9 Ups And 11 Downs From WrestleMania 32
Was WrestleMania 32 all smoke and mirrors?

WWEs hyperbole machine will be in full swing in the coming days and weeks, as the company will undoubtedly tell anyone who will listen repeatedly how WrestleMania XXXII was the biggest and best of all time. The company will cite the appearances of megastars like the Rock (including an impromptu match), Steve Austin, Mick Foley and Shawn Michaels, as well as a surprise appearance by John Cena, a death-defying leap off Hell in a Cell, and tons of fireworks.
Oh, and WWE will almost certainly try to sell everyone on how much everyone loves Roman Reigns and that he persevered to dispatch of the hated Authority, making him the most popular guy on the roster, right? The Roman Empires renaissance is upon us, and WWE is confident that this not Shane McMahon will usher in change for the company moving forward.
WrestleMania XXXII wasnt the worst of all time, but it certainly could rank toward the bottom of the bottom tier when its all said and done. WWE very clearly didnt have much in the tank for this year, so they fell back on retired superstars, gimmicks and pyro to try to keep the large crowd fired up.
It wasnt all bad this year, but the hype might be stretched just a bit thin this year. So what was truly entertaining and what was a disappointment? Lets get to it
Downs...
11. A Total Divas Mess

But still, this was a mess of a match, with no real flow to it. Unfortunately, these multi-woman matches often end up like this because there are less experienced women in the matches. In this case, you had Eva Marie returning to the main roster and Lana making her in-ring debut. Their participation was thankfully kept brief. But you end up with a rushed match with experienced hands like Paige, Emma, Naomi and Natalya having to hold things together and get all the spots into a five-minute match.
10. A Forgettable Title Bout

Maybe this is WrestleManias fault itself, being a five-plus hour event. But the first match of the night, the United States Championship match between Kalisto and Ryback, was largely forgotten even by the time Mania proper began (what with three matches on the pre-show card).
It really is a shame, because Ryback and Kalisto tried, but the two were fighting against a terrible buildup (shunted to the background in the name of the other marquee matches) and a terrible slot (80 minutes before the official start of the PPV, with the stadium barely half-full). With no story and a sparse crowd, it was only natural that the crowd was dead throughout most of the match.
Perhaps it would have been better if the United States Championship match a signature bout at Mania last year just was left off the card altogether and took place instead on Raw the next night. You hate suggesting something like that, because the match wasnt offensive or anything, but it certainly didnt leave a lasting impression either.
9. Why Bother, Brother?

When the Dudley Boyz turned heel on the Usos a couple months ago, it looked like the perfect way to revitalize an Attitude Era tag team that was treading water and give the tag team division a legit heel team.
Instead, we got a stalled feud that dragged out until Sunday night, when the Usos dispatched of them in five minuteswith a series of superkicks, then splashed them through tables to bury them. And just like that, the Dudley Boyz renaissance was pretty much declared over before it could even get past the first step.
But heres the other problem with that: It was at the hands of the Usos, who have gotten a noticeably cool reaction from the fans since returning. They are no longer the hot young tag team they were when they were tearing up the tag ranks a couple years ago.
For better or worse, fans arent responding to the Samoan brothers like they were, so having them knock off the Dudleys just like that probably wasnt the best move if WWE was going to pull the plug on the Dudleys at this point.
8. Did AJ Forget To Shake Vinces Hand?

Lets see if weve got this right. Veteran Chris Jericho betrays newcomer AJ Styles, turning on him after their tag title match. Jericho continues to distract AJ during his matches, occasionally attacking him.
WWE, with a need to build new, younger stars with so many veterans either reaching retirement age or being injured more often (see Cena, John), decides in its infinite wisdom to have Jericho defeat Styles clean (well, mostly clean) in the middle of the ring.
Is that all correct?
Look, its understandable that WWE doesnt want to have every match outcome being predictable and a foregone conclusion, but sometimes, you need to do whats best for business rather than trying to surprise or outsmart the fans. Jericho is a legendary wrestler and his winning on its own is not a bad thing.
But having Styles, in his WrestleMania debut, lose a match that could have put him in a position to be a top level star is just baffling. You can almost see AJ being shuttled down the card to another face in the crowd. Maybe thats a really pessimistic view, but weve seen it happen multiple times, so it really wouldnt be shocking to see Styles fighting for the Intercontinental Championship in a month.
Of course, well have to see whats next in this rivalry. But man oh man
7. Blandness Personified

