve seen during the past several years. Seth Rollins and AJ Styles were forced to team up despite being opponents at the next PPV. Revival was turned into a punchline because they might be leaving the company. The Usos were turned into comedians instead of a killer tag team establishing themselves on Raw. Sami Zayn was literally thrown away in the trash.

But hey, Shane McMahon shrugged off two solid chairshots without so much as going to a knee. And we heard all about how the Lucha House Party loves to have fun. And we weren’t bored with in-ring action from Samoa Joe, Rey Mysterio, Cesaro or Cedric Alexander… or a teased tag match between Revival and the Good Brothers (The Club).

If this episode is how WWE responds to its worst ratings in eons, then they – and we mean Vince – clearly don’t get it.


Ups...

9. Wild Card Not All That Wild

daniel bryan kofi kingston
WWE.com

How they got there was pretty silly, but the final idea was not all that crazy.

After SmackDown’s Roman Reigns, Daniel Bryan and Kofi Kingston all showed up on Raw without permission, Vince McMahon tried to play it off by deciding a new rule in the wake of the Superstar Shakeup: the Wild Card Rule (trademark pending).

Under the rule, three (or is it now four?) wrestlers from Raw could travel to SmackDown each week, and three (or four) SmackDown wrestlers could visit Raw each week. There’s no set rule on who could show up when, so there’s an air of unpredictability and some different one-time matchups we could get.

Considering where Raw and SmackDown’s ratings are, and that they still want/need to have separate rosters, this was about the best they could do with shaking things up and juicing the shows.

It’s not a perfect solution – writing better television and booking more logical and smart feuds like they’ve been doing in NXT for four years would be a solution – but it’s something, and it might work in the short term.


8. Kofi Sasses The Boss

Kofi Kingston Vince McMahon
WWE.com

There aren’t many wrestlers who can talk down to a McMahon on camera. Unless it’s part of an ongoing feud, you just don’t see superstars mouth off to Vince, Stephanie or Shane regularly, no matter how outrageous they’re acting.

That’s why it was gratifying to see Kofi Kingston immediately give lip to Vince after coming out on Raw Monday night. Kingston showed up to rebut Daniel Bryan’s whining about his “fluke” loss at WrestleMania and his desire to commune with the chairman.

Kofi told Bryan to “forget the McMahons” and focus on the WWE Champion, pretty clearly dismissing the boss (who he earlier told to chill when he got in the ring). Later, when McMahon “came up” with his Wild Card Rule (trademark pending), Kingston snorted at him, “OK, whatever you need to tell yourself.”

It wasn’t on par with Roman Reigns telling Vince to watch his mouth, but it was good to see after everything Kofi went through with McMahon previously that he wasn’t giving an inch.


7. AJ Has Reasons

vince mcmahon aj styles
WWE.com

After criticizing WWE writers for not being internally consistent within the same segment, let’s give credit in an instance where they did something right.

Last week, AJ Styles attacked Seth Rollins after their WWE Universal Championship match contract signing (a signing ended in a brawl? Shocking!). But this week, Styles explained his reasoning: AJ had offered to shake Rollins’ hand, but Seth instead hoisted the title up in his face. Then, when Styles tried to walk away, Rollins kept running his mouth, leading to AJ popping him and triggering the braw that led to a Phenomenal Forearm through the table.

And watching the replay from last week, all of that happened. Styles offered a sportsman’s handshake, and Rollins got braggadocios, and it went downhill from there. AJ still can easily be in the wrong, but there was a certain logic to what he did, and he believes it. Smart storytelling.

And then we got the wacky tag partners. So, one step forward, one step backward.


6. Mercy, Mercy Me

Bray Wyatt Firefly Fun House
WWE.com

Bray Wyatt’s Firefly Fun House continues to be the weirdest part of Raw, but in a good way.

Monday, we saw Wyatt’s buzzard Mercy eating some stuffing, which was revealed to be Rambling Rabbit, another friend of the show. Mercy apparently didn’t like the rabbit’s attempts to make him “adhere to his Bohemian world view and ideology.”

Huh.