Reigns however? Hes vanilla in a flack jacket. That doesnt make him a bad wrestler who should be booed, but it doesnt give the average fan a reason to cheer him. Sure, he has his supporters as many wrestlers do but Roman isnt exactly inspiring new fans to flock to him.
Witness the entrances Sunday night. WrestleMania entrances typically are super-elaborate and over-the-top. Guys like Ryder and Charlotte wore robes. New Day had a Booty-Os cereal prop. Shane McMahon made it rain. And Triple H had his typical over-the-top entrance.
But Reigns? He walked out, slammed his fist on the ground and fireworks went off. Its hard to describe, but its hard to pin down his persona. And maybe others see it right away and love him, and thats cool. But he just feels bland. And thats a shame, because this writer wants to really like him and not just be indifferent.
6. Knocking Current Stars Down A Peg

Dont worry, there will be praise for these surprise appearances later, as it was an awesome moment. However, first a criticism for the Hall of Fame beatdown of the League of Nations at WrestleMania.
Having three men in their 50s who have been retired for a combined 20-plus years beat up four men who were compared to the Four Horsemen just 15 minutes earlier really is an indictment more of the current generation of wrestlers than anything else. Sure, we could talk about how its holding down the stars, but more importantly, its an admission that WWE hasnt built this current generation up enough.
Try to imagine during the Attitude Era if Bob Backlund, Jake The Snake Roberts and the Ultimate Warrior came out to beat up the Hardy Boyz and Edge & Christian. That might not be an entirely fair comparison, but the point is that you didnt see long-retired stars come out to beat up active wrestlers like this.
But for WWE today, the retired superstars are the biggest bullets the company has in the chamber. While its great seeing them (and more on that later), this is simply reflective of a bigger problem, when a team knocks off the Tag Team Champions and then immediately is beaten by three 50-somethings. Tomorrow, the three Hall of Famers will be at home, and the League of Nations will have to show up to work.
5. Bankrupt

WWE really suckered us all in.
With Snoop Dogg rapping her entrance and the announcers noting that she was paying attention to the late Eddie Guerrero, you would have thought that Sunday would have been Sasha Banks coronation as the new WWE Womens Champion. After all, fans have been chanting, We want Sasha! for months now, and officials are high on her, so why wouldnt she win the title on the biggest stage of them all?
Except thats not what happened. Sasha had several standout moments during the excellent triple threat match, but ultimately, she lost, being kept out of the ring by Ric Flair while Charlotte submitted Becky Lynch. And just like that, Sashas dream was dashed. And we, as fans, will have to wait until another day for the Boss to reach the throne.
But it wasnt all bad, as well see later
4. Buzzards Are Pecking The Wyatt Family

If you follow the buzzards, you might see them land on the carcasses of the Wyatt Family and start pecking out their innards because apparently, the Wyatts as an act is dead in the water.
The Wyatt Family burst onto the scene around the same time as the Shield and was an extremely promising group. Bray Wyatt is a gifted speaker and talented in the ring. Luke Harper is amazing for a man his size. And Erick Rowan has a nice beard. But the Wyatts have done nothing of consequence, aside from cut creepy promos and be menacing for brief periods of time.
So when they engaged the Rock, you kind of knew they werent getting the best of the Brahma Bull. And so, in a continuation of a theme for the night, the semi-retired Rock and a still-injured John Cena proceeded to dismantle all three members of the family (sans Luke Harper) in a matter of moments, showing everyone who the big stars are.
If youre keeping score at home, thats Austin, Foley, HBK and Rock (with an assist from Cena) taking out the League of Nations and the Wyatt Family, and embarrassing the New Day. Part-timers rule, mid-carders drool.
3. Preserving The Status Quo

So after weeks of playing up the idea that Shane McMahon could usher in a new era for WWE, and that the current leadership was destroying the company nothing changed. Shane McMahon played the role of a maniacal stuntman and lost a cartoonish Hell in a Cell match to the Undertaker.
There really should not have been any way that McMahon hung in there with Taker without some sort of serious assistance. And no, a triangle choke doesnt count as serious assistance. The rumors of Goldberg interfering is more along the lines of thinking. If anyone thought this was a realistic battle and that Shane had Undertaker on the ropes, then you suspended disbelief for that one match more than most wrestling fans do in a year.
But putting aside the silliness of Shane McMahon kicking out of a Last Ride and a chokeslam, and powering out of Hells Gate, lets recognize what the result of the match means: nothing changes. Shanes play for power failed, and the Authority will continue to rule over WWE. This, after weeks of the babyface telling us what we all already know, that the product is stale.
But hey, Undertaker can wrestle at next years WrestleMania, so yay.