Wyatt not only forgave him, he invited him to a picnic with a bunch of kids who were less than elated to be there, to say the least. The stone-faced kids looked like they wanted to be anywhere but with Bray.

And that was that. It was short this week, but the segment certainly was odd. It’ll be interesting to see what comes next.


5. Closing A Loop

ricochet bobby roode
WWE.com

When Ricochet came out (with that stupid bullet sound effect) for a match with his Money in the Bank ladder match slot on the line, this writer groaned. Was he already being de-pushed?

It turns out the opposite was true. A couple weeks ago, Robert Roode handed Ricochet his first singles loss in WWE, so Roode felt he deserved his spot in the MITB match. That’s actually a fair point. So the two tangled with the spot on the line.

Ricochet managed to pull off the win with a picture-perfect 630 splash, earning his ladder match spot (which no one else has done), and he avenged his loss to Roode, so that isn’t hanging over his head.

That was a nice piece of continuity.


4. Lynch Shuts Lacey’s Yap

becky lynch lacey evans
WWE.com

Lacey Evans is a piece of work. Scented, formal invitations to watch her beat up a jobber? That’s certainly something.

After making short work of her opponent, Lacey ran her mouth on the four Money in the Bank ladder match participants, and then took shots at Becky Lynch. The Double Champ stormed to the ring, pummeled Evans and chased her off in short order, with fans chanting “Becky!”

It was a simple, but effective segment, with Evans winning a match, running down the roster and putting them on notice, and Lynch mixing it up to show she’s up for a brawl whenever possible.

Evans still has work to do to prove herself, both in the ring and on the mic, but she at least didn’t look like a lost lamb out there. That’s something.


3. Raiders Tear Through Tag Champs

viking raiders
WWE.com

The current NXT Tag Team Champions annihilated the Raw Tag Team Champions Monday night, and no one blinked.

The Viking Raiders made short work of Zack Ryder & Curt Hawkins, running through the tag champs in a non-title match on Raw. Ryder & Hawkins tried employing quick tags, but they were ridiculously overmatched.

You’ve got to believe that this signals the end for the Ryder & Hawkins experiment. A month as tag champs where no one cares anymore is long enough. Hopefully, the Raiders earned a tag title match at Money in the Bank, where they run through the champs just as quickly to have this tag division turn a corner.

And hopefully, the Viking Raiders can keep the same name until then.


2. Rematch Better Than The Original

roman reigns drew mcintyre
WWE.com

Maybe with a month to continue to heal and recover, Roman Reigns is becoming more like himself again.

Reigns and Drew McIntyre had a WrestleMania rematch Monday night, with McIntyre hitting some brutal moves, including a deadlift suplex and a reverse Alabama Slam into the apron. Roman countered a top rope leap with a Superman Punch and broke out a DDT for the first time in memory.

Roman caught Drew with a spear, but he didn’t get to a cover right away. When he did, Shane McMahon and Elias attacked, causing a DQ. That was the only dark spot on the match, which was pretty good.

The post-match hijinks kept Elias one step ahead of Reigns with their PPV match looming. No one is giving Elias much of a chance, but they’re at least making you think he has a shot here.


1. Kofi Defends

kofi kingston daniel bryan
WWE.com

Let’s give it up to Kofi Kingston, who successfully defended his WWE Championship against Daniel Bryan and kept the fans into the action after a brutal third hour of Raw.

Kingston’s fairytale reign will continue for at least a couple more weeks, as Bryan lost clean to a Trouble in Paradise after a series of reversals. The match itself was pretty good, with Kofi taking some abuse from Bryan but staying in the match with some well-timed comebacks. You almost forget after years in a tag team how smooth he is. At one point, Bryan tried to whip Kofi into the stairs, and his simply vaulted to the top rope and hit a rebound clothesline to the floor, almost in one fluid motion.

No one thinks Kofi is going to be a long-term champ, but hearing the reaction from fans and seeing him have another good match with Bryan makes you think he could keep this momentum a little longer.

Regardless, it was a nice way to end a dismal, aggravating Raw.


Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